You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Roy Hodgson Q&A 27th November 7pm All Welcome
November 16 2026 5.53am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Roy Hodgson Q&A 27th November 7pm All Welcome


sw16girl Flag Effingham 06 Nov 19 1.25pm

The Trust are having their AGM on 27th November at 7pm in Speroni's at the club. Roy Hodgson has kindly agreed to be the guest speaker and to do a Question and Answer session.

This will be up first and the Trust has opened this up to everyone who wants to come along and hear Roy and ask questions. This is a great opportunity to engage with Roy in person and I hope that people will come along. Questions are not pre-vetted or scripted and anyone from the audience will have a chance to ask questions although we would expect people to keep it polite.

If you are intending to turn up please email us so we can get an idea of numbers here

cpstrustagm@hotmail.com

And people are welcome to stay for the AGM as well of course.

The club are also opening the bar before and during the meeting

 


A lie is halfway around the world before the truth has a chance to get its boots on

Sainsburys do not have a lease on their store - they own it outright together with both carparks.

sw16girl Flag Effingham 26 Nov 19 12.40pm

bumpity bump

 


A lie is halfway around the world before the truth has a chance to get its boots on

Sainsburys do not have a lease on their store - they own it outright together with both carparks.

HeathMan Flag Purley 26 Nov 19 11.48pm

bumpity bump

Are you telling the world that you are expecting twins?

 

sw16girl Flag Effingham 27 Nov 19 2.15pm

Just encouraging people to come to the Q&A with Roy - there has been a reasonable amount of interest but good to see as many people there as possible.

 


A lie is halfway around the world before the truth has a chance to get its boots on

Sainsburys do not have a lease on their store - they own it outright together with both carparks.

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 27 Nov 19 11.20pm

Any one has a short version of the Q&A with our manager yesterday?

 

sw16girl Flag Effingham 28 Nov 19 10.16am

The club were filming it but not sure when or where it will appear. Roy was really good - was happy to answer questions in depth and you really understood his thinking.

highlights - feeling invigorated by job - is aware of age but will carry on while he feels he is able to give it the attention he deserves.

He feels that he could not really comment on Wickham having never really seen him play to full ability. Feels that if he is fit he would be best out on loan to recover match fitnesses.

He considers players are often under-rated by the press and even fans. The players are a really willing and whole hearted bunch that are a pleasure to coach - and either he is the world best actor or he really means that.

He realises that an aging squad is not ideal and need to address that as you cannot keep hiring Gary Cahill type players - it works for a while but is not long term

His first match watching Palace was when he was about 7 back in the mid fifties - he can't remember who we played though!

The club have to work within their means - there is no sugar daddy.

He commented that sometimes the longer a player is not in the squad the better he seems to become in some peoples eyes.

He is very happy with Centre Back position but would like a new forward. right back position is not good with injury to Joel Ward - look for Martin Kelly there next match

There was a lot more but often not things that could be put down in little sound bites.

Edited by sw16girl (28 Nov 2019 10.17am)

Edited by sw16girl (28 Nov 2019 10.19am)

 


A lie is halfway around the world before the truth has a chance to get its boots on

Sainsburys do not have a lease on their store - they own it outright together with both carparks.

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 28 Nov 19 10.39am

Originally posted by sw16girl

The club were filming it but not sure when or where it will appear. Roy was really good - was happy to answer questions in depth and you really understood his thinking.

highlights - feeling invigorated by job - is aware of age but will carry on while he feels he is able to give it the attention he deserves.

He feels that he could not really comment on Wickham having never really seen him play to full ability. Feels that if he is fit he would be best out on loan to recover match fitnesses.

He considers players are often under-rated by the press and even fans. The players are a really willing and whole hearted bunch that are a pleasure to coach - and either he is the world best actor or he really means that.

He realises that an aging squad is not ideal and need to address that as you cannot keep hiring Gary Cahill type players - it works for a while but is not long term

His first match watching Palace was when he was about 7 back in the mid fifties - he can't remember who we played though!

The club have to work within their means - there is no sugar daddy.

He commented that sometimes the longer a player is not in the squad the better he seems to become in some peoples eyes.

He is very happy with Centre Back position but would like a new forward. right back position is not good with injury to Joel Ward - look for Martin Kelly there next match

There was a lot more but often not things that could be put down in little sound bites.

Edited by sw16girl (28 Nov 2019 10.17am)

Edited by sw16girl (28 Nov 2019 10.19am)

Thanks useful information I agree with his point about the longer a player is out of the first team the better they get. We've seen this many times with England players.

 


One more point

PatrickA Flag London 28 Nov 19 12.56pm

Did anyone ask how much he is involved in choice of new players and how it works with Freedman?
Seems little point in bringing in 3 new players in January if Roy isn’t going to play them.

 

KAOS Flag In a tree 28 Nov 19 1.21pm

I think we can all safely say, we'll never see Wickham start in a Palace shirt again after that comment and recent times.

 

CharlesPaterson Flag 28 Nov 19 7.18pm

I think there is more to this Wickham story.
Maybe the club are hiding something.
The whole thing doesn't make any sense.
Why extend his contract if the current manager doesn't fancy him and would send him out on loan when he's fit.
Doesn't add up?

 

Phil H Flag 30 Nov 19 2.53pm

Originally posted by sw16girl

The club were filming it but not sure when or where it will appear. Roy was really good - was happy to answer questions in depth and you really understood his thinking.

highlights - feeling invigorated by job - is aware of age but will carry on while he feels he is able to give it the attention he deserves.

He feels that he could not really comment on Wickham having never really seen him play to full ability. Feels that if he is fit he would be best out on loan to recover match fitnesses.

He considers players are often under-rated by the press and even fans. The players are a really willing and whole hearted bunch that are a pleasure to coach - and either he is the world best actor or he really means that.

He realises that an aging squad is not ideal and need to address that as you cannot keep hiring Gary Cahill type players - it works for a while but is not long term

His first match watching Palace was when he was about 7 back in the mid fifties - he can't remember who we played though!

The club have to work within their means - there is no sugar daddy.

He commented that sometimes the longer a player is not in the squad the better he seems to become in some peoples eyes.

He is very happy with Centre Back position but would like a new forward. right back position is not good with injury to Joel Ward - look for Martin Kelly there next match

There was a lot more but often not things that could be put down in little sound bites.

Edited by sw16girl (28 Nov 2019 10.17am)

Edited by sw16girl (28 Nov 2019 10.19am)

Excellent summary, thanks for that, interesting for those that couldn't make it.

 

topcat Flag Holmesdale / Surbiton 30 Nov 19 5.09pm

Originally posted by CharlesPaterson

I think there is more to this Wickham story.
Maybe the club are hiding something.
The whole thing doesn't make any sense.
Why extend his contract if the current manager doesn't fancy him and would send him out on loan when he's fit.
Doesn't add up?

I don't know but suspect that it is a way to try and get some money for him if he plays well on loan rather than letting him go for free. It's a gamble, obviously.

 


It's 106 miles to Chicago, we got a full tank of gas, half a pack of cigarettes, it's dark... and we're wearing sunglasses.

CharlesPaterson Flag 02 Dec 19 8.16pm

Originally posted by topcat

I don't know but suspect that it is a way to try and get some money for him if he plays well on loan rather than letting him go for free. It's a gamble, obviously.


I get the loan thing but let's say he did go out on loan and started banging in the goals somewhere, then what? Roy doesn't fancy him. He's on record of saying that he'd be interested in getting another striker in the next transfer window..

 

palace99 Flag New Mills 02 Dec 19 8.47pm

pretty sure the Wickham extension was a Stevie P decision, clearly made with little or no managerial input.
Similar decisions have been made over the years with Paddy Mac, Jonny Williams etc.

Clearly not a business decision. If Wickham is on c£55k a week as has been mooted the sooner he is off the wage bill the better.

If fit he could go on loan to the championship but how much of his wage will they pay? Surely not even half.

 

the.universal 02 Dec 19 9.27pm

There are some FFP reasons why you’d want to extend a players contract, if you’re close to the profit/loss limit.

Extending a player’s contract will mean you can increase their book value ie it will make your balance sheet look better.

Of course, it will cost you wages in cash terms. So it’s not necessarily a great decision, but maybe a case of ‘needs must’.

This could explain the otherwise strange looking extension for Wickham (and to a lesser extent Benteke).

 


Vive le Roy!

CharlesPaterson Flag 02 Dec 19 10.36pm

Originally posted by the.universal

There are some FFP reasons why you’d want to extend a players contract, if you’re close to the profit/loss limit.

Extending a player’s contract will mean you can increase their book value ie it will make your balance sheet look better.

But his contribution has been 20 apps in the last 4 seasons and that's cost us (if rumours are true) 12m in wages alone.

Who is going to pay any sort of money for him, based on that?

Yet someone at the club has decided to pay him a further 3m to stay an extra year and then he can just walk away and retire, makes no sense. I'm baffled.

 


You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Roy Hodgson Q&A 27th November 7pm All Welcome