You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Five into One
November 16 2026 5.02am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Five into One


Plaistow Eagle Flag 21 Jan 21 7.17pm

I can't make up my mind if I'm excited by the signing of JP "Mateta" or not, a quick You Tube search of his "show real" - seems to show more misses than goals;

[Link]

I can't help thinking he just looks like a younger version of Tekkers and we have enough strikers capable of missing opportunities.

I hope I'm wrong and that JP turns out to be a really shrewd move and he delivers what we really need in a potent goal scorer.

Beyond that we now have 5 strikers on the books for one position in the way Roy lines up so; JP, Tekkers, Bats, Ayew and "sicknote" Wickham.

That means at least 3 will be on the bench, not in the squad - you can obviously discount Wickham from that equation.

What this means for Bats I have no idea.

We've got more strikers than Arthur Scargill..!!

My other concern is that we desperately need youthful and mobile central midfielders - if nothing else to release/make/get the most of Eze.

I do have to wonder if whatever money we have would have been better spent/invested on a youthful/mobile CDM, especially given our current league position of relative safety and this being the January transfer window.

I'm sure there are reasons for it in that JP is one we have been following for a while and now is the right time and we could sign him on a deal that suited our finances.

I just hope that also in this window we will at least sign one youthful and mobile CDM to help with our aging options in this area and open up the opportunities to getting the most our of Eze/Zaha etc..

Meantime with the 5 into 1 equation in terms of strikers I'm assuming that at least 2 are on there way and won't be seeing much of the first team squad for the remainder of the season.

Meantime it's really positive to see us doing some business and hopefully having identified a striker that can develop into a proven goal scorer - which is something we have been desperately lacking.

Just hope he can defend - coz that will be a pre requisite for Roy..!!

COYP

 

kennybrowns leftfoot Flag Reigate 21 Jan 21 7.40pm

Originally posted by Plaistow Eagle

I can't make up my mind if I'm excited by the signing of JP "Mateta" or not, a quick You Tube search of his "show real" - seems to show more misses than goals;

[Link]

I can't help thinking he just looks like a younger version of Tekkers and we have enough strikers capable of missing opportunities.

I hope I'm wrong and that JP turns out to be a really shrewd move and he delivers what we really need in a potent goal scorer.

Beyond that we now have 5 strikers on the books for one position in the way Roy lines up so; JP, Tekkers, Bats, Ayew and "sicknote" Wickham.

That means at least 3 will be on the bench, not in the squad - you can obviously discount Wickham from that equation.

What this means for Bats I have no idea.

We've got more strikers than Arthur Scargill..!!

My other concern is that we desperately need youthful and mobile central midfielders - if nothing else to release/make/get the most of Eze.

I do have to wonder if whatever money we have would have been better spent/invested on a youthful/mobile CDM, especially given our current league position of relative safety and this being the January transfer window.

I'm sure there are reasons for it in that JP is one we have been following for a while and now is the right time and we could sign him on a deal that suited our finances.

I just hope that also in this window we will at least sign one youthful and mobile CDM to help with our aging options in this area and open up the opportunities to getting the most our of Eze/Zaha etc..

Meantime with the 5 into 1 equation in terms of strikers I'm assuming that at least 2 are on there way and won't be seeing much of the first team squad for the remainder of the season.

Meantime it's really positive to see us doing some business and hopefully having identified a striker that can develop into a proven goal scorer - which is something we have been desperately lacking.

Just hope he can defend - coz that will be a pre requisite for Roy..!!

COYP

Well if he is a younger version of Tekkers and can replicate what Tekkers did at Villa then I for one will be happy!!

Good post by the way.

 


Don't waste your time with jealousy. Sometimes your ahead, sometimes your behind, the race is long. But in the end it's only with yourself!!

sprites Flag Auckland 21 Jan 21 7.42pm

Yep, you're quite right. I'm happy to give this fella a chance and see what he's got...but if Belgium's #2 and #3 striker can't get a sniff, I don't see why this guy would be able to.

 

Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 21 Jan 21 7.44pm

Thought this was going to be a thread about dogging

 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

Croydon-Trucker Flag 21 Jan 21 7.45pm

Or a gang bang

 

General Flag 21 Jan 21 7.59pm

Good idea to get someone now who can hopefully be ready to fire next season..

Give the kid a few months to learn and acclimatise while we have the other strikers aswell

Then in summer Bat’s is gone and I’d be very surprised if Wickham is still here

A bonus if the kid bangs some goals in this season.

 

Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 21 Jan 21 8.16pm

Originally posted by General

Good idea to get someone now who can hopefully be ready to fire next season..

Give the kid a few months to learn and acclimatise while we have the other strikers aswell

Then in summer Bat’s is gone and I’d be very surprised if Wickham is still here

A bonus if the kid bangs some goals in this season.

That’s probably about right

 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

Jacey Flag 21 Jan 21 8.30pm

It simply has not worked out for Bats this time round and perhaps his loan signing will be cancelled.
Not entirely his fault.Quality striker for his International side who play to his strengths rather than to Roy's reliance on a defensive strategy that has badly affected the confidence of Benteke and Sorloth in this outdated regime.
Should BFS come calling for Benteke and we foolishly let him go,just watch him start scoring for fun again in a positive environment motivated by the Fat One.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 21 Jan 21 8.59pm

Originally posted by Jacey

It simply has not worked out for Bats this time round and perhaps his loan signing will be cancelled.
Not entirely his fault.Quality striker for his International side who play to his strengths rather than to Roy's reliance on a defensive strategy that has badly affected the confidence of Benteke and Sorloth in this outdated regime.
Should BFS come calling for Benteke and we foolishly let him go,just watch him start scoring for fun again in a positive environment motivated by the Fat One.

You are joking of course.

 

coulsdoneagle Flag London 21 Jan 21 9.55pm

A younger version of Benteke was one of the best strikers in the league.

At 23 he’s one to develop. We need to plan for the future. The most important bit of business we can do now is to get Jairo to extend his contract.

A new manager coming in in the summer may well have a different plan for the players we have at the club, but with a core of Eze, JP, TM, and Jairo, that is several positions in the team locked down for years to come.

 

sprites Flag Auckland 22 Jan 21 2.51am

I don't think he's joking at all.

I also have no doubt that in a big Sam team that actually plays to his strengths, CB would score a hatful.

Originally posted by Tickled pink

You are joking of course.


 

taylors lovechild Flag 22 Jan 21 10.50am

Bentenke and Wickham out of contract in the summer and Batman's loan will come to an end (if not cancelled before then). Getting him now means the club can see if he works out and if not they might renew Big Ben's contract (they might anyway).

Very few strikers score even double figures in the PL each season, especially outside of the so-called big six clubs. Therefore, as much as goals it will be what else he brings to the team that we need to judge him on. For us he will need to be able to retain the ball, win direct balls in the air and bring others into play. I think that's why on reflection Batshuayi just doesn't fit in as he is just a good 6-yard poacher and we need more than that. It is also why I think Bentenke should be given more credit for his recent displays.

Ultimately though, if we are to push on we do need a regular goal scorer. You only have to look at what Leicester, Southampton and even West Ham (with Antonio) have achieved by having someone who regularly chips in with goals.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 22 Jan 21 11.00am

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

Bentenke and Wickham out of contract in the summer and Batman's loan will come to an end (if not cancelled before then). Getting him now means the club can see if he works out and if not they might renew Big Ben's contract (they might anyway).

Very few strikers score even double figures in the PL each season, especially outside of the so-called big six clubs. Therefore, as much as goals it will be what else he brings to the team that we need to judge him on. For us he will need to be able to retain the ball, win direct balls in the air and bring others into play. I think that's why on reflection Batshuayi just doesn't fit in as he is just a good 6-yard poacher and we need more than that. It is also why I think Bentenke should be given more credit for his recent displays.

Ultimately though, if we are to push on we do need a regular goal scorer. You only have to look at what Leicester, Southampton and even West Ham (with Antonio) have achieved by having someone who regularly chips in with goals.

These teams play football with far more energy and vibrancy and goalscorers do rely on those around them.
These teams don't have 15 players either about to reach 30 or in their 30s.

Edited by Willo (22 Jan 2021 11.03am)

 

taylors lovechild Flag 22 Jan 21 12.40pm

Originally posted by Willo

These teams play football with far more energy and vibrancy and goalscorers do rely on those around them.
These teams don't have 15 players either about to reach 30 or in their 30s.

Edited by Willo (22 Jan 2021 11.03am)

While you make a good point, Ings, Vardy and Antonio all make things happen, they don't just wait for the ball to arrive on a plate. They work hard outside the box as well as in it and make runs that give the midfield something to aim for. Wilf has done a good job this year but he is not a striker and still often drifts out wide. I have a feeling that Mateta could be the sort of player that will cause chaos; I think it's those long, awkward legs. I'm definitely positive even if the YouTube clips suggest he will miss some sitters.

 

The Dolphin Flag 22 Jan 21 3.23pm

Assuming that he is fit then he needs to play because if we wait until next season he will have had the talent knocked out of him.
"Listen Son - I know you think you're a striker but we don't take kindly to them here - alright! I expect you to learn to defend first and attack second - that's the way it works at Palace now. We concede two goals to every one that we score so don't make me look stupid otherwise I will sit you on the bench like Batshuayi and make sure you never play again. Dougie bought you - not me or Ray - so do it our way or you will have a sore arse"!

 

palace99 Flag New Mills 22 Jan 21 4.15pm

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

While you make a good point, Ings, Vardy and Antonio all make things happen, they don't just wait for the ball to arrive on a plate. They work hard outside the box as well as in it and make runs that give the midfield something to aim for. Wilf has done a good job this year but he is not a striker and still often drifts out wide. I have a feeling that Mateta could be the sort of player that will cause chaos; I think it's those long, awkward legs. I'm definitely positive even if the YouTube clips suggest he will miss some sitters.

Agree, Antonio on form can transform WH, while when Haller was playing they looked slow and lethargic.

Similar to us and Zaha to an extent. Add a willing runner with height and strength and we could be a different team

 

beak Flag croydon 22 Jan 21 4.40pm

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

While you make a good point, Ings, Vardy and Antonio all make things happen, they don't just wait for the ball to arrive on a plate. They work hard outside the box as well as in it and make runs that give the midfield something to aim for. Wilf has done a good job this year but he is not a striker and still often drifts out wide. I have a feeling that Mateta could be the sort of player that will cause chaos; I think it's those long, awkward legs. I'm definitely positive even if the YouTube clips suggest he will miss some sitters.

He looks like Paulo Wanchope, a very elastic goal scorer.

 

Uphill Flag Bedford 22 Jan 21 4.41pm

One of his supposed assets is his height - 6'4"
but as we are incapable of making accurate crosses and corners we have to hope he is quick on his feet.

The position of striker in a Palace team is a poisoned chalice. You just can't be too critical when we have such a God-awful 'get rid of it quick' midfield and a manager too slow to mix things up in a constructive way.

Regardless, if he does still manage to bag a few we should be happy.

 


Man and boy Palace since my first game in 1948 sitting on my dad's shoulders

Pierre Flag Purley 22 Jan 21 5.24pm

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

While you make a good point, Ings, Vardy and Antonio all make things happen, they don't just wait for the ball to arrive on a plate. They work hard outside the box as well as in it and make runs that give the midfield something to aim for. Wilf has done a good job this year but he is not a striker and still often drifts out wide. I have a feeling that Mateta could be the sort of player that will cause chaos; I think it's those long, awkward legs. I'm definitely positive even if the YouTube clips suggest he will miss some sitters.

You may have hit upon something there in that they make runs! Something that Palace do so little of knowing that firstly the ball will never arrive on a plate and secondly when have our midfield recently ever aimed for somebody playing up front and successfully completed the pass?
Mateta does however look to be a little more mobile & quicker across the ground than CB but that's not difficult is it!!

 

Harpo Flag Oxfordshire 22 Jan 21 6.54pm

Is this guy Schlupp's taller brother?

 


You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Five into One