You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Blood on the Carpet at Sky Football studio
November 22 2026 7.22pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Blood on the Carpet at Sky Football studio


Page 2 of 10 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
Teddy Eagle Flag 27 Aug 20 1.53am


They insist on female pundits on the cricket as well but at least the mechanics of the game are the same, albeit that the fastest bowlers are 20 mph slower but women talking about men’s rugby is just daft.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 27 Aug 20 2.10am

Originally posted by lefty27

I get a little irritated by this. During the womans World Cup a female pundit said ‘ don’t compare our game to the men’s game, they are different sports’ she was discussing how the ladies game was different and should be adapted(goals made smaller etc) to make it more competitive. The average size of a goal keeper in the men’s and woman’s games are different but the goals are the same size.
Anyway it’s a different sport, I find some of the female pundits pretty embarrassing, it would be like employing a male fan who has played a bit of 5 a side with his mates as a pundit.
Pointless, they add little to no value. The same can also be said of male pundits commenting on the female game.

They actually have a point I agree on. The pitches are too long and the goals too big. But that’ll mean different venues or bringing the goals in and making it obviously smaller. It would be better viewing though because they run out of stamina in the box. The width is ok. Women like width.

 


COYP

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 27 Aug 20 7.17am

Originally posted by PalazioVecchio

why are there so many women footballers doing punditry on men's football ?

like, i do not see a quota for male commentators to discuss the latest Female activity.

the BBC are shoving these women into these roles. The old boys club that was 'soccer saturday' will have been broken for good. It will be as wet as the last Terminator movie.

When I watch MOTD I actually fast forward when the pundits talk I have no interest in them as the game is over so it doesn't matter what they say. I haven't listen to Lineker and Co in years and I don't have SSN either.

Anyway a mate who does listen to the pundits pointed out that the woman on MOTD (don't know her name) is useless not because she is a woman but because she agrees with the other ex pro's. She's a female Trevor Brooking.

As I said it doesn't bother me but what's the point of having pundits who agree all the time.

Oh I should add that the female commentator gets on my nerves so much I now listen to her highlights on mute. I'm sure she knows her stuff I just don't like her voice.

Edited by Badger11 (27 Aug 2020 7.19am)

 


One more point

A89M Flag Streatham 27 Aug 20 7.53am

If you know football, neither the men or the women offer any insight into the game your watching. They all just point out the obvious and over analyse it.

The only enjoyment I get from the pundits is the heated debates on Sky with Keane, Neville and Carragher or the nostalgia talks BT Sport have with Rio, Owen, Keown etc.

The soccer Saturday lot offer nothing to the game, they’re dinosaurs who repeat the same nonsense week in week out. They’ll be missed for the ‘banter‘ aspect but nothing more.

 

the.universal 27 Aug 20 8.14am

Originally posted by leejaneagles

A little while ago, a certain small streaming company named after the Rainforest decided it wanted to get into the world of Car shows. The BBC had the market completely sewn up and the most popular car show in history called Top Gear and they got so cocky they sacked the Hosts for a ‘refresh’ because obviously it was the show and the cars that brought in the viewers right, not the bumbling Hosts?

An even littler while ago, last season in fact, this same streaming company with unlimited resources and most of the Country already signed up because of its parcel delivery service decided it wanted to get into the world of Football. It streamed flawless games, all games in fact, in a pick and choose your game environment that gave Viewers the freedom of choice and made Sky look very old hat with its rigid schedule.

Anyone else connecting the dots here thinking we’ll see how popular ‘Sky Soccer Saturday’ is if there’s an Amazon stream of ‘Prime Football Saturday’ consisting of Jeff and the boys up against Sky’s no-name black, female and non-binary panel (please understand that if Jeff and the ‘boys’ happened to be black, gay and trans I’d want to watch them, this isn’t about that).

Admittedly Top Gear was easier to sort as the person they sacked first was actually the Head Honcho Jeremy Clarkson whereas Sky have kept Jeff but he’s surely unhappy and I’m not sure Amazon would have too much an issue trebling his salary.

Clarkson got sacked for sparking a producer ‘because there was no hot food’. No mention of refresh. If you don’t get sacked for punching a fellow employee the it’s hard to imagine what you would get sacked for.

Grand tour is thought to have viewing figures on par with current Top Gear. So apart from bucketloads of cash, it doesn’t seem to be a great split for either parties.

 


Vive le Roy!

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 27 Aug 20 8.41am

If this had happened a year ago, I don't think it would have merited much discussion.

Now there is debate around whether Sky have an ulterior motive behind what would historically have been seen as a programme refresh.

Personal preference, but I won't miss Thompson or Nicholas but I do like Le Tiss.

Interesting to see what happens next....

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 27 Aug 20 9.07am

Originally posted by NEILLO

If this had happened a year ago, I don't think it would have merited much discussion.

Now there is debate around whether Sky have an ulterior motive behind what would historically have been seen as a programme refresh.

Personal preference, but I won't miss Thompson or Nicholas but I do like Le Tiss.

Interesting to see what happens next....

No prizes for guessing the types of people who will make up the panel.

Can't have all these white males on there even though they have all played the game to a high level and bring perspective and insight to the table.

 

YoDougie Flag London 27 Aug 20 9.20am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Sorry but I draw the line at sex change freaks. I also switch of to females from 14 year old male speed football. As much as Alex Scott is easy on the eye, she just points out what 99% of people have seen. I want to hear a view from a professional who reads deeper stuff than ‘he did great at...’

There really are things that men or women can’t do. It’s just nature. Trying to meddle in all of it is arrogant idiocy.

This is truly such a disgusting and disappointing comment. Putting football aside, how can you possibly think it's acceptable to comment on people like this, using this language?

Some of the comments on this thread have amazed me. Representation of all types of people is an important and much needed step to take in our inclusive society that moves towards equality.

Also, women are not objects to comment on their looks and football is not 'human nature'. How you can possibly believe this is appropriate amazes me.

Whatever the reason behind Sky's decision is, change does happen in work and the truth is, having 4/5 white men on the panel is not fair representation and is not where we have arrived at in 2020.

As a 'white straight man', I'd welcome whoever they put on the show, as long as their qualifications and knowledge on the topic are good enough. I'm not going to 'draw the line' at anyone. People are who they are.

Edited by YoDougie (27 Aug 2020 9.22am)

 

A89M Flag Streatham 27 Aug 20 9.22am

Originally posted by Willo

No prizes for guessing the types of people who will make up the panel.

Can't have all these white males on there even though they have all played the game to a high level and bring perspective and insight to the table.

Do they though? Apart from what i've mentioned about the nostalgia talk on BT. Do the Soccer Saturday lot actually add anything to your viewing experience? Other than the comfort of seeing them every saturday for god knows how long. Do you learn anything new? They just spew the same old rhetoric over and over again. Charlie and Phil are awful.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 27 Aug 20 9.26am

Originally posted by A89M

Do they though? Apart from what i've mentioned about the nostalgia talk on BT. Do the Soccer Saturday lot actually add anything to your viewing experience? Other than the comfort of seeing them every saturday for god knows how long. Do you learn anything new? They just spew the same old rhetoric over and over again. Charlie and Phil are awful.

Our opinions are polarised on this matter.

Esteemed pundits have been cast aside to pander to the PC Brigade.

In my humble opinion 'Soccer Saturday' will be poorer for their absence and I can say with a great degree of confidence that I will certainly NOT be tuning in to watch it.

Edited by Willo (27 Aug 2020 9.26am)

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 27 Aug 20 9.39am

Originally posted by YoDougie

This is truly such a disgusting and disappointing comment. Putting football aside, how can you possibly think it's acceptable to comment on people like this, using this language?

Some of the comments on this thread have amazed me. Representation of all types of people is an important and much needed step to take in our inclusive society that moves towards equality.

Also, women are not objects to comment on their looks and football is not 'human nature'. How you can possibly believe this is appropriate amazes me.

Whatever the reason behind Sky's decision is, change does happen in work and the truth is, having 4/5 white men on the panel is not fair representation and is not where we have arrived at in 2020.

As a 'white straight man', I'd welcome whoever they put on the show, as long as their qualifications and knowledge on the topic are good enough. I'm not going to 'draw the line' at anyone. People are who they are.

Edited by YoDougie (27 Aug 2020 9.22am)

People are who they are until their opinions differ apparently.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 27 Aug 20 9.58am

Originally posted by YoDougie

This is truly such a disgusting and disappointing comment. Putting football aside, how can you possibly think it's acceptable to comment on people like this, using this language?

Some of the comments on this thread have amazed me. Representation of all types of people is an important and much needed step to take in our inclusive society that moves towards equality.

Also, women are not objects to comment on their looks and football is not 'human nature'. How you can possibly believe this is appropriate amazes me.

Whatever the reason behind Sky's decision is, change does happen in work and the truth is, having 4/5 white men on the panel is not fair representation and is not where we have arrived at in 2020.

As a 'white straight man', I'd welcome whoever they put on the show, as long as their qualifications and knowledge on the topic are good enough. I'm not going to 'draw the line' at anyone. People are who they are.

Edited by YoDougie (27 Aug 2020 9.22am)

Can women man heavy road digging machinery?
Should women be out late at night doing grocery deliveries?

Alex Scott brings nothing to the table. Mainly because she hasn’t played at the top level and at that speed because, guess why, she’s a woman.

I’m not bothered who is on a programme or panel either but they’ve got to be qualified and have the presentation skills and charisma. I remember when Ruud Gullit came on the scene. Cool as.

Thanks for your outrage and lesson in occupational thinking. I’ll file it under blithering bollox.

 


COYP

YoDougie Flag London 27 Aug 20 10.30am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Can women man heavy road digging machinery?
Should women be out late at night doing grocery deliveries?

Alex Scott brings nothing to the table. Mainly because she hasn’t played at the top level and at that speed because, guess why, she’s a woman.

I’m not bothered who is on a programme or panel either but they’ve got to be qualified and have the presentation skills and charisma. I remember when Ruud Gullit came on the scene. Cool as.

Thanks for your outrage and lesson in occupational thinking. I’ll file it under blithering bollox.

Can women man heavy road digging machinery? Yes
Should women be out late at night doing grocery deliveries? Yes

I'm not sure if you're inferring that women can't do these jobs or not... but if you are saying they can't. You're talking about operating machinery and driving a truck. Of course they can.


 

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 27 Aug 20 10.36am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Can women man heavy road digging machinery?
Should women be out late at night doing grocery deliveries?

Alex Scott brings nothing to the table. Mainly because she hasn’t played at the top level and at that speed because, guess why, she’s a woman.

I’m not bothered who is on a programme or panel either but they’ve got to be qualified and have the presentation skills and charisma. I remember when Ruud Gullit came on the scene. Cool as.

Thanks for your outrage and lesson in occupational thinking. I’ll file it under blithering bollox.

Women can certainly do heavy manual work.

My ex-wife was a decoy to a whaling fleet.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 27 Aug 20 10.41am

Originally posted by YoDougie

Can women man heavy road digging machinery? Yes
Should women be out late at night doing grocery deliveries? Yes

I'm not sure if you're inferring that women can't do these jobs or not... but if you are saying they can't. You're talking about operating machinery and driving a truck. Of course they can.


They could, but they don’t, and don’t last more to the point.

Operating heavy machinery is very wearing on the body, and I’m talking about big blokes.

Women out late at night on their own in unlit and dodgy places with nobody around isn’t the place for a woman and again carrying dozens of boxes off vans and up stairs doesn’t get many women applying or staying in these kind of jobs if they do.

Nature is nature. There are just some things that either sex aren’t good at or as good at or stick with. A bit like you trying to persuade me that your perfect view is now correct. Money and time and performance matter everywhere, and if you can’t keep up or deliver then it doesn’t last or happen in the first place. Save me the millennial drivel.

You’ll actually find that loads of men now say it would be great if women did their job with them as well. But you’ll also hear them say they can’t stick at it because of body strength or ability to not get injured or physically tired to the point they can’t deliver the work or meet targets.

Anyway, Matt Le Tissier gets the sack but Gary Lineker is BBC’s poster boy.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (27 Aug 2020 10.49am)

 


COYP

leejaneagles Flag 27 Aug 20 10.47am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Can women man heavy road digging machinery?
Should women be out late at night doing grocery deliveries?

Alex Scott brings nothing to the table. Mainly because she hasn’t played at the top level and at that speed because, guess why, she’s a woman.

I’m not bothered who is on a programme or panel either but they’ve got to be qualified and have the presentation skills and charisma. I remember when Ruud Gullit came on the scene. Cool as.

Thanks for your outrage and lesson in occupational thinking. I’ll file it under blithering bollox.

The trouble is these days no one can have differing opinions. I'm in my early 30's and in certain pubs (not posh bars) and with people I'd consider 'close' friends and not acquaintances, if I openly put forward a slightly alternative opinion, people would stop talking to me or ask me to sit on my own and liken me to Hitler. Younger people these days are scared of debate or compromise, it's going to be a truly shocking World in a few years thanks to my Generation unfortunately.

For what it's worth, I disagree with you on 'drawing the line' with Trans people. This is from personal experiences and knowing some. However, I don't agree it's not a mental/chemical imbalance. If a sex change remedies those symptoms it doesn't affect me in the slightest and I'm glad that person is feeling better. I just don't agree with the notion you can truly be a woman trapped in a mans body and vice-versa (but it wouldn't be a topic of discussion I'd feel compelled to have with them if I was with them). I'm just not fussed about sitting down for drinks or dinner with someone who has had this change and I don't find them revolting.

It's completely okay that you are not okay with it and I'd have a drink with you as well. I'm sick of the people that spit their dummies out the pram though and berate you for a differing opinion.

Don't get me started on non-binary. I'm not revolted by it or actively want to see people suffer but I couldn't hold a conversation with someone that idiotic. That really does smack of 'we've got all the rights we possibly want for gay people and trans people, lets make something up completely to keep moaning and be the shunned". And I know a lot of trans people that feel the same when it comes to the ridiculousness of a spoilt teenager wanting to wake up one morning as a boy and the next a girl and the next a lamp. Because it mocks the true struggle of the pain of feeling like you need to get your whole body permanently changed to feel okay in yourself.

Getting told it's 2020 and that's not where we are now is also laughable. We are worse off than we've ever been and there is a divide and full tantrum/argument/riot over every tiny difference of opinion. Just a false feeling of superiority for blindly following every active equality cause but then abusing anybody that dares to be different. Not very equal that is it?

Circling back to the topic, if they have a panel lined up better than the people sacked and they happened to all be minorities then I'd be fine wit that. We all know that won't be the case. Some people's opinion is the people fired are bumbling moronic buffoons (again your own opinion is fine) but ratings and reviews for Soccer Saturday suggest otherwise on the whole, so not sure why they've decided to pander for no reason. Time will tell.

 

Wilesy01 Flag Bristol 27 Aug 20 10.53am

Does anyone get a bit fed up of this long held assumption that high level ex pros make the best pundits?

Some admittedly are good but many others are woeful. I can't say I've ever learned anything from listening to the likes of Ferdinand, Shearer or Le Tissier.

I'd much rather listen to senior journalists like Henry Winter discuss the game. Nor am I against the likes of Alex Scott who has ran rings around the likes of Paul Ince on MoTD provide such commentary.

 

deleted 25 Flag 27 Aug 20 10.58am

Maybe they can take a leaf out of the Neville bros book, and go in to football management?, on second thoughts - enjoy your retirement lads!

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 27 Aug 20 10.59am

.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (27 Aug 2020 11.14am)

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 27 Aug 20 11.03am

Originally posted by Wilesy01

Does anyone get a bit fed up of this long held assumption that high level ex pros make the best pundits?

Some admittedly are good but many others are woeful. I can't say I've ever learned anything from listening to the likes of Ferdinand, Shearer or Le Tissier.

I'd much rather listen to senior journalists like Henry Winter discuss the game. Nor am I against the likes of Alex Scott who has ran rings around the likes of Paul Ince on MoTD provide such commentary.

Yes they are all terrible although Shearer isn’t as bad as that. He’s just overpaid. Alex Scott being better than Paul Ince isn’t saying much. I was genuinely optimistic about women on the panel but all she does is just point out what anybody who knows nothing about football can see. There’s no reading between the lines or exposing of the opposition formation. It’s just what one individual player has done in a certain moment. It’s a waste of someone else being able to say something. The others keep quiet and wait for her to finish and carry on.

 


COYP

Page 2 of 10 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Blood on the Carpet at Sky Football studio