This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Gribbo
He is not going to play here until he is over 23, so why not go. Tottenham played a 16 year old in the cup, we did not bring any youngsters in. Stay with Palace and you might get loaned out to Tranmere or Torquay. According to those that watch the development squad regularly there aren't any players there good enough for our first team and if the two that were loaned out to Tranmere and Torquay were good enough they would have been loaned to clubs in higher divisions. My understanding is that the current under 23 squad contains players that might make it at a lower level plus those that won't make it at all but the future is with the under 18 squad some of whom are highly thought of and I really can't see Parish spending all that money on upgrading the academy and employing a manager that won't utilise the players as the whole idea of the academy is to save on transfer fees in the future
|
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
No-one has said that he isn't any good There's plenty saying it if our first team midfielders are better.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
There have been loads of 16 year old breaking through in other teams. Never here, certainly not recently. I'm getting on in years, so my memory isn't as good as it was - who are the '' loads of 16 year old '' you are referring to ? And '' never here, certainly not recently '' - well which it it ? I haven't seen Atta play, but I'm interested in your opinion as you clearly have if you can guarantee that he can pass the ball better than some of our highly experienced first teamers.
Old, Ungifted and White |
|
|
Originally posted by NEILLO
I'm getting on in years, so my memory isn't as good as it was - who are the '' loads of 16 year old '' you are referring to ? And '' never here, certainly not recently '' - well which it it ? I haven't seen Atta play, but I'm interested in your opinion as you clearly have if you can guarantee that he can pass the ball better than some of our highly experienced first teamers. Highly experienced doesn't equate to any good. I've always considered McArthur as industrious but by no means a passer. Surely you see us play - do I have to go over our lack of creativity in midfield? It's not my rating of Atta that matters - he is rated.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by doombear
Looking at our squads, Atta isn't even in the U18s. Should he have been? No idea. Our U18s (and apparently the younger squads) are exciting prospects, We will inevitably lose some who either can't wait to progress or are star-struck by bigger clubs purportedly interested in them. Once we start seeing players from the U18s etc. progressing to the first team squad and staying there, more youngsters may be prepared to stay, but that is probably a couple of years or so down the line. We just have to hope we can retain our PL status until we see the fruit from the Academy investment. Touch and go imo. Hope Atta makes a good choice when he does leave. He wont be 'listed' per se in out squads, as he hasn't/wont sign a Development/Professional terms with the club.
This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise. |
|
|
Originally posted by eagleman13
He wont be 'listed' per se in out squads, as he hasn't/wont sign a Development/Professional terms with the club. It's an interesting point but my reading was that we signed him from Millwall. Surely, he is on some kind of terms?
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
It's an interesting point but my reading was that we signed him from Millwall. Surely, he is on some kind of terms? Good point, short answer, ive not got a bloody clue. I assume he is on a 'youth' contract that enabled us to get him from the knuckledraggers, i know he did feature a few times in the U18's pre Cat1 status. What happens now, is anyones guess.
This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise. |
|
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
Highly experienced doesn't equate to any good. I've always considered McArthur as industrious but by no means a passer. Surely you see us play - do I have to go over our lack of creativity in midfield? It's not my rating of Atta that matters - he is rated. Yes, I do so see us play. Yes, we lack creativity in midfield. You are advocating playing an untried, if highly rated, 16 year old - who you '' guarantee '' can pass the ball better than experienced Premier League players, but have never actually seen play. Read that back and ask yourself exactly how much sense that makes. He hasn't even signed professional terms for Palace, yet you think he should be considered for first team. Yes, it's annoying that we stand to lose him, I imagine Millwall felt the same way when we signed him from them, but that's the game.
Old, Ungifted and White |
|
|
Originally posted by NEILLO
Yes, I do so see us play. Yes, we lack creativity in midfield. You are advocating playing an untried, if highly rated, 16 year old - who you '' guarantee '' can pass the ball better than experienced Premier League players, but have never actually seen play. Read that back and ask yourself exactly how much sense that makes. He hasn't even signed professional terms for Palace, yet you think he should be considered for first team. Yes, it's annoying that we stand to lose him, I imagine Millwall felt the same way when we signed him from them, but that's the game. Fair enough. Probably academic anyway.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by dreamwaverider
Football really needs to take a look at this. We have spent millions on our academy and no doubt millions more running it. Yet we can’t lock youngsters in with a contract. So any real potential we find can just walk whenever they want. This system is a free funnel of players to the Super clubs. If A Super club wants someone like Zion they get him free. Not only will he see the big lights and money but for sure they bribe them to go. Bit like we did to Millwall. And West Brom...
|
|
|
Originally posted by eagleman13
Good point, short answer, ive not got a bloody clue. I assume he is on a 'youth' contract that enabled us to get him from the knuckledraggers, i know he did feature a few times in the U18's pre Cat1 status. What happens now, is anyones guess. I have no idea about any contract but I believe he has accepted a scholarship from Palace. Not sure why we are, apparently, bound to pay Millwall money
|
|
|
Originally posted by pompeyeagle
I’m sure every Premier League club has got a youngster, probably several, who are “destined for great things” as they say. As we all know the vast majority don’t make it. If he thinks he would be better off somewhere else we should just let him go. It’s not like we have a manager who likes to give youth a chance anyway. Remember Kyle da Silva ? According to the Palace coaching staff, he was '' better than Victor Moses was at the same age ''....but unfortunately he couldn't maintain that progress...happens a lot as you said.
Old, Ungifted and White |
|
|
There is a system in place that is designed to guard against this. The compensation package set by a tribunal. Issue is the amounts for players they come to is laughably low so as to become irrelevant. Originally posted by dreamwaverider
Football really needs to take a look at this. We have spent millions on our academy and no doubt millions more running it. Yet we can’t lock youngsters in with a contract. So any real potential we find can just walk whenever they want. This system is a free funnel of players to the Super clubs. If A Super club wants someone like Zion they get him free. Not only will he see the big lights and money but for sure they bribe them to go. Bit like we did to Millwall.
|
|
|
Originally posted by NEILLO
He's not the only one as there have been several more "next big things" that didn't turn out to be so including a Norwegian lad called Breymar (or similar) who arrrived in a blaze of publicity only to disappear soon afterwards and Reise Allassani who it was only a matter of time before he ran our midfield but is now at Dulwich Hamlet
|
|
|
Originally posted by crvenaeagle
And West Brom... Nah. Zion came from the Den.
|
|
|
Originally posted by dreamwaverider
Nah. Zion came from the Den.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.