You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Thanks Roy
November 16 2026 5.03am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Thanks Roy


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 06 Jan 21 11.05am

In the final analysis, we play in a 'Tired' old stadium with one of the lowest capacities in the PL.

The much heralded 'Stadium Re-Development' in essence consists of a much-needed replacement for an ancient rickety stand, not a complete overhaul to modernise Selhurst Park and of course the building work is yet to get off the ground.
We don't have state-of-the-art training facilities enjoyed by other PL clubs and we have only quite recently attained 'Category 1' status for the academy.
We have an aged squad with little or no sell-on value for many of the players and I believe 78% of our income is spent on wages.
Our 'Net Spend covering this season and the previous 3 seasons has been about £10 Mill.

This is the reality and against this backdrop Mr Hodgson has secured PL survival for 3 seasons and many are of the opinion that this will extend to 4 seasons.
He has met his objectives and whilst many question his tactics, the end has justified the means.

Finally, we have now been in the PL for a few seasons and enjoyed watching our players perform on the 'Big stage' against some of the best players in the world.
A far cry from time when CPFC2010 took charge of the club after 'Administration'.

Edited by Willo (06 Jan 2021 11.14am)

 

A1969Eagle Flag Redhill 06 Jan 21 1.37pm

So if new manager comes and struggles after Roys three years of "holding fort" and he/she struggles with the team left, lets give the new person a "break"..

Originally posted by Willo

In the final analysis, we play in a 'Tired' old stadium with one of the lowest capacities in the PL.

The much heralded 'Stadium Re-Development' in essence consists of a much-needed replacement for an ancient rickety stand, not a complete overhaul to modernise Selhurst Park and of course the building work is yet to get off the ground.
We don't have state-of-the-art training facilities enjoyed by other PL clubs and we have only quite recently attained 'Category 1' status for the academy.
We have an aged squad with little or no sell-on value for many of the players and I believe 78% of our income is spent on wages.
Our 'Net Spend covering this season and the previous 3 seasons has been about £10 Mill.

This is the reality and against this backdrop Mr Hodgson has secured PL survival for 3 seasons and many are of the opinion that this will extend to 4 seasons.
He has met his objectives and whilst many question his tactics, the end has justified the means.

Finally, we have now been in the PL for a few seasons and enjoyed watching our players perform on the 'Big stage' against some of the best players in the world.
A far cry from time when CPFC2010 took charge of the club after 'Administration'.

Edited by Willo (06 Jan 2021 11.14am)

 

Knightstar Flag Guildford 06 Jan 21 2.09pm

I agree with Willo. It will be a very slow haul to get out of this lower mid-table position whilst the ownership structure remains as it is. In my view we desperately need new investment to exploit the fantastic potential we have of being the premier club in South London, which enjoys a great catchment area for support and recruits to our academy. I hope SP is making it a top priority to find new owners.

 

babylonjohn Flag St Leonards-on-Sea 06 Jan 21 2.14pm

Originally posted by Badger11

I think most people see the PL as 3 leagues relegation fodder, mid table and top 6.

Everton have spent a fortune and now have a world class manager and yet they still have not quite made the step up from mid table team to top 6/7.

They may do this season but it just shows how hard it is to make that next step. I see Palace as the top of a group of clubs that are potential relegation candidates out next step is to become solid mid table like Everton and Southampton.

I agree. I often check oddschecker relegation odds to see how others view us. We are between 9-1 and 11-1 for the drop. We are currently top of the relegation scrap with 6 teams below us on shorter odds.

 

PatrickA Flag London 06 Jan 21 2.38pm

What seems to have been lost is the point of the original poster’s position.
He’s not disputing whether Roy has met his objectives.
He’s not suggesting we should be higher in the table.
He’s not demanding Roy’s head.
He’s not suggesting that we’re not punching our weight.
He’s merely asking us to play the more attractive football we’ve shown we’re capable of this season more frequently, and allow Zaha and Eze off the leash.
Not really that controversial.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 06 Jan 21 3.31pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

What seems to have been lost is the point of the original poster’s position.
He’s not disputing whether Roy has met his objectives.
He’s not suggesting we should be higher in the table.
He’s not demanding Roy’s head.
He’s not suggesting that we’re not punching our weight.
He’s merely asking us to play the more attractive football we’ve shown we’re capable of this season more frequently, and allow Zaha and Eze off the leash.
Not really that controversial.

Maybe not, but Hodgson isn't going to change the habits of a lifetime. I don't think he even knows what to do with Eze, apart from playing him out of position. It's pure chance and bad luck for Schlupp that Eze got introduced after Schlupp's injury - however note how Eze gravitated to the centre of the field when he went on his run, not down the line. Why? Because that is his natural position. Poor square peg round hole Roy doesn't get it though.

 

nectoneagle Flag necton 06 Jan 21 3.50pm

Hi Guys , look I have been watching palace since Div 3 South days and can safely say this is the best it's been.
I agree that there is not a plan B and that with the financial constraints which are in place Roy is doing a decent job.
But for goodness such why oh why do we sometimes have to wait til half-time before we start playing , surely the players should know their orders from minute 1 .It almost looks as though they are told don't f**k up which puts the frighteners on them. As far as Riedewald is concerned he was brilliant , recalled for international duty then dropped for a work horse which is typical Roy

 

Westina Flag 06 Jan 21 3.51pm

Patrick..thanks for you support after my original post.
I read such a lot of negative stuff on this forum and I strongly believe that seeing the glass half full is always a better way of living life.
With that in mind all I was saying is that we should up the anti with regards to our teams style of playing football.
We have such a talented squad..and some very talented youngsters who compliment our more senior players...free them up a bit to play more attacking football...I am not suggesting we drop all of our defensive attributes but just go for it a bit more..let’s face it in the games we have played using negative tactics we have lost...so nothing to lose.
Nothing wrong with wanting to see our team play more attractive looking football!

 

babylonjohn Flag St Leonards-on-Sea 06 Jan 21 4.06pm

Its getting the balance right though isnt it. We thought we could go toe to toe with liverpool and get back into that game and they just went through us like a hot knife through butter. Was interesting to see us pressing sheff U high up the pitch when we were 2 up and confident that we had the match won.

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 06 Jan 21 4.28pm

Originally posted by babylonjohn

Its getting the balance right though isnt it. We thought we could go toe to toe with liverpool and get back into that game and they just went through us like a hot knife through butter. Was interesting to see us pressing sheff U high up the pitch when we were 2 up and confident that we had the match won.


It is about balance. The balance has to be based on defenders that can attack without being constantly caught out. And attackers that can defend seriously, and can retain the ball well in most situations.
Palace ,are not there yet. On both counts. Of course we can pull it off against some oppositions. But as we have seen recently against both Liverpool, and Villa,, the attacking intent was there , the balance was not. And in the second half of both games we paid dear.
Tactics don’t fetch brilliant performances on the whole ability does, and when put to a serious test we don’t have quiet enough of it throughout the side. to be able get the balance needed to play in an attractive style week in week out.

 

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 06 Jan 21 6.32pm

Originally posted by Willo

There is a saying "A bird in the hand is worth two in Shepherd's Bush".
My old 'Bird' now my wife hails from around that vicinity and on occasions used to watch Fulham play,as well as QPR when she was a young lass.

Next up....... Mrs Willo joins the Hol to answer the ‘old bird’ throwaway line and give her opinions on a young Willo and why she fell for him. Will the dictionary figure??

 


Bring back Brolin

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 06 Jan 21 6.37pm

Originally posted by dynamicdick

Next up....... Mrs Willo joins the Hol to answer the ‘old bird’ throwaway line and give her opinions on a young Willo and why she fell for him. Will the dictionary figure??

We met whilst both holidaying abroad and she has asserted that I was the last "Resort".

 

kingdowieonthewall Flag Sussex, ex-Cronx. 06 Jan 21 8.09pm

Originally posted by Willo

We met whilst both holidaying abroad and she has asserted that I was the last "Resort".

bognor is not abroad Willo

 


Kids,tired of being bothered by your pesky parents?
Then leave home, get a job & pay your own bills, while you still know everything.

Brinscalleagle2 Flag Brinscall 06 Jan 21 8.23pm

Originally posted by Willo

In the final analysis, we play in a 'Tired' old stadium with one of the lowest capacities in the PL.

The much heralded 'Stadium Re-Development' in essence consists of a much-needed replacement for an ancient rickety stand, not a complete overhaul to modernise Selhurst Park and of course the building work is yet to get off the ground.
We don't have state-of-the-art training facilities enjoyed by other PL clubs and we have only quite recently attained 'Category 1' status for the academy.
We have an aged squad with little or no sell-on value for many of the players and I believe 78% of our income is spent on wages.
Our 'Net Spend covering this season and the previous 3 seasons has been about £10 Mill.

This is the reality and against this backdrop Mr Hodgson has secured PL survival for 3 seasons and many are of the opinion that this will extend to 4 seasons.
He has met his objectives and whilst many question his tactics, the end has justified the means.

Finally, we have now been in the PL for a few seasons and enjoyed watching our players perform on the 'Big stage' against some of the best players in the world.
A far cry from time when CPFC2010 took charge of the club after 'Administration'.

Edited by Willo (06 Jan 2021 11.14am)

To me this is why we are in such good shape despite all these issues we are still in the top flight . As Nectoneagle said since the Third Division South days which is when I started watching CPFC these are halcyon days. Roy and the owners and management team have done well to maintain our position. The real issue now is how we move forward from here when Roy goes. The next manager will not be judged on keeping us in the top flight but managing a team that gets consistently in the top ten or higher. That will take a very talented manager with the current squad and for me with this squad is highly unlikely to be achieved. So to progress we need new players as well as a new manager. Can we actually afford it ?

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 06 Jan 21 9.38pm

Originally posted by Putitout


It is about balance. The balance has to be based on defenders that can attack without being constantly caught out. And attackers that can defend seriously, and can retain the ball well in most situations.
Palace ,are not there yet. On both counts. Of course we can pull it off against some oppositions. But as we have seen recently against both Liverpool, and Villa,, the attacking intent was there , the balance was not. And in the second half of both games we paid dear.
Tactics don’t fetch brilliant performances on the whole ability does, and when put to a serious test we don’t have quiet enough of it throughout the side. to be able get the balance needed to play in an attractive style week in week out.


Well said Putitout.

We simply don't have the right players to play attacking football against every opponent. Yes, we did well against WBA, West Ham and Sheff U, but we lack the speed required to press high and get back quick when moves break down.

I believe Hodgson will allow a more attacking set-up in some of our future games but it will depend on who we're playing.

 

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 06 Jan 21 9.54pm

Originally posted by Brinscalleagle2

To me this is why we are in such good shape despite all these issues we are still in the top flight . As Nectoneagle said since the Third Division South days which is when I started watching CPFC these are halcyon days. Roy and the owners and management team have done well to maintain our position. The real issue now is how we move forward from here when Roy goes. The next manager will not be judged on keeping us in the top flight but managing a team that gets consistently in the top ten or higher. That will take a very talented manager with the current squad and for me with this squad is highly unlikely to be achieved. So to progress we need new players as well as a new manager. Can we actually afford it ?

We cud free up a lot of wages by not renewing various contracts this summer, and we could replace the oldies and over-paid with up and coming players on lower salaries. Two out of Luka, Kouyate and the two Macs should not be in the first team squad next season, add Meyer and that's three midfielders to go, with Jairo + 2 we wud only need to bring in one frontline midfielder and have a youngster as the fifth midfielder (Banks or Dreher?) ... so I think a progressive squad rebuild is not only possible but necessary, urgent even.

 

Brinscalleagle2 Flag Brinscall 06 Jan 21 10.13pm

Originally posted by ex hibitionist

We cud free up a lot of wages by not renewing various contracts this summer, and we could replace the oldies and over-paid with up and coming players on lower salaries. Two out of Luka, Kouyate and the two Macs should not be in the first team squad next season, add Meyer and that's three midfielders to go, with Jairo + 2 we wud only need to bring in one frontline midfielder and have a youngster as the fifth midfielder (Banks or Dreher?) ... so I think a progressive squad rebuild is not only possible but necessary, urgent even.

Yes you are right a complete reshuffle is needed and maybe moving on our high wage earners could be our way to enabling change but I guess as well as Roy has done it will take a new manager to achieve it.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 07 Jan 21 10.04am

Originally posted by PatrickA

Perhaps the point being made in the original post which has been lost is that we can win, and win well, playing good football.
Our most negative performances against the likes of Chelsea, Burnley and Newcastle have resulted in defeats in any event.
Defend strongly by all means with our ageing defenders, and allow Zaha and Eze to flourish.
None of us can say for sure that playing attractively will result in worse results.
We weren’t exactly on the front foot playing attractively when we had that terrible losing run at the end of last season .

I’m content with our points total so far this season, and playing attacking football against Man U, Leeds, WBA has made a significant contribution.
Like the original poster, I would like that to continue and don’t see it as contentious.

You're looking at results and not performances and you're pigeon holing everything.
You need to analyse both teams on the day and not just ours.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 07 Jan 21 10.12am

Originally posted by PatrickA

We’ll have to agree to disagree.
Football is to be enjoyed not endured.

Results determine that, your team could be under huge pressure all game with their opponents hitting the bar and posts countless times and with balls cleared off the line, then with just one opportunity and through an awful mistake your team scores and wins the game and you'd be as happy as Larry wouldn't you.

60% + of football is actually quite boring.

The watched performance would suggest to me that the other team was playing the better football, the result suggests otherwise. Sad that I have to spell that out.

Edited by Tickled pink (07 Jan 2021 10.17am)

 

PatrickA Flag London 07 Jan 21 11.08am

I won't be lectured by the likes of you about how to watch football.
If you find 60% of football boring suggest you find a new pastime or a new team.

 

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Thanks Roy