This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by NEILLO
Sorry, I may be old skool, but I can't take any pundit seriously that wears animal print tops and pink (!) stilettos. I know Lineker is a looney leftie but I didn’t realise
|
|
|
Originally posted by NEILLO
Sorry, I may be old skool, but I can't take any pundit seriously that wears animal print tops and pink (!) stilettos. Jealousy's not a good trait you know
Living down here does have some advantages. At least you can see them cry. |
|
|
Originally posted by JRW2
I regret that I wouldn't trust a former referee to be objective. I still remember with bitterness that goal against Leeds (I think) many years ago which clearly crossed the line then was cleared - and disallowed. It was such a blatant refereeing error that the BBC actually brought on a retired official on the Today programme the following Monday to try to justify it. This guy was utterly shameless, pointing out that the ref had relied on the linesman, who couldn't see the ball because a player was obstructing his view. Yes, and the player obstructing his view was behind the goal line! So where was the ball? I was there and believe it was a cup game and the ref may have been Dermot Gallagher. Not only did the ball cross the line it was handled on the way in (I think Michael Duberry). It was at the Sainsburys end and I saw it clearly from the Upper Holmesdale. Not only was the goal not given but the handball (and resulting sending off) was also missed. This was perhaps the worst bit of refereeing I have ever seen at Selhurst and that is saying a lot! Referees stick together and always seem to go out of their way to find an excuse not to criticise one another. Occasionally Clattenburg (Mark to you Willo) appears on TV and he is truly nauseating and still totally up himself. Referees should be seen and not heard or neither in Clattenburg's case. Edited by Plumpton eagle (15 Jan 2021 2.29pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
Apart from John Fashanu, or was it Justin, I can’t remember which? Edited by Eaglecoops (15 Jan 2021 1.39pm) I cracked the very same comment of Facebook this morning ! ps - it was Justin ( appropriate name )
Old, Ungifted and White |
|
|
Originally posted by mezzer
Jealousy's not a good trait you know Don't get me wrong, I wouldn't have the guts to tell Souness to his face
Old, Ungifted and White |
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
From my personal perspective I would rather we went back to the old days and have just one commentator whose primary role was to identify the player on the ball and dispense with all the other drivel
|
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
From my personal perspective I would rather we went back to the old days and have just one commentator whose primary role was to identify the player on the ball and dispense with all the other drivel Agree
|
|
|
Originally posted by Spiderman
Agree With respect I disagree.I enjoy being educated by the supplementary information in relation to players. The commentators have treated us to a plethora of information relating to the players and the clubs on display and long may it continue.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
With respect I disagree.I enjoy being educated by the supplementary information in relation to players. The commentators have treated us to a plethora of information relating to the players and the clubs on display and long may it continue.
You say you disagree with Midlands, but you both agree that commentators don't need an assistant - "a sentiment with which I fully concur" (have to get the language right!). Midlands doesn't want the added-on information at all, while you want it but say that commentators already provide it. And you're right - I can't recall any "expert" ever telling us where someone was born or when he first scored a hat-trick. I'm reminded of dear old Bill Maclaren, the rugby commentator, who for years - before "progress" took over - handled the whole match on his own. He had what he called his "board", on which he wrote random but interesting facts about every player. Anyone who heard him will recall, after a player had perhaps scored a particularly good try, how he would exclaim, "They'll be celebrating in the streets of Selkirk/Llanelli/Cork/Northampton, or at xyz grammar school." Good old days!
|
|
|
Originally posted by JRW2
Midlands doesn't want the added-on information at all, while you want it Sky currently devote two channels for each match with one carrying artificial crowd noise and the other au naturel. When spectators are allowed back the second channel will be redundant so why not have one channel for those that just want to watch football and the other with additional commentary for all those that need to know the name of the player's first teddy bear or the colour of his favourite socks
|
|
|
Originally posted by JRW2
You say you disagree with Midlands, but you both agree that commentators don't need an assistant - "a sentiment with which I fully concur" (have to get the language right!). Midlands doesn't want the added-on information at all, while you want it but say that commentators already provide it. And you're right - I can't recall any "expert" ever telling us where someone was born or when he first scored a hat-trick. I'm reminded of dear old Bill Maclaren, the rugby commentator, who for years - before "progress" took over - handled the whole match on his own. He had what he called his "board", on which he wrote random but interesting facts about every player. Anyone who heard him will recall, after a player had perhaps scored a particularly good try, how he would exclaim, "They'll be celebrating in the streets of Selkirk/Llanelli/Cork/Northampton, or at xyz grammar school." Good old days! Where 'Midlands Eagle' and I are of different opinions is that he has a preference for just one commentator whose primary role is to identify the player on the ball and "dispense with all the other drivel". I have not had an issue with a former footballer acting as co-commentator providing insight from a footballer's perspective. Edited by Willo (15 Jan 2021 6.30pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by JRW2
You say you disagree with Midlands, but you both agree that commentators don't need an assistant - "a sentiment with which I fully concur" (have to get the language right!). Midlands doesn't want the added-on information at all, while you want it but say that commentators already provide it. And you're right - I can't recall any "expert" ever telling us where someone was born or when he first scored a hat-trick. I'm reminded of dear old Bill Maclaren, the rugby commentator, who for years - before "progress" took over - handled the whole match on his own. He had what he called his "board", on which he wrote random but interesting facts about every player. Anyone who heard him will recall, after a player had perhaps scored a particularly good try, how he would exclaim, "They'll be celebrating in the streets of Selkirk/Llanelli/Cork/Northampton, or at xyz grammar school." Good old days! This reminds me of the quip from Jeff Stelling "They will be dancing in the streets of 'Total Network Solutions' tonight"
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
Where 'Midlands Eagle' and I are of different opinions is that he has a preference for just one commentator whose primary role is to identify the player on the ball and "dispense with all the other drivel". I have not had an issue with a former footballer acting as co-commentator providing insight from a footballer's perspective. Edited by Willo (15 Jan 2021 6.30pm) And what I'm saying - and I thought (wrongly it seems) you were saying earlier - is that it's the "lead" commentator who provides the supplementary information, and he does that on his own. To repeat myself, I genuinely don't recall the "assistant" providing any of the background stuff. They aren't full-time, they don't feel any need to gen up on every player on the pitch beforehand, and all most of them can do is throw in a few observations that the average schoolboy footballer could make. I'm no expert, but I would hardly regard their contributions as providing insights.
|
|
|
b Edited by TheBigToePunt (15 Jan 2021 8.30pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by JRW2
And what I'm saying - and I thought (wrongly it seems) you were saying earlier - is that it's the "lead" commentator who provides the supplementary information, and he does that on his own. To repeat myself, I genuinely don't recall the "assistant" providing any of the background stuff. They aren't full-time, they don't feel any need to gen up on every player on the pitch beforehand, and all most of them can do is throw in a few observations that the average schoolboy footballer could make. I'm no expert, but I would hardly regard their contributions as providing insights. We clearly differ about the contributions of the erstwhile professional footballers who are co-commentators. These are not "Average schoolboy footballers" they are players who have been there and done it on the 'Big stage', been in 'Pressure cookers' at a high level and their experiences show through in commentary in various match situations. Besides instead of hearing a single voice for 90+ minutes there are two voices and the interactions between the two can often contain jocularity to add to the match experience for the viewer.
|
|
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
Sky eh? Where do you start? 1. Either stuff your coverage full of advert breaks every three minutes, or charge me a pretty penny to tune in. Doing both is a piss take. 2. Your unique selling point for cricket was that your subscribers would 'never miss a ball'. Why then do you think it's OK to cut away from a football match when the ball is in play to show me a series of shots of a manager chewing gum, or a replay of something I just saw for myself, or a section of the crowd carefully chosen for its positive social cross section? Last night sky had to show a replay of Tompkins getting booked because we'd missed it live as sky were showing a replay at the time. Good job nothing important happened during the second replay really. I reckon I miss five minutes of actual football most games due to replays. 3. Patrice Evra. Please explain? 4. By all means have top female former players as pundits. Christ knows they can't do any worse than some of the men (see 3 above), but don't pretend and/or infer that when commenting on the male game they have the same or equivalent experience and potential insight as male former players. It's unnecessary and insults everyones intelligence. For one thing, when the two genders play the same sport they will inevitably interpret the space differently, resulting in notably different versions of the game in terms of physicality, tactics and approaches. For another, the social and economic context is incomparable. I'm as interested in the views of Alex Scott or Karen Kearney (or a well informed sports journalist) as any male former player, but don't ask them about the pressure of a big Premier league match, or the demands of the high tempo pressing game as they plainly haven't experienced either themselves. Give them a chance to tell me something they do know and I don't. 5. Call a dive a dive, a cheat a cheat. All the time you brush over it or use super slow motion replays to highlight some minor contact, and justify fit strong athletes throwing themselves to the floor the game will continue to be ruined. You're just protecting your precious product. And yes I include Palace players in that. 6. I might be able to agree to disagree on your ongoing support for BLM if you applied the same moral consideration to human rights abusing states funding football clubs, or the incessant, creepy, insidious promotion of gambling, or the role third world sweat shops play in producing football kit, boots, balls etc. All the time your moral, social and political stance is so closely aligned to what is commercially beneficial, it's difficult to conclude that you aren't just virtue signalling. 7. From personal experience, your customer service is genuinely appalling. Spend a bit less on pundits and a bit more responding reasonably when you've failed, yet again, to provide fair value for money.
Edited by TheBigToePunt (15 Jan 2021 8.32pm) Usually disinclined to read long posts for a variety of reasons I will not state at the risk of offending anybody... but this one kept my attention and I thoroughly agree with the points. Sad thing is you could even add plenty more!
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by silvertop
Pundits always pro top 6. They know their base. If you read the messages posted on the BBC stream all arsenal. I thought Arsenal are mid table fodder just like us these days.
|
|
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
Sky eh? Where do you start? 1. Either stuff your coverage full of advert breaks every three minutes, or charge me a pretty penny to tune in. Doing both is a piss take. 2. Your unique selling point for cricket was that your subscribers would 'never miss a ball'. Why then do you think it's OK to cut away from a football match when the ball is in play to show me a series of shots of a manager chewing gum, or a replay of something I just saw for myself, or a section of the crowd carefully chosen for its positive social cross section? Last night sky had to show a replay of Tompkins getting booked because we'd missed it live as sky were showing a replay at the time. Good job nothing important happened during the second replay really. I reckon I miss five minutes of actual football most games due to replays. 3. Patrice Evra. Please explain? 4. By all means have top female former players as pundits. Christ knows they can't do any worse than some of the men (see 3 above), but don't pretend and/or infer that when commenting on the male game they have the same or equivalent experience and potential insight as male former players. It's unnecessary and insults everyones intelligence. For one thing, when the two genders play the same sport they will inevitably interpret the space differently, resulting in notably different versions of the game in terms of physicality, tactics and approaches. For another, the social and economic context is incomparable. I'm as interested in the views of Alex Scott or Karen Kearney (or a well informed sports journalist) as any male former player, but don't ask them about the pressure of a big Premier league match, or the demands of the high tempo pressing game as they plainly haven't experienced either themselves. Give them a chance to tell me something they do know and I don't. 5. Call a dive a dive, a cheat a cheat. All the time you brush over it or use super slow motion replays to highlight some minor contact, and justify fit strong athletes throwing themselves to the floor the game will continue to be ruined. You're just protecting your precious product. And yes I include Palace players in that. 6. I might be able to agree to disagree on your ongoing support for BLM if you applied the same moral consideration to human rights abusing states funding football clubs, or the incessant, creepy, insidious promotion of gambling, or the role third world sweat shops play in producing football kit, boots, balls etc. All the time your moral, social and political stance is so closely aligned to what is commercially beneficial, it's difficult to conclude that you aren't just virtue signalling. 7. From personal experience, your customer service is genuinely appalling. Spend a bit less on pundits and a bit more responding reasonably when you've failed, yet again, to provide fair value for money.
Edited by TheBigToePunt (15 Jan 2021 8.32pm) Good post TBTP.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.