This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Benteke, welcome return to form
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
The Yorkshire Eagle Great Ouseburn, N Yorkshire 16 Jan 21 10.24am |
|
|
CB has certainly improved recently, but the clue is in the title.. striker! 3 goals including a tap in, is not good enough at this level. That said, a strikers role is not just scoring...would that he did... but flick ons, hold up play etc, which he does pretty well, and he is a decent target when we use the flanks. I just wish he would use his ample frame and get stuck in. He is lightweight. One thing that he and the rest of the squad are guilty of is not shooting. Stats shown on Sky last night show Patrick Bamford top of the ‘shots attempted’ (28!) and his goal tally is resultant of same. H Kane was 2nd. The lucky deflection HK got against us proves the point, we don’t shoot enough! Aside from an ageing team, that frequently give the ball away, get outpaced in most positions, and regularly sit back rather than press ( as we actually did against the Gooners), we are not a bad side!
Keep the faith.
|
Tom-the-eagle Croydon 16 Jan 21 10.35am |
|
Originally posted by HKOwen
The post is " return to form ".
The post will only wind up those who don't read well.
And I had him at 10/1 to score against West Ham when all faith was lost
To me, return to form is when he scores 18 goals again in one season, not 9 in 4 seasons
"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit
|
Pete53 Hassocks 16 Jan 21 12.14pm |
|
|
He still has a heck of a lot to do in the rest of the season if he is going to make up for the paucity of his contributions in the last 3 years, and to convince me he has found his form.
For me he doesn't have the niggling aggression that majority of good centre forwards have. I don't see him making a nuisance of himself around the opposition penalty area. He's a big bloke and should be putting the fear of god up defenders.
|
nectoneagle necton 16 Jan 21 12.25pm |
|
|
If Benteke had just joined for £30 mil we would all be saying what a load of rubbish.Yes he has improved but that was not difficult , I think his only use is that he takes some of the physical side of the game away from Wilf. I think the new position for Wilf has been bought about because of our lack of someone to play as a lone striker.Benteke is a lump up front his all round play is poor and he fails to find space particularly by using the wings to drag defends away to allow for Wilf and Eze through that middle area. Hope this makes sense to some of you.
|
Den1923 16 Jan 21 12.41pm |
|
Originally posted by nectoneagle
If Benteke had just joined for £30 mil we would all be saying what a load of rubbish.Yes he has improved but that was not difficult , I think his only use is that he takes some of the physical side of the game away from Wilf. I think the new position for Wilf has been bought about because of our lack of someone to play as a lone striker.Benteke is a lump up front his all round play is poor and he fails to find space particularly by using the wings to drag defends away to allow for Wilf and Eze through that middle area. Hope this makes sense to some of you.
Yes, it certainly does, well said!
|
A1969Eagle Redhill 16 Jan 21 12.43pm |
|
|
Always amazed how many people dont understand football. A player in a position needs help from other players to perform. A keeper needs defenders to keep down the shots coming in. A centre or full back needs help from like wise defenders and the keeper. The midfield need help from forwards and defenders.
So what does a Forward need? Some think nothing, like the supply has constantly been lacking to Benteke and yet he supposed to do it by himself LOL..
|
AERO 16 Jan 21 12.50pm |
|
|
He has had decent service over the years maybe not enough ,but he has wasted too many good opportunities for a centre forward and the statistics don't lie .Murray got similar service and look at his return in goals.Plus Murray put a decent shift in when he played unlike Benteke who goes missing.
|
MonsterMunch Cambridge 16 Jan 21 12.51pm |
|
Originally posted by A1969Eagle
Always amazed how many people dont understand football. A player in a position needs help from other players to perform. A keeper needs defenders to keep down the shots coming in. A centre or full back needs help from like wise defenders and the keeper. The midfield need help from forwards and defenders.
So what does a Forward need? Some think nothing, like the supply has constantly been lacking to Benteke and yet he supposed to do it by himself LOL..
Do me a favour..He’s an experienced premier league and international player whose all round game bar winning headers is non existent. You need to raise your expectations imo. And so do palace.
|
southnorwoodhill 16 Jan 21 12.54pm |
|
Originally posted by A1969Eagle
Always amazed how many people dont understand football. A player in a position needs help from other players to perform. A keeper needs defenders to keep down the shots coming in. A centre or full back needs help from like wise defenders and the keeper. The midfield need help from forwards and defenders.
So what does a Forward need? Some think nothing, like the supply has constantly been lacking to Benteke and yet he supposed to do it by himself LOL..
Nonsense. There are many examples of one on ones with keeper whereby he shoots straight at the keeper, headers over the bar, scuffed shots that are more of a danger to the corner flag than the net, etc. The supply is there, he can't convert, hence his appalling record.
Edited by southnorwoodhill (16 Jan 2021 1.04pm)
|
MonsterMunch Cambridge 16 Jan 21 12.57pm |
|
Originally posted by AERO
He has had decent service over the years maybe not enough ,but he has wasted too many good opportunities for a centre forward and the statistics don't lie .Murray got similar service and look at his return in goals.Plus Murray put a decent shift in when he played unlike Benteke who goes missing.
Exactly. To say he hasn’t had chances is nonsense. He’s shot in front of goal. That effort against Arsenal on his left foot leaning so far back he was almost horizontal was an example of someone whose confidence and ability as long since left him. Yes we are bloody awful to watch but if we had a quality centre forward we would look so much different. We’ve not had one for years.
|
kev64 Cambs 16 Jan 21 1.20pm |
|
|
Return to form ??? Do you mean Roy playing him trying to drum up interest in offloading him, or blagging the fans he deserves another 3 years of bleeding the club dry ..
Tekkers, Sakho, cW and Meyer so long and goodbye .. I
|
Elphers40 Sunny South Coast 16 Jan 21 1.37pm |
|
Originally posted by kev64
Return to form ??? Do you mean Roy playing him trying to drum up interest in offloading him, or blagging the fans he deserves another 3 years of bleeding the club dry ..
Tekkers, Sakho, cW and Meyer so long and goodbye .. I
Spot on Kev - couldn’t agree more.
CB has been better recently - no doubt. But frankly that wasn’t too difficult was it - he has been absolutely garbage for the previous 18 months! Got to get them all off the books as soon as possible and bring replacements in who will bring something different.
I’d add Hennessey and Dann to that list too. Hennessey is not required now JB is in and Dann (a brilliant servant to the club) is 3 yards too slow now days.
|
nectoneagle necton 16 Jan 21 2.17pm |
|
Originally posted by A1969Eagle
Always amazed how many people dont understand football. A player in a position needs help from other players to perform. A keeper needs defenders to keep down the shots coming in. A centre or full back needs help from like wise defenders and the keeper. The midfield need help from forwards and defenders.
So what does a Forward need? Some think nothing, like the supply has constantly been lacking to Benteke and yet he supposed to do it by himself LOL..
|
nectoneagle necton 16 Jan 21 2.23pm |
|
|
Sorry if you thought I know nothing about football! I have played and managed to a decent level and have experienced situations like this. Benteke tends to be a 1 trick pony , I am fed up of experts saying we do not play to his strengths.No we need a versatile front man who can adapt , sorry but Benteke is NOT that player
|
doombear Too far from Selhurst Park 16 Jan 21 2.32pm |
|
Originally posted by kev64
Return to form ??? Do you mean Roy playing him trying to drum up interest in offloading him, or blagging the fans he deserves another 3 years of bleeding the club dry ..
Tekkers, Sakho, cW and Meyer so long and goodbye .. I
In the ideal world yes. However as I've said elsewhere with Batshuayi warming the bench are we really going to fork out £20m for him? If not and we get rid of Wickham (a no brainer) can we afford to get rid of Tekkers as well? I doubt it because I don't see the board forking out the money needed to replace two strikers. I expect Benteke will get another year especially if he continues his recent contributions.
|
doombear Too far from Selhurst Park 16 Jan 21 2.49pm |
|
Originally posted by nectoneagle
Sorry if you thought I know nothing about football! I have played and managed to a decent level and have experienced situations like this. Benteke tends to be a 1 trick pony , I am fed up of experts saying we do not play to his strengths.No we need a versatile front man who can adapt , sorry but Benteke is NOT that player
Agreed but I doubt the board would bankroll such a purchase. IMO whether we like it or not, Benteke will get a 1 year extension (if he wants it), especially if Wickham goes (a no brainer) and we decide not to take up the Batshuayi option.
|
palace99 New Mills 20 Jan 21 3.27pm |
|
Originally posted by Elphers40
Spot on Kev - couldn’t agree more.
CB has been better recently - no doubt. But frankly that wasn’t too difficult was it - he has been absolutely garbage for the previous 18 months! Got to get them all off the books as soon as possible and bring replacements in who will bring something different.
I’d add Hennessey and Dann to that list too. Hennessey is not required now JB is in and Dann (a brilliant servant to the club) is 3 yards too slow now days.
spot on - need these deadwood off the wage bill asap.
Re Tekkers why does he never bully defenders. Backing in, out muscle them etc. Murray could always do that and nick a free kick etc.
|
eagleman13 On The Road To Hell & Alicante 20 Jan 21 3.33pm |
|
Originally posted by palace99
spot on - need these deadwood off the wage bill asap.
Re Tekkers why does he never bully defenders. Backing in, out muscle them etc. Murray could always do that and nick a free kick etc.
Coz last time he did he was sent off
This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.
|
Eaglecoops CR3 20 Jan 21 4.10pm |
|
|
Fair point!
|
doombear Too far from Selhurst Park 20 Jan 21 4.11pm |
|
Originally posted by southnorwoodhill
Nonsense. There are many examples of one on ones with keeper whereby he shoots straight at the keeper, headers over the bar, scuffed shots that are more of a danger to the corner flag than the net, etc. The supply is there, he can't convert, hence his appalling record.
Edited by southnorwoodhill (16 Jan 2021 1.04pm)
This concurs with how I've seen Benteke's performances over the last 3 seasons, he's fluffed too many or failed to make the obvious move a CF should make much to the annoyance of those trying to play him in. To be fair his form since his recall this season has been better but as one poster has already said - 'that's not saying much'.
|