You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Your XI when everyone is back from injury?
November 16 2026 5.35am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Your XI when everyone is back from injury?


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
Charles Flag Forest Hill 20 Jan 20 1.38pm


Guaita

Ward Cahill Tomkins PVA


Townsend Luka Kouyate Riedewald

Ayew Tosun Zaha


Hennessy, Kelly, Schlupp, McArthut, Benteke

McArthur / Kouyate is a hard call. I hope Tosun will kickstart Benteke into making that a harder call but Tosun seems to have a much better instinct for where his team mates are headed. I've included the bench just because I like the look of it so much (I'm even a Hennessy fan; he provides decent cover for a budget club)

 

rollercoaster Flag Cornwall 20 Jan 20 2.30pm

Originally posted by Charles


Guaita

Ward Cahill Tomkins PVA


Townsend Luka Kouyate Riedewald

Ayew Tosun Zaha


Hennessy, Kelly, Schlupp, McArthut, Benteke

McArthur / Kouyate is a hard call. I hope Tosun will kickstart Benteke into making that a harder call but Tosun seems to have a much better instinct for where his team mates are headed. I've included the bench just because I like the look of it so much (I'm even a Hennessy fan; he provides decent cover for a budget club)

sorry, one too many.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 20 Jan 20 2.33pm

Originally posted by Charles


Guaita

Ward Cahill Tomkins PVA


Townsend Luka Kouyate Riedewald

Ayew Tosun Zaha


Hennessy, Kelly, Schlupp, McArthut, Benteke

McArthur / Kouyate is a hard call. I hope Tosun will kickstart Benteke into making that a harder call but Tosun seems to have a much better instinct for where his team mates are headed. I've included the bench just because I like the look of it so much (I'm even a Hennessy fan; he provides decent cover for a budget club)

I'm sorry Charles but I think you've chosen 12 players. who' the unlucky one to bedropped to the bench?

 

aj36094 Flag Derbyshire 20 Jan 20 2.46pm

Guaita

Ward - although replacement is needed in summer
Tompkins
Cahill
PVA

McArthur
Kouyate
McCarthy

Ayew
Tosun
Zaha

I rate Jairo highly but PVA gives someone for Wilf to offload to in front of him when overlapping and Jairo's fast walk/ slow jog when tracking something he won't catch annoys me. Should Jairo play then I would put Schlupp in for McCarthy to add some pace/ threat.

Luka- I don't see what he offers apart from penalties, free kicks are ok and corners lack power.

 

mattteo Flag 20 Jan 20 3.36pm

Just a round up so far:

Goalkeeper- no question, Guaita

Right back: 11 picks for Ward
3 picks for new right back
0 picks for Kelly

Center backs: 15 picks for Tomkins
14 for Cahill
2 for Sakho
0 for Dann or Kelly

Left back: 10 for PVA
4 for Riedewald
0 for Schlupp

Central midfielders: 12 Kouyate
12 McArthur
6 Luka
4 Riedewald
2 McCarthy

Right midfielder: 6 for Townsend
6 for Ayew
3 for Zaha
0 for Meyer


Left midfielder: 12 for Zaha (not really another option here)
1 for PVA
1 for Riedewald
1 for Schlupp

Strikers: 13 for Tosun
5 for Jordan Ayew
1 for Wickham

So it's basically an easy 11 to make, with the only question either Townsend or Luka. If Townsend plays, then Jordan plays centrally. If Luka plays, then Jordan playes in the right and McArthur plays in Jordan's original second striker slot.

If I may say, I think the team would defend even better with Townsend in the team inatead of Luka. Even though Luka is a defensive midfielder, Townsend is faster, presses more and can drop back fast with the opposing players. Luka can be a "wall" for the opposition and knows gow and when to fault, but is easily outran on counter attacks.

Plus, having a left footed player cut on from the right and Zaha cut in from the left means opportunities for fullbacks to go up and create chances. Jordan is right footed. As a right winger, he isn't as suited as Townsend.

And actually playing with 2 hard working and mobile strikers like Jordan Ayew and Tosun should give enough cover for the midfield so that both Kouyate and Luka aren't used at the same time. Either Jordan or Tosun would press and draw back to help. They're not like Benteke. I've seen the Turkish in other matches. He isn't a lazy one

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 20 Jan 20 7.36pm

11 Alan Lee's

 


Red and Blue Army!

Palace Passion Flag Bromley, South London 20 Jan 20 8.38pm

Originally posted by sprites

Really? Completely out of position? He's even slower than Kelly...would get skinned every game!

Really! He did very well at RB for West Ham..

 


|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|||||||||||P|A|L|A|C|E|||||||||||
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||


***Oliver Glasner's RED BLUE ARMY***
Be loud.. Be proud.. Be PALACE!

staffie - missed but never forgotten 19/04/15

sprites Flag Auckland 21 Jan 20 6.20am

Originally posted by coulsdoneagle

That’s why I said for me it does. PVA is our best left back when fit and on form. He has the most going forward and links up with Wilf well. He hasn’t been in form but at the moment he is still our best option.

Luka comes in as he has the best range of passing and can build attacks from the back. While he hasn’t had his best season, the scapegoating of him has hardly been fair. He has frequently had the most forward passes, key passes, and passes in the oppositions half when he plays as well as among the highest tackle rates in our 11. If we can get him back to his best he offers the most going forward other than Macca of our CDM options.

Ayew keeps his place for me, I’d say it’s more a question of Tosun or Townsend for me. Either Tosun up top with Ayew out wide, or Ayew up top with Townsend playing out wide.


On current viewing I’d say yes he is a better option. He had a fantastic match with his back to goal and offered a threat to the goal throughout.

Yeah, all fair points. Only thing I'd disagree with is Tosun/Wickham...but who really knows.

 

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 21 Jan 20 6.50am

I can't answer.

Observations would be that I rate Kelly extremely highly as a centre back. And I'm not as sold as many on Cahill's defensive qualities. Especially in tight situations.

But basically I feel good about all our centre backs when fully fit, although Dann would be bottom of the pecking order.

I think McCarthy will prove our best midfielder if he stays fit. And I'd love to see what Riedewald could do in a passing-minded midfield.

Ayew has probably nosed in front of Townsend out right.

Assuming Riedewald is not going to stay at left back, I feel our distribution from both full-back positions is a profound weakness.

VG, Wilf, Tosun & McCarthy are the four I suspect we'll come to miss most when they're not in it.

EDIT/OBSERVATION: Tosun still has plenty of time to prove himself a dud. I'm imagining he plays as he did v Man City every week.

Edited by Ginger Pubic Wig (21 Jan 2020 6.54am)

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

TheBigToePunt Flag 21 Jan 20 2.26pm

Guaita

Kelly Tomkins Cahill PVA (just)

Luka
Koyaute

Zaha Townend Schlupp

Tosun

I always thought Townsend would be good as a o10. He can shoot from distance quite well, is a decent all round footballer with a very good engine to get back into a five man midfield when we defend but still get up nesar the forward when we attack, and could drift from wing to wing to overload the opposition in wide areas too.

 

taylors lovechild Flag 22 Jan 20 8.32am

Now we have two forwards who are willing to run I would go back to 4-4-2, although against the bigger teams I would probably go 4-5-1 and switch Tosun or Ayew for Kouyate or Luka.

Vicente

Ward Tomkins Cahill PvA

Townsend McArthur McCarthy Wilf

Ayew Tosun


 

Elpis Flag In a pub 22 Jan 20 11.51am

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig

EDIT/OBSERVATION: Tosun still has plenty of time to prove himself a dud. I'm imagining he plays as he did v Man City every week.

Edited by Ginger Pubic Wig (21 Jan 2020 6.54am)

Didn't need plenty of time did he , just 3 days in fact

 

Shifty97 Flag Croydon 22 Jan 20 12.16pm

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

Guaita

Kelly Tomkins Cahill PVA (just)

Luka
Koyaute

Zaha Townend Schlupp

Tosun

I always thought Townsend would be good as a o10. He can shoot from distance quite well, is a decent all round footballer with a very good engine to get back into a five man midfield when we defend but still get up nesar the forward when we attack, and could drift from wing to wing to overload the opposition in wide areas too.

Kelly over Ward?

 

Bangell Flag Oxford 22 Jan 20 12.37pm

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

Now we have two forwards who are willing to run I would go back to 4-4-2, although against the bigger teams I would probably go 4-5-1 and switch Tosun or Ayew for Kouyate or Luka.

Vicente

Ward Tomkins Cahill PvA

Townsend McArthur McCarthy Wilf

Ayew Tosun


Wilf does not have the defensive discipline to play in a 4-4-2 unless he's one of the strikers. Nor would it be an effective use of his talents.

 

Bud Flag 22 Jan 20 12.55pm

Roy’s Team

Goalkeeper

Defender-Defender-Defender-Defender

Defender-Defender-Defender-Defender

Defensive Midfielder

Them hope.
I WISH I WAS WRONG

My Team
Guiata

Ward-Tonks-Sakho-PVA

Luka-Meyer-McArthur

Townsend-Tuson-Zaha

This could change if we ever bring anyone in.
I think our biggest problem area is in midfield we have nothing going forward


Edited by Bud (22 Jan 2020 1.12pm)

 

taylors lovechild Flag 22 Jan 20 2.02pm

Originally posted by Bangell

Wilf does not have the defensive discipline to play in a 4-4-2 unless he's one of the strikers. Nor would it be an effective use of his talents.

You may be right, but he has previously played well in that position and he's hardly set the world on fire in his current role this season.

 

Elpis Flag In a pub 23 Jan 20 9.24am



Guiata

Ward- Cahill Tomkins PVA

Luka McArthur

Townsend Ayew Zaha

Wickham


Edited by Elpis (23 Jan 2020 9.25am)

 

TheBigToePunt Flag 23 Jan 20 7.06pm

Originally posted by Shifty97

Kelly over Ward?

Yeah I think so, just about. There's nothing to choose between them really but kelly can also play centre back pretty well so he gets the nod.

 

TheBigToePunt Flag 23 Jan 20 7.09pm

I tell you what I find interesting: The two most expensive players we've ever signed are barely being mentioned, and are being left out of most of our XIs in favour of far less expensive alternatives.

Just shows you how easy it is to get your fingers burnt in the transfer market, and we are no different.

 

Shifty97 Flag Croydon 23 Jan 20 10.00pm

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

Yeah I think so, just about. There's nothing to choose between them really but kelly can also play centre back pretty well so he gets the nod.

For me I’d pick Ward, Kelly gets beaten quite easily these days and he doesn’t get forward as well as he used to, I think he’s lost a bit of pace

 

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Your XI when everyone is back from injury?