You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Max Meyer Departs
November 16 2026 5.03am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Max Meyer Departs


Page 2 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >
Harpo Flag Oxfordshire 16 Jan 21 12.29am

He did show flashes of brilliance.

Sometimes as much as twice a match.

 

Charles Flag Forest Hill 16 Jan 21 12.32am

Originally posted by doombear


Considering how little we've paid (in relative terms) for the following:
McCarthy, Ayew, Tomkins, Kouyate, Riederwald and Butland and the 'frees' but no doubt with signing on fees (Cahill, Clyne and Guaita) who are all the poor signings over the last four/five years other than Benteke, Sakho and Wickham?

As for a big rebuilding operation in the summer, I wouldn't hold your breath. We might offload three or four at most. Expect an evolution not a revolution, especially if Hodgson stays.

Camarasa (if bizarrely)? Sorloth?

But, having said that, I don't accept Benteke was a bad signing at all and hope he's just embarking on the process of making up significantly for the disappointingly long injury lay-offs he's had. Wickham has lived up to his reputation sadly for us and him; a foolish gamble from the beginning. But both Benteke and Wickham were Pardew signings. Sakho was hardly a bad signing; he was key to the Allardyce escape; in hindsight we would probably have been better advised to have said thanks for the loan and ended his connection with Palace after that; but I don't remember hearing that view much when he joined permanently and he is arguably the most talented footballer in our impressive array of centre backs. Disappointing rather than bad perhaps. Whatever we think about tat, he was an Allardyce signing, loan and permanent. Jairo Riedwald, come to that, was a Frank de Boer signing.

Sticking to signings made under the current regime, Doombear's right; they've done very well; with both the exceptions I've mentioned mitigations can be made; we have yet to see Ferguson but Banks nad Lewis seem to be setting the under 23s alight in Premier 2 - which marks another upgrade for the club. With Meyer departed, I'm keen to see which of the exciting midfield prospects we've been linked with might replace him. My view is we're in year 3 of the second five year plan; we can't win a game we control yet but it's beginning to look feasible.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 16 Jan 21 3.02am

Originally posted by Westina

Do believe that this signing along with others must post the question about Freedmans ability.
Roy always diverts questions about transfers to Dougie but you have wonder whether Roy has any say in transfers at all.
We have too many poor signings that have outweighed the good ones.... and we always seem to be so slow off the mark in signings or the selling of players.
I don’t understand the technicalities of player sales but why are we always so slow in getting players in/out.?
Clearly we have a big rebuilding operation required in the summer but are we going to leave it until the end of August.?


Yup. The last day last hour

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 16 Jan 21 3.08am

Bert Head. He was a real trader. Brought in some top players and sold plenty.
Current leaders of club don’t seem capable of this. However, when Benteke and Wickham signed the extra year maybe they dropped to a tiny salary. Say a million? You know the type I would dream of.

 

deleted9 Flag 16 Jan 21 6.11am

I wouldn’t be surprised if Max isn’t replaced at all but instead we see Banks promoted to more first team squad appearances. Sadly, I believe it’s all about cutting costs now and that would represent a decent saving.

He was only a fringe player anyway so wouldn’t be a gamble.

 

StrangerThing Flag Brisbane 16 Jan 21 6.43am

170k a week according to the press or 8.7m a year. London’s googled average wage is 86400. So he was earning 100 people’s wages for not playing. Yet Arsenal make 50 redundant to save money. Football gone crazy.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 16 Jan 21 8.02am

Originally posted by StrangerThing

170k a week according to the press or 8.7m a year. London’s googled average wage is 86400. So he was earning 100 people’s wages for not playing. Yet Arsenal make 50 redundant to save money. Football gone crazy.

But if we paid up his contract it doesn't save us anything at all as presumably we paid him the balance all in one go

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 16 Jan 21 8.03am

Originally posted by kennybrowns leftfoot

Be interesting to see what happens with this young man's career now... Was it that he wasn't a Roy player or is there something underlying regarding his personality, attitude etc...

According to Roy a couple of weeks ago he was a model professional

 

pompeyeagle Flag Relocated to Shropshire 16 Jan 21 8.30am

Glad to see him off the wage bill but it’s still sad to see him depart. I think there’s a decent player in there somewhere. Can’t help thinking a different manager would have found a way to fit him in the team but I guess we’ll never know. It will be interesting to see what he does next.

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 16 Jan 21 8.42am

Originally posted by StrangerThing

170k a week according to the press or 8.7m a year. London’s googled average wage is 86400. So he was earning 100 people’s wages for not playing. Yet Arsenal make 50 redundant to save money. Football gone crazy.

More than twice that number - there are an awful lot of people in London earning considerably less than £40,000.

 

EddieMac Flag 16 Jan 21 8.52am

Thank the lord we have one dead weight off our books. He certainly wasn’t earning 170k a week but I for one will be happy to see the back of him. Has to go down as one of our worst signings taking into account the reputation he came with and the high wages he was being paid.

 

Knightstar Flag Guildford 16 Jan 21 9.08am

I would imagine this explains why we haven't seen him at all for some time now, as negotiations would have been going on about his leaving terms. Let's hope a sensible deal was concluded. In any event it's good news to see the back of him, as he wasn't up to PL standard. Hopefully we will seek a proper midfield playmaker in the summer.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 16 Jan 21 9.18am

The money saved can now go to keeping Benteke and Wickham for another year

 

Painter Flag Croydon 16 Jan 21 10.10am

Looks like its the best bit of business, we are going to do this window.

The lad was overhyped on his arrival and just didnt adapt to Premier football, it happens.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards berlinpalace Flag berlin 16 Jan 21 10.12am

I hope there’s no pictures of Hennessy waving him goodbye...

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 16 Jan 21 10.25am

Originally posted by alexdyoung87

I wouldn’t be surprised if Max isn’t replaced at all but instead we see Banks promoted to more first team squad appearances. Sadly, I believe it’s all about cutting costs now and that would represent a decent saving.

He was only a fringe player anyway so wouldn’t be a gamble.

I wish.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 16 Jan 21 10.28am

Originally posted by Painter

Looks like its the best bit of business, we are going to do this window.

The lad was overhyped on his arrival and just didnt adapt to Premier football, it happens.

Phenomenal through the German youth system and the creative midfielder we were and are screaming for. A risk true but sadly one that didn't pay off. Depressing.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 16 Jan 21 10.28am

Originally posted by pompeyeagle

Glad to see him off the wage bill but it’s still sad to see him depart. I think there’s a decent player in there somewhere. Can’t help thinking a different manager would have found a way to fit him in the team but I guess we’ll never know. It will be interesting to see what he does next.


Not at all sure about that. If another PL manager thought he could play in our league, then why did none of them try and buy him? Was it simply because he was on silly wages or because they doubted he was strong enough to do a job?

Meyer was neat and tidy, could play some good passes but couldn't protect the ball for toffee.

Edited by doombear (16 Jan 2021 10.29am)

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 16 Jan 21 10.38am

Originally posted by doombear


Not at all sure about that. If another PL manager thought he could play in our league, then why did none of them try and buy him? Was it simply because he was on silly wages or because they doubted he was strong enough to do a job?

Meyer was neat and tidy, could play some good passes but couldn't protect the ball for toffee.

Edited by doombear (16 Jan 2021 10.29am)

You've answered your own question. Which begs another: Why did the trio of Parish, Freedman, and Hodgson think it was a good idea? Chuck in Sorloth for good measure and it is not too difficult to conclude that scouting and recruitment is not up to par.

Edited by southnorwoodhill (16 Jan 2021 10.39am)

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 16 Jan 21 10.39am

Originally posted by doombear


Not at all sure about that. If another PL manager thought he could play in our league, then why did none of them try and buy him? Was it simply because he was on silly wages or because they doubted he was strong enough to do a job?

Meyer was neat and tidy, could play some good passes but couldn't protect the ball for toffee.

Edited by doombear (16 Jan 2021 10.29am)

Perhaps,just perhaps many supporters have concluded that the scenario went along the lines of :

"Roy, we have a 'Wonderkid' from Germany who has arrived on a 'Free', fit him into your side".
Roy then is a tad bemused that a 'Wonderkid' who had been given a big fanfare was not being chased by some of the big clubs in his homeland or in this country.


-.-'

 

Page 2 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Max Meyer Departs