You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Why aren't we an established Premier League club
November 16 2026 5.23am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Why aren't we an established Premier League club


Page 2 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 07 Aug 20 4.08pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

Another word: facilities

I agree with the poor scouting and have mentioned it previously. We seem to think the old boys network is fine but it isn't. We just buy from word of mouth or who we are offered. This has to come down to Dougie. For me, he is not the answer to transfers.

But facilities too. A player comes to our offices in a portacabin to sign his contract. We have managed to install a gym somewhere in some space designed for something else, plus our stadium is uninspiring.
Then look at other sides. Custom made multi million pound training and physio facilities. Office blocks and fancy hotels in some grounds. Look at our players lounge or club shop in comparison to anyone else (including plenty of championship sides).
You're a young player, do you sign here or for West Ham at the London Stadium and all of its facilities? They may be sh1t and have no heart but nearly all the teams are a more attractive prospect for a player currently.
Glad we are gradually upgrading but a heck of a way to go. Slow progress, considering the last 8 years.

Good point. I live just down the road from Ashton Gate in Bristol and their stadium has probably had more renovation over the period we have been in the PL than Selhurst. Clearly we have overspent on player's wages, as that can be the only reason why we have struggled in the transfer market and to not grow the stadium facilities.

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

cryrst Flag The garden of England 07 Aug 20 5.09pm

Originally posted by RyWa

The issue is that 75-80% of our income goes out on wages..we've hugely overpaid players for doing mediocre jobs.
Like stated above, until we get that down, we are effectively cash poor.

Most businesses pay more in wages than anything.
8-10% profit will keep you afloat. Of the remainder 3/4 will be wages I reckon.

 

lefty27 Flag ipswich 07 Aug 20 5.26pm

Originally posted by cryrst

Most businesses pay more in wages than anything.
8-10% profit will keep you afloat. Of the remainder 3/4 will be wages I reckon.


Football isn’t ‘most businesses’ .
Outside of football a wage to turnover ratio of more than 50% is unusual. There are though a few football clubs that have a lowing wages to turnover ratio, Spurs are 38%.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 07 Aug 20 7.31pm

Money primarily, the Premiership is a mercenary place where money buys short term loyalty. Long term planning, and a definitive "Palace" playing style. To date we've had Holloway, Pulis, Pardew, Allerdyce, De Boer, and Hodgson plug gamely away just to tread water. Parish has only just got round to upgrading the Academy and Selhurst Park has had zero investment. We've stood still, and are slowly sliding backwards.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 07 Aug 20 7.45pm

Originally posted by lefty27


Football isn’t ‘most businesses’ .
Outside of football a wage to turnover ratio of more than 50% is unusual. There are though a few football clubs that have a lowing wages to turnover ratio, Spurs are 38%.


And we all know who's responsible for that!

 

martin2412 Flag Living The Dream 07 Aug 20 8.03pm

The major problem is the ownership. They always want to do everything on the cheap, and when the fans start to get a bit agitated Parish releases a CGI image of a stand or training ground so the sycophants can gush all over him again.

If he really wanted the new stand built it would be under way by now.

 

Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 07 Aug 20 8.30pm

Originally posted by RyWa

It has nothing to do with stature and has everything to do with us trying to get a bargain all the time.
We overspent when we first came up and our main survival tactic was usually spend aload of money in January and just about scrape survival.

That tactic backfired on us as we were left with very little room to spend money in the following seasons due to FFP and our 75/25 wage to profit ratio.

The club now seem to be doing the opposite by trying to low ball everyone, and i think we miss out because other teams offer more.
We also wait too long, again its because we want a bargain and know that if we wait till the last day we might get a couple grand off, however it leaves us open to losing out due to other teams being willing to pay a few grand more in exchange for getting business done early.

is the correct answer

 


This was once a quality forum....

slubglurge Flag welling 07 Aug 20 8.45pm

There are only about 7 0r 8 clubs genuinely established in the Prem and sadly we will never be one of them. Bigger clubs than us have tried and failed but have always been one bad decision away from the drop. So far we have managed to not make one yet but when it happens we will go down

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 07 Aug 20 8.46pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Let's not argue over the definition of established. It's pretty clear from the OP that what he is looking for is reasons why, after an extended period in the PL, we have not grown as a club. This topic has been discussed many times before and its not an easy one to answer.

As others have pointed out, it's not just staying in the PL that is an indicator of growth, I would argue that in 7 years we should by now, have better training/academy facilities sorted, a proper scouting network that brings in players who we can turn at a profit and most importantly we should be a lot further down the road with the ground improvements.

I appreciate that some of these matters are being attended to albeit slowly, however we are still not the attraction we should be given we are the only PL team in South London. We should have schools and colleges on a short leash for talent in the south London Boroughs, Kent and East Surrey but we inevitably lose out as many turn us down, probably because they consider us unfashionable.

OK so why haven’t we grown wealthier and better set up in facilities
In order to gain respect as a performer in the Premier league .? Well in all my years of supporting Palace in every division , that question has raised its head . Minus the Premier bit time and time again . The potential of Palace was as Malcom Allison, once saw it ,as great as Liverpool’s with our catchment area. That could be argued about , but in that period alone 50,000 crowds were still possible . How come nobody has ever invested in that sort of potential?
They have never really completely reached that potential , so the mystery goes on. But surely the reasons must go beyond the lack of owner. ambition to reach that potential. Why . Maybe the OP could have said why are we not establishment in football terms.
If he had maybe the answer would be because the establishment in football makes sure it’s not meant to be joined.

Edited by Putitout (07 Aug 2020 10.39pm)

 

bicycle repair man 07 Aug 20 9.36pm

But we are an established Premier League club.
For the past seven seasons we've finished in a comfortable position, well clear of the relegation zone, I don't know how anyone could say we aren't.


 

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 07 Aug 20 10.29pm

Originally posted by bicycle repair man

But we are an established Premier League club.
For the past seven seasons we've finished in a comfortable position, well clear of the relegation zone, I don't know how anyone could say we aren't.


Completely concur with this.

However, I think that the average fan has the attention span of a goldfish. We are a club that had been financially mismanaged for several decades before 2010. We owned nothing when Parish & co saved us. Admittedly, they were not ownership savvy. But we reached the Premier League and stayed there. The whingers seem to think that Rome can be built in a day. We are in a far better place than we financially should be. Put up with it for now, improvements take time and cost money.

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

palace chick Flag South Croydon 07 Aug 20 10.52pm

Originally posted by bicycle repair man

But we are an established Premier League club.
For the past seven seasons we've finished in a comfortable position, well clear of the relegation zone, I don't know how anyone could say we aren't.


Can’t argue with that - I do think with present manager and squad we are in for our hardest season and may not stay up this time? Other than a cup final appearance at the beginning of this tenure we don’t have much to show for our stay. I do wish we had got some (at least one) silverware to remember this time spent :-( Perhaps we will sell and buy players to prove me wrong and Hodgson and Lewington work miracles again but at this time I’m not looking forward to September as I fear the end is near :-(

 

BlueJay Flag UK 07 Aug 20 10.57pm

Management and playing style. Roy isn't exactly experimental, so I can't see much changing for now. Credit where credit's due though, he's keeping us up.

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 07 Aug 20 10.57pm


There seems to be some confusion here . Are we an established Premier club? Yes we are an established Premier club, every time we don’t get relegated..
But are we respected as a Premier club, even by some of our own support it seems ? No. Is the answer for some. Two different questions being treated as one.

Edited by Putitout (07 Aug 2020 11.04pm)

 

syd snot Flag munich 08 Aug 20 1.39am

Because we're cheap.
We refuse to come close to a valuation for a good player.
We refuse to let a player leave when we can get top money for him.
Because none of our players can actually pass a ball to another bloke in red and blue stripes.

Because we cannot get a stadium sorted.
Because we are Crystal Palace FC.

 

CT Charlie Flag 08 Aug 20 1.49am

My countrymen owners aren't known for their generosity, and I don't think our scouting has been top quality. It's a shame our facilities are so creaky because our match day fan support is first-rate.

As a point of perspective, however, our current run of years in the PL has only been matched by 9 other clubs.

 

BlueJay Flag UK 08 Aug 20 2.43am

Originally posted by Putitout


There seems to be some confusion here . Are we an established Premier club? Yes we are an established Premier club, every time we don’t get relegated..
But are we respected as a Premier club, even by some of our own support it seems ? No. Is the answer for some. Two different questions being treated as one.

Edited by Putitout (07 Aug 2020 11.04pm)

The tailend of our season didn't exactly scream 'established premier league club' though, which is likely what he's getting at.

 

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 08 Aug 20 6.38am

Originally posted by Palace Passion

Are you being sarcastic or are you really silly enough to believe that rubbish? Any team that has been up in the Premier league more then 2 season HAS money. The club gets a considerable amount just for staying up. We are loaded. We have a very tight consortium. We have money, we just never spend any.

are you being sarcastic? or are you really silly enough to beleive the rubbish you just typed?

try doing some research, like reading club accounts before posting incorrect info like above.

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


crvenaeagle Flag 08 Aug 20 7.32am

I can't say West Ham seem to achieve much more than us, despite coming in and paying the price. They spend so much money but struggle as much, if not more than us.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 08 Aug 20 9.24am

Originally posted by BlueJay

The tailend of our season didn't exactly scream 'established premier league club' though, which is likely what he's getting at.

But we'd already established our involvement in this league long before the tailend lol, apart from the top six or seven clubs in this league no one is really really safe from relegation anyway are they and the top six need all of us below them to stay there to feed on for their monopoly and fun.

 

Page 2 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Why aren't we an established Premier League club