You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Government cock-up thread 2019-2024
November 21 2026 10.14pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Government cock-up thread 2019-2024


Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
Henry of Peckham Flag Eton Mess 29 Dec 19 2.40pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

By that token football comes under the control of the Ministry of Sport therefore the stupid disallowed goal yesterday is the fault of the Government

Whoever drew that line should have used a thicker pen ... I blame procurement

 


Denial is not just a river in Egypt

derby eagle Flag Derby 29 Dec 19 3.04pm

Originally posted by Cucking Funt

In practice, the elected government, whilst obviously responsible for the civil service, is completely at its mercy. Governments come and go - the civil service is the one constant factor in the mechanism of government itself. All civil service appointments are decided internally and not by ministers. Ministers are advised by their officials and obstructed if the minister disagrees. The convention has always been that the minister takes the credit for success and takes the bullet for civil service f*ck ups.

Never lose sight of the fact that what we see as government policy is in reality civil service policy. Stronger PMs (Thatcher, Wilson etc) have tried to reform it. All have failed.

That is an interesting narrative. So the government decides nothing according to you. That is clearly incorrect by any sort of logical reasoning. Conflating appointments with overall policy direction and decisions, is tendentious at best.

 

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 29 Dec 19 3.11pm

Originally posted by derby eagle

That is an interesting narrative. So the government decides nothing according to you. That is clearly incorrect by any sort of logical reasoning. Conflating appointments with overall policy direction and decisions, is tendentious at best.

On the contrary. Government does decide things. It's just that the people who are doing the deciding are not who you think they are.

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 29 Dec 19 3.41pm

I'm in my forties and have kids. What did I do wrong?

 


Red and Blue Army!

derby eagle Flag Derby 29 Dec 19 4.17pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

I'm in my forties and have kids. What did I do wrong?

I dont know...my guess is whether you had kids or not is unrelated to your possible wrongdoing!

 

derby eagle Flag Derby 29 Dec 19 4.25pm

Originally posted by Cucking Funt

On the contrary. Government does decide things. It's just that the people who are doing the deciding are not who you think they are.

Like I said conflating appointment decisions, practical control and policy decisions is not appropriate. You said, "what we see as government policy is in reality civil service policy". With all due respect, you should split you points into seperate discussions.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 29 Dec 19 5.19pm

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle

There are over 400,000 of them. Is Boris responsible for every mistake they make?

Yes under the principle of collective responsibility.

Personally I think this is a forgettable non event on a quiet news day that will be chip wrap by tomorrow

Much better gaffs to come??

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 29 Dec 19 5.37pm

Originally posted by silvertop

Yes under the principle of collective responsibility.

Personally I think this is a forgettable non event on a quiet news day that will be chip wrap by tomorrow

Much better gaffs to come??

Really? Some clerical officer with two weeks experience makes a mistake and Boris is to blame? They are Her Majesty’s Civil Service so why not blame the Queen? Or Denis Compton.

 

derby eagle Flag Derby 29 Dec 19 5.52pm

Originally posted by silvertop

Yes under the principle of collective responsibility.

Personally I think this is a forgettable non event on a quiet news day that will be chip wrap by tomorrow

Much better gaffs to come??

I dont agree it's a forgettable non event as personal details for such high profile people whatever you think about them, is a security risk.

I agree there will be some bigger howlers to come though. With the proposed changes to the structure of Government planned by Cummings, Brexit and the political power shift transition, it will create a toxic environemnt and the fallout will be highly amusing.

 

derby eagle Flag Derby 29 Dec 19 5.55pm

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle

Really? Some clerical officer with two weeks experience makes a mistake and Boris is to blame? They are Her Majesty’s Civil Service so why not blame the Queen? Or Denis Compton.

So you think a clerical officer is responsible for this? I dont think Johnson has got fingered for this...just yet. Anyway ultimately any leader has to take responsibility for its subordinates.

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 29 Dec 19 6.01pm

Originally posted by derby eagle

So you think a clerical officer is responsible for this? I dont think Johnson has got fingered for this...just yet. Anyway ultimately any leader has to take responsibility for its subordinates.

I think it’s highly unlikely that a Head of Department is responsible for emailing documents, so yes. I do.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 29 Dec 19 6.06pm

Originally posted by derby eagle

So you think a clerical officer is responsible for this? I dont think Johnson has got fingered for this...just yet. Anyway ultimately any leader has to take responsibility for its subordinates.

Quite right and ultimate responsibility must rest with the Queen as head of the Government.

She should be checking up on what the civil servants are doing rather than swanning off for Christmas

 

chris123 Flag hove actually 29 Dec 19 6.13pm

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle

Really? Some clerical officer with two weeks experience makes a mistake and Boris is to blame? They are Her Majesty’s Civil Service so why not blame the Queen? Or Denis Compton.

It's a Cabinet Office cock up.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 29 Dec 19 6.20pm

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle

Really? Some clerical officer with two weeks experience makes a mistake and Boris is to blame? They are Her Majesty’s Civil Service so why not blame the Queen? Or Denis Compton.

Ibdudntvsay he is ACTUALLY to blame. I said he is constitutionally to blame under the convention of collective responsibility. A major civil service gaffe and the wholly blameless ministers head rolls.

I don't make the rules...

 

chris123 Flag hove actually 29 Dec 19 6.22pm

Originally posted by silvertop

Ibdudntvsay he is ACTUALLY to blame. I said he is constitutionally to blame under the convention of collective responsibility. A major civil service gaffe and the wholly blameless ministers head rolls.

I don't make the rules...

Sir Mark Sedwill then.

 

derby eagle Flag Derby 29 Dec 19 6.28pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Quite right and ultimate responsibility must rest with the Queen as head of the Government.

She should be checking up on what the civil servants are doing rather than swanning off for Christmas

Quite bizzare but not surprising! The conversation descending into farce...if only a moderator could sort this out.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 29 Dec 19 7.11pm

Originally posted by derby eagle

Quite bizzare but not surprising! The conversation descending into farce...if only a moderator could sort this out.

Mmmmm...started with it you mean.

No, a leader doesn't just take the wrap for a mistake made by underlings.

A leader takes the wrap for the results of decisions they make.....It's not their fault if a civil servant does A or B.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

derby eagle Flag Derby 29 Dec 19 7.36pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

Mmmmm...started with it you mean.

No, a leader doesn't just take the wrap for a mistake made by underlings.

A leader takes the wrap for the results of decisions they make.....It's not their fault if a civil servant does A or B.

Underlings? Class. A leader should by default take the wrap when it goes wrong and take personal responsibility for success and failure and the actions of their team. If you cannot understand or dissect the exact detail of what is going on in your organisation you probably ain't up to the task, and it would be wise not get that high up the ladder.

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 29 Dec 19 8.11pm

Originally posted by derby eagle

Underlings? Class. A leader should by default take the wrap when it goes wrong and take personal responsibility for success and failure and the actions of their team. If you cannot understand or dissect the exact detail of what is going on in your organisation you probably ain't up to the task, and it would be wise not get that high up the ladder.

Different skill set. Why else do organisations employ specialists?

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 29 Dec 19 8.11pm

Originally posted by derby eagle

Underlings? Class. A leader should by default take the wrap when it goes wrong and take personal responsibility for success and failure and the actions of their team. If you cannot understand or dissect the exact detail of what is going on in your organisation you probably ain't up to the task, and it would be wise not get that high up the ladder.

There are thousands of civil servants you cannot expect the PM or the minister to be personally responsible for their individual mistakes.

I do expect the senior politicians to take responsibility for policy decisions so if they ignore warnings from civil servants e.g. the policy is doing harm or if they fail to act after being warned of systemic failures or cover up I would hold them responsible for that.

Someone pushing a wrong button , no.

 


One more point

Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Government cock-up thread 2019-2024