You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Loan Outs
November 16 2026 5.02am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Loan Outs


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 25 Jan 21 9.49am

I see another U23 player has gone out on loan, Scott Banks, but, in SCOTLAND, why?

[Link]

Imo, he was one of the better players for the U23's along with Webber, Woods & Mathews. Still, i suppose the club knows whats its doing.

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

dreamwaverider Flag London 25 Jan 21 9.50am

So there goes Banks for the rest of the season, just when I thought he was on the cusp of the first team. I really hope he is a regular with us in the premier next season. Just what our first team needs right now. A flair midfielder who can score from outside the box.

 

Palace in the Blood Flag 25 Jan 21 10.34am

Originally posted by Badger11

Maybe WBA will agree a fee for Ferguson as part of the Benteke deal?

There is a WBA journalist suggesting that too. I can't see how it will work with Ferguson injured as the fee will now be for potential if he recovers plus a sell on percentage. That fee if it goes to tribunal at present could be around £1 million and a hefty sell on fee. WBA
can't afford Benteke wages and are asking us to subsidise. Benteke needs game time to get into Euros squad.
It depends if Benteke will take a pay drop I suspect he will and also what his plans are on contract. I don't think anyone will offer current wage.
Buying out his contact in full makes no sense, cancelling it by agreement with no buy out does and he then moves for free now.

 

inflikted Flag 30 Jan 21 5.23pm

Originally posted by Ketteridge

Kirby has been out on loan before to Blackpool looks like he did well from what I read at the time but no one has been back in for him so what does that say. If you look at the players over the last few years that have been closest to the first team they have hardly gone on to prove us wrong in our decision to get rid of them.
Levi Lumeka is at Troyes in the French second division, Jason Lokilo is at Doncaster, Sullay Kai Kai is at Blackpool but underperforming according to this from 2 weeks ago [Link] Hiram Boateng is at Cambridge and kicked around a few League 1 and 2 clubs, Gio MacGregor is a Dulwhich Hamlet along with Reece Allassani from a previous generation of future stars . Ryan Innis is at Charlton only played a few games but does seem to be doing ok , to be fair we persevered with him the longest. Even poor old Johnny Williams and he got more of chance then most.
That are not loads of players that we have released because they didn’t get a chance that are tearing up the championship, when Wan Bissaka and Mitchell were good enough they got their chance. Lewis Grabban is the last I can think of who we got shot of and had a good Championship/Career.
We have done well with younger players when we have had to chuck them in like Wan Bissaka or Mullins and Morrison and Clyne, Moses and Zaha who were all given their chances early because of administrations, so may be giving them games at an earlier age gives them the experience they need. Although to be fair Osborne, Rodgers Southgate and later Watson, Soares and Routledge all came through regardless in more settled periods and being skint and forcing us to play hardly helped Woozley and Wayne Carlisle.
So if we had to give Boateng a run of 20 matches would he now be the energetic box to box midfielder we need? Lets see what the academy does over next few years.

Lumeka has actually done well since leaving. Was one of the stars of the Portuguese second tier last season which earned him his move to Troyes and he scored a brace on his debut. Kirby should be playing at a higher level by now and I feel like part of the problem is the lack of opportunities he's been given in the past 4 years.

 


Milkshakes Against Fascism

esox lucius Flag Deal 30 Jan 21 5.42pm

Sometimes a player takes time to develop. Harry Kane went on loan about half a dozen times and only really broke through at Spurs aged 22, so their is still time for some.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 31 Jan 21 9.31am

Both Kirby and Street started for their respective clubs yesterday.
Kirby was substituted at HALF TIME in his game for Tranmere in League 2
Street was substituted after 73 mins (the first of 3 subs Torquay made in their clash against bottom of the table Barnet in the National League.
Banks started on the bench for Dunfermline and came on after 68 mins in their 1-0 defeat at runaway leaders Hearts.
It will be interesting to see how these three fare during the rest of the season. I'll try and keep a look out. Why? Well a lot of people on this site are always moaning about the lack of game time the youngsters get in the first team. These three are among the better U23 squad players. If they can't hack it in the leagues they've been loaned out to, then they're clearly either not ready or not good enough yet.

 

Ketteridge Flag Brighton 31 Jan 21 11.26am

Originally posted by inflikted

Lumeka has actually done well since leaving. Was one of the stars of the Portuguese second tier last season which earned him his move to Troyes and he scored a brace on his debut. Kirby should be playing at a higher level by now and I feel like part of the problem is the lack of opportunities he's been given in the past 4 years.

I get you point had we played Lumeka would his development have been smoother and better, well probably, but would we have been in the premier league?That's where we need a balance


Fair play to Lumeka I wish him well but would you be excited by a player who had done well in the Portuguese second division if we were to sign him now? It looks like as sub for Troyes in the main but been injured recently. Fair enough young lad getting used to new team and country so might be the manager trying to ease him in , then he got injured [Link] Wonder if the Troyes forum were all up in arms about the new signing that scores two on his debut after coming on as sub and probably wont’ start another came for six months but I digress.
Looked up Blackpool forum today and they seem disappointed that didn't get Kirby back [Link] maybe covid has had a bit of an effect and smaller clubs and not going to take the punt of bringing someone in on higher wages, I don’t know really. Kirby turns 21 today according to Wikipedia so maybe he has time but he needs to show something soon. Also good to see that they seem obsessed with ex players mentioning Sullay.
If you are Mitchell you will have learnt more from playing Man City then you would in a season loan in league 1 or 2 , playing alongside experienced players and being punished for you mistakes learning that you might have closed down the run for De Bruyne but he can hit a sweet ball in with the outside of his foot, but Mitchell was already at a high standard when he got his chance.
That’s the bigger point, if Lumeka or Kirby came available today there would not be a string of championship clubs looking to sign them up for their first team that should tell you their current ability.
A couple more wins and we might see less pressure on results then it would be nice at that point to see Reidwald starting regularly and chances for Pierick, Woods and others.

 


One supporter of hacking argued that without it "you will do away with the courage and pluck of the game, and I will be bound to bring over a lot of Frenchmen who would beat you with a week's practice -Blackheath secretary at first meeting of the F.A

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 31 Jan 21 12.06pm

Originally posted by Ketteridge

I get you point had we played Lumeka would his development have been smoother and better, well probably, but would we have been in the premier league?That's where we need a balance


Fair play to Lumeka I wish him well but would you be excited by a player who had done well in the Portuguese second division if we were to sign him now? It looks like as sub for Troyes in the main but been injured recently. Fair enough young lad getting used to new team and country so might be the manager trying to ease him in , then he got injured [Link] Wonder if the Troyes forum were all up in arms about the new signing that scores two on his debut after coming on as sub and probably wont’ start another came for six months but I digress.
Looked up Blackpool forum today and they seem disappointed that didn't get Kirby back [Link] maybe covid has had a bit of an effect and smaller clubs and not going to take the punt of bringing someone in on higher wages, I don’t know really. Kirby turns 21 today according to Wikipedia so maybe he has time but he needs to show something soon. Also good to see that they seem obsessed with ex players mentioning Sullay.
If you are Mitchell you will have learnt more from playing Man City then you would in a season loan in league 1 or 2 , playing alongside experienced players and being punished for you mistakes learning that you might have closed down the run for De Bruyne but he can hit a sweet ball in with the outside of his foot, but Mitchell was already at a high standard when he got his chance.
That’s the bigger point, if Lumeka or Kirby came available today there would not be a string of championship clubs looking to sign them up for their first team that should tell you their current ability.
A couple more wins and we might see less pressure on results then it would be nice at that point to see Reidwald starting regularly and chances for Pierick, Woods and others.

Good point. If you are a lower league club and looking for a loan player you are hoping for that unpolished diamond e.g. Beckham going to Preston.

I suspect that most of our under 23 squad could do a job in Div 1 or 2 but that is not the point. Those clubs can always find someone to do a job but a loan from the PL should bring a sprinkle of stardust.

My Charlton mate told me that have had some terrific loans from Chelsea and Arsenal who have gone onto better things if not in the PL then the Championship.

 


One more point

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 31 Jan 21 12.20pm

Originally posted by Badger11

Good point. If you are a lower league club and looking for a loan player you are hoping for that unpolished diamond e.g. Beckham going to Preston.

I suspect that most of our under 23 squad could do a job in Div 1 or 2 but that is not the point. Those clubs can always find someone to do a job but a loan from the PL should bring a sprinkle of stardust.

My Charlton mate told me that have had some terrific loans from Chelsea and Arsenal who have gone onto better things if not in the PL then the Championship.

Pardew signed Alex Song, then a teenager, for Charlton on loan from Arsenal.
Scott Sinclair was on loan to Charlton before he signed for us and I believe Carlton Cole was on loan from Chelsea.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 31 Jan 21 1.22pm

Originally posted by Willo

Pardew signed Alex Song, then a teenager, for Charlton on loan from Arsenal.
Scott Sinclair was on loan to Charlton before he signed for us and I believe Carlton Cole was on loan from Chelsea.

I was thinking more recently like the last 2/3 seasons. I don't remember names but they were players that Charlton wanted back on loan or to sign but that didn't happen as they went on to better things.

 


One more point

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 31 Jan 21 6.09pm

Another one gone out on loan, Sam Woods CB

[Link]

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

glaziermart Flag 31 Jan 21 10.25pm

Any news on Luke Dreher? is he fit again now?

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 01 Feb 21 10.03pm

Pierrick gone to Kilmarnock on loan. At least he's gone to a Scottish Prem team. Will be interesting to see how he fares especially if he gets to play against Rangers and/or Celtic.

Edited by doombear (01 Feb 2021 10.51pm)

 

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 01 Feb 21 10.43pm

Kilmarnock are managed by none other than Alex Dyer. One of those players -- Bruce Dyer happened to be another -- who we signed because they played well against us. Hope he's a better manager than he was a player. Pierrick has something and playing senior at this level, if he can cut it, will be great for him.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

inflikted Flag 01 Feb 21 10.55pm

Definitely sounds like we missed a trick with Kwadwo Baah, releasing him in 2017. Now he's about to join Man City from Rochdale.

 


Milkshakes Against Fascism

topcat Flag Holmesdale / Surbiton 02 Feb 21 9.14am

Originally posted by inflikted

Definitely sounds like we missed a trick with Kwadwo Baah, releasing him in 2017. Now he's about to join Man City from Rochdale.

Glad for the lad, hope he does well but it's a big step from (18th in) League 1 Rochdale to the Champions League. Lets see if he ever plays for the first team.

 


It's 106 miles to Chicago, we got a full tank of gas, half a pack of cigarettes, it's dark... and we're wearing sunglasses.

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 02 Feb 21 9.24am

Originally posted by topcat

Glad for the lad, hope he does well but it's a big step from (18th in) League 1 Rochdale to the Champions League. Lets see if he ever plays for the first team.

Not this season, he got loaned straight back to Rochdale.

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

palace99 Flag New Mills 02 Feb 21 10.54am

let's hope Kirby can kick on. Last loan was in div 1 so a drop to div 2 is a little surprising, although he's had injuries in between.

Heavy pitches this time of year may not help him too.

I think Alex Dyer has just been sacked at Kilmarnock!!

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 02 Feb 21 11.01am

Originally posted by palace99

let's hope Kirby can kick on. Last loan was in div 1 so a drop to div 2 is a little surprising, although he's had injuries in between.

Heavy pitches this time of year may not help him too.

I think Alex Dyer has just been sacked at Kilmarnock!!

Indeed he has [Link]

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 02 Feb 21 2.43pm

Originally posted by inflikted

Definitely sounds like we missed a trick with Kwadwo Baah, releasing him in 2017. Now he's about to join Man City from Rochdale.

Who remembers him doing this . . .

[Link]

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Loan Outs