You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > One improvement to the game
November 22 2026 7.22pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

One improvement to the game


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 17 Jun 20 10.39am

Originally posted by jeeagles

Stop teams piling everyone behind the ball.

Make them have two players in the opposition half at all times. Like the oposite to offside. To acount for the offside rule make it that a pass played from your own half cannot result in the player recieving the ball being offside.

Should make the game a lot more attacking.

This happening has almost killed football and made most matches not worth watching on tv for me.

 


COYP

Fatherken Flag 17 Jun 20 12.14pm

I agree with the 10min in a sin bin for a yellow card
I think when a injured player ( after a foul )who has to leave so should the player who committed foul

 

Elpis Flag In a pub 17 Jun 20 10.17pm

We should have 3 points for a goal and One point for over the bar or ten yards wide

Yes Christian Im doing it , ..and teams only allowed 3 touches before they have to cross it !

 

Laszlo Panaflex Flag 17 Jun 20 10.37pm

All footballers must have proper names like Alf, Jimmy, or Bob, and proper hairstyles too. Bonus points for RAF-worthy moustaches.

 

kennybrowns leftfoot Flag Reigate 18 Jun 20 3.22am

Completely ban short corners... They have got to be the most pointless things ever and totally infuriate me!!

 


Don't waste your time with jealousy. Sometimes your ahead, sometimes your behind, the race is long. But in the end it's only with yourself!!

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 18 Jun 20 3.00pm

I know the point here is about changing the on pitch rules of the game. I wish they would leave them alone, every season something more ridiculous is introduced, only to be scrapped the next season. The cynic inside me thinks this is just to give Carra and Nevs something to talk about after a 0-0 draw.
Where football should actually change is off the pitch. FFP is b0ll0x and may as well be done away with.
A draft system like NFL would be interesting. But most of all agents, stupid transfer fees and ridiculous wages need to be dealt with somehow but the gutless FA will not do anything. As for the Premier League - they are quite literally representative of everything that is wrong with modern football. But I guess that may take away from big Jim's yellow tie on transfer deadline day (why do we need a deadline? Just to create hype).

 


Red and Blue Army!

JohnB Flag 18 Jun 20 4.59pm

In the spirit of the current world we live in, I think each team should have a minimum of 1 man, 1 woman, 1 gender neutral, 1 homosexual man, 1 lesbian, 1 transgender, 1 black player, 1 asian player, 1 ethinic minority player, 1 disabled player (physical), 1 disabled player (mental), 1 OAP, 1 under 16 and a mascot that in no way shape or form can be offensive to anyone in the world.

Oh and everyone gets a medal at the end of the match, regardless of the result.

Crowd to replace clapping with jazz hands and criticism with messages of love and acceptance. Anyone found tutting should be forced to cuddle an away fan for a minimum of 5 minutes.

Edited by JohnB (18 Jun 2020 5.00pm)

 

Stirlingsays Flag 18 Jun 20 6.14pm

Originally posted by JohnB

In the spirit of the current world we live in, I think each team should have a minimum of 1 man, 1 woman, 1 gender neutral, 1 homosexual man, 1 lesbian, 1 transgender, 1 black player, 1 asian player, 1 ethinic minority player, 1 disabled player (physical), 1 disabled player (mental), 1 OAP, 1 under 16 and a mascot that in no way shape or form can be offensive to anyone in the world.

Oh and everyone gets a medal at the end of the match, regardless of the result.

Crowd to replace clapping with jazz hands and criticism with messages of love and acceptance. Anyone found tutting should be forced to cuddle an away fan for a minimum of 5 minutes.

Edited by JohnB (18 Jun 2020 5.00pm)

Quality post.

Let's get to it.....Which side can win the oppression Premier league?

Edited by Stirlingsays (18 Jun 2020 6.14pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

eaglesfans Flag 18 Jun 20 7.10pm

Reduce the length of a match to 80 minutes BUT time to be controlled by an off pitch time keeper and clock ticks only when the ball is actually in play . Also enforce laws about GK holding ball with hands for more than whatever number of seconds are deemed appropriate

I imagine most matches from official KO time to official end of 80 minutes (not counting half time )might be 100 minutes

would eventually stop ridiculous times wasting late game substitutions
GKs messing over goal kicks .
Delayed thrown ins and free kicks etc etc .

I believe a study was once done re how long the ball is in play for but cannot recall stats ,It could be my 100 minutes guess might be low >

 

eaglesfans Flag 18 Jun 20 7.17pm

re my last post ,Just found this

[Link]

looks like average game is only about 55 Minutes ,So my new law would another 25 minutes of the football we pay to watch

 

Shifty97 Flag Croydon 19 Jun 20 12.57pm

I would make diving a red card offence, allow players to actually tackle without receiving a card and I would give a maximum of 2 minutes for VAR decisions to be made, if it takes longer then it can’t really be a clear and obvious mistake

 

Pete53 Flag Hassocks 20 Jun 20 5.14pm

Some interesting ideas. However, I believe the rules of the game should remain as simple as possible.

The more rules for technical infringements that are added the more complex it becomes, and the harder it would be for referees to keep tabs on all that is happening. It could also mean more stoppages. One of the great attractions of football is that it is fairly easy for the uninitiated to familiarise themelves with the rules of the game. The offside rule probably still provides the biggest challenge.

God forbid football should ever become like rugby union. a sport whose rules I still find largely impenetrable.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 20 Jun 20 5.25pm

Originally posted by eaglesfans

re my last post ,Just found this

[Link]

looks like average game is only about 55 Minutes ,So my new law would another 25 minutes of the football we pay to watch

Follow rugby, clock stops at any stoppage, we may actually see nearer 90 mins of football. Complete overhaul of referees, after watching Rowan Atkinson today this is long overdue

 

YT Flag Oxford 20 Jun 20 5.55pm

Originally posted by JohnB

In the spirit of the current world we live in, I think each team should have a minimum of 1 man, 1 woman, 1 gender neutral, 1 homosexual man, 1 lesbian, 1 transgender, 1 black player, 1 asian player, 1 ethinic minority player, 1 disabled player (physical), 1 disabled player (mental), 1 OAP, 1 under 16 and a mascot that in no way shape or form can be offensive to anyone in the world.

Oh and everyone gets a medal at the end of the match, regardless of the result.

Crowd to replace clapping with jazz hands and criticism with messages of love and acceptance. Anyone found tutting should be forced to cuddle an away fan for a minimum of 5 minutes.

Edited by JohnB (18 Jun 2020 5.00pm)

Do you mean that the starting 11 should include the stated minima? If so, care would be needed over the make-up of the bench. Otherwise clubs could make politically incorrect substitutions eg pull off the homosexual man (so to speak) the lesbian and the Asian disabled person and replace them with 3 Anglo-Saxon males.

On the other hand, if substitutions must be 'like-for-like' then squad sizes will need to be much larger than at present.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

cryrst Flag The garden of England 20 Jun 20 7.43pm

Originally posted by JohnB

In the spirit of the current world we live in, I think each team should have a minimum of 1 man, 1 woman, 1 gender neutral, 1 homosexual man, 1 lesbian, 1 transgender, 1 black player, 1 asian player, 1 ethinic minority player, 1 disabled player (physical), 1 disabled player (mental), 1 OAP, 1 under 16 and a mascot that in no way shape or form can be offensive to anyone in the world.

Oh and everyone gets a medal at the end of the match, regardless of the result.

Crowd to replace clapping with jazz hands and criticism with messages of love and acceptance. Anyone found tutting should be forced to cuddle an away fan for a minimum of 5 minutes.

Edited by JohnB (18 Jun 2020 5.00pm)

That's brighton!

 

pompeyeagle Flag Relocated to Shropshire 20 Jun 20 10.32pm

1. Take time keeping out of the referees responsibility and have a clock like in rugby so everyone knows how long to go, and stop the clock when substitutions are being made so we don’t have this ridiculous process where players are substituted with 30 seconds to go.
2. When a player takes a penalty they should have one go at it like in penalty shootouts, that way it would get rid of the problem of encroachment.
3. When a player is holding someone’s shirt when a corner is being taken it has to be a penalty. Why doesn’t VAR pick up on that?

 

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 21 Jun 20 8.17am

Originally posted by JohnB

In the spirit of the current world we live in, I think each team should have a minimum of 1 man, 1 woman, 1 gender neutral, 1 homosexual man, 1 lesbian, 1 transgender, 1 black player, 1 asian player, 1 ethinic minority player, 1 disabled player (physical), 1 disabled player (mental), 1 OAP, 1 under 16 and a mascot that in no way shape or form can be offensive to anyone in the world.

Oh and everyone gets a medal at the end of the match, regardless of the result.

Crowd to replace clapping with jazz hands and criticism with messages of love and acceptance. Anyone found tutting should be forced to cuddle an away fan for a minimum of 5 minutes


Edited by JohnB (18 Jun 2020 5.00pm)

&#128514;

 

crvenaeagle Flag 21 Jun 20 11.32am

An extra, smaller, circular goal should be attached the top of the crossbar. If scored in, klaxons go off and 12 extra balls get fed into the pitch for 5 (added) minutes.
An alternative option is that a pack of French Bulldogs also get released.

 

jeeagles Flag 29 Jun 20 8.30pm

Not against drinks break. It should be beer in the first half and shots in the second half.

Players should be forced to eat Lunch at half time as well.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 30 Jun 20 1.05pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

Not against drinks break. It should be beer in the first half and shots in the second half.

Players should be forced to eat Lunch at half time as well.

They do in cricket, not sure why football should be any different.

 

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > One improvement to the game