This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Is Cahill our best ever centre back?
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
sprites Auckland 01 Mar 20 7.24pm |
|
|
Personally still think Sakho is a better football player. But Cahill a massive coup for sure.
|
johnmcormick8 Brundish 01 Mar 20 9.12pm |
|
|
And the winning correct is answer
|
deetee 01 Mar 20 9.21pm |
|
|
I will go with Thorn and Young - so solid
|
kennybrowns leftfoot Reigate 02 Mar 20 1.47am |
|
|
Cahill has been superb... even in the twilight of his career you can see he oozes quality... maybe it’s rose tinted glasses but Chris Coleman for me brings back fond memories... in my opinion he was one of our first ‘ball playing’ centre backs’...
He was a lump of a man and a cracking centre back who also could play a bit as well... I haven’t read the whole thread so could be wrong but I’m surprised no one has mentioned him.
Don't waste your time with jealousy. Sometimes your ahead, sometimes your behind, the race is long. But in the end it's only with yourself!!
|
supernaut Armagh 02 Mar 20 6.50am |
|
|
Cahill's definitely one of the best, but for me Jim Cannon.
Supernaut - Ireland's premier Black Sabbath tribute band Facebook: [Link]
Palace Forever!
|
Beastie 02 Mar 20 7.58am |
|
|
I suspect Cahill, Sakho, Tomkins, Dann and Kelly are all up there with best centre-halves the club has ever had.
|
Stirlingsays 02 Mar 20 8.02am |
|
|
Cannon.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)
|
Badger11 Beckenham 02 Mar 20 8.42am |
|
|
Is the correct answer, a player with the most club appearance. Cahill hasn't even completed 1 season so cannot be compared to the legend that is Big Jim Cannon.
One more point
|
Sansbup Norfolk 02 Mar 20 9.30am |
|
|
my vote would go to Craig Moore. He was much like Cahill, oozed class but sadly only stayed one season and I think went back to Rangers.
But Gary Cahill is certainly class, plus huge respect to the others already named in this thread...
Edited by Sansbup (02 Mar 2020 9.33am)
|
Willo South coast - west of Brighton. 02 Mar 20 9.39am |
|
Originally posted by Badger11
Is the correct answer, a player with the most club appearance. Cahill hasn't even completed 1 season so cannot be compared to the legend that is Big Jim Cannon.
Record appearance maker with I think 571 appearances. I saw his debut, when he scored in the Holmesdale goal in a 2-0 victory over Chelsea. It was nice to see Cannon at the Newcastle game looking rather resplendent in a blue suit and tie.
|
crvenaeagle 02 Mar 20 10.22am |
|
|
I've spent the majority of the season stuffed to the bridges on the sofa with humble from the local pie shop. Banged on and on in the summer about how this was a s*** signing that showed no aspiration and we'll suffer for it. D'oh! At least I'm behind a keyboard and can admit it with little to no shame 
Back to winning ways now that's he's back in the team.
|
beak croydon 02 Mar 20 10.44am |
|
Originally posted by doombear
Cahill is very good - a great piece of business in the summer transfer window (as was Ayew). The best ever? I only go back to the early days of Jim Cannon who was immense for us and still gets my vote.
Yes....but the answer is Alan Stephenson who was a Rolls Royce of a centre half.
|
pssguy 02 Mar 20 11.29am |
|
Originally posted by palace chick
But Cahill is still playing as good as ever and is as good / better as any of the centre backs presently playing for England. /quote]
That may well be so - although I doubt if the England manager agrees with you. But the paucity of decent English players currently is of no relevance, logically, as to whether he is out best centre back ever
|
eritheagle Erith 02 Mar 20 12.12pm |
|
Originally posted by sprites
Personally still think Sakho is a better football player. But Cahill a massive coup for sure.
Totally agree with you. I think Sakho is the best centre back outside the top 6 clubs, when he is fit.
Always thought Cahill is overated. I was never impressed with him when he played against us for Chelsea. I agree that he was brilliant on Saturday and has had some other very good performances like at Watford but I haven't been as bowled over with his displays this season as others have been.
|
Palace Passion Bromley, South London 02 Mar 20 12.19pm |
|
|
Gary Cahill is the reason we are not in a relegation battle.
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||| |||||||||||P|A|L|A|C|E||||||||||| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
***Oliver Glasner's RED BLUE ARMY*** Be loud.. Be proud.. Be PALACE!
staffie - missed but never forgotten 19/04/15
|
Ghostship Norfolk 02 Mar 20 1.00pm |
|
|
Cahill is still at 34 a quality defender, I actually think he is one of the best English centre backs in the Premier League although he won't get pick for England now. He is a better defender than Stones, Maguire and quite a few others.
|
ASCPFC Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 02 Mar 20 1.09pm |
|
|
He's especially good considering the way our expansive football and lack of holding midfielders leaves the central defenders so exposed.
Red and Blue Army!
|
Bangell Oxford 02 Mar 20 1.11pm |
|
|
In my relatively short life, Sakho's performances for that half-season when he first arrived at the club were the best example of centre-back play I've ever seen for Palace. He was an absolute beast defensively, and we saw an instant improvement in our play with his balls forward. We beat West Brom in our first or second game and this one centre-back had boosted the level of the whole team.
Unfortunately, injury means he might never get back to that level.
As for Cahill, fantastic, solid defender and a great organiser too. He and Dann don't have much pace between them but have shown in the last couple of games what excellent footballing brains they've got.
|
dynamicdick Dormansland 02 Mar 20 1.16pm |
|
|
and... one Vincente Guaita
Bring back Brolin
|
Uphill Bedford 02 Mar 20 4.34pm |
|
|
One of Cahill's strengths is his leadership.
He brings out the best of the defenders and galvanises the whole team by example.
He is everything that Miliovejic is not and should be given the captaincy.
|