You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Strongest starting eleven
November 16 2026 5.53am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Strongest starting eleven


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
EddieMac Flag 21 Aug 19 10.55am

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

Camarasa himself said his best position is as a supporting forward. This is where he got Cardiff's players' POTY award from last season. I'm hanging my hopes on him being the link we so desperately need, as in the last two games there has appeared to be this massive void between the midfield and our front two.

This is exactly where the problem lies with us. When we attacked on Sunday Zaha would pull out wide, Meyer would stay out wide, Townsend stays wide and Luca and Jimmy stand on the half way line and then Benteke is the only man in the box. Out numbered 5 to 1.

When Townsend and Zaha look up and see this then they dont cross because oBenteke will not be winning the ball while completley out numbered.

THis happened time and time again. We need an midfielders to attack the box.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 21 Aug 19 11.00am

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

How many top teams play like this nowadays?

Like what? Delivering crosses? Plenty of teams deliver crosses. They may not do it as much, but they still do. A 4-2-3-1 or 4-3-3 can achieve this AND with a decent attacking midfielder, hopefully in camerasa, it wouldn’t be the only line of attack. Teams may not put hopeful balls into the box but they put them in areas everyone is on the same page with. What we plan or practice is anyone’s guess.

 


COYP

PatrickA Flag London 21 Aug 19 11.14am

I agree and hope that Camarasa will be the missing link in an attacking midfield role.
The problem is that we got an idea of Roy’s thinking when a fit Camarasa didn’t even make the bench on Sunday.
If you don’t fit Roy’s shape you don’t play.
We’ve seen him stick Meyer in a left sided role where his impact is limited, play Schlupp in central midfield in preference to Kouyate because Kouyate didn’t retain the all important ‘shape.’
When asked about Ayew , Hodgson’s first response was to talk about his defensive capabilities and his ability to bolster the midfield area.
Nothing about what Ayew could contribute offensively.
For the reasons above I think it may be while until we see much of Camarasa.

 

aj36094 Flag Derbyshire 21 Aug 19 12.08pm

Strongest possible eleven for me would be

Guaita

Ward Tomkins Sakho PVA

Luka
Meyer McCarthy

Zaha Benteke Townsend

It seems we are playing inverted wingers to keep Wilf and Andros happy and blaming the striker for not getting his fair share, a similar situation to Benzema at Real, 17/18 it was all focused on Ronaldo which worked, he left and 18/19 Benzema's league goal/game ratio almost quadrupled, didn't fill the void but Zaha isn't Ronaldo.

It may be worth trying Ayew and Schlupp on the wings against Colchester and give Wickham/ Benteke 45 mins each.

 

TrickyCPFC Flag Lords Wood 21 Aug 19 1.26pm

Guaita
Cahill Tomkins Sakho
Luka
Ward Mayer Camarasa Schlupp

Wilf Townsend

Sub: Kelly; PVA; Kouyate; Ayew; Wickham; Benteke/McArthur; Hennessey

I've gone with the 3 at the back with wingbacks (going with the "don't score enough goals" tactic). We have a good team when you write down all the names on paper (or computer!) but they need the fight that they lacked on Sunday to make any formation work.

 

aj36094 Flag Derbyshire 21 Aug 19 1.54pm

Originally posted by TrickyCPFC

Guaita
Cahill Tomkins Sakho
Luka
Ward Mayer Camarasa Schlupp

Wilf Townsend

Sub: Kelly; PVA; Kouyate; Ayew; Wickham; Benteke/McArthur; Hennessey

I've gone with the 3 at the back with wingbacks (going with the "don't score enough goals" tactic). We have a good team when you write down all the names on paper (or computer!) but they need the fight that they lacked on Sunday to make any formation work.

[Link] just like the good old days?? Ward has little attacking threat and Schlupp looks lost when playing in midfield

 

EddieMac Flag 21 Aug 19 2.26pm

Originally posted by aj36094

Strongest possible eleven for me would be

Guaita

Ward Tomkins Sakho PVA

Luka
Meyer McCarthy

Zaha Benteke Townsend

It seems we are playing inverted wingers to keep Wilf and Andros happy and blaming the striker for not getting his fair share, a similar situation to Benzema at Real, 17/18 it was all focused on Ronaldo which worked, he left and 18/19 Benzema's league goal/game ratio almost quadrupled, didn't fill the void but Zaha isn't Ronaldo.

It may be worth trying Ayew and Schlupp on the wings against Colchester and give Wickham/ Benteke 45 mins each.

It may be worth leaving Schlupp on the team bus against Colchester. I get a knot in my stomach when I see his name next or near the team sheet.

 

HerneBayPalace Flag Herne Bay 21 Aug 19 2.39pm

It's difficult to say what our actual best XI might be, as Roy doesn't change shape and we haven't seen Camarasa yet.

I'd suggest we have two line ups, away and home.

Away (451) :

Guaita

Ward
Cahill
Sakho
PVA

Townsend
Kouyate
Luka
McArthur
Zaha

Benteke

Home (433) :

Guaita

Ward
Cahill
Sakho
PVA

Camarasa
Luka
Meyer

Zaha
Benteke
Townsend

Clearly this is fantasy, but I can dream...

 

Fatherken Flag 21 Aug 19 2.41pm

I have the same knot when I see PVA name on the team sheet

 

taylors lovechild Flag 21 Aug 19 2.56pm

If Wickham or Bentenke can't start scoring then I'd be tempted to throw Schlupp up top. He has a great shot on him, he's good in the air and he's quick and strong. Most of his shots are also on target. I seem to remember one of Palace's coaches saying he is the best striker of a ball. It may not work, but surely we have to start experimenting. I also believe he scored when Roy played him up top in pre-season.

In midfield he's quite lazy, is not the greatest passer and we have plenty of better players for the middle of the park. He hasn't played left-back for ages and looked no better at defending than PvA when he did play there.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 21 Aug 19 3.31pm

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

If Wickham or Bentenke can't start scoring then I'd be tempted to throw Schlupp up top. He has a great shot on him, he's good in the air and he's quick and strong. Most of his shots are also on target. I seem to remember one of Palace's coaches saying he is the best striker of a ball. It may not work, but surely we have to start experimenting. I also believe he scored when Roy played him up top in pre-season.

In midfield he's quite lazy, is not the greatest passer and we have plenty of better players for the middle of the park. He hasn't played left-back for ages and looked no better at defending than PvA when he did play there.

Schlupp did start life as a striker apparently, presumably got pushed back down the pitch for a reason however,

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

taylors lovechild Flag 21 Aug 19 3.43pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

Schlupp did start life as a striker apparently, presumably got pushed back down the pitch for a reason however,

I'm not excited by this option, but as they say, necessity is the mother of invention!

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 21 Aug 19 3.45pm

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

I'm not excited by this option, but as they say, necessity is the mother of invention!

Personally, I wouldn't be against trialling anyone from the squad up front. Failing that, include it as a second prize for the Selhurst Super Draw!

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

taylors lovechild Flag 21 Aug 19 4.03pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

Personally, I wouldn't be against trialling anyone from the squad up front. Failing that, include it as a second prize for the Selhurst Super Draw!

Starting up front for Palace today is a green ford cortina, registration plate...

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 21 Aug 19 4.08pm

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

Starting up front for Palace today is a green ford cortina, registration plate...

Lamborghini, registration plate CEO4TAG

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

madcap_v2 Flag SE25 / Ibiza 21 Aug 19 4.12pm

For me:

Guaita

Ward Cahill Sakho PVA

Luka Meyer
Camarasa

Zaha Benteke Townsend

 


La la la your mum

Daddyorc Flag Atlantic Highlands, NJ 21 Aug 19 4.16pm

In pre-season he was started up front with Benteke. I thought he did quite well. He's not a great defender or passer, so this is the position I would play him.

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

I'm not excited by this option, but as they say, necessity is the mother of invention!

 

Dhutch23 Flag 24 Aug 19 2.17pm

Guita

Kelly sakho Tompkins pva

Luka kouyate

Meyer/camarasa

Zaha Townsend
Benteke/zaha

 

Dhutch23 Flag 24 Aug 19 2.18pm

Originally posted by Dhutch23

Guita

Kelly sakho Tompkins pva

Luka kouyate

Meyer/camarasa

Zaha benteke/ayew Townsend

 

Palace Passion Flag Bromley, South London 26 Aug 19 10.42pm

Guaita


Tomkins--Cahill--Sakho--Van Aanholt


Milivojevic--Kouyate


Townsend--Camarasa--Zaha


Ayew

 


|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|||||||||||P|A|L|A|C|E|||||||||||
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||


***Oliver Glasner's RED BLUE ARMY***
Be loud.. Be proud.. Be PALACE!

staffie - missed but never forgotten 19/04/15

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Strongest starting eleven