You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > VAR - a new suggestion?
November 22 2026 7.32pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

VAR - a new suggestion?


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
cryrst Flag The garden of England 11 Jan 20 6.32am

I dont like WH but I think they were harsh for dissalowing their goal last night.
How can you run with your arms down by your side.

 

Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 11 Jan 20 7.15am

Originally posted by cryrst

I dont like WH but I think they were harsh for dissalowing their goal last night.
How can you run with your arms down by your side.

To be fair, VAR got it right last night. It’s the ridiculous new hand ball rule which was the issue. ‘Clear and obvious’ has to be introduced.

I’m just completely sick of it. People now celebrate VAR decisions in their favour and can’t actually properly celebrate goals being scored. All we read about is VAR rather than match analysis.

I’d rather it was just scraped completely as it’s taking a lot enjoyment out of football. Referee injustice is part of the game and can effect the stadium atmosphere in a good way. I’ve always believed the bad decisions will even themselves out over a season.

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 11 Jan 20 7.32am

Originally posted by Goal Machine

To be fair, VAR got it right last night. It’s the ridiculous new hand ball rule which was the issue. ‘Clear and obvious’ has to be introduced.

I’m just completely sick of it. People now celebrate VAR decisions in their favour and can’t actually properly celebrate goals being scored. All we read about is VAR rather than match analysis.

I’d rather it was just scraped completely as it’s taking a lot enjoyment out of football. Referee injustice is part of the game and can effect the stadium atmosphere in a good way. I’ve always believed the bad decisions will even themselves out over a season.

Correct to the law yes but tbh even rice didnt compute at the time that he had done anything out of the ordinary
Last night Oliver should have looked at the screen.
He did for Lukas red.

 

Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 11 Jan 20 3.17pm

Great to see the protest banner from the HF today. Hopefully other fans will see and produce similar.

It worked in our favour today, but that doesn’t cover up the continued farce. 2 mins 33 seconds to make the decision apparently.

 

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 14 Jan 20 7.11am

2 appeals makes perfect sense.

clear and obvious forces one ref to criticise another, or pressures a ref to admit a bad error if they try pitch side review.

I'd like offside to be "full daylight". The game would be better with a goal or two more per match, which is all you'd get. Advantage the attacking team a little.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

dreamwaverider Flag London 17 Jan 20 8.16am

All the players wear an electronic device between their shoulder blades. The ball is electronic. Use these devices as the point to measure and it is full proof. It will eliminate the need for human intervention. The machine willl beep in the refs ear if a player is offside immediately. No looking at screens etc.
Identical to goal line technology. That hasn’t been questioned at all. Football resisted VAR for years when Blatter was at the helm. Now it is being used gingerly. If we are going to use technology then maximise its abilities. Full proof. Just like in the tennis. Nobody ever questions it.
So for offside do this. For fouls etc, like the Meyer tackle I wouldn’t use it. THats what the ref is for. Even when VAR is used it is just a matter of opinion. That’s why we have a ref.

 

stuckinbristol Flag In the woodwork. 20 Jan 20 9.20pm

Why was the Liverpool goal disallowed?
The alleged foul on the keeper that the ref didn't give happened well before the goal was scored.
How far back can they go when checking for infringements?

Edited by stuckinbristol (20 Jan 2020 9.23pm)

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 20 Jan 20 9.48pm

Originally posted by stuckinbristol

Why was the Liverpool goal disallowed?
The alleged foul on the keeper that the ref didn't give happened well before the goal was scored.
How far back can they go when checking for infringements?

Edited by stuckinbristol (20 Jan 2020 9.23pm)

Dermot Gallagher explained (excused) it this morning by saying it was because de Gea had two hands in the ball when he collided with van Dijk so was deemed to be in control of the ball. He then added it’s the same as if the ball is on the ground and the keeper has one hand in it which was news to me - I thought one hand meant the opposing player could still go for it. Live and learn.

 

samprior Flag Hamburg 20 Jan 20 9.55pm

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig

2 appeals makes perfect sense.

clear and obvious forces one ref to criticise another, or pressures a ref to admit a bad error if they try pitch side review.

I'd like offside to be "full daylight". The game would be better with a goal or two more per match, which is all you'd get. Advantage the attacking team a little.

I'm with you on advantage for attacking team.

My suggestion would be if the heel of the furthest forward foot or rear shoulder is level then that is onside. It'd make checks a lot quicker as you're not having to dissalow goals for a toe nail.

I still like VAR in principle and it was always going to be a work in progress. The NFL still votes on rule changes every year and I feel the premier league/ FA need to be more honest with its feedback. I also think overall it will level out big club/ small club decision bias.

Other suggestions I would say is a set limit of how far back in a sequence things are being checked - I'd suggest 4 passes.

Any rules will always create some controversial moments as there will always be some freak examples but in my opinion the areas to address first are rules which will make the speed of decision quicker and eradicate goals being disallowed when a player is 99% level.

Edited by samprior (20 Jan 2020 9.57pm)

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 21 Jan 20 7.55am

I was chatting to a Millwall mate last night his team unfortunately are doing well because he reckons they don't have VAR. He claimed if Millwall were in the PL they would be finding ways to disallow goals to get rid of them asap.

It's funny most fans of small clubs think VAR will benefit them but not Millwall. Anyway here's hoping they stay where they are.

 


One more point

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 22 Jan 20 1.57pm

I can think of many suggestions about where VAR should go.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 19 Feb 20 3.26pm

Wenger is suggesting a change to the offside rule.

[Link]

This will give the advantage back to the striker. According to Talksport there is a meeting of the rules committee next week and this has a real change of passing as Wenger is the official FIFA person for this.

In simple terms if your elbow / hand is offside but the rest of you isn't then it's a goal.

 


One more point

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 19 Feb 20 3.45pm

Originally posted by Badger11

Wenger is suggesting a change to the offside rule.

[Link]

This will give the advantage back to the striker. According to Talksport there is a meeting of the rules committee next week and this has a real change of passing as Wenger is the official FIFA person for this.

In simple terms if your elbow / hand is offside but the rest of you isn't then it's a goal.

It just creates a new measurement that will need to be examined by VAR each time. May mean more goals but probably means even more VAR.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 19 Feb 20 4.01pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

It just creates a new measurement that will need to be examined by VAR each time. May mean more goals but probably means even more VAR.

I await the new proposal with interest.
Wider line ? But flagged offside for a nose being marginally over that wider line? And if that player had a shorter nose he would have been onside.

Edited by Willo (19 Feb 2020 4.06pm)

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 19 Feb 20 4.39pm

Originally posted by Willo

I await the new proposal with interest.
Wider line ? But flagged offside for a nose being marginally over that wider line? And if that player had a shorter nose he would have been onside.

Edited by Willo (19 Feb 2020 4.06pm)

Dont worry too much about it Willo, IfaB have dissmissed any changes in this area at this time. The BBC link that was put up has been edited from 2 stories & merged into 1, coveniently ommiting the bit about IfaB not following thru with concrete change.

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

crvenaeagle Flag 24 Feb 20 12.57am

As I have said before the fact that new technology was brought in without first rewriting any of the rules to comply with it is ludicrous.

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 24 Feb 20 1.02am

Originally posted by Willo

I await the new proposal with interest.
Wider line ? But flagged offside for a nose being marginally over that wider line? And if that player had a shorter nose he would have been onside.

Edited by Willo (19 Feb 2020 4.06pm)

Good job Phil Thompson retired.


 

DutchEagleJohan Flag Vlissingen, Netherlands 24 Feb 20 5.35pm

I think last weekend showed there is more to the refereeing problems then simply VAR and how rules should be interpreted. Simply said: the level of refereeing is atrocious, can anyone ever take David Coote serious again? Even Atkinson who I thought was decent in the past has lost his ways. And the smirking man without a heart Oliver was brave enough to go to the monitor at Selhurst but missing a tackle like that right in front of him is a bad call, then no way would he walk the walk in a high profile league game would he? A missed call that can happen yes, which does not go for the VAR decision.

As for Wenger's idea: it would change nothing at all, just the position where the lines are applied. Why not start with stopping that ridiculous 3D line drawing. Only done in the premier league.

Edited by DutchEagleJohan (24 Feb 2020 5.36pm)

 

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > VAR - a new suggestion?