You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > VAR at its worst
November 22 2026 7.13pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

VAR at its worst


Page 2 of 7 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 17 Jun 20 10.22pm

Originally posted by Phil’s Barber

That’s not what cryst is stating. The information is that the cameras and GLT worked but there was failure in transmitting the decision to the referee.

The second statement is wrong as thirty seconds basic research on the internet reveals countless GLT errors...non goals given incorrectly and perfectly good goals not given. The French top league even suspended its use in 2018 after repeated errors.

[Link]

I am only relaying the comments from 'Hawkeye' who stated that it was the first time such an error had occurred in more than 9,000 matches using the system.
I don't know if the French League use 'Hawkeye'.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 17 Jun 20 10.25pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Haha, the camera that picked up the shot of the keeper holding the ball against the post inside of the goal was pretty perfect. All the VAR ref had to do was say to the ref. “The ball was over the line, do you want to award a goal or did you see something to rule it out?”

This was not one of the 7 cameras used by 'Hawkeye' to determine whether the ball has crossed or not crossed the line as 'Hawkeye' have stated that the views of cameras used as part of the system were obscured.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 17 Jun 20 10.44pm

Harsh on Sheffield Utd.

BLADES DON’T MATTER

 


COYP

Superhorns3 Flag Harpdenden 17 Jun 20 11.02pm

Originally posted by Phil’s Barber

As has been said already, farcical all round.

Jobsworths sticking to the "rules" rather than using common sense I guess .

Even Dean Smith accepted it was a goal.

 

Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 17 Jun 20 11.29pm

Originally posted by Willo

I am only relaying the comments from 'Hawkeye' who stated that it was the first time such an error had occurred in more than 9,000 matches using the system.
I don't know if the French League use 'Hawkeye'.

So which is it?

Do we know whether Hawkeye was ‘obscured’ and couldn’t detect the goal or the goal was correctly detected but there was a failure in the technology to relay it to the referee? Both cannot be right.

I’d be massively concerned if Hawkeye are saying ALL of their cameras were obscured simply because of the goalposts?!? and two players being in the way! The posts are always there and there will be plenty of scenarios when two players are on the goal line...most corners for instance.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 17 Jun 20 11.41pm

Originally posted by Phil’s Barber

So which is it?

Do we know whether Hawkeye was ‘obscured’ and couldn’t detect the goal or the goal was correctly detected but there was a failure in the technology to relay it to the referee? Both cannot be right.

I’d be massively concerned if Hawkeye are saying ALL of their cameras were obscured simply because of the goalposts?!? and two players being in the way! The posts are always there and there will be plenty of scenarios when two players are on the goal line...most corners for instance.

I have not heard any official explanation that the issue was a relaying of the information to the referee's watch.

Hawkeye have asserted that views of the cameras were obscured not just by the goalpost but the goalkeeper and defender.Hawkeye uses 14 cameras, 7 pointing towards each goal.

I am not totally 'Au Fait' with the technological intracacies of the system other than it uses 'Triangulation' but the general consensus has been that it's introduction has been a success and a welcome addition.

Edited by Willo (17 Jun 2020 11.48pm)

 

HeathMan Flag Purley 18 Jun 20 12.04am

A crowd reaction was missing, so that Michael Oliver did not get the assistance he would usually receive. Cannot imagine a full Holmesdale Stand no giving the required help. Perhaps supporters panels (a few from each side) could help. COYP

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 18 Jun 20 7.17am

Ironic this is the first failure in it's use in England.

The alternate system that FIFA favoured and was used in Europe had lots of failures not sure if that is still used.

It's hard luck on Sheffield United who seem to get the worst end of VAR decisions. That said I prefer to think of all the correct decisions that Hawkeye has made rather than the one mistake.

 


One more point

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 18 Jun 20 8.21am

I think it’s more of an embarrassment for the system and the rule makers of the game that the VAR officials couldn’t intervene. The whole point of VAR is to rule out serious errors in the game. If anything is clear it is that this was a serious error and a game changing decision. If I was a Blades fan I’d be pretty pissed as that result would have put them above Manure and in the Euro slots.

 

crystalsteve Flag Colwyn Bay 18 Jun 20 8.51am

... and what was the lino doing, has he (or she!) not have a say on these matters as they used to have before GLT?

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 18 Jun 20 9.18am

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

I think it’s more of an embarrassment for the system and the rule makers of the game that the VAR officials couldn’t intervene. The whole point of VAR is to rule out serious errors in the game. If anything is clear it is that this was a serious error and a game changing decision. If I was a Blades fan I’d be pretty pissed as that result would have put them above Manure and in the Euro slots.

Excellent point surely the VAR team have seen that the ball was over line?

 


One more point

chris123 Flag hove actually 18 Jun 20 9.25am

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

I think it’s more of an embarrassment for the system and the rule makers of the game that the VAR officials couldn’t intervene. The whole point of VAR is to rule out serious errors in the game. If anything is clear it is that this was a serious error and a game changing decision. If I was a Blades fan I’d be pretty pissed as that result would have put them above Manure and in the Euro slots.

The referee should have got an error message and then gone to VAR.

 

Superhorns3 Flag Harpdenden 18 Jun 20 9.38am

Seems VAR isn't allowed to get involved ..

I sure some common sense could have been applied though as it was clearly over the line.

[Link]

Edited by Superhorns3 (18 Jun 2020 9.39am)

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 18 Jun 20 11.04am

It's such a surprise that:
1. This helps Man Utd
2. This helps Man Utd

 


Red and Blue Army!

Spiderman Flag Horsham 18 Jun 20 11.18am

Originally posted by cryrst

To be fair it's the first mistake it's Made I think, from what must be a fair few and it didnt actually make a mistake in the decision. The software and connectivity let it down. The actual GLT is good, bluetooth is the problem me thinks.

Agree. I like GLT, the biggest issue here is why can VAR not get involved? Surely the ref should be able to ask for assistance if there is some doubt. Very poor.
Villa players knew it was a goal, didn’t they benefit last season when Bielsa insisted his team allowed them to score? I suppose too much is at stake for sportsmanship to kick in

 

Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 18 Jun 20 4.08pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

I think it’s more of an embarrassment for the system and the rule makers of the game that the VAR officials couldn’t intervene. The whole point of VAR is to rule out serious errors in the game. If anything is clear it is that this was a serious error and a game changing decision. If I was a Blades fan I’d be pretty pissed as that result would have put them above Manure and in the Euro slots.

Agreed, all valid points.

 

Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 18 Jun 20 4.17pm

Originally posted by crystalsteve

... and what was the lino doing, has he (or she!) not have a say on these matters as they used to have before GLT?

I don’t think the positioning or concentration levels, by the assistant referees, for this type of decision, is anything like what it used to be. They rely too heavily on the (flawed) technology nowadays and they just aren’t alert enough or focused on this type of thing. I’d include penalty decisions here too as they know the technology is there to take the responsibility off their hands.

We’ve seen a similar thing with ‘No balls’ in cricket and the umpire relying on the technology post event, rather than focusing like they used to, at the point of delivery.

 

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 09 Jul 20 5.58pm

Important VAR news!!

The Premier League have lost control of the Video Assistant Referee after FIFA took full control of the technology protocol.

The VAR supremo will be none other than Pierluigi Collina, remember him? The bald italian ref regularly officiated in the top games, only retired because of age.

He will want everything to be uniform.......

That means referees consulting pitch-side monitors which we have not seen here.

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 09 Jul 20 6.16pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

Important VAR news!!

The Premier League have lost control of the Video Assistant Referee after FIFA took full control of the technology protocol.

The VAR supremo will be none other than Pierluigi Collina, remember him? The bald italian ref regularly officiated in the top games, only retired because of age.

He will want everything to be uniform.......

That means referees consulting pitch-side monitors which we have not seen here.

About time. Collins was a good ref, in addition to which he had a stare which could curdle milk.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 09 Jul 20 6.17pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

Important VAR news!!

The Premier League have lost control of the Video Assistant Referee after FIFA took full control of the technology protocol.

The VAR supremo will be none other than Pierluigi Collina, remember him? The bald italian ref regularly officiated in the top games, only retired because of age.

He will want everything to be uniform.......

That means referees consulting pitch-side monitors which we have not seen here.

Apart from the other night in the Leicster game.

I put my trust in Collina rather than FIFA.

 


One more point

Page 2 of 7 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > VAR at its worst