This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
You obviously haven't seen 'Callan' lately, we bumped off just as many of theirs. Lived to 98 that is quite a score considering he was a spy. He admitted that communism, Russian style, had not been made to work. But his view of the communist cause as being a just and equal society remained, and that humanity my return to it. I think that is a valid argument. Except that’s not a valid argument at all. Communism may look all fine and dandy on paper but the one thing it completely fails to take into account is human nature, the desire to better oneself and improve one’s lot in life, a trait that has marked the onward progress of humanity through the millennia. Communism, by its very nature, stifles that quintessential urge. Communism can only ‘succeed’ through the suppression of the population by brutality, the denial of freedom of speech and thought, the suffocation of ideas at variance with its dogma which gives rise to the emergence of a privileged governing elite completely unanswerable to the governed, at which point it ceases to communist. This has happened everywhere that has been unfortunate enough to live under the system. Communism = totalitarianism. You absolutely can’t separate the two.
|
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
There was a big debate in the Soviet Union after the war, the main premise being that they won the war without the Allies help. This is mainly the view even today, but they do acknowledge the help particularly from USA armanents factories. But considering the sheer scale of the eastern front and the fact that 87% of German production was concentrated there, it is an epic victory for the soviets. it is difficult to imagine they would have been successful with a Tsar they would simply have chucked it in. And for us, if the Soviet Union had not been successful, Hitler and his superior military machine would have returned to fighting us on one front. When FDR said thank you Uncle Joe that's the reason IMO. The truthful versions of WW2 were never released in the mainstream. They got the Hollywood version. If you want the truth you have to go looking and it makes what was already horrific orders of magnitude worst. The British talk of the Blitz and rations and of losing relatives....I don't want to diminish that but when you compare how much the British suffered to where the decisive stuff happened it pales into comparison. It's certainly true that the Soviets killed the majority of Germans.....when I last looked they killed something like 4 out of 5 Germans who died. Like WW1 and indeed most large wars it came down to attrition and so those most ruthless and with the most human capital ultimately won....and then wrote the narrative. But there have been enough honest historians over the decades for the truth...that's rarely said in the mainstream to emerge that the Soviets won the majority of WW2. However, the Germans killed at least double of them and if you factor in civilians probably four times, though the real figures will never be known.....Indeed, the Soviets won pretty much the same way Vietham survived. Insomuch as they didn't care and just threw endless armies of unwilling human capital at the Germans until that and the winters turned the tide. The Germans were a nation of 80 million and with the Romanians and others collectively about a hundred fighting the Soviets.....a similarly disgusting leadership willing to butcher their own....who had hundreds of millions more. Hitler gambled as he knew that he had a year to defeat the Soviets and once 1942 was up Germany's defeat was an ever increasing certainty. But let it be said that as much as Hitler's regime was a nightmare, Stalin's was actually worse in terms of murdering innocence.....We slept with one devil to defeat another. Edited by Stirlingsays (28 Dec 2020 3.03pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Cucking Funt
Except that’s not a valid argument at all. Communism may look all fine and dandy on paper but the one thing it completely fails to take into account is human nature, the desire to better oneself and improve one’s lot in life, a trait that has marked the onward progress of humanity through the millennia. Communism, by its very nature, stifles that quintessential urge. Communism can only ‘succeed’ through the suppression of the population by brutality, the denial of freedom of speech and thought, the suffocation of ideas at variance with its dogma which gives rise to the emergence of a privileged governing elite completely unanswerable to the governed, at which point it ceases to communist. This has happened everywhere that has been unfortunate enough to live under the system. Communism = totalitarianism. You absolutely can’t separate the two. That may well be true, but interestingly many of these criticisms are present in capitalist societies too. Just with an illusion of genuine choice and autonomy bolted on.
|
|
|
Originally posted by BlueJay
That may well be true, but interestingly many of these criticisms are present in capitalist societies too. Just with an illusion of genuine choice and autonomy bolted on. That's true....but it doesn't as yet come with the bullet at the back of the head.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
That's true....but it doesn't as yet come with the bullet at the back of the head. True, rather than a bullet it is more of a long and lingering death of the spirit for the working man here!
|
|
|
Originally posted by BlueJay
That may well be true, but interestingly many of these criticisms are present in capitalist societies too. Just with an illusion of genuine choice and autonomy bolted on. It's just human nature, innit. Throughout history and to the present day, the strong will always oppress the weak.
|
|
|
Originally posted by BlueJay
True, rather than a bullet it is more of a long and lingering death of the spirit for the working man here! Yep, I think it's certainly true that our overlords aren't exactly overtly invested in improving the lives of little people. As has always been the case they seek what they think is best for themselves and then sell it, via their proxies, as best for you too. Edited by Stirlingsays (28 Dec 2020 3.45pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.