You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Roy In
November 16 2026 5.23am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Roy In


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 24 Oct 20 8.58pm

Originally posted by EddieMac

Rachid, There are people on here who would rather we lost just so they can have a go at Roy. Their first reaction is to say we don’t deserve 3 points no matter what. They havn’t a clue. They think possession is the stat that wins you games.

We managed 57% at home to Huddersfield opening day 2017.
Honestly couldn't give a monkeys all the time we stay at the top table and turn a few of the big teams over occasionally.

 

rikz Flag Croydon 24 Oct 20 9.01pm

I dont mind playing counter attacking football if we play with more intent and direct going forward and getting wilf on the ball deeper on the pitch, I can handle 25% possession, its when we play 442 with wilf trying to play off the last defender we look terrible. That is entirely down to roy, I dont think Hodgson is doing a bad job but he is not doing a great job. Look at our squad its the first time we can put out 2 different 11 who can both compete at this level.
We are too good to go down but id hope this is Hodgsons last year at the club.

 

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 24 Oct 20 9.02pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

It was my lame attempt at humour to demonstrate how fickle the average football fan is - including myself.
I have never doubted Roy’s ability to get us the points to stay up.
If this is, as most would argue, the criteria to be deemed a success, then he’s a success.
I just feel this group of players could play more on the front foot, as we did at Man U, and still get the points.
His advocates will claim we’re sitting 5th in the table with ten points and this can’t be disputed.
I will point at the minus goal difference and many will say ‘so what?’
Football is all about opinions.

you could well be correct, but that ethos cost pardew his job after doing a very good job beforehand.

for most of our PL tenure, we have been an effective counter attacking team, tbf why change something that works.

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


redshift Flag Toronto 24 Oct 20 9.19pm

Originally posted by doombear

WE won a game we needed to win if we are to stay up again this season. Fulham look strong favourites for relegation imo.

We are 5th now, but probably won't be come the end of this round of matches on Monday.

Having said that it was good that we showed more attacking intent today than in the previous two games put together.

Am I happy? yes, but I'm probably more relieved that we didn't slip on a banana skin today and managed what we've been good at since Roy came and that is to beat the teams that are likely to be below/around us.

The next two games (Wolves and Leeds) will provide a more realistic picture of how we are shaping up this season.

This echoes pretty much how I feel. Still, hard to understand how this was the same team the played Brighton. Let's hope it sticks around. That negative goal differential is worrisome though, as it has been in past years.

 


Success will lie to you but failure always tells you the truth.

EddieMac Flag 25 Oct 20 8.17am

I’m not for for one minute saying I love to watch Palace under Roy week in and out but what I will say is that there is more to football than the way Fulham played yesterday and the way Brighton played last weekend, passing the ball around from side to side with absolutely no end product. It may look nice to watch but it means nothing without points on the board.

I have been one of Roy’s defenders over the last couple of years because I really believe he has done a great job in keeping us up considering the squad depth and injuries we have had but I have also said that now is the season that he will really be judged because we have some squad depth for once.

People have to remember that we have started off this season riddled with injuries once again our only regular starting defender in the first few games from last year was Ward but yet we still looked solid at the back. This isn’t by chance, it is because of the tactics that a lot of you hate. Players know the system.

Liverpool havnt shut up because they are missing VVD but we were missing Cahill, Sakho, Tomkins, PVA and all to long injuries. These are facts that a lot of you seem to erase from your memories when it suits.

I have no doubt there is going to be some awful performances this season but I also believe we are going to have our best ever season in the division.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 25 Oct 20 8.43am

Originally posted by braunstoneagle

you could well be correct, but that ethos cost pardew his job after doing a very good job beforehand.

for most of our PL tenure, we have been an effective counter attacking team, tbf why change something that works.

Precisely and it's for me the best way to watch if done properly, yesterday we had two offsides and another two brilliant opportunities to score against Fulham who hit the post twice from distance with Guaita being in the right position to save them anyway, people always always forget that the keepers hand can quite easily still be able to save the ball if the shot is another three to four inches nearer to his hand to get inside the post!

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 25 Oct 20 8.46am

Originally posted by EddieMac

I’m not for for one minute saying I love to watch Palace under Roy week in and out but what I will say is that there is more to football than the way Fulham played yesterday and the way Brighton played last weekend, passing the ball around from side to side with absolutely no end product. It may look nice to watch but it means nothing without points on the board.

I have been one of Roy’s defenders over the last couple of years because I really believe he has done a great job in keeping us up considering the squad depth and injuries we have had but I have also said that now is the season that he will really be judged because we have some squad depth for once.

People have to remember that we have started off this season riddled with injuries once again our only regular starting defender in the first few games from last year was Ward but yet we still looked solid at the back. This isn’t by chance, it is because of the tactics that a lot of you hate. Players know the system.

Liverpool havnt shut up because they are missing VVD but we were missing Cahill, Sakho, Tomkins, PVA and all to long injuries. These are facts that a lot of you seem to erase from your memories when it suits.

I have no doubt there is going to be some awful performances this season but I also believe we are going to have our best ever season in the division.


Very correct.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 25 Oct 20 9.22am

Originally posted by EddieMac

I’m not for for one minute saying I love to watch Palace under Roy week in and out but what I will say is that there is more to football than the way Fulham played yesterday and the way Brighton played last weekend, passing the ball around from side to side with absolutely no end product. It may look nice to watch but it means nothing without points on the board.

I have been one of Roy’s defenders over the last couple of years because I really believe he has done a great job in keeping us up considering the squad depth and injuries we have had but I have also said that now is the season that he will really be judged because we have some squad depth for once.

People have to remember that we have started off this season riddled with injuries once again our only regular starting defender in the first few games from last year was Ward but yet we still looked solid at the back. This isn’t by chance, it is because of the tactics that a lot of you hate. Players know the system.

Liverpool havnt shut up because they are missing VVD but we were missing Cahill, Sakho, Tomkins, PVA and all to long injuries. These are facts that a lot of you seem to erase from your memories when it suits.

I have no doubt there is going to be some awful performances this season but I also believe we are going to have our best ever season in the division.


Nor have the media. It's the same with Citeh and the loss of Aguero and Jesus in the opening games (as well as the longer Laporte absence) BUT barely a mention of our injury list (a reserve back four for most of our games so far), nor of how well Kouyate has filled in in the absence of THREE regular CBs. Similarly, the media make little comment about Burnley's injury list. Basically teams like Burnley and us are not wanted in the PL because the media don't like our style of football. When we do our counter-attacking well, it works a treat - like yesterday; sometimes (and sadly over the last six months or so more frequently) it's dreadful to watch (last week being the pits despite our getting a draw).

We have our strongest ever squad this season - with cover in all positions. Hodgson has options he hasn't really had before. let's see how he uses them. we should be looking to stay in the top half of the table.

 

Alexi_the_Eagle Flag Newton-le-Willows 25 Oct 20 1.34pm

Originally posted by PalazioVecchio

Fifth in the table and a win at Old Trafford and some of your feckers are still not happy.


jeeez , i give up.

Some fans will never be happy. They let pessimism and cynicism drive their unhealthy obsession with wanting us to ditch Roy for an attack minded manager.

 


"Look at that. Accident blackspot? These aren't accidents! They're throwing themselves into the road gladly! Throwing themselves into the road to escape all this hideousness!"

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 25 Oct 20 3.01pm

in to the end of the season then we go for Gerrard as some poster has already suggested - the Brighton performance was a low point but Jairo seems to be playing like a new signing and is great in possession - he will help us to make the game more so I hope and expect him to keep his place in the team

 

croydon proud Flag Any european country i fancy! 25 Oct 20 7.02pm

Originally posted by EddieMac

I’m not for for one minute saying I love to watch Palace under Roy week in and out but what I will say is that there is more to football than the way Fulham played yesterday and the way Brighton played last weekend, passing the ball around from side to side with absolutely no end product. It may look nice to watch but it means nothing without points on the board.

I have been one of Roy’s defenders over the last couple of years because I really believe he has done a great job in keeping us up considering the squad depth and injuries we have had but I have also said that now is the season that he will really be judged because we have some squad depth for once.

People have to remember that we have started off this season riddled with injuries once again our only regular starting defender in the first few games from last year was Ward but yet we still looked solid at the back. This isn’t by chance, it is because of the tactics that a lot of you hate. Players know the system.

Liverpool havnt shut up because they are missing VVD but we were missing Cahill, Sakho, Tomkins, PVA and all to long injuries. These are facts that a lot of you seem to erase from your memories when it suits.

I have no doubt there is going to be some awful performances this season but I also believe we are going to have our best ever season in the division.

Yehmun!

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 25 Oct 20 9.18pm

Originally posted by rob1969

Tip

Top London club tonight too - if that’s worth anything !


Still top London club tonight with the Arse losing to a late Vardy goal (only his 11th against them!). Only Spurs can overtake us but they'll need to beat Burnley up North to do so.
COYP

 

redshift Flag Toronto 25 Oct 20 9.36pm

Originally posted by doombear

...nor of how well Kouyate has filled in in the absence of THREE regular CBs.

I just wanted to support doombear's observation here. Kouyate has been stellar at CB imho. I never really liked him in the midfield but he's filled in here wonderfully.

 


Success will lie to you but failure always tells you the truth.

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Roy In