You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > James McCarthy (rumour)
November 16 2026 5.24am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

James McCarthy (rumour)


Page 2 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >
braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 02 Aug 20 3.00pm

Originally posted by Cucking Funt

Only if he's replaced by someone younger, though, and that's by no means guaranteed.

jairo & max are both younger & already here.

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


Laszlo Panaflex Flag 02 Aug 20 3.08pm

If he goes, we'll have to replace him - the squad's too thin already.

The whole point of offloading the big earners like Sakho is that the wages freed up could pay for two or more younger players to bulk out the squad. We don't have enough decent options in enough positions as it is. McCarthy's in the one position where we do have abundant cover, so while we don't need another DM, we do need to bring in another player - we saw just how much we struggle with injuries given the average age of our squad already and can't do that during a proper season.

I just don't want to see us sign another DM to replace him. The last thing anyone wants is Etienne Capoue in a Palace shirt, right?

 

Crystal_Clear Flag Belfast 02 Aug 20 3.57pm

If we could sell him for £5m that's a £2m profit in 1 season. We rarely make profits !!!!

We have Luka, Kouyate, McArthur who can all play the same role.

It's the other type of creative midfielder we are missing.

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 02 Aug 20 4.47pm

Originally posted by Crystal_Clear

If we could sell him for £5m that's a £2m profit in 1 season. We rarely make profits !!!!

We have Luka, Kouyate, McArthur who can all play the same role.

It's the other type of creative midfielder we are missing.

What like a meyer type !

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 02 Aug 20 5.09pm

He's completely average, perfect for a Hodgson midfield. Take the money and run.

 

ambrose7 Flag Croydon 02 Aug 20 8.24pm

I'd take the money use it to buy something we don't have, then using Riedewald/Meyer to take the pitch time McCarthy has.

Oyasi-Samuel at QPR is the same money, a winger, and 7 years younger. I'd rather have Oyasi-Samuel on our bench than McCarthy.

Luke Dreher is back training from his all-season injury to act as back up to Luka, McArthur, Kouyate, Riedewald, Meyer, Schlupp, even if we didn't make another purchase in the middle.

 


26th January 2010 - Enter Administration
2nd May 2010 - D-Day 1 - Survival at Hillsborough
1st June 2010 - D-Day 2 - Survival at Lloyds
7th June 2010 - CPFC2010 exchange contracts.

Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 03 Aug 20 12.16am

no brainer.. sell all day every day...

 


This was once a quality forum....

EddieMac Flag 03 Aug 20 10.21am

Nonsense!
Sell and then what?

Pay 10/12 million for an unknown quantity. McCarthy was a steal at the price we got him and is a good player. He is the only player in our squad that is capable of a heavy challenge. A lot of you need to get over your Meyer crush.

 

Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 03 Aug 20 11.04am

He's ok, an average squad player. Wouldn't be in my starting 11.

One position where we are not thin is in central midfield. He's no different, or better than Luka, Kouyate or McArthur. Freeing up a slot in CM would hopefully give Jairo and Max more game time. We've also got Schlupp in there.

£5m? Yes please. Put the money towards a striker/winger.

 

Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 03 Aug 20 11.05am

Originally posted by EddieMac

Nonsense!
Sell and then what?

Pay 10/12 million for an unknown quantity. McCarthy was a steal at the price we got him and is a good player. He is the only player in our squad that is capable of a heavy challenge.


A lot of truth in this (I would also add Luka to the (very short) list of our midfield players capable of a solid challenge though).

I would rather off load the high wage earners who have offered us very little in recent times, such as Sakho and Meyer.


 

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 03 Aug 20 12.21pm

Originally posted by EddieMac

Nonsense!
Sell and then what?

Pay 10/12 million for an unknown quantity. McCarthy was a steal at the price we got him and is a good player. He is the only player in our squad that is capable of a heavy challenge. A lot of you need to get over your Meyer crush.

Is the right answer.

 

Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 03 Aug 20 1.09pm

Originally posted by Phil’s Barber


A lot of truth in this (I would also add Luka to the (very short) list of our midfield players capable of a solid challenge though).

I would rather off load the high wage earners who have offered us very little in recent times, such as Sakho and Meyer.


The ‘solid challenge’ is sadly a dying art in professional football and is now more of a negative than a positive. There’s no benefit in getting regular yellow cards. The game has moved on from that and it’s all about technical ability ahead of physicality.

I agree with Sakho, but I think Meyer could do well if played as a number 10 or under a new manager/formation.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 03 Aug 20 1.20pm

Originally posted by Goal Machine

The ‘solid challenge’ is sadly a dying art in professional football and is now more of a negative than a positive. There’s no benefit in getting regular yellow cards. The game has moved on from that and it’s all about technical ability ahead of physicality.

I agree with Sakho, but I think Meyer could do well if played as a number 10 or under a new manager/formation.

I agree, McCarthy is an old school style footballer along with several others of our no nonsense midfield. We could afford to lose him from the squad and not notice he had gone. £5m could be put to better use such as the young lad from QPR. We are short of wingers, we are not short of stoppers in the middle of the park, especially old ones.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 03 Aug 20 1.23pm

I’ll wait and see what we do if after and he’s sold.

 


COYP

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 03 Aug 20 2.01pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

I’ll wait and see what we do if after and he’s sold.

Wise move, whilst I don't mind if we sell him, I'd rather he was there than no-one at all.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 03 Aug 20 3.33pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Wise move, whilst I don't mind if we sell him, I'd rather he was there than no-one at all.

Exactly, We need to be getting people in before we let others go.

 

Uphill Flag Bedford 03 Aug 20 5.02pm

Originally posted by Goal Machine

Has someone told our captain that ?

The ‘solid challenge’ is sadly a dying art in professional football and is now more of a negative than a positive. There’s no benefit in getting regular yellow cards. The game has moved on from that and it’s all about technical ability ahead of physicality.

I agree with Sakho, but I think Meyer could do well if played as a number 10 or under a new manager/formation.

 

slubglurge Flag welling 03 Aug 20 5.44pm

Out of our four midfield plodders he's probably the only one i'd keep. Since the restart Jimmy Mac superb v Bournemouth than total rubbish for 8 games. Luka likewise and Kouyate ditto. McCarthy probably played our most creative pass of the season which was to Wilf at the Etihad that set up the equaliser

 

the.universal 03 Aug 20 9.25pm

McCarthy is a very solid pro with many more years to give. No wonder so many clubs are rumoured to want him.

What’s the point in selling for £5m? A small profit on what we paid but another place to recruit for.

As someone else said, if we could move on Meyer and Sakho that would be a touch, without really weakening the squad too much. Free up some wages for new recruits too.

 


Vive le Roy!

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 03 Aug 20 10.00pm

Originally posted by the.universal

McCarthy is a very solid pro with many more years to give. No wonder so many clubs are rumoured to want him.

What’s the point in selling for £5m? A small profit on what we paid but another place to recruit for.

As someone else said, if we could move on Meyer and Sakho that would be a touch, without really weakening the squad too much. Free up some wages for new recruits too.


Exactly. He's the same age as Luka, so younger than Kouyate and McArthur (the latter, despite his grand service for Palace seems to be on his last legs at 32). McCarthy has probably got another 2/3 years in him at this level. I'd be surprised if Palace let him go before his contract expires in 2 years time.

 

Page 2 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > James McCarthy (rumour)