You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Roy's Boreball
November 16 2026 5.24am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Roy's Boreball


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
Coach 3 Flag Sandown Isle of Wight 19 Oct 20 7.35am

Roy has done a very good job given the circumstances(we've spent a net £23m when the south coast mob have spent £106m in the same 5 windows) but the style of our play is sucking the joy out of the game. We can't keep going playing that way, matches are won by scoring goals not sitting on the edge of your own box and hoping for the break away. He isn't going to change, so maybe a fresh voice would help. Having said that I'm mindful of the "be careful of what you wish for"!

 

MonsterMunch Flag Cambridge 19 Oct 20 7.50am

Originally posted by Coach 3

Roy has done a very good job given the circumstances(we've spent a net £23m when the south coast mob have spent £106m in the same 5 windows) but the style of our play is sucking the joy out of the game. We can't keep going playing that way, matches are won by scoring goals not sitting on the edge of your own box and hoping for the break away. He isn't going to change, so maybe a fresh voice would help. Having said that I'm mindful of the "be careful of what you wish for"!

Yes I am concerned about post Roy- however it’s not as though it’s our first season in the PL, we have a decent squad. Why should we not think someone could do better? The tools are there, it would be a different matter if they weren’t. They won’t do anything with Roy unless results put our status at risk. Resigned to hoping for better things next season if and it’s a big if Roy moves on.

 

kingdowieonthewall Flag Sussex, ex-Cronx. 19 Oct 20 7.53am

a friend recently reminded me of Charltons demise.
However they had lofty ambitions, as I remember they played some decent football under Curbishley but were not satisfied.

All we're asking for is to give it a go, at least against the run of mill sides.

Roy gave us 7 or so defeats in a row end of last season & what worries me is he'll put this run of defeats together again soon serving up the scrape together points dross he's doing now.

Yesterdays match was like watching a league side containing a prem team in the cup.
He must be destroying some players.

 


Kids,tired of being bothered by your pesky parents?
Then leave home, get a job & pay your own bills, while you still know everything.

EddieMac Flag 19 Oct 20 8.19am

I’d love to hear the instructions Roy have to the team to before that game to get an exact picture of how they were sent out to play. Is it all his fault or are players half to blame?

In my opinion Roy doesn’t trust Mitchell at left back which is why we are basically sacrificing a winger and having 2 left backs. On the right side Ward has a serious lack of pace but Kouyate is able to move across and help him and if not Townsend is there. Roy seems so obsessed with protecting our full backs that he is creating havoc through out the rest of the team as we never have any players far enough up the pitch when we do get the ball.

When we had PVA and AWB we played differently because Roy trusted that they had the pace to look after themselves.

As soon as PVA is fully fit he will be straight back in at left back.

He needs to get Eze into the roll Zaha played yesterday and get Zaha back onto the wing but this won’t happen while Mitchell is playing as Roy doesn’t trust him enough.


Edited by EddieMac (19 Oct 2020 8.20am)

 

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 19 Oct 20 9.16am

Originally posted by EddieMac

I’d love to hear the instructions Roy have to the team to before that game to get an exact picture of how they were sent out to play. Is it all his fault or are players half to blame?

In my opinion Roy doesn’t trust Mitchell at left back which is why we are basically sacrificing a winger and having 2 left backs. On the right side Ward has a serious lack of pace but Kouyate is able to move across and help him and if not Townsend is there. Roy seems so obsessed with protecting our full backs that he is creating havoc through out the rest of the team as we never have any players far enough up the pitch when we do get the ball.

When we had PVA and AWB we played differently because Roy trusted that they had the pace to look after themselves.

As soon as PVA is fully fit he will be straight back in at left back.

He needs to get Eze into the roll Zaha played yesterday and get Zaha back onto the wing but this won’t happen while Mitchell is playing as Roy doesn’t trust him enough.


Edited by EddieMac (19 Oct 2020 8.20am)

you could be onto Something there.

Mitchell played pretty good yesterday - but he still gave the ball away needlessley, and in dangerous areas on a Few occasions.
needs to grow a bit as we've got an excellent player there, but he needs to cut those errors out of his game.
I think PVA will be back in as soon as he's ready.

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

jeeagles Flag 19 Oct 20 9.37am

Originally posted by EddieMac

I’d love to hear the instructions Roy have to the team to before that game to get an exact picture of how they were sent out to play. Is it all his fault or are players half to blame?

Edited by EddieMac (19 Oct 2020 8.20am)

I listened to most of the first half on 5 live yesterday. They were diving into far more detail than Sky/BT/MOTD ever do. There was far less sensalisim and a lot more substance.

I've wanted journalist to ask managers more difficult questions for years. They do in other sports. I guess in football it would end a lot of the debates that keep people talking about it so we have no chance of quality journalist for the foresable future.

Interviews in recent years have all been sterilies and become more predicable than our style of play.

 

PatrickA Flag London 19 Oct 20 9.39am

PVA will make a difference going forward and he has a good understanding with players on the left which give us more thrust down that side.
Townsend and Schlupp have started the season reasonably well and hopefully Zaha will rediscover his form.
If Jairo gets a run in midfield this should improve our passing range.
On the other hand, I still think we’ll struggle to score goals this season though.
We create very little and Batshuayi only comes alive in the penalty area. I suspect Ayew will start ahead of him when fit as he suits Roy’s way of playing with his work rate.
I also suspect we’ll only see Eze in a limited role until he’s indoctrinated in Roy’s methods which is disappointing.
In summary, we should be less boring than we were yesterday in the coming weeks but don’t expect too much!

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 19 Oct 20 9.54am

It was extremely painful to say the least but we all understand that Roy is short term here, he is leaving as manager it could be at any time, I think the club are waiting for the right moment and man and we need to just hold on because nothing is sadly going to change on the pitch until then, meanwhile we will continue to pick up sufficient points for safety and that at least is something.

 

Skip Flag 19 Oct 20 9.55am

Does it not make more sense to rather than play Schlupp in a role so that he can hold Mitchell's hand and ensure he doesn't get overwhelmed, that he plays at left back himself ? Leaving Zaha to play on the left in front of him and Eze in the middle ?

 

Frickin Saweet Flag South Cronx 19 Oct 20 10.30am

Is this really a surprise to anyone? Steve Parish and co know Roy's limitations so they have signed us up for another season of this. The only thing that will get Roy the boot is an extended run of defeats that shows no signs of stopping thus threatening relegation. Dour football won't and I think we'll have to wait until the season ends. Let's just hope that there's some serious succession planning going on behind the scenes.

 

Terry Ven Flag 19 Oct 20 10.50am

Originally posted by glaziermart

The crap posted by Roy's supporters about he can only do what he can with the tools he has does not wash any more. He has a squad full of internationals. We were not playing Liverpool, Man City or Chelsea today. It was totally unacceptable. Lets not dress it up, it was disgusting

I have to agree; if we can't play with some enterprise or passion against our biggest rivals then what is the flippin' point? Seaweed look like they are trying to build a new attacking sh1t or bust style, which at least their fans must like watching, while we just look like we have settled for being hard to beat and that's all. Boring.

 

EddieMac Flag 19 Oct 20 11.03am

Originally posted by Tickled pink

It was extremely painful to say the least but we all understand that Roy is short term here, he is leaving as manager it could be at any time, I think the club are waiting for the right moment and man and we need to just hold on because nothing is sadly going to change on the pitch until then, meanwhile we will continue to pick up sufficient points for safety and that at least is something.

Very true. This is the main reason I don’t get too worked up about Roy. He will be gone soon. With Covid and the loss of earnings there would be no worse season to get relegated.

 

Gallery3 Flag South Croydon 19 Oct 20 11.24am

‘A hard working defensive display’ says Roy. It is Brighton FFS!!! UnAmbitious dross!

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 19 Oct 20 11.27am

Originally posted by Gallery3

‘A hard working defensive display’ says Roy. It is Brighton FFS!!! UnAmbitious dross!

Played at home against Brighton, only 1 shot on target and that was from the penalty spot.
Totally unacceptable and I believe the supporters have had enough.

 

Neilsym26 Flag Bromley 19 Oct 20 11.40am

When everyone was raving about Meyer before he signed, I hadn't even heard of him and struggled to get involved in the hype! But as we slowly got glimpses of him you could see he is a fantastic little footballer who is very confident with the ball. He keeps possession and very rarely gives the ball away. These are the players we need if we are to get the midfield involved with the forwards. These type create space and make other players run into space. To think Camarasa (of whom we'll never know) Meyer and Jairo have not featured at all is criminal and clarifys what Hodgson is about. McArthur who was our box to box now often resides in front of the back 4 along with the majority of our midfield!! Even Luka has stopped scoring. I've never been a fan of Hodgson and like a lot of fans at the moment, I'm glad I'm not going. Just gutted they are still taking my season ticket money. Give the job to Freedman for the rest of the season.... he has unfinished business!

 

MonsterMunch Flag Cambridge 19 Oct 20 11.47am

Originally posted by Neilsym26

When everyone was raving about Meyer before he signed, I hadn't even heard of him and struggled to get involved in the hype! But as we slowly got glimpses of him you could see he is a fantastic little footballer who is very confident with the ball. He keeps possession and very rarely gives the ball away. These are the players we need if we are to get the midfield involved with the forwards. These type create space and make other players run into space. To think Camarasa (of whom we'll never know) Meyer and Jairo have not featured at all is criminal and clarifys what Hodgson is about. McArthur who was our box to box now often resides in front of the back 4 along with the majority of our midfield!! Even Luka has stopped scoring. I've never been a fan of Hodgson and like a lot of fans at the moment, I'm glad I'm not going. Just gutted they are still taking my season ticket money. Give the job to Freedman for the rest of the season.... he has unfinished business!

Oh no.. he said it!

That’s a step too far for even the Roy our brigade like myself!

 

Jacey Flag 19 Oct 20 11.55am

Originally posted by Gallery3

‘A hard working defensive display’ says Roy. It is Brighton FFS!!! UnAmbitious dross!

Oh dear,a very tough,uncertain season ahead if Mr Negative remains in place.

 

G O Eagle Flag 19 Oct 20 12.50pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'destROYing the beautiful game' by becky

What a disgrace not even trying to play football, not even taking any responsibility for creating a game.

What a disgrace not even recognising this.

BBC counted 20 shots from Brighton, 1 from us, the homeside against a team in lower league position than ours!!!

It can't possible get worse and more embarrassing.

 

manoftaste Flag Hastings 19 Oct 20 1.15pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'destROYing the beautiful game' by becky

Completely agree with G O Eagle. That was such a depressing, dismal performance. No attempt to attack.
And those other stats they put up on screen covering the whole year: 20th out of 20 on passes completed; 20th out of 20 on possession; equal botttom goals scored. The rest of the country must groan when they see it's us on telly.
We have some potentially exciting players who can take the game to the opposition - Wilf, Eze, Bats, Townsend, Schlupp... but they're all being told to defend. It's totally dispiriting. Joyless.

 

m/k mick Flag milton keynes 19 Oct 20 1.37pm

I am a glass half full, i think the latest transfer window was successful, depending on which figures you believe, net spend of about £6 million, Sorloth/ Iniss sold, £16 mill Eze, signed two late 20s English internationals Clyne /Butland, promising full back Ferguson and an international striker Batman, defensive injuries clearing up, then Brighton, Cahil, Sclhupp, Batman first games, Wilf, jimmy mac, carrying injuries, so whilst Roy is defensive, he had to be
Once we bed in and get some points on the board he can be a little more expansive, all these wanting radical change should be careful, dont throw the baby out with the bathwater, personally i am more than happy overall with the stewardship of my club, from Parish, Dougie and Roy

 

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Roy's Boreball