You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > politicians accountability
November 21 2026 10.14pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

politicians accountability


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
Wilesy01 Flag Bristol 16 May 20 3.18pm

Seems as though there are a few objections to my earlier post about the failure of the governments response to this pandemic.

I'll willingly concede I think the Chancellor has a got a lot more right than he has wrong in the current climate, but I'm baffled at the stance that the PM is doing the best with a bad hand. He's compounded the problem by listening to a select group of scientists on the herd immunity approach, and refused to budge on this positon before it was too late and now we've ended up with a particularly high death toll because of it. This, I believe was published in the Times some weeks ago.

As for care homes if anyone wants to correct me on when the government's advice changed regarding local transmission I'm all ears.

This isn't about "blame culture" it's about accountability in a severe situation. I'd like to know why things have got as bad as they have in the UK compared with other European nations such as Germany. Hopefully a public enquiry will bring this to light.

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 16 May 20 4.16pm

Originally posted by Wilesy01

Seems as though there are a few objections to my earlier post about the failure of the governments response to this pandemic.

I'll willingly concede I think the Chancellor has a got a lot more right than he has wrong in the current climate, but I'm baffled at the stance that the PM is doing the best with a bad hand. He's compounded the problem by listening to a select group of scientists on the herd immunity approach, and refused to budge on this positon before it was too late and now we've ended up with a particularly high death toll because of it. This, I believe was published in the Times some weeks ago.

As for care homes if anyone wants to correct me on when the government's advice changed regarding local transmission I'm all ears.

This isn't about "blame culture" it's about accountability in a severe situation. I'd like to know why things have got as bad as they have in the UK compared with other European nations such as Germany. Hopefully a public enquiry will bring this to light.

Care homes are private for a start. I have sympathy for all the dead and poorly but these places charge a fortune and couldnt get their own reserves of PPE. They must have pandemic procedures and all are saying they knew better but still early doors followed the government advice. A bit like after the horse has bolted and let's find a scapegoat for our cock up. Our death toll is high but bearing in mind we are reporting every death where C19 is mentioned on the death cert,even without a test I'm not surprised. Germany are only reporting hospital deaths on tested people. Do you actually beleive that their deaths are 5 times less than ours. Have they got different ventilators or better doctors?
No they havent at all and italy have underreported big style along with spain and others.
You are trying to blame the government and there may be merit in that but we are a long way from the end of this so judging rights and wrongs atm could leave egg on your face come the final SP. I doubt a public enquiry will happen any time soon if ever. It would serve no purpose now or in the future. All it would do is give people even more of a chance to hammer the government. There are lots of secondary repercussions on the back of this and I for one would prefer that time was spent dealing with those than going over something that no one on the planet had any idea how to deal with initially and potentially still dont, bug wise anyway.

 

HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 17 May 20 3.16am

Good post.

Private care homes are run as money making machines.

For any owner to now jump on the PPE bandwagon as if they were an NHS facility is really really annoying.

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

Pete53 Flag Hassocks 18 May 20 4.33pm

It does seem to me that the old constitutional convention of individual ministerial responsibility
( and of course accountability) has been eroded over the years.

Once upon a time it didn't take a lot for a minister to feel obliged to resign if there was any question mark over their honesty, or apparent culpability for a poor decision on an important issue. It was almost a case of assumed guilty until proved innocent.

These days ministers seem to wriggle and squirm their way out of difficult situations and hang on until the PM decides they have become a liability and tells them their time is up.

This is not a good thing as the old deterrent of losing your post if you were caught being deceitful (lying)or just being downright incompetent, did, I think, encourage greater integrity.

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 18 May 20 4.44pm

Originally posted by Pete53

It does seem to me that the old constitutional convention of individual ministerial responsibility
( and of course accountability) has been eroded over the years.

Once upon a time it didn't take a lot for a minister to feel obliged to resign if there was any question mark over their honesty, or apparent culpability for a poor decision on an important issue. It was almost a case of assumed guilty until proved innocent.

These days ministers seem to wriggle and squirm their way out of difficult situations and hang on until the PM decides they have become a liability and tells them their time is up.

This is not a good thing as the old deterrent of losing your post if you were caught being deceitful (lying)or just being downright incompetent, did, I think, encourage greater integrity.

Good point. There is some thought that Profumo lost his job not because of any wrong doing but because he lied about it.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 19 May 20 6.48am

Originally posted by Pete53

Once upon a time it didn't take a lot for a minister to feel obliged to resign if there was any question mark over their honesty, or apparent culpability for a poor decision on an important issue. It was almost a case of assumed guilty until proved innocent.

These days ministers seem to wriggle and squirm their way out of difficult situations

And some like Priti Patel are sacked for dubious behaviour (I'm being polite) and a few short months later get handed one of the top jobs

 

DanH Flag SW2 19 May 20 7.59am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

And some like Priti Patel are sacked for dubious behaviour (I'm being polite) and a few short months later get handed one of the top jobs

Pretty much the entire cabinet are in place due to loyalty rather than ability.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 19 May 20 8.35am

Originally posted by DanH


Pretty much the entire cabinet are in place due to loyalty rather than ability.

And then there's Michael Gove who I assume got his job on the basis of "keeping one's enemies closer still"

 

DanH Flag SW2 19 May 20 8.38am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

And then there's Michael Gove who I assume got his job on the basis of "keeping one's enemies closer still"

Haha yes, I think you’re right there.

 

chris123 Flag hove actually 19 May 20 8.41am

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle

Good point. There is some thought that Profumo lost his job not because of any wrong doing but because he lied about it.

He lied in Parliament.

 

chris123 Flag hove actually 19 May 20 8.42am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

And then there's Michael Gove who I assume got his job on the basis of "keeping one's enemies closer still"

He's competent though.

 

Henry of Peckham Flag Eton Mess 19 May 20 12.43pm

Originally posted by DanH

Pretty much the entire cabinet are in place due to loyalty rather than ability.

It's widespread across the public sector.

Government Departments are run on the same basis ... I was always fascinated by the crony brownnoser/ boss relationships and how they would reap the benefits of accelerated promotion however inept they were. As soon as something went wrong or their idol moved on they would dissipate to the winds never to be seen again.

 


Denial is not just a river in Egypt

Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 19 May 20 2.01pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

And some like Priti Patel are sacked for dubious behaviour (I'm being polite) and a few short months later get handed one of the top jobs

I wouldn’t mind some dubious behaviour with Priti Patel

 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

cryrst Flag The garden of England 19 May 20 6.21pm

Originally posted by Tom-the-eagle

I wouldn’t mind some dubious behaviour with Priti Patel

Tom. Do you get much or are you just a walking talking rampant rabbit

 

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > politicians accountability