You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Guita how much?
November 16 2026 5.53am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Guita how much?


Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 02 Jan 20 9.37am

Originally posted by pssguy

Agreed. If Norwich had him rather than Krul they would be in a far better situation. Probably too late now though Newcastle or Bournemouth could be interested.
Guaita to Man City seems highly implausible unless they guarantee him all the Champions League games

Why would Newcastle want him? They have Dubravka who is as good as Guaita.

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 02 Jan 20 7.30pm

Originally posted by JohnB

Last season Hennessey started in goal from first game until Leicester.

In those 16 league games we lost 10 games, drew 3 and won 3.

Guaita came in from Leicester and played 20 games. We lost 6, drew 4 and won 10.

This season we have been ravaged by injuries, scored only 19 goals in 21 games and yet we still have 28 points. Guaita is an absolutely massive part of that.

You can tell me it's tosh all you want, but I still firmly believe with Wayne in goal we'd be about 10 points worse off this season.

It's tosh.

Last season 1st 16 games with Hennesey goals against 21.
After that with Guaita next 16 games goals against 20.

Just one goal difference between them and yet you attribute the early season losses down to Hennessey.

What that tells me is that the defensive record is equal but the attack much better after those first 16 games.

Explain why Watford, just a few games ago were bottom of the league when they have the best keeper in the league in their goal namely Ben Foster. League position is not always down to the keeper.

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

the silurian Flag The garden of England.(not really) 02 Jan 20 7.40pm

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

It's tosh.

Last season 1st 16 games with Hennesey goals against 21.
After that with Guaita next 16 games goals against 20.

Just one goal difference between them and yet you attribute the early season losses down to Hennessey.

What that tells me is that the defensive record is equal but the attack much better after those first 16 games.

Explain why Watford, just a few games ago were bottom of the league when they have the best keeper in the league in their goal namely Ben Foster. League position is not always down to the keeper.


He ISNT the best keeper in the league by a long way!!

 

nead1 Flag 02 Jan 20 7.45pm

I don't think its "tosh" at all. I remember being at the Man city away game and the confidence Guita generates was very visible that day. It has certainly carried on into this season and you can see the confidence the defence has in him. Just look at Norwich yesterday - he was the difference between getting a draw or losing. For a free transfer, he is an incredibly good signing and all credit to those who identified him and then got the deal over the line.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 02 Jan 20 7.48pm

It is hypothetical whether we would have amassed the same number of points this season with Hennessey in goal.
What is evident is that Guaita has performed with admirable aplomb and the plaudits he has received are not misplaced.

Bien hecho al Senor Guaita.

Edited by Willo (02 Jan 2020 7.51pm)

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 02 Jan 20 8.22pm

Originally posted by nead1

I don't think its "tosh" at all. I remember being at the Man city away game and the confidence Guita generates was very visible that day. It has certainly carried on into this season and you can see the confidence the defence has in him. Just look at Norwich yesterday - he was the difference between getting a draw or losing. For a free transfer, he is an incredibly good signing and all credit to those who identified him and then got the deal over the line.

Yup so true

 

JohnB Flag 02 Jan 20 8.30pm

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

It's tosh.

Last season 1st 16 games with Hennesey goals against 21.
After that with Guaita next 16 games goals against 20.

Just one goal difference between them and yet you attribute the early season losses down to Hennessey.

What that tells me is that the defensive record is equal but the attack much better after those first 16 games.

Explain why Watford, just a few games ago were bottom of the league when they have the best keeper in the league in their goal namely Ben Foster. League position is not always down to the keeper.

That would be true except Guaita didn’t play against Liverpool where Hennessey conceded 4 and Burnley where he conceded 1 in those games you’ve counted. So actually my stats were wrong, Guaita played in 2 less games than I credited him for.

Edited by JohnB (02 Jan 2020 8.32pm)

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 02 Jan 20 8.42pm

In fairness Julian Speroni conceded the four against Liverpool. Wayne came of for Guaita against Watford the week before, conceded two and then got injured.

With regard to the main point Guaita has, without any shadow of a doubt, won us a number of points this season.

 

Casual Flag Orpington 02 Jan 20 9.05pm

If we need any player to stay fit for the season it’s him. POTY so far for me. Quality.

 

NickinOX Flag Sailing country. 02 Jan 20 9.27pm

Premier league games last season.

Hennessey: Games 17: Clean sheets 5; Wins 4; Draws 3; Losses 9

Guaita: Games 19: Clean sheets 8; Wins 10; Draws 4; Losses 5

That does not include one shared game where Hennessey replaced an injured Guaita at half time and Palace went from a winning position to losing (Watford).

Also remember that Hennessey had the better defense for most of his time in goal too. I don’t think Hennessey is as bad as some claim but he is certainly not as good as Guaita.

Edited by NickinOX (02 Jan 2020 9.28pm)

 


If you come to a fork in the road, take it.

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 02 Jan 20 10.15pm

Originally posted by the silurian


He ISNT the best keeper in the league by a long way!!

So you know more than the guys who have played at the top level do you? It wasn't my own opinion but what I have read and seen quoted by people who know what they are talking about.The best keepers around based on form this season are De Gea, Alison, Edison, Fabianski, Heaton, Dubravka. Foster and, if you like, Guaita.

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

southnorwoodhill Flag 03 Jan 20 9.36am

Guaita has won two player of the month awards this season. If that doesn't say something about our league position then nothing will.
I'm never in favour of letting our best players go, unless there is an adequate replacement.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 03 Jan 20 9.52am

Originally posted by NickinOX

Premier league games last season.

Hennessey: Games 17: Clean sheets 5; Wins 4; Draws 3; Losses 9

Guaita: Games 19: Clean sheets 8; Wins 10; Draws 4; Losses 5

That does not include one shared game where Hennessey replaced an injured Guaita at half time and Palace went from a winning position to losing (Watford).

Also remember that Hennessey had the better defense for most of his time in goal too. I don’t think Hennessey is as bad as some claim but he is certainly not as good as Guaita.

Edited by NickinOX (02 Jan 2020 9.28pm)

All this stat stuff doesn’t prove anything, it is too dependant on who we are playing and who the defenders are. It’s performance that really counts.
There is no doubt Guaita is the number 1 keeper and Hennessey is an adequate number 2.
Guaita is the best keeper we have had since Martyn, I cannot imagine there are any plans to accept any offer for him.

 

susmik Flag PLYMOUTH -But Made in Old Coulsdon... 03 Jan 20 10.36am

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

It's tosh.

Last season 1st 16 games with Hennesey goals against 21.
After that with Guaita next 16 games goals against 20.

Just one goal difference between them and yet you attribute the early season losses down to Hennessey.

What that tells me is that the defensive record is equal but the attack much better after those first 16 games.

Explain why Watford, just a few games ago were bottom of the league when they have the best keeper in the league in their goal namely Ben Foster. League position is not always down to the keeper.

Here we go again another battle with PZ as no matter who we put in goal and we find that they are better than "Flapper" all the stats come out from PZ trying to convince us he is the best...even though he is just a backup goal keeper. Guaita is by far the more reliable keeper and thus gives our defenders more confidence. As for Ben Foster being the best keeper in the league that is quite laughable.
Mind you bearing in mind that PZ idolizes "flapper" we have no chance on this board of getting any sense out of him.

 


Supported Palace for over 69 years since the age of 7 and have seen all the ups and downs and will probably see many more ups and downs before I go up to the big football club in the sky.

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 03 Jan 20 11.12am

Originally posted by susmik

Here we go again another battle with PZ as no matter who we put in goal and we find that they are better than "Flapper" all the stats come out from PZ trying to convince us he is the best...even though he is just a backup goal keeper. Guaita is by far the more reliable keeper and thus gives our defenders more confidence. As for Ben Foster being the best keeper in the league that is quite laughable.
Mind you bearing in mind that PZ idolizes "flapper" we have no chance on t

You are a fcuking joke. Not once in this thread have I said Hennessey is better than Guaita and the statistics quoted did not originate from me but someone else. It's laugable that someone said Hennnessey had a better defense in front of him when statistics showed the opposite. So you are another
who knows better than people who have played the game at the top level. Ben Foster is as good as Guaita any day according to people who have more knowledge of the game in their little finger than you do in your whole body, it was their opinion I was quoting and not my own.

In future try actually reading the whole thread before jumping in and spouting lies as usual.

FYI our back up keeper will be playing for his country in the European Championships this summer whereas our No 1 will be ??. Just saying.


Edited by PZ Eagle (03 Jan 2020 11.15am)

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 03 Jan 20 11.31am

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

Originally posted by susmik

Here we go again another battle with PZ as no matter who we put in goal and we find that they are better than "Flapper" all the stats come out from PZ trying to convince us he is the best...even though he is just a backup goal keeper. Guaita is by far the more reliable keeper and thus gives our defenders more confidence. As for Ben Foster being the best keeper in the league that is quite laughable.
Mind you bearing in mind that PZ idolizes "flapper" we have no chance on t

You are a fcuking joke. Not once in this thread have I said Hennessey is better than Guaita and the statistics quoted did not originate from me but someone else. It's laugable that someone said Hennnessey had a better defense in front of him when statistics showed the opposite. So you are another
who knows better than people who have played the game at the top level. Ben Foster is as good as Guaita any day according to people who have more knowledge of the game in their little finger than you do in your whole body, it was their opinion I was quoting and not my own.

In future try actually reading the whole thread before jumping in and spouting lies as usual.

FYI our back up keeper will be playing for his country in the European Championships this summer whereas our No 1 will be ??. Just saying.


Edited by PZ Eagle (03 Jan 2020 11.15am)

They have both performed with some aplomb this season and in my humble opinion there is precious little to choose between them based on their performances this campaign.Perhaps Foster has been the busier keeper and the strengths of both players lie in their shot-stopping.

I accept there are those with far more knowledge of the game than I have in my little finger !

 

JohnB Flag 03 Jan 20 11.52am

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

FYI our back up keeper will be playing for his country in the European Championships this summer whereas our No 1 will be ??. Just saying.


Edited by PZ Eagle (03 Jan 2020 11.15am)

Yes and Tom Lockyer will be playing centre back for Wales too, doesn't mean I'd want him over Tomkins who can't get in the national team. -.-'

Edited by JohnB (03 Jan 2020 11.53am)

 

Casual Flag Orpington 03 Jan 20 12.04pm

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

Originally posted by susmik

Here we go again another battle with PZ as no matter who we put in goal and we find that they are better than "Flapper" all the stats come out from PZ trying to convince us he is the best...even though he is just a backup goal keeper. Guaita is by far the more reliable keeper and thus gives our defenders more confidence. As for Ben Foster being the best keeper in the league that is quite laughable.
Mind you bearing in mind that PZ idolizes "flapper" we have no chance on t

You are a fcuking joke. Not once in this thread have I said Hennessey is better than Guaita and the statistics quoted did not originate from me but someone else. It's laugable that someone said Hennnessey had a better defense in front of him when statistics showed the opposite. So you are another
who knows better than people who have played the game at the top level. Ben Foster is as good as Guaita any day according to people who have more knowledge of the game in their little finger than you do in your whole body, it was their opinion I was quoting and not my own.

In future try actually reading the whole thread before jumping in and spouting lies as usual.

FYI our back up keeper will be playing for his country in the European Championships this summer whereas our No 1 will be ??. Just saying.


Edited by PZ Eagle (03 Jan 2020 11.15am)

Edited by Casual (03 Jan 2020 12.26pm)

 

NickinOX Flag Sailing country. 03 Jan 20 12.56pm

Originally posted by Painter

All this stat stuff doesn’t prove anything, it is too dependant on who we are playing and who the defenders are. It’s performance that really counts.
There is no doubt Guaita is the number 1 keeper and Hennessey is an adequate number 2.
Guaita is the best keeper we have had since Martyn, I cannot imagine there are any plans to accept any offer for him.

Who said it did prove something?

Stats do provide information that can reasonably be interpreted. Also, PZ did not provide stats for the whole PL season. I did, as I thought that would provide a more accurate picture.

As I said, I don’t think Hennessey is that bad but I don’t think the stats prove he is just as good as Guaita as PZ has repeatedly implied ignoring all evidence to the contrary.

 


If you come to a fork in the road, take it.

thechaddyboy Flag Peterborough 03 Jan 20 4.21pm

Lost count of the essential saves he's made this season, that & the way he's settled in & adapted to the Palace way he's nigh on priceless for us at the moment. Struck Gold getting him for peanuts, to sell him at the first hint of interest would be crazy in view of being left with Hennessey

 


Red & Blue since 73'

Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Guita how much?