You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Man City Ban overturned
November 22 2026 7.22pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Man City Ban overturned


doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 13 Jul 20 9.42am

Well that was a surprise

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 13 Jul 20 10.36am

Reading the BBC website the CAS report said that some of the more serious charges were time barred I assume they meant there was a statute of limitations. They then go on to confirm that UEAFA were correct that City failed to co-operate with the investigation but that didn't warrant a ban in itself.

So if I understand correctly if you do something wrong your lawyers will advise you not to co-operate and drag the investigation out for as long as possible and eventually the charges will be dropped as time has run out.

I believe they call this the Julian Assange defence.

[Link]

Edited by Badger11 (13 Jul 2020 10.37am)

 


One more point

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 13 Jul 20 6.33pm

Originally posted by Badger11

Reading the BBC website the CAS report said that some of the more serious charges were time barred I assume they meant there was a statute of limitations. They then go on to confirm that UEAFA were correct that City failed to co-operate with the investigation but that didn't warrant a ban in itself.

So if I understand correctly if you do something wrong your lawyers will advise you not to co-operate and drag the investigation out for as long as possible and eventually the charges will be dropped as time has run out.

I believe they call this the Julian Assange defence.

[Link]

Edited by Badger11 (13 Jul 2020 10.37am)

I bet no backhanders were involved. Those mansions in Monaco are simply coincidental.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 13 Jul 20 10.28pm

Look on the bright side, it’s going to keep Tottenham or Arsenal or both out of Europe if we are lucky.

 

leejaneagles Flag 14 Jul 20 10.55am

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Look on the bright side, it’s going to keep Tottenham or Arsenal or both out of Europe if we are lucky.

As a Palace fan with no hope of Europe, I don't see this as a silver lining to be honest.

Most weekends, I'm bemoaning the diving/cheating/getting in ref's face way that the top clubs go about their Business and I hate that Palace will never be there.

But there's a sweet spot in middle of the season where on a Tuesday/Wednesday/Thursday night, a Competition that has absolutely nothing to do with Palace ore relegation is on and I can just have a few beers and root for an English side because, well, it's still okay to be patriotic and hope an English Team does better than another Country from time to time, no matter how many people seem to hate being English recently!

I'd rather watch a good Arsenal or Tottenham with more chance to go far in a Competition play good football than a Burnley or Sheffield United be cannon-fodder. What's more, even if one of those 2 clubs go on a good run in Europe, I still don't get excited about coming home after work mid-week and watching Sheffield. I'd rather watch Tottenham/Inter or Arsenal/Dortmund for example.

Of course if it was Palace that forced their way into that spot, I'd be overjoyed and buzzing to see a lower league Team try Europe midweek. Does that make me a hypocrite? Yes. I'm a football fan.

 

crvenaeagle Flag 14 Jul 20 1.16pm

Money talks

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 14 Jul 20 2.04pm

Haha, as a reward to Pep and in light of their escape with penalties from UEFA regarding FFP, the Board are going to give Pep £150m to bolster his squad. You couldn't make it up! As you say Crvenaeagle, money talks.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 14 Jul 20 2.09pm

Originally posted by leejaneagles

As a Palace fan with no hope of Europe, I don't see this as a silver lining to be honest.

Most weekends, I'm bemoaning the diving/cheating/getting in ref's face way that the top clubs go about their Business and I hate that Palace will never be there.

But there's a sweet spot in middle of the season where on a Tuesday/Wednesday/Thursday night, a Competition that has absolutely nothing to do with Palace ore relegation is on and I can just have a few beers and root for an English side because, well, it's still okay to be patriotic and hope an English Team does better than another Country from time to time, no matter how many people seem to hate being English recently.

I'd rather watch a good Arsenal or Tottenham with more chance to go far in a Competition play good football than a Burnley or Sheffield United be cannon-fodder. What's more, even if one of those 2 clubs go on a good run in Europe, I still don't get excited about coming home after work mid-week and watching Sheffield. I'd rather watch Tottenham/Inter or Arsenal/Dortmund for example.

Of course if it was Palace that forced their way into that spot, I'd be overjoyed and buzzing to see a lower league Team try Europe midweek. Does that make me a hypocrite? Yes. I'm a football fan.

I disagree, I think its great that there are other teams getting a chance to play Euro football and I think it makes a refreshing change to not see teams who think they deserve to be in Europe just because of previous seasons successes. If the traditional top 6 had it their way they would not have to qualify for european football at all and that situation would not be good for football.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 14 Jul 20 2.16pm

UEAFA have to decide what FFP actually means then they can redraw the rules accordingly.

I think FFP should be about stopping clubs buying success then going bust and owing money.

On that basis I am fine with Man City and their mega rich owner pumping money into the club, maybe it will be Palace one day.

UEAFA seem to think that FFP is about protecting the elite well established clubs by pulling up the ladder behind them.

 


One more point

leejaneagles Flag 14 Jul 20 4.01pm

Originally posted by Badger11

UEAFA have to decide what FFP actually means then they can redraw the rules accordingly.

I think FFP should be about stopping clubs buying success then going bust and owing money.

On that basis I am fine with Man City and their mega rich owner pumping money into the club, maybe it will be Palace one day.

UEAFA seem to think that FFP is about protecting the elite well established clubs by pulling up the ladder behind them.


In defence of UEFA here, they did try to ban City from European Competition for 2 seasons which would've sent a clear message to the whole football world - you cannot buy success.

It would've stopped the Newcastle deal as it looks likely they'll be the new PSG and as someone mentioned above, it would have meant City won't just throw £150 million at the Summer transfer window to have the Title sewn up by February. They are already in better form than Liverpool and Liverpool are restricted who they can buy in the Summer, so an injury to the front 3 combined with City spending £150 million will make the league an absolute farce and snore-fest again.

It was this weird independent Body that made UEFA look like fools. Now no one will ever take them seriously again or comply with their Searches. They basically need to avoid UEFA and be as unhelpful as possible until the statute of limitations passes and the random Independent Body clears them.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 14 Jul 20 5.14pm

Originally posted by leejaneagles


In defence of UEFA here, they did try to ban City from European Competition for 2 seasons which would've sent a clear message to the whole football world - you cannot buy success.

It would've stopped the Newcastle deal as it looks likely they'll be the new PSG and as someone mentioned above, it would have meant City won't just throw £150 million at the Summer transfer window to have the Title sewn up by February. They are already in better form than Liverpool and Liverpool are restricted who they can buy in the Summer, so an injury to the front 3 combined with City spending £150 million will make the league an absolute farce and snore-fest again.

It was this weird independent Body that made UEFA look like fools. Now no one will ever take them seriously again or comply with their Searches. They basically need to avoid UEFA and be as unhelpful as possible until the statute of limitations passes and the random Independent Body clears them.

Do you mean CAS? I don't think they are weird at all they are a legal body the fault lies with UEFA rules. I am not surprised that City got away with it. Practically every time Football rules are tested in a court of law they are found wanting e.g. Bosman ruling.

It is quite clear from the judgement that CAS did not clear City completely but they can only go by the rules that UEFA set which obviously had loopholes that City exploited.

 


One more point

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 15 Jul 20 2.09pm

The football authorities do not have the money to challenge the super rich clubs head on in the courts.
No one on the gravy train stands to gain from it anyway.

They might as well scrap Fairplay rules if they are not enforceable and replace them with a simpler system that can be enforced to keep the playing field as level as possible.
Trouble is that the media companies that pump so much money into football want the big clubs doing well so they can sell more advertising. They hate it when there are smaller clubs are in the PL.

Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (15 Jul 2020 2.09pm)

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 15 Jul 20 2.32pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

The football authorities do not have the money to challenge the super rich clubs head on in the courts.
No one on the gravy train stands to gain from it anyway.

They might as well scrap Fairplay rules if they are not enforceable and replace them with a simpler system that can be enforced to keep the playing field as level as possible.
Trouble is that the media companies that pump so much money into football want the big clubs doing well so they can sell more advertising. They hate it when there are smaller clubs are in the PL.

Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (15 Jul 2020 2.09pm)

PSG already got away with it as well so it is obviously a pointless set of rules. It basically only seems to serve as an excuse for Teams such as us to not buy anyone. And FFP only seems to apply to small teams making the whole idea of it useless and not fit for purpose.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 15 Jul 20 3.26pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

The football authorities do not have the money to challenge the super rich clubs head on in the courts.
No one on the gravy train stands to gain from it anyway.

They might as well scrap Fairplay rules if they are not enforceable and replace them with a simpler system that can be enforced to keep the playing field as level as possible.
Trouble is that the media companies that pump so much money into football want the big clubs doing well so they can sell more advertising. They hate it when there are smaller clubs are in the PL.

Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (15 Jul 2020 2.09pm)

I agree keep it simple and focus on stopping clubs going bust.

You could insist that clubs do the following on time:

Produce annual accounts

Pay the tax man

Pay players and staff

Pay transfers fees owed.

Etc.

If they are late then hit them with sanctions which increase in severity including withholding their license to play football. Once clubs get the idea they will get themselves in order because payers will not sign for clubs in that mess.

 


One more point

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 16 Jul 20 11.47am

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

The football authorities do not have the money to challenge the super rich clubs head on in the courts.
No one on the gravy train stands to gain from it anyway.

They might as well scrap Fairplay rules if they are not enforceable and replace them with a simpler system that can be enforced to keep the playing field as level as possible.
Trouble is that the media companies that pump so much money into football want the big clubs doing well so they can sell more advertising. They hate it when there are smaller clubs are in the PL.

Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (15 Jul 2020 2.09pm)


Indeed they do. Look at the bias on Sky whenever we are featured. The Liverpool game saw a plethora of ex Liverpool players as pundits and commentators with our sole ex-player on the Sky Sports News channel. Against Villa, it was all about Villa pre-game, during the game and post-game. It was if we were only there to make up the numbers and sooner we're not there, the better in their view.
THIS is why:
1. We need to do all we can to stay in the Prem.
2. We should applaud teams like Leicester and Wolves challenging for the Champions League (although I think they will both fall short this year, sadly) and Sheffield U going for the Europa League.
3. We should be happy to see the Spurs and Arsenals of this world struggling to make Europe, not so much because they are London clubs, but because they are seen as the elite.

 

Superhorns3 Flag Harpdenden 16 Jul 20 12.43pm

Sounds like they simply won because UEFA took too long to change City..

Edited by Superhorns3 (16 Jul 2020 12.44pm)

 


You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Man City Ban overturned