You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Clyne Impact
November 16 2026 5.03am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Clyne Impact


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 10 Nov 20 8.39am

PVA links up with Zaha and Eze brilliantly though, it's a horrible problem.

 

palace chick Flag South Croydon 10 Nov 20 9.47am

Originally posted by Tickled pink

PVA links up with Zaha and Eze brilliantly though, it's a horrible problem.

Not only that, we moan that we don’t get enough players in the opposition box but PVA constantly gets forward causing problems. Thought against Leeds it was him pushing forward that caused them greater problems than if Mitchell had played? It’s a good dilemma to have and I prefer at the moment PVA being selected?

 

eaglesdare Flag 10 Nov 20 10.02am

Originally posted by palace chick

Not only that, we moan that we don’t get enough players in the opposition box but PVA constantly gets forward causing problems. Thought against Leeds it was him pushing forward that caused them greater problems than if Mitchell had played? It’s a good dilemma to have and I prefer at the moment PVA being selected?

remember his winning goal at old trafford last season? 93rd min and he is in the opposition box scoring a goal!

I do like PVA getting forward!

 

PatrickA Flag London 10 Nov 20 10.04am

The way that many sides play by blocking central spaces attacking full backs are very useful.
They are sometimes the only players with space on the field to operate.
I’m of the opinion that we look better as an attacking team when PVA plays.
His overlaps help take the markers away from Wilf.
If PVA was a very good defender as well he’d possibly with. Champions League Club.
I hope Mitchell works out but at the moment he’s promising.
He has a tendency to allow crosses.
Ward is still a reliable and consistent defender without offering much going forward.
I’m hoping Clyne will improve as he increases his fitness levels.
As to Ferguson, that’s anybody’s guess.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 10 Nov 20 10.32am

It's good to have options as there will be games when we will need FBs who are more solid defensively and others where we will want the attacking options.

 

samprior Flag Hamburg 10 Nov 20 11.37am

I'm just glad we signed him otherwise we'd be a bit stuffed with Ward injured and Fergusson no where near fit.

His performances have been solid enough and tbh honest more than I was expecting as he'd not played on the prem for something like 18 months.

 

palace99 Flag New Mills 10 Nov 20 12.08pm

Originally posted by esox lucius

Thought he could have done better with Branford’s goal on Saturday. He got across to Banford then didn’t do anything, maybe he thought he was second to win the ball and might concede a pen. He’ll do for now but personally I prefer Wardy.

i think you are being quite hard on him. We had 2 centre backs on Sat and Leeds only had 1 striker. For both the goal and the VAR one it looked like Dann was pulled out of position and then Koyoate 'lost' Bamford. Not sure if the right back can be at fault.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 10 Nov 20 12.39pm

Originally posted by palace chick

Not only that, we moan that we don’t get enough players in the opposition box but PVA constantly gets forward causing problems. Thought against Leeds it was him pushing forward that caused them greater problems than if Mitchell had played? It’s a good dilemma to have and I prefer at the moment PVA being selected?

We obviously all want/need mitchell to keep on progressing but you're right we also very much need PVA outside the oppositions box, Harry Hill would say 'Fight!' lol

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 10 Nov 20 12.54pm

Originally posted by palace99

i think you are being quite hard on him. We had 2 centre backs on Sat and Leeds only had 1 striker. For both the goal and the VAR one it looked like Dann was pulled out of position and then Koyoate 'lost' Bamford. Not sure if the right back can be at fault.

It's not always a fault for any of our players to have to face the sort of good play that Leeds had to make their opportunity, sometimes some moves are just too good and if I'm honest I enjoyed watching it even though it was against my team and I know that sounds weird but I'd rather watch us play and beat a team that is able to harm us and Leeds did a good job of upsetting our team, it makes the enjoyment of beating these teams so much more.

Thankfully in the end they made far more mistakes and in the wrong place than we did.

I'd like to add I've watched first hand us trying to beat Shrewsbury at home too many times so I fully understand the really bad moments we've had.

Edited by Tickled pink (10 Nov 2020 12.59pm)

 

eaglesdare Flag 10 Nov 20 2.47pm

without mistakes there would hardly be any goals scored in football.

Cant be perfect every match!

 

The Dolphin Flag 10 Nov 20 3.30pm

I think signing him was a good move and given how long it is since he played I reckon he has done really well.
A positive impact on the team in my opinion and I love when old players return - especially when they still have something to offer.
A win win for me!

 

A1969Eagle Flag Redhill 11 Nov 20 3.20pm

Well done Clyne.. I see promise.

For a player out with serious injury last season and not played for a year and now has quality to return the Premiership says some thing people may under estimate just how good the Premiership is.
Yes he needs a few games under his belt and some confidence and I think it shows, he loves the Palace... remember our club sold him, he didnt want to leave.. my respect to give him a season with us.. remember the value the team said with Sako, so much they brought him back again, but his injuries took their toll.

 

sprites Flag Auckland 11 Nov 20 7.34pm

Originally posted by palace99

i think you are being quite hard on him. We had 2 centre backs on Sat and Leeds only had 1 striker. For both the goal and the VAR one it looked like Dann was pulled out of position and then Koyoate 'lost' Bamford. Not sure if the right back can be at fault.

MMmmm nah I agree with the previous post...Clyney definitely bottled it. Ward would've thrown himself at it and probably stopped the goal.

 

eaglesdare Flag 12 Nov 20 10.19am

Originally posted by sprites

MMmmm nah I agree with the previous post...Clyney definitely bottled it. Ward would've thrown himself at it and probably stopped the goal.

Perhaps clyne thought he was last man and if miss timed it would be down to ten men plus a penalty.

Its not like ward has never made a mistake. Clyne is doing his best and has been thrown straight in!

 

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 12 Nov 20 12.41pm

Originally posted by A1969Eagle

Well done Clyne.. I see promise.

For a player out with serious injury last season and not played for a year and now has quality to return the Premiership says some thing people may under estimate just how good the Premiership is.
Yes he needs a few games under his belt and some confidence and I think it shows, he loves the Palace... remember our club sold him, he didnt want to leave.. my respect to give him a season with us.. remember the value the team said with Sako, so much they brought him back again, but his injuries took their toll.

That's not how I remember it.
Thought that he was straight ip with us - and said that he wouldn't be signing a new contract, but wanted to move on when he did. he didn't sulk, or let it affect his play. He got the Move he wanted and all were happy for him.
I remember thinking that it was very professional way of going about things, and moved him up in my estimations.

Maybe I just made that all up!

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 12 Nov 20 3.47pm

Originally posted by eaglesdare

Perhaps clyne thought he was last man and if miss timed it would be down to ten men plus a penalty.

Its not like ward has never made a mistake. Clyne is doing his best and has been thrown straight in!

Clyne never played at all last season so I never expected him to hit the ground running with us.

 

Charles Flag Forest Hill 12 Nov 20 4.23pm

Originally posted by Willo

He was at Bournemouth the season before last and played 14 times for them in the PL. He wasn't at Bournemouth last season, in fact he never played a single game 2019-20.
His last game prior to joining us was in May 2019 when he played for Bournemouth in their 5-3 defeat against us.

Edited by Willo (09 Nov 2020 2.17pm)

In fact as I recall it we were said to be seriously considering him in the summer of 2019 but interest was terminated by his injury.

 

taylors lovechild Flag 13 Nov 20 10.58am

I think he's looked fairly solid and gets forward more than Ward. On that point though, Townsend never seems to pass to him unless he absolutely has to, even when it seems like the right option. It does mean Townsend is getting a bit more space (as Clyne pulls a defender away) but I just wonder why he isn't passing to him? Regarding PvA, I don't think it's any coincidence that we're looking more threatening with him back in the team. He seems to get in the opposition box more than our midfield. As well as I think Mitchell has done, he just doesn't carry that threat.

 

aashman12 Flag 13 Nov 20 11.20am

Originally posted by AppleSource

I think Clyne's recent impact on Palace has gone under the radar a little: No fireworks, just defensive consistency, which is exactly what we need.

He offers great defensive solidity - where Ward lacks, tactical nous, has the speed to get himself out of trouble and provides support in the attacking half.

It will take more time to integrate and adjust, but he's already proven real astute signing. Well done to management!

Don't think you've been watching enough of joel ward.

 

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Clyne Impact