You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Our elderly squad...
November 16 2026 5.35am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Our elderly squad...


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
Elpis Flag In a pub 05 Jul 20 10.22am

Its not as if the team is old individually but yes it is old collectively . They all have at least another two /three years in the tank yet so my thoughts are don't panic yet .

A gradual replacement programme should be in place with a young non goalscoring centre forward ,wingers who cant cross a ball and some good defensive midfielders the priority

 

PatrickA Flag London 05 Jul 20 12.29pm

Not sure I’d trust Hodgson to choose a new striker.
He was desperate for us to get Solanke after all.
He was also keen to offload Sorloth who has scored around as many goals this season as our entire team put together (yes, I know in a weaker league).

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 05 Jul 20 1.01pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

Not sure I’d trust Hodgson to choose a new striker.
He was desperate for us to get Solanke after all.
He was also keen to offload Sorloth who has scored around as many goals this season as our entire team put together (yes, I know in a weaker league).

On loan.

We pulled out when Liverpool wanted a permanent deal and Eddie Howe went and spunked £19m on him.

Sorloth ? I would contend that the decision was made based upon training as well as match performances. It was also Hodgson's buy so although it didn't work out at that time with Palace, the guy clearly has something which Hodgson spotted.

We did however spend £2m on Jordan Ayew - that turned out ok from where I'm sitting.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

PatrickA Flag London 05 Jul 20 1.25pm

Some are convinced Hodgson can do no wrong so I'm giving up trying and starting a campaign for him to become England manager again.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 05 Jul 20 1.49pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

Some are convinced Hodgson can do no wrong so I'm giving up trying and starting a campaign for him to become England manager again.

I'm not sure it's that, I think it's basically that relegation has seemed unlikely, whilst our squad is poor. So Roy must be doing something right.
However, if we don't get category 1 academy status and we don't get ground improvements, plus we don't win even a cup (or even try to), what will be the point in this Premier League spell? I'm suspecting we will be looking nostagically at this period when we are in the Championship in a few years time.

 


Red and Blue Army!

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 05 Jul 20 2.00pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

I'm not sure it's that, I think it's basically that relegation has seemed unlikely, whilst our squad is poor. So Roy must be doing something right.
However, if we don't get category 1 academy status and we don't get ground improvements, plus we don't win even a cup (or even try to), what will be the point in this Premier League spell? I'm suspecting we will be looking nostagically at this period when we are in the Championship in a few years time.


'O the good old days' we will be saying as we struggle to retain our position in the Championship.

 

palace99 Flag New Mills 06 Jul 20 12.40pm

our ageing squad is a real concern and shows a number of issues - lack of transfer strategy, poor contract negotiation and a lack of academy players coming through.

Transfer strategy. Why buy a 28 year old defensive mifdielfer, McCarthy, last summer when we already had 4 or so defensive mids in the squad?
Cahill was less of issue as we had injuries in that position and he was a free.
Event he Sakho purchase a few years ago was a strange one. SP bought him when we didn't have a manager - he was already 27/28 on big wages and we know he was injury prone and likely to make bizarre errors. He hasn't disproved either of those traits.

Contracts - why give a 5 year contract to a 29 year old? Surely 3 or 4 years tops. We did this for both Punch and Dann. A new contract for Tomkins when he still has 2 years to go? 4 years for Luka at 28, same for Jimmy that has subsequently be extended.
I have no issue in playing older players but would like them on shorter contracts. I notice we still have Ryan Inniss on our books - he's 25 now and has never made a league appearance. Surely he should have gone years ago

Academy - very few are getting through, it's as simple as that. Maybe that's why Richard Shaw left. Hopefully Mitchell can make an impact,which would be great.

Hopefully next year we will have Ferguson on the right, Mitchell on the left and maybe Gallagher from Chelsea on loan, plus a young striker for the bench

 

slubglurge Flag welling 06 Jul 20 4.54pm

Originally posted by doombear


'O the good old days' we will be saying as we struggle to retain our position in the Championship.

There are a few clubs who have stayed in the Prem for a while and thought they had cracked it. Fulham, Wigan and Clowns come to mind. A club like ours will never be classed as a permanet Prem club, we just aren't the type

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 06 Jul 20 8.09pm

Originally posted by slubglurge

There are a few clubs who have stayed in the Prem for a while and thought they had cracked it. Fulham, Wigan and Clowns come to mind. A club like ours will never be classed as a permanet Prem club, we just aren't the type

We suffer from being a London club:

1. Arsenal / Spurs / Chelsea
2. West Ham
3. Palace / Watford

We are probaly the 5th biggest club in London. If any of the above are interested in a player chances are they will get him first as bar Watford they are bigger clubs.

It's always going to be difficult unless we get lucky with our scouting or an owner who has deep pockets.


 


One more point

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Our elderly squad...