You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Benteke & Batshuayi
November 16 2026 5.03am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Benteke & Batshuayi


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 01 Dec 20 12.04am

Originally posted by sprites

That's harsh. Benteke changed the dynamic when he came on. We finally had a focal point and could build attacks.

He did well to beat the defender to that header and it was a great save from the keeper. Another day, that goes in.

Can't recall the other moments you're talking about (but not doubting they happened).

If we have other strikers banging them in, the fair enough, we can't justify CB's inclusion. But when no one's scoring, we might as well include him if we play better as a whole.

Edited by sprites (30 Nov 2020 11.28pm)

Up until Zaha's absence I don't think the selection of Bats had been a problem and Benteke hasn't exactly covered himself in glory in the meantime IMO.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 01 Dec 20 12.19am

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

Up until Zaha's absence I don't think the selection of Bats had been a problem and Benteke hasn't exactly covered himself in glory in the meantime IMO.

I would not be surprised to see Benteke start against WBA.

 

sprites Flag Auckland 01 Dec 20 1.23am

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

Up until Zaha's absence I don't think the selection of Bats had been a problem and Benteke hasn't exactly covered himself in glory in the meantime IMO.

It hasn't been a problem as such...but nor has it solved the lack of goalscoring issues. And while he may not have covered himself in glory in terms of scoring, we've looked a more dangerous outfit with him on the field.

I'd 100% start him against WBA.

 

eag-les Flag Coulsdon 01 Dec 20 9.08am

The problem is RH. He destroys players' confidence
Wrong tactics, wrong team selection - plays a wing back as CF -jeeze! no plan B, no clue on subs
Bats will go the same way as Tekkers (and Max!) if he stays here. Just my opinion of course

 


If I agreed with you we'd both be wrong

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 01 Dec 20 7.17pm

A bit like Shearer and Sutton. Slightly less prolific perhaps.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 01 Dec 20 8.52pm

Originally posted by Willo

I would not be surprised to see Benteke start against WBA.

Interesting. If I were in Roy's position at the moment I'm not sure I'd be willing to trust Benteke to help preserve my job.

 

sprites Flag Auckland 01 Dec 20 10.24pm

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

Interesting. If I were in Roy's position at the moment I'm not sure I'd be willing to trust Benteke to help preserve my job.

I'm not sure I'd trust a lot of the current squad. VG, Cahill, PVA, Luka, Macca, Wilf. Maybe Eze. That's about it.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 02 Dec 20 2.11am

Originally posted by Willo

Benteke has played in 2 games for Belgium since season 2016-17 and in those games he scored against Cyprus and San Marino.In the 2016-17 season he scored against Gibraltar.

Batshuayi has scored in recent seasons for Belgium against the likes of Iceland,Cyprus, San Marino,Kasakhstan, Tunisia etc etc so hardlly world beaters.
In club matches he has scored a solitary goal in his last 24 games and that was against Hull.


Look at you trying to discredit people you can only play against what is put up against you.

That is a dumb argument they are playing for number one ranked team in the world so you really think they are going to just select two useless players.

You are looking at things way to single even Roy seize this stats do not tell the full story if you are in a club team which do not create hardly any chances or play a way which benefits/ uses your skill traits are are you suppose to get the goals it also doesn't take into account the other work done on the pitch a strikers job is not to just score goals.

I bet you right now if you transferred Benteke to even a team like West Ham he would start scoring may not be 20 goals season but it would be 10 at least (Palace play football like they want to walk the ball into the net from center that doesn't benefit either of these players)

 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

sprites Flag Auckland 02 Dec 20 2.38am

Originally posted by grumpymort


Look at you trying to discredit people you can only play against what is put up against you.

That is a dumb argument they are playing for number one ranked team in the world so you really think they are going to just select two useless players.

You are looking at things way to single even Roy seize this stats do not tell the full story if you are in a club team which do not create hardly any chances or play a way which benefits/ uses your skill traits are are you suppose to get the goals it also doesn't take into account the other work done on the pitch a strikers job is not to just score goals.

I bet you right now if you transferred Benteke to even a team like West Ham he would start scoring may not be 20 goals season but it would be 10 at least (Palace play football like they want to walk the ball into the net from center that doesn't benefit either of these players)

Couldn't agree more with this...he'd start banging them in.

Edited by sprites (02 Dec 2020 2.39am)

 

Rogers Don Flag Horsham 02 Dec 20 10.20am

I have always been a fan of Townsend, but his recent form has been woeful. Eze and Zaha are our best attacking options plus Ayew when he is at his best. Batshuayi has need very disappointing since he returned and should be on the bench. So I would play 4-3-3 with Benteke leading the line and a midfield of Schlupp, McArthur and McCarthy (when fit) plus a defence of Ward, Tomkins (when fit), Cahill and Van Arnholt.
We also need an attacking midfielder 8n January. Barkley would have been perfect.

 


Let's keep the ball this season!

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 02 Dec 20 11.50am

Originally posted by Rogers Don

I have always been a fan of Townsend, but his recent form has been woeful. Eze and Zaha are our best attacking options plus Ayew when he is at his best. Batshuayi has need very disappointing since he returned and should be on the bench. So I would play 4-3-3 with Benteke leading the line and a midfield of Schlupp, McArthur and McCarthy (when fit) plus a defence of Ward, Tomkins (when fit), Cahill and Van Arnholt.
We also need an attacking midfielder 8n January. Barkley would have been perfect.

If we had an attacking midfielder he'd be so busy tracking back it would be pointless. Even Eze and Wlif have to constantly track back. Eze let it slip in an interview which was then backed up by Roy. You really couldn't make this up. Think of the attacking midfielders we have or have had since Roy (I'm trying to forget). What happened to them?

 


Red and Blue Army!

southnorwoodhill Flag 02 Dec 20 12.01pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

If we had an attacking midfielder he'd be so busy tracking back it would be pointless. Even Eze and Wlif have to constantly track back. Eze let it slip in an interview which was then backed up by Roy. You really couldn't make this up. Think of the attacking midfielders we have or have had since Roy (I'm trying to forget). What happened to them?

Under Hodgson we never had / have a midfielder who can carry the ball forward 10 yards and break the opposition line. It's all square / back / pass to Wilf. Square pegs round holes, unbalanced team. When Schlupp gets put out as a centre forward you know something is very wrong indeed.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 02 Dec 20 12.07pm

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

Under Hodgson we never had / have a midfielder who can carry the ball forward 10 yards and break the opposition line. It's all square / back / pass to Wilf. Square pegs round holes, unbalanced team. When Schlupp gets put out as a centre forward you know something is very wrong indeed.

Yes we have. RLC, however he unfortunately went back to Chelsea. He made a massive difference to our side when fit.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 02 Dec 20 12.08pm

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

Under Hodgson we never had / have a midfielder who can carry the ball forward 10 yards and break the opposition line. It's all square / back / pass to Wilf. Square pegs round holes, unbalanced team. When Schlupp gets put out as a centre forward you know something is very wrong indeed.

Schlupp has played as a striker.Many years ago,when Schlupp was a teenager, Brentford signed him on loan from Leicester as a striker and he did score a few goals for them.

A few years back I recall seeing him play up front,possibly for Leicester, and I formed the view that he seemed to lack composure in front of goal.
He has certainly played in a few positions and has been given that "Versatile" tag.


Edited by Willo (02 Dec 2020 12.12pm)

 

PatrickA Flag London 02 Dec 20 12.13pm

Benteke and Batshuayi may have been better appreciated in an earlier era when 4_4-2 was the norm ànd teams tried to get the ball to the strikers as quickly as possible.
In a similar vein to the way we used to utilise Bright and Wright.
Occasionally I used to visit the old training ground at Mitcham and many of the drills were exclusively on providing crosses to them.
You may remember Neil Redfearn who was a decent footballer with a very good shot.
I once asked him why he didn't have more shots on goal. He said he wasn't allowed as he was instructed to always hit Bright and Wright when in an attacking position.
The build up is much slower now and strikers are expected to be the first line of defence.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 02 Dec 20 12.16pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Yes we have. RLC, however he unfortunately went back to Chelsea. He made a massive difference to our side when fit.

Yes, you're right, RLC is the type of player I had in mind, that seems like an age ago now. He was injured for a fair few games if I recall.
I was hoping Kouyate might be able to do a Viera and fulfil that role but alas no.

Edited by southnorwoodhill (02 Dec 2020 12.22pm)

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 02 Dec 20 12.19pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

Benteke and Batshuayi may have been better appreciated in an earlier era when 4_4-2 was the norm ànd teams tried to get the ball to the strikers as quickly as possible.
In a similar vein to the way we used to utilise Bright and Wright.
Occasionally I used to visit the old training ground at Mitcham and many of the drills were exclusively on providing crosses to them.
You may remember Neil Redfearn who was a decent footballer with a very good shot.
I once asked him why he didn't have more shots on goal. He said he wasn't allowed as he was instructed to always hit Bright and Wright when in an attacking position.
The build up is much slower now and strikers are expected to be the first line of defence.

Perhaps we should try 4-2-4 and play long ball

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 02 Dec 20 12.52pm

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

Yes, you're right, RLC is the type of player I had in mind, that seems like an age ago now. He was injured for a fair few games if I recall.
I was hoping Kouyate might be able to do a Viera and fulfil that role but alas no.

Edited by southnorwoodhill (02 Dec 2020 12.22pm)

Trouble is Kouyate hasnt been able to do that due to been used as a CB, especially end of last season & all this.

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

sprites Flag Auckland 02 Dec 20 7.53pm

Originally posted by eagleman13

Trouble is Kouyate hasnt been able to do that due to been used as a CB, especially end of last season & all this.

Kouyate has lots of energy and zip...but has the control of a donkey and zero vision. CB is his future, I reckon.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 03 Dec 20 4.10pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

If we had an attacking midfielder he'd be so busy tracking back it would be pointless. Even Eze and Wlif have to constantly track back. Eze let it slip in an interview which was then backed up by Roy. You really couldn't make this up. Think of the attacking midfielders we have or have had since Roy (I'm trying to forget). What happened to them?


Only if that is what the system is setup to do.

Wilf doesn't track back at all hes very lazy now watch him spends more time walking around and when you do see him back their its due to reasons like defending a corner etc.

This is Roy system it isn't a bad system if you are playing against big teams away but for everyone else its terrible which is why you keep seeing our home form plus the teams below mid table we don't look great against. (top managers adapt Roy has never been able to do this he got away with it in the past because of the talent he had but even then that can only take you so far)

Look at his record it sums him up same pattern smaller teams he doesn't know how to play against.

 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Benteke & Batshuayi