This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by JohnB
I just don't know who comes in for Wilf though. Can't see Everton wanting him anymore. Newcastle takeover hasn't happened and I have no idea if the Saudi's bid will go through. Genuine Top 6 clubs won't be interested in him. Not sure which European club would want him and have the money for transfer and wages. Also if Pulisic is worth £54m, Werner £48m, Sane £40m and Ziyech £36m, how is Wilf going to be valued at what Parish values him at. At the going rate, we'd be lucky to get £40m after the season he's had and the perception of his attitude outside of Palace. I feel sorry for the board having to manage this one to an outcome that works for everyone.
|
|
| palace99 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by JohnB
I just don't know who comes in for Wilf though. Can't see Everton wanting him anymore. Newcastle takeover hasn't happened and I have no idea if the Saudi's bid will go through. Genuine Top 6 clubs won't be interested in him. Not sure which European club would want him and have the money for transfer and wages. Also if Pulisic is worth £54m, Werner £48m, Sane £40m and Ziyech £36m, how is Wilf going to be valued at what Parish values him at. At the going rate, we'd be lucky to get £40m after the season he's had and the perception of his attitude outside of Palace. I feel sorry for the board having to manage this one to an outcome that works for everyone. whilst i agree getting more than £40m for Wilf will be difficult after his form and attitude last season and impact of covid but re your valuation comparisons..
|
|
|
Originally posted by doombear
Do you think Zaha was worth more than the highest offer from Arsenal of £45 mil spread over 6-7 transfer windows. It’s this issue that many incorrectly blame Parish and the board, and I’m not exactly in the Parish can do no wrong gang.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by davehuggins
IMO we need to shift Wilf asap, can only be a problem if he stays. So obvious he wants out and the squad know it so thanks and goodbye from me. The problem will be if it isn’t done early and happens near the deadline, whether down to us, the buyer, Zaha or his agent or the p1ss taking idiots he employs.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by JohnB
I just don't know who comes in for Wilf though. Can't see Everton wanting him anymore. Newcastle takeover hasn't happened and I have no idea if the Saudi's bid will go through. Genuine Top 6 clubs won't be interested in him. Not sure which European club would want him and have the money for transfer and wages. Also if Pulisic is worth £54m, Werner £48m, Sane £40m and Ziyech £36m, how is Wilf going to be valued at what Parish values him at. At the going rate, we'd be lucky to get £40m after the season he's had and the perception of his attitude outside of Palace. I feel sorry for the board having to manage this one to an outcome that works for everyone. Borussia Dortmund. If he has to go would like it to be to them. The price? I have no idea
|
|
|
I believe that I will have cause to look forward to the start of the new season.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
Do you think Zaha was worth more than the highest offer from Arsenal of £45 mil spread over 6-7 transfer windows. It’s this issue that many incorrectly blame Parish and the board, and I’m not exactly in the Parish can do no wrong gang.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad
Roy will still be manager, Zaha wont find a buyer, Kouyate will be first choice centre back, the team that finished will start next season, and 3/4 cheap young players will be added to the squad, no other signings. Early thoughts? We're f***ed.
|
|
|
Originally posted by doombear
So what would you price or have priced Zaha at instead of £80 mil to arrive at £50-60 mil? Bear in mind Arsenal didn’t come back. Zaha’s Klingons meddled in the media and arsenal signed someone else for almost double over their 7 transfer windows payment strategy. We then had the Everton media circus that never was as well. My suspicion is there’s a lot of hindsight on this issue that we didn’t sell him when the fact is if we did, for the derisory bid we received and in the form he finished the season in before this poor season, the amount of uproar on here would’ve reached epic proportions by many, including those suddenly upset we didn’t sell him 12 months ago because he now might be worth less, or possibly worse, play even worse for us next season.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
So what would you price or have priced Zaha at instead of £80 mil to arrive at £50-60 mil? Bear in mind Arsenal didn’t come back. Zaha’s Klingons meddled in the media and arsenal signed someone else for almost double over their 7 transfer windows payment strategy. We then had the Everton media circus that never was as well. My suspicion is there’s a lot of hindsight on this issue that we didn’t sell him when the fact is if we did, for the derisory bid we received and in the form he finished the season in before this poor season, the amount of uproar on here would’ve reached epic proportions by many, including those suddenly upset we didn’t sell him 12 months ago because he now might be worth less, or possibly worse, play even worse for us next season. Despite his poor form this season, there seems to be a lot of Arsenal fans (and Emery) who still seem pi$$ed that they got Pepe instead of Wilf. If you took out their strikers they have little creativity at the moment, so I still think they'll at least ask the question, even if Parish prices them out of it. They might even be happy that Wilf has driven down his price with abject performances. If we'd sold Wilf for less than AWB fans would definitely have been royally pi$$ed last summer. Some fans were even saying nothing less than 100m!
|
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
So what would you price or have priced Zaha at instead of £80 mil to arrive at £50-60 mil? Bear in mind Arsenal didn’t come back. Zaha’s Klingons meddled in the media and arsenal signed someone else for almost double over their 7 transfer windows payment strategy. We then had the Everton media circus that never was as well. My suspicion is there’s a lot of hindsight on this issue that we didn’t sell him when the fact is if we did, for the derisory bid we received and in the form he finished the season in before this poor season, the amount of uproar on here would’ve reached epic proportions by many, including those suddenly upset we didn’t sell him 12 months ago because he now might be worth less, or possibly worse, play even worse for us next season.
|
|
|
Originally posted by doombear
If Wilf had been sold for say £60m last year and we had to give 25% of the profit to Utd, the board would have been lynched on here. Now they're being blamed for having too high a valuation for him. I think the biggest issue is the board believed that his worth to us was £80m and if he wasn't sold, he would still give his all despite the disappointment of not moving. They unfortunately, read him wrong and he didn't play as well as we all know he can do, probably in part due to that as well as the tactics not being suited to him. Dortmund are great at spotting young talent like Sancho and Bellingham, I just can't see them plumping for Wilf.
|
|
|
Originally posted by doombear
You aren’t making a very good case for a negotiation. Value him at £65 mil to get £60 mil. £50 mil would’ve been an outrage and not far off what Arsenal bid anyway, only they wanted to spread it over 3 years or 3 generations lol. This is football players and stupid figures, not house negotiations. Hindsight is ludicrous in this subject and some of the very same people would’ve said don’t sell low or what Arsenal or Everton were alleged to have bid, but in fact didn’t. I think his lack of end product and media shenanigans put clubs off. Oh and none of the top clubs need him or suit him recently over this period. Plus his wages aren’t worth what you get, and seeing as he could be benched, what’s the point? Plus no sell on value. God the reasons for not buying him haven’t looked good since he extended his contract on £130k a week.
COYP |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.