You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Are we better than when we were promoted?
November 16 2026 5.35am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Are we better than when we were promoted?


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
jeeagles Flag 06 Jul 20 11.08am

I'm not sure like for like wages or vaule of the squad is a easy comparison as wages and transfer fee inflation is always huge.

Comparing the team we went up with to the current side:

Speroni, Ward, Moxey, Gabbidon, Delaney, Jedinak, KG, Garvin, Williams, Zaha, Wilbriham

to;

Guaita, Ward, PVA, Sakho, Cahill, Riedewald, Milivojevic, McArthur, Ayew, Zaha, Benteke.

I'd say we've got better quality in most positions and better strenght in depth.

If the starting 11 in the side we were promited with were fit all season (swapping Bolasie, Moritz, and Murray). We might have got automatic promotion. We just had no strenght in depth at all. It was a fairly high risk stratergy which worked over the season.

Guaita is better than an ageing Speroni.

PVA, Sakho and Cahill are better than Moxey, Gabbidon and Delaney. Dann, Tompkins, Kelly, and Schlupp are far better the Ramags, Parr, and Jaz Richards.

We only really had O'Keefe as a back up holding midfielder, now we have Kayoute and McCarthy.

Mayer, is possibly an upgrade on Jonny Williams, Garvin and Moritz. Who can really tell though we never use them.

Would have Bolasie back (in his prime) compaired to Townsend/Ayew/Schlup.

Murray is better than Benteke, with Phillips as a back up and Willibraham as a last resort.

It looks as though we've invested too much in centre backs and holding midfielders and not given ourselves many attacking options. Was adding Cahill, Kayoute, McCarthy to the squad a good idea when we were desperately weak in other areas?

 

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 06 Jul 20 11.29am

Difficult comparison as quite rightly fans expectations have gone up. However we did remarkably well to stay up that first season, particularly after Ollie's sweet shop raid in the transfer market at the
beginning and being just promoted. As we started this season without this type of difficulty and knowing where our issues on the field were, we really should of done better attacking wise this seaason. Whilst the transfer system is a complicated beast to manipulate I find it hard to feel that this season in 2 windows we couldn't find a player meeting our monetary requirements and who the present manager was willing to play ? Feel something has to change there in the future because if the defense starts to creek we will be up to our heads in it. Commentator mentioned on Saturday that we had scored only 9 goals in the 1st half all season, 2 were recently at Bournemouth !?!

Edited by Booted Eagle (06 Jul 2020 11.34am)

Edited by Booted Eagle (06 Jul 2020 11.36am)

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

Canterbury Palace Flag Whitstable 06 Jul 20 12.06pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

Well when we got promoted, we had Ian Holloway as our manager. Just stop and think about that one for a moment ! Add in the players that we were able to attract to the club at that time - a multitude of mediocrity. Since then we have signed a far higher calibre of player.So yes, we are better than when we were promoted.

People will always find something to moan about. But I have been supporting Palace since 1967 and I am celebrating the fact that we have retained our Premier League status for 8 consecutive years. For a club of our size I see that as a real achievement.

It's very easy to point fingers at the way the club is being run and of course mistakes have been made, but I think overall Steve Parish has done a great job.

There are some challenges ahead in terms of the short term managerial situation and a squad in need of refreshing, but I believe these issues have been recognised and will be addressed.


We're in agreement that the playing squad are significantly better now, player for player, reflecting the higher wages being paid. But with that in mind do you not think that progress should be reflected in some way, whether in our league position or how competitive we are on a match to match basis?

CPFC2010 and Steve Parish are the best things to have happened to this club, it's beyond dispute. This is the most successful period in the history of the club and I'm hugely grateful to them for saving us.

However, saying that shouldn't come with the caveat of abandoning all ambition for future progress. The bottom line is that we are spending more and achieving the same as we were 8 years ago whereas clubs like Burnley, Newcastle, Wolves and Sheffield United are all achieving more than us despite having been in the Championship more recently and on more modest budgets.

In the Championship there was always the chance that we might win promotion. With the Premier League sneaking into the Europa League or winning a cup probably represents the ceiling of what we can achieve. We had a genuine chance to achieve the former this season and I suppose I'm just disappointed that, barring a miracle, we've blown it and the the opportunity will probably go to one of a number of clubs that I don't view as being particularly bigger than us.

 


We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...

Canterbury Palace Flag Whitstable 06 Jul 20 12.10pm

Originally posted by kennybrowns leftfoot

I totally agree with you Canterbury and thank you for your original post to.. Very informative and must have taken some research and effort so fair play..

Like you I'm of the opinion that surely no fan secretly wants us relegated??.. However in this day an age who knows how bizarre some people think!!

It's interesting recent threads/comments etc.. The majority of my mates are Chelsea fans and when I've raised concerns about RH and how we play they can't get there heads round it and the stock answer is 'better the devil you know' and Hodgson does a job for us... Obviously I can't get them to come and watch what us Palace fans watch week in week out!!

Are we better than our 1st season??.. Individual player wise without a doubt but I like you have serious concerns at where our club is heading and the football (or lack of) we are playing.

How much more can a 72 year old offer us??.. His total disregard of any player (bar wilf) who has some flair to his game is very concerning for me.


Ah thank you. It's concerning and, as much as I like and admire Roy, I feel like three seasons of steadying the ship is enough and now we should have bigger ambitions if we're not going to be left behind.

The fact that we have the oldest squad in the division is very significant to me and an extra year on some of those aging legs will make a huge difference. We desperately need some fresh faces next season.

 


We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 06 Jul 20 12.18pm

Originally posted by Canterbury Palace


We're in agreement that the playing squad are significantly better now, player for player, reflecting the higher wages being paid. But with that in mind do you not think that progress should be reflected in some way, whether in our league position or how competitive we are on a match to match basis?

CPFC2010 and Steve Parish are the best things to have happened to this club, it's beyond dispute. This is the most successful period in the history of the club and I'm hugely grateful to them for saving us.

However, saying that shouldn't come with the caveat of abandoning all ambition for future progress. The bottom line is that we are spending more and achieving the same as we were 8 years ago whereas clubs like Burnley, Newcastle, Wolves and Sheffield United are all achieving more than us despite having been in the Championship more recently and on more modest budgets.

In the Championship there was always the chance that we might win promotion. With the Premier League sneaking into the Europa League or winning a cup probably represents the ceiling of what we can achieve. We had a genuine chance to achieve the former this season and I suppose I'm just disappointed that, barring a miracle, we've blown it and the the opportunity will probably go to one of a number of clubs that I don't view as being particularly bigger than us.

Wolves 'Net spend' over the last two seasons has been nigh on £165 Mill.
Sheff Utd 'Net spend' this season has been just over £60 Mill.
Newcastle this season spent around £56 Mill on Joelinton and Saint-Maximin.

Edited by Willo (06 Jul 2020 12.18pm)

 

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Are we better than when we were promoted?