You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > 3rd goal ruled out for offside
November 22 2026 7.22pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

3rd goal ruled out for offside


K9Teddy Flag Epsom 25 Oct 20 7.35am

Anyone else got a view on our disallowed 3rd goal yesterday that was ruled out for offside. TV only showed one replay and I couldn’t see where the offence occurred. Was hoping to see again on MOTD but it wasn’t shown for some reason which I don’t understand. Maybe I’ve gone mad but did anyone else think the same.

 

A89M Flag Streatham 25 Oct 20 7.43am

Yes I thought the same, it wasn’t offside. The replay slowed down when the ball was played through to PVA and it didn’t look like he was offside, Wilf was but he wasn’t involved at that point. When PvA played it across the goal, Wilf was behind the ball so not offside. It baffled me why it was never looked at or even mentioned by the commentary. Maybe PVA was offside but it was so close I thought it needed VAR and the lines to confirm it to us.

 

BarEagle Flag Monmouth 25 Oct 20 7.46am

Originally posted by A89M

Yes I thought the same, it wasn’t offside. The replay slowed down when the ball was played through to PVA and it didn’t look like he was offside, Wilf was but he wasn’t involved at that point. When PvA played it across the goal, Wilf was behind the ball so not offside. It baffled me why it was never looked at or even mentioned by the commentary. Maybe PVA was offside but it was so close I thought it needed VAR and the lines to confirm it to us.

I was of the same opinion. It just seemed to be fudged.

 

K9Teddy Flag Epsom 25 Oct 20 7.51am

I wonder whether the AR has just messed up and because he flagged Fulham could argue they stopped playing, which is why VAR couldn’t get involved. Like you say I’m sure PVA was on side, and then so was Wilf by the time it was crossed in.

 

subbuteo Flag 25 Oct 20 9.58am

Originally posted by A89M

Yes I thought the same, it wasn’t offside. The replay slowed down when the ball was played through to PVA and it didn’t look like he was offside, Wilf was but he wasn’t involved at that point. When PvA played it across the goal, Wilf was behind the ball so not offside. It baffled me why it was never looked at or even mentioned by the commentary. Maybe PVA was offside but it was so close I thought it needed VAR and the lines to confirm it to us.

I think point is that wilf was involved because he went on to score. He gained an advantage and was able to be first to cross by being offside when ball played to PVA. Shame but that’s the rule

 

K9Teddy Flag Epsom 25 Oct 20 10.04am

I’m pretty certain gaining an advantage only applies to the ball coming back of the post or keeper or defender

 

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 25 Oct 20 11.27am

it looked a decent goal to me.

this year the referees are ruining the game with overzealous rules.

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 26 Oct 20 7.56am

Originally posted by subbuteo

I think point is that wilf was involved because he went on to score. He gained an advantage and was able to be first to cross by being offside when ball played to PVA. Shame but that’s the rule

Yes, I get confused as to the difference between one or two phases of play and returning from an offside position to collect the ball. Is he offside as he was returning from an offside position to an onside position in the same phase of play. If it is two separate phases of play then surely he would not have been offside?

Do we have a ref on this Board who can clarify?

 

K9Teddy Flag Epsom 26 Oct 20 10.45am

I take my initial comments back PVA was offside when the ball was played through, I’ve just managed to find a replay online. I need my eyes tested. Still strange MOTD didn’t show it though.

 

h.smith91 Flag Sanderstead 27 Oct 20 10.10am

Originally posted by K9Teddy

I take my initial comments back PVA was offside when the ball was played through, I’ve just managed to find a replay online. I need my eyes tested. Still strange MOTD didn’t show it though.

I've been searching for the footage as i was convinced PVA was onside, but can't find it anywhere, Where did you find it? could you post a link? Cheers

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 27 Oct 20 10.16am

Originally posted by K9Teddy

I take my initial comments back PVA was offside when the ball was played through, I’ve just managed to find a replay online. I need my eyes tested. Still strange MOTD didn’t show it though.

If it was a controversial or contentious decision I am sure MOTD would have shown the incident.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 27 Oct 20 10.23am

Originally posted by Willo

If it was a controversial or contentious decision I am sure MOTD would have shown the incident.

No Willo, you give us too much credit, you know MOTD couldn't give a stuff about something that benefits Palace.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 27 Oct 20 10.28am

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

No Willo, you give us too much credit, you know MOTD couldn't give a stuff about something that benefits Palace.

This has not been part of my thinking.
For avoidance of doubt, I have not seen the incident.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 27 Oct 20 10.56am

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

No Willo, you give us too much credit, you know MOTD couldn't give a stuff about something that benefits Palace.

Indeed, there was not a lot of incidents and they did not show Bats offside goal either

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 27 Oct 20 11.18am

Originally posted by Spiderman

Indeed, there was not a lot of incidents and they did not show Bats offside goal either

I will assume it was clearly offside and as such not a contententious decision for MOTD to highlight.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 27 Oct 20 1.25pm

Willo, please don't tell me you are a supporter of MOTD's unbiased approach to tv coverage!

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 27 Oct 20 2.02pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Willo, please don't tell me you are a supporter of MOTD's unbiased approach to tv coverage!

I cannot form an opinion as to the approach of MOTD as I watch the programme once in a blue moon.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 27 Oct 20 9.38pm

Originally posted by Willo

I will assume it was clearly offside and as such not a contententious decision for MOTD to highlight.

It was one of the few incidents worth watching for the neutral. They seem to show similar incidents for other clubs

 

Scott67 Flag Eastbourne 27 Oct 20 10.05pm

I thought it was a good goal but have seen it since and it was off-side. PVA was clearly off-side when the ball was played through to him.

 


You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > 3rd goal ruled out for offside