You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > What do you actually expect from Palace?
November 16 2026 4.45am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

What do you actually expect from Palace?


Page 2 of 8 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 03 Mar 21 12.54am

Great. Another thread whereby we either do exactly what we’re doing or play expansive football and get relegated. Give it 1-2 pages and it’ll be relegation to the 3rd or 4th tier and then probably the conference.

 


COYP

Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 03 Mar 21 4.33am

Originally posted by HKOwen

My expectation is each season PL survival, a cup run now and again, the occasional scalp of a top club, some memorable moments ( Ayew wonder goal, Eze free kick, Mateta back heel, Wilf on fire etc ). With that goes the other side of the coin, grinding out results, some dull games and some horrendous defensive errors by individuals.

Basically what we have now.

What I do not expect is a regular supply of exciting play week in week out. We last had that in the season when Murray was top Championship scorer, or when we were terrifying defences with Wilf down one wing and Bolasie down the other but those days have gone.

It's easy to criticise the performances from an entertainment aspect but I can't see we are going to consistently have stability and entertainment without a substantial amount of cash appearing from somewhere.

That's just my opinion, but it's gets a bit wearing having so much moaning and criticism based on someone not enjoying watching.


Win, lose or drawn, I expect to be entertained.

What entertains me, a flash of brilliance... a youth player holding his own... players fighting for the badge...

If I get that and we win... brilliant, well deserved.

If I get that and we draw... good effort, better luck next time...

If I get that and we lose... at least we tried, on to the next...


What I don't expect is falling asleep mid game..
What I don't expect is players bottling two games we should be terrorizing.. what I don't expect is no plan b, no youth being blooded and a manager that is happy with that...

 


This was once a quality forum....

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 03 Mar 21 7.58am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Great. Another thread whereby we either do exactly what we’re doing or play expansive football and get relegated. Give it 1-2 pages and it’ll be relegation to the 3rd or 4th tier and then probably the conference.

No, just footballers who can pass the ball to each other and not taking so long to do it that they're stretching themselves beyond the capabilities they have to achieve the pass and in doing so encouraging the opposition to come at them, that's all we all want to see ..the ability and confidence is just not quite their with too many of our knackered players, Eze shows beautifully what we can achieve and I believe we will eventually that's our next step ..remove all the old wood and the urgency we so dreadfully miss at the moment will be improved considerably.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 03 Mar 21 8.07am

Originally posted by Vaibow

Win, lose or drawn, I expect to be entertained.

What entertains me, a flash of brilliance... a youth player holding his own... players fighting for the badge...

If I get that and we win... brilliant, well deserved.

If I get that and we draw... good effort, better luck next time...

If I get that and we lose... at least we tried, on to the next...


What I don't expect is falling asleep mid game..
What I don't expect is players bottling two games we should be terrorizing.. what I don't expect is no plan b, no youth being blooded and a manager that is happy with that...

He is of course reasonably pleased with the results we've had but to say he's happy with the performances is too far in all honesty, I'm pretty sure he's as pissed off as we are with the aged squad the injuries the horrendous mistakes and the inability of our defenders to do the simple things as is the same with everyone else, under this manager we've had some of these games you mention where we get stuck in and play well but it's just highlighted at the moment squads like ours are suffering with everything that's happening at this given time, I think we can only improve on the pitch and off it.

 

jeeagles Flag 03 Mar 21 8.11am

Originally posted by HKOwen
So, you're saying if we finish 15th or higher that is a reasonable season, fair enough.

There is usually a congested mid table so the difference between 15th and say 12th could easily be 1 pt and one extra goal conceded.

Why do you call those who aren't on the Roy Out bandwagon zealots? The facts are clear in terms of results and points, enjoyment of performance is a personal thing.

I really enjoyed the Brighton game for example.

Didn't enjoy the Fulham game at all but was happy we got a clean sheet and a point from a game where we were not favourite and playing a bang in form team. Thankfully VG made a couple of good saves

I'm not overly concerned about playing attractive football. But then, two touches in the Brighton area and being told the best we could hope for against Fulham was a draw should add to the numerous red flags that a are already there.

I called them zealots to differentiate from those that know he'll be gone at the end of the year and those that refuse to see how he can do any wrong. They are the ones already coming out with excuse after excuse for him.

The middle of the table is congested, but we aren't performing well in the cups, and it would be hypocritical to claim that 11th was a very good season but to dismiss a lower finish because of "congestion".

Can't you see how quickly some have been to roll out excuses for him already on this thread, without stating what a respectable position in the league is?

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 03 Mar 21 8.53am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Great. Another thread whereby we either do exactly what we’re doing or play expansive football and get relegated.

Most of the current threads seem to be remarkably similar with the same people making the same arguments in all of the threads and I can't be the only person spending less and less time here as reading the posts reminds me too much of groundhog day

 

HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 03 Mar 21 8.53am

Who can possibly know he'll be gone, people can speculate but don't know.

People are entitled to their own opinion but not their own facts.

If people aren't being well enough entertained that's a personal thing but unless you are blinkered then clearly our points so far with so many injuries and an old squad built on a shoestring does not need to be excused in my opinion.

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 03 Mar 21 8.58am

My expectations change as the club changes...which has been very little over the last 3/4 years.

With the same manager, with largely the same ( ageing ) squad and with a minimal spend in that time, I'm getting what I largely expect. A mild flirtation with the bottom of the table but generally lower mid table finishes. A cup run is always a pleasant bonus, that's been somewhat disappointing of late.

When change does come - new manager, revamped squad, Academy investment bearing fruit, my expectations will change. As with investments, they could go up but could also go down !

 


Old, Ungifted and White

gmostone Flag 03 Mar 21 9.02am

What do I expect??
To be bored season after season, sacrificing entertainment for all imports safety.
I’d rather have a season of uncertainty if there was some entertainment. I can’t stand the premier league. I can’t stand the new fans it brought with it. I’d rather be scrapping in the championship than treading water in the top flight.
Palace no longer feels like the club I grew up loving.

I love what parish and co have done for the club, but I miss the roller coaster that used to be palace

 

slubglurge Flag welling 03 Mar 21 9.03am

After eight years in the Prem i feel we have wasted an opportunity to move the club forward. When we finally go down (and we will) apart from the academy which is great by the way we still have Selhurst looking in almost the same condition as when we went up. We are at max achievement for a club of our size and resources, even the Clowns went down with a much improved ground. Our natural place in the football food chain is the Championship. Our desperation to stay in this league is reflected in our negative playing style and i think Sky will be delighted when we finally leave because we are not enhancing their product with our negative tactics.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 03 Mar 21 9.11am

Originally posted by slubglurge

After eight years in the Prem i feel we have wasted an opportunity to move the club forward. When we finally go down (and we will) apart from the academy which is great by the way we still have Selhurst looking in almost the same condition as when we went up. We are at max achievement for a club of our size and resources, even the Clowns went down with a much improved ground. Our natural place in the football food chain is the Championship. Our desperation to stay in this league is reflected in our negative playing style and i think Sky will be delighted when we finally leave because we are not enhancing their product with our negative tactics.

Sadly, very true. There is still time to sort it out, but I don’t believe the leadership and will (certainly from a monetary standpoint) is there to do it correctly. We are huffing and puffing but we won’t be blowing any houses down.

 

fish mitten Flag Chelmsford 03 Mar 21 9.18am

I think we have all known for the last couple of years that the squad has needed more investment. We can all see that many of the current players were getting older and that were gaps in the squad. We have had bad injury records for about the last 3-4 seasons. It wasn't likely to improve this year, with a more hectic schedule and those players a year older.

I therefore do think that Roy has limited options and has well to gain the number of points we have. However, the football has been shockingly poor. It's no longer the odd poor game, it's every game is poor. We won't continue picking up many points if we carry on the way we are. We may limp over the line this year, but next season we are likely to fail spectacularly if we carry on the way we are playing.

I haven't watched the last two games. I can't stand watching us entrenched in our own half, making the odd foray into the opposition's half. It's anti-football and I don't want to watch it and I guess many of the fans don't.

Do I expect us to be really entertaining, no. But I do expect us to try and win a game against those in the mid/bottom of the table. Even with a more limited squad.

My main expectation is that the Board invest sufficiently in the squad that it can be competitive and backs the manager. I think the Board has been neglectful in that fact. I don't think we'll replace 10-11 players in the summer. We are now stuck with the conundrum of replacing too many and having half a new team or being stuck with many of these old injury prone players another year.

Personally, I think Roy should retire in the summer. He has done a sterling job, but it feels like it's time for change and for him to go with his head held high. I expect if he's here next year, the Board will again be trying to make do on the cheap and Roy's reputation will be tarnished by being sacked or by taking us down. He doesn't deserve that.

 

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 03 Mar 21 9.21am

The only thing I expect is for us to be showing signs that we are actively trying to move forward as a club and as a business.

What I want is to watch sustainable premiership football that doesn't bore me to tears.

but in the immortal words of Jagger "You can't always get what you want.....You get what you need"

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

taylors lovechild Flag 03 Mar 21 9.30am

From a personal perspective I don't ever remember a season where (Brighton aside) I've taken so little joy from the games we've won. So often it feels like we've cheated somehow rather than earned the win. The occasional lucky win is great, but when every result seems lucky you start to question how sustainable that is.

As shocking as it might seem to some, I actually enjoy seeing our players pass the ball to each other and do some neat interplay, even when they don't score. I also enjoy seeing our flair players get the ball in the final third more than twice a game and trying something creative even when it doesn't produce goals. On top of that, I even enjoy seeing us have some shots and creating some drama in the opposing box. I know for some this might not seem important as it doesn't generate goals and points, but call me a romantic, I actually like watching football and not just the vidiprinter.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 03 Mar 21 9.42am

My expectation is to stay in the PL and play some half decent football, mid table mediocrity is fine as long as we have the occasional good run and occasional results against some of the big 6.

 


One more point

Putitout Flag Oxford 03 Mar 21 9.56am

Originally posted by fish mitten

I think we have all known for the last couple of years that the squad has needed more investment. We can all see that many of the current players were getting older and that were gaps in the squad. We have had bad injury records for about the last 3-4 seasons. It wasn't likely to improve this year, with a more hectic schedule and those players a year older.

I therefore do think that Roy has limited options and has well to gain the number of points we have. However, the football has been shockingly poor. It's no longer the odd poor game, it's every game is poor. We won't continue picking up many points if we carry on the way we are. We may limp over the line this year, but next season we are likely to fail spectacularly if we carry on the way we are playing.

I haven't watched the last two games. I can't stand watching us entrenched in our own half, making the odd foray into the opposition's half. It's anti-football and I don't want to watch it and I guess many of the fans don't.

Do I expect us to be really entertaining, no. But I do expect us to try and win a game against those in the mid/bottom of the table. Even with a more limited squad.

My main expectation is that the Board invest sufficiently in the squad that it can be competitive and backs the manager. I think the Board has been neglectful in that fact. I don't think we'll replace 10-11 players in the summer. We are now stuck with the conundrum of replacing too many and having half a new team or being stuck with many of these old injury prone players another year.

Personally, I think Roy should retire in the summer. He has done a sterling job, but it feels like it's time for change and for him to go with his head held high. I expect if he's here next year, the Board will again be trying to make do on the cheap and Roy's reputation will be tarnished by being sacked or by taking us down. He doesn't deserve that.


That’s a very fair assessment. Many fans have a clear idea of what they think the club should be, but it’s no more than a wish.
We all wish the club , could find a way to be more successful and entertaining than it is.
The reality is , unless something quiet spectacular happens to the clubs finances, we have reached our zenith, The manager gets a lot of stick we know, but the fact is if it was progress we wanted in style and achievement , the process has been massively under funded , in terms of transfer business. Some point to the wage bill as a reason for why we should have success. That is nothing more than a question for the board ,to answer. Paying good wages doesn’t always equate with paying good players. Our wage policy hasn’t been totally successful most would agree.
It seems to me we could change style ,as Brighton, and many others have tried , and fail very easily, even allowing for further investment.
The Premier is built for the outfits with mega means at their disposal ,and that’s not us, that’s what everyone has to come to terms with.
From a fans point of view ,scrapping it out in the Championship is most often not a fantastic watch, all ways made better if your a winning side. If you are a winning side the goal is more Premier, where the same old problems are waiting.
Personally I just love Palace, good bad or ugly. And the chance to upset the mega rich Royalty of football, which we do from time to time , is enough to keep me patient for better days.

 

Elphers40 Flag Sunny South Coast 03 Mar 21 10.03am

Originally posted by jeeagles

I've tried asking this question a few times and getting Roy's ardent supporters to lay down a benchmark of what success looks like.

For me, finishing higher than Sheffield United, West Brom, and Fulham won't represent a successful season. The narrative that staying up by any means mark some kind of miracle is simply not true anymore.

Trying to make it objective. We have:

The 9th biggest wage bill
The 15th most expensively assembled squad.

So somewhere between 9th and 15th wouldn't be unreasonable.

Given we are in our 8th year in the premiership, and our finishes have been 11th, 10th, 15th*, 14th, 11th, 12th, and 14th. (*for the cup final). I don't think would be unreasonable to claim that 14th with poor cup performance would represent a very poor season. 11th would represent a very good season. Any higher than 11th would be excellent.

Roy's remaining zealots will point out that after 26 games we are 13th. However, we have 12 games left, only 3 of which are against teams in the bottom half of the table. We did manage to obtain a staggering 15 points from the teams coming up in the first half of the season. In the run in I doubt we will get more that 9 in a best case scenario. 15th or 16th is all we have to look forward to this year.

Good post.

I know some may have an unrealistic hope for “total football” but I think most Palace fans are happy with pragmatic football with the occasional victory over the big boys. I personally love us being a “party pooper” for any of the top six and regarded as a tough game in their calendar.
But the thing I can’t bare is the lack of ambition or attacking intent. If that’s limited to corners and free kicks when needed - I wouldn’t mind that. We’re not even having a go any more! A balance can be struck between defending well and getting on the ball and playing with some intent - as Fulham showed last week. If they can do it why can’t we? I believe it’s the Manager.

After such a distinguished career I would like the club to recognise the good job he has done in bringing Premier League stability and create an ambassadorial/support role for him. I would also like Roy to bow out on a high and hope we get to the magic 40 points and then start playing some football.

But I suspect Roy (given what we have seen of Roy’s reluctance to be proactive or change the mental approach to games) he would stick to playing the same old sh!te.

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 03 Mar 21 10.12am


For clubs without hundreds of millions to spend there is a Faustian aspect to playing in this league and I think the current situation is part of that.
Looking at the managers of the clubs around us, Espirito-Santo, Bielsa, Dyche and Hasenhuttl they all seem to receive more praise for their achievements than Roy.
Having had a look at a Brighton site they would swap their style for our points. It’s a long standing debate as to whether football is a points or entertainment driven industry - in our case it seems clear.

 

Gallery3 Flag South Croydon 03 Mar 21 10.18am

Originally posted by davehuggins

Fact- many teams of our size have tried to play expansive football and failed.
Stoke had Pulis for ages in PL and what happened when they tried to change?
Swansea tried and succeeded for a while where are they now?
Sheffield Utd did well last season and now?
The list goes on, what I want to see is passion in our play which IMO is lacking right now!!

I agree. We do not want to be like Fulham or Brighton and play expansive football but lose every game. But I would expect more ambition against the lower teams and to look like we are able to beat them. Overall our play looks over negative every game regardless of who we are playing and our passing is shocking. Roy seems happy with less than half the points from 5 games from teams at the bottom. I expected 9 from those 15 and that should have been easily achievable. The flashes like the 2 goals against Brighton are not enough out of 180 minutes of football.

 

Wymington 1066 Flag Wymington 03 Mar 21 10.26am

My expectations, more than 1 shot on target a game . Doesn't have to be total football , just more attacking. Must be some sort of middle ground between total football and pure defensive way we play

 

Page 2 of 8 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > What do you actually expect from Palace?