You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Curious Case of Wilfred Zaha
November 16 2026 5.02am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The Curious Case of Wilfred Zaha


Page 2 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >
Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 03 Feb 21 8.34am

We are a better team with him in it and yes he has been more effective this season than last but it was going to be difficult for him to be any less effective than last season. He has lost his blistering pace and doesn’t take players on like he used to. Yes he is fouled a lot but then so are other players like Mane & Messi and they just get on with it without all the histrionics. His tantrums are embarrassing and his moaning and petulance do him no favours at all. As someone else mentioned in the Newcastle match thread last night, there is also his open displays of frustration and annoyance of playing alongside certain players of our own such as Batshuayi.

He is past his best but he is still a good player and worth keeping for now, as no one in their right mind are going to pay anything decent for him. He is also one of the very few players we have who can be, at times, exciting to watch. He would just do himself a massive favour if he could sort his moaning and his attitude out.

 

beak Flag croydon 03 Feb 21 8.41am

Originally posted by ASCPFC

Our stars without him are atrocious though. How do we explain that?

Because our stars are out of alignment ?

 

MonsterMunch Flag Cambridge 03 Feb 21 9.09am

He certainly appears to be far more petulant these days, as much as he tries to fob it off with its just 'passion'. I think its a culmination of things, he can possibly see that hes missed the boat to move to another club, win things in the game and also as much as the Roy brigade may dislike it he is probably not too enamoured with the tactics of the team. And of course the fact he has chronic back pain, carrying the team every week/season. He also gets very frustrated with his team mates, even more so now. If he was in a better team, with players that could actually pass him the ball in open space he would fly.

The other thing about Wilf is we do not see Wilf in full flow anymore, no more taking on his man at pace. He slows his man down now and gets caught far more than he used too. However his 9 goals in what is it 18/19 games cannot be sniffed at. Thats an excellent return in this side.

 

Canterbury Palace Flag Whitstable 03 Feb 21 9.27am

I'm actually writing an article arguing why we should sell him. I'll post it here later for everyone to disagree with.

 


We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...

madcap_v2 Flag SE25 / Ibiza 03 Feb 21 9.36am

Overrated or not (I don't think he's overrated), he's still our best player and one of the most exciting players in the league. You see immaturity, I see passion.

 


La la la your mum

m/k mick Flag milton keynes 03 Feb 21 9.49am

Wilf is at times brilliant, but will never be a great footballer because of his flaws, he whines and moans too much, take Lineker, played when you really on kicked on the pitch in two of the toughest leagues, never ever got a booking, not one, his only retaliation was to score

 

The Dolphin Flag 03 Feb 21 10.04am

He is a great player and a joy to watch.
Does he have a dark and petulant side - yes he does and so what?
With talent there are flaws but he is fouled the whole time so I get his frustration.
Without him we would have been playing Championship football for the last few years so as far as I am concerned people need to get off his back.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 03 Feb 21 10.10am

I note that Wilf doesn't smile much like he used to. The petulance and body language suggests that something is bothering him. He needs a therapist to help talk it over and bring the smile back.

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 03 Feb 21 10.12am


There are many great footballers with flaws (both on and off the pitch) - not putting him at their level but George Best and Maradona come to mind, Ronaldo is a drama queen and Pele wasn’t above a strop.
With Wilf it doesn’t bother me much when he’s playing well but does when he’s having an off-game.

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 03 Feb 21 10.21am

Wilf, is special that’s for sure, and the states show clearly how special he is to Palace. But his petulance is a flaw ,without doubt.
It’s wasted mental energy, disrupts his use of physical energy, and feeds an anti Wilf, culture in the select band of Premier league referees .

 

Eaglehamster Flag Storrington 03 Feb 21 10.56am

Do we yet know the nature of his injury?

Whatever his merits - we don't win when he's out.

 


I have now sufficient funds to last me the rest of my life. Provided I don't buy anything.

Stirlingsays Flag 03 Feb 21 11.02am

Originally posted by m/k mick

Wilf is at times brilliant, but will never be a great footballer because of his flaws, he whines and moans too much, take Lineker, played when you really on kicked on the pitch in two of the toughest leagues, never ever got a booking, not one, his only retaliation was to score

Well he did, but I take your point.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

palace99 Flag New Mills 03 Feb 21 11.03am

Originally posted by CT Charlie

He's a drama king, but he's OUR drama king.

I only wish he would:

1) realize that complaining about uncalled fouls makes him a boy-who-cried-wolf in the eyes of referees,
2) understand that usually when his teammates' passes don't reach him, it's because of their lack of skill rather than character flaws or lack of effort or vision
3) stop committing make-up fouls when he is angry at an opponent for a foul that should have been called

I believe he is worth 2-3 times more to Palace than he is to any of the top 6 clubs. I hope he will stay at Palace for the rest of his career.

Edited by CT Charlie (03 Feb 2021 1.30am)

totally agree with 1 and 3 - and he appears to be getting worse. Reacted badly v Sheff Utd when a foul wasn't given and was booked for reaction v wolves when a foul was given.

Although his goalscoring has improved this season his influence on games appears to have reduced a bit. Appears less able to take people on and his pace has definitely declined a bit - 1 to 1 with Fabino v Liverpool springs to mind, so easily dispossessed. His all round game hasn't really improved too - positional awareness in the box when we attack is poor and his inability to head the ball is a joke (look at how Ronaldo improved that part of his game).

I love the guy and Palace are clearly a better team with him in it but at £130k a week he is incredibly well remunerated for his services. If a top 6 club came in for him and made a decent offer i'd have no issue with him moving on - but to react like he did when we rejected the Everton bid last season was very disappointing IMHO

 

A1969Eagle Flag Redhill 03 Feb 21 12.03pm

Lineker not getting booked was a joke.
I lived as a CP season ticket holder in Southampton for ten years, I saw the odd Soton game with a mate from work, when Palace wasnt playing home or away, yes every game following palace, like many supporters who live a distance away(every game felt like an away game) hats off to you.
Any way Lineker (for Spurs) at Soton. He chopped a player down and the ref just spoke to him. Later right in front of me in the Soton fans end, Lineker said annoyed with a decision, you are a F...in C,,t Ref, we all heard it, the ref heard it and just smiled at Lineker!!

Originally posted by m/k mick

Wilf is at times brilliant, but will never be a great footballer because of his flaws, he whines and moans too much, take Lineker, played when you really on kicked on the pitch in two of the toughest leagues, never ever got a booking, not one, his only retaliation was to score

 

Uphill Flag Bedford 03 Feb 21 12.04pm

Some people overlook the value he brings to the team.

Even when not at his best the opposition need to have at least one, and usually two, defenders up his backside.

This should, but often doesn't, give his fellow forwards extra space. Unfortunately our forward line, especially Beneteke and Bats often fail to use this advantage.

His liaison with Eze is starting to bear fruit and will eventually blossom further.

Hopefully our new signing will greatly benefit.

 

A1969Eagle Flag Redhill 03 Feb 21 12.06pm

Great header by Wilf in the SF Play offs at Brighton.. before he headed (pun) off to utd??

Originally posted by palace99

totally agree with 1 and 3 - and he appears to be getting worse. Reacted badly v Sheff Utd when a foul wasn't given and was booked for reaction v wolves when a foul was given.

Although his goalscoring has improved this season his influence on games appears to have reduced a bit. Appears less able to take people on and his pace has definitely declined a bit - 1 to 1 with Fabino v Liverpool springs to mind, so easily dispossessed. His all round game hasn't really improved too - positional awareness in the box when we attack is poor and his inability to head the ball is a joke (look at how Ronaldo improved that part of his game).

I love the guy and Palace are clearly a better team with him in it but at £130k a week he is incredibly well remunerated for his services. If a top 6 club came in for him and made a decent offer i'd have no issue with him moving on - but to react like he did when we rejected the Everton bid last season was very disappointing IMHO

 

NorthYorkshireEagle Flag Bedale 03 Feb 21 12.11pm

I don't wish the boy an injury.... But I will be happy not see his winging, sulky, miserable face on the pitch for a while.
Zaha is just turning into a petulant child, constantly complaining.
Ayew in particular, Eze, Jairo and Benteke all got hammered in that game and all of them got up, trotted off and back in their position.
Watch Zaha, sit on the floor and throw his hands in the air, not winning a freekick.
He has flashes of brilliance, but they are few and far between now. Build the team with the decent players we have - Eze is the man, Benteke up front, and interchange with the new lad and Bats. that is a good forward line.

 

JRW2 Flag Dulwich 03 Feb 21 12.15pm

Originally posted by Eaglehamster

Do we yet know the nature of his injury?

Whatever his merits - we don't win when he's out.

Roy said after the game that they wouldn't know till Thursday.

(I love the title of this thread: sounds like an Agatha Christie murder story.)

 

eaglesdare Flag 03 Feb 21 12.23pm

He would never be allowed to do what he does or get away with things if he went to a "top 6" side!

we are still a better side with him in it! he is 29 this year and wont change only a few more years left for him at the club

 

Jacey Flag 03 Feb 21 12.24pm

Originally posted by PalazioVecchio

sure , wilf is not great.

one of the best fellas to ever wear the shirt, but not as good as Kevin De Bruyne or Messi.

Almost!!

 

Page 2 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Curious Case of Wilfred Zaha