You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > GOAT or GPPOAT
November 16 2026 4.45am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

GOAT or GPPOAT


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
Casual Flag Orpington 06 Mar 21 5.50pm

The best forwards I’ve seen are Wright and Johnson.
Beat winger Salako.
Beat attacking Ivorian winger Zaha.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 06 Mar 21 6.03pm

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

loved Don Rogers, kenny Samson, Ian Wright and Wilf too but for me Johnny Byrne is the greatest I've ever seen in a Palace shirt. consider that he played for England while in the3rd Div, unheard of toady and rare even then, ,when sold it was a British record transfer fee equivalent to Bale's record of 83 million now.

Edited by PZ Eagle (06 Mar 2021 5.46pm)

Peter Taylor played for England whilst we were in the old 3rd division and he wasn’t the best player I have seen in a Palace shirt.

 

Palace Old Geezer Flag Midhurst 06 Mar 21 6.14pm

Originally posted by Palace Old Geezer

Nice one. I don't clearly recall seeing Byrne in his pomp, but I watched him play when he came back for a while. Past his best really. My Dad used to wax lyrical though, always his favourite player.

Now John (Stonewall) Jackson I do remember seeing and he certainly was a cracking keeper. He came to a youth club event to answer questions from us kids. I got his autograph by handing him a programme but was too nervous to speak.

On the topic of Budgie I thought I'd look on YouTube to see if there are any clips. Found a couple. Our game against Oldham in 1960 and one of him in an England shirt.

Always fascinating.

[Link]

[Link]

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 06 Mar 21 6.24pm

Originally posted by Palace Old Geezer

On the topic of Budgie I thought I'd look on YouTube to see if there are any clips. Found a couple. Our game against Oldham in 1960 and one of him in an England shirt.

Always fascinating.

[Link]

[Link]

Could do with him today, quality player.

 


One more point

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 06 Mar 21 7.21pm

Everyone would stand up when Kenny Samson ran forward with the ball, he was something else.

 

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 06 Mar 21 8.18pm

It is unfair IMHO to compare across generations. Here are my players of the decades since I have been watching from 1974:
70’s Peter Taylor
80’s Ian Wright
90’s Dougie Freedman ( although arguably played more in his second spell in 00’s)
00’s AJ
10’s to date Wilf

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 06 Mar 21 8.32pm

My first game was 1976 and it's Wilfried Zaha.

 

The Heath Eagle Flag Thornton Heath 06 Mar 21 8.40pm

Calvin Andrew.

 

Paaalaaace Flag Croydon 06 Mar 21 8.56pm

Doris

 

Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 06 Mar 21 9.03pm

Originally posted by Tickled pink

Everyone would stand up when Kenny Samson ran forward with the ball, he was something else.

Everyone would stand when Kenny Sansom ran towards the bar

 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

Spiderman Flag Horsham 07 Mar 21 7.52am

Kenny Sansom and Johnny Byrne

 

The Yorkshire Eagle Flag Great Ouseburn, N Yorkshire 07 Mar 21 8.42am

You are all forgetting Per Bartrum!

His work rate, ability on the ball, especially in front of goal, was something to behold.

His his all round ineptitude as a footballer makes ‘Teckers’ look World class! &#128512;&#128512;

Seriously though, given all factors included in previous posts - and I watched ‘Budgie’ in his heyday, the standard of football was not the same then, so for me, our most exciting player has always been ‘Wrighty’ ... just ahead of Cliff Holton... (again I jest &#128512. His two goal coming on as a sub in the Cup Final against Man U were magic.

 

sotac464 Flag Berkshire 07 Mar 21 11.40am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

True but statistics don't tell you everything as if I recall most of his appearances and goals were in the second tier as he broke his leg and missed half of his single season in the top league

Who knows what may have happened, if he didn’t break his leg playing for Italy after earning a recall. We were mid table when that happened, when he came back towards the end of the season we were bottom.

Goldberg took over in January that year, so if we had stayed in the division then things may have been different, who knows?

He only played half a season when we got relegated, and was shipped out in January as we spiralled towards administration.

Top 3 for me.
Zaha
Wright
Lombardo

 


My equalibrium unbalanced me. Paul Draper Brighton 19/2/2018

est1905 Flag 07 Mar 21 12.32pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

You can't include Lombardo as great player that he was he was only with Palace for five minutes.

Don Rogers had a greater goal scoring record with us with 28 goals in 70 appearances and almost all of them were a wonder to behold.

Doesn't matter if a player was with us 5 seconds. If we signed Messi and he played only two games but they were against City and Liverpool and he ran the show and scored hatricks in both everyone would agree he was our best ever player.
For the record Lombardo was not with us 5 minutes but for one and three quarter seasons and in my opinion was the best player Palace ever had (certainly in my time of supporting Palace). Best Englishman> Budgie Byrne I imagine.

 

kevlee Flag born Wandsworth emigrated to Lanc... 07 Mar 21 12.33pm

Its difficult as so many played at different times and memories sometime make things look better than they were.
When I started going it was all Kenny and Vince - and while Kenny was better, Vince was more popular, as I remember. When Vince got the ball if felt like it feels now when Wilf gets it.
You cant deny Ian Wright his place at the top table either, nor Andy Johnson (he must be close to the best strike rate ever for Palace?).
So, from my time of 1978 to date its
1. Wilf
2. Kenny
3. Vince
4. Ian W
5. AJ
But when I started the guys were like a crazy gang, with some hard players full of character - Rashid - Billy Gilbert - Doris - Jim Cannon, and then Mickey Droy. Hard players who fought like lions.

Edited by kevlee (07 Mar 2021 12.33pm)

 


Following Palace since 25 Feb 1978

Palace 1979 Flag Surrey 07 Mar 21 1.00pm

First game in 1977 for me.

Best I have seen is hard as the game has changed a lot over the years.

Best keeper - Nigel Martyn

Best center back - Jim Cannon,
Best full back - Kenny Sansom
Best center midfield - Gerry Francis
Best winger - Wilf
Best forward - Ian Wright

There were loads of alternatives !

 


Some people are like Slinkies … not really good for anything, but you can’t help smiling when you see one tumble down the stairs.

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 07 Mar 21 1.22pm

Wilfs our best ever player for sure, followed by JB.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 07 Mar 21 2.09pm

As far as I'm concerned, Salako and McGoldrick were equal to Wilf. Probably Hilaire too. Watch the shift McGoldrick put in on any replay. He literally never stopped. That's not part of the current game.
Wilf is a good player - very skillful. Probably the most skillful player we've ever had, Hilaire is the other close one there. But best is totally different. Probably Sansom.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 07 Mar 21 2.23pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

As far as I'm concerned, Salako and McGoldrick were equal to Wilf. Probably Hilaire too. Watch the shift McGoldrick put in on any replay. He literally never stopped. That's not part of the current game.
Wilf is a good player - very skillful. Probably the most skillful player we've ever had, Hilaire is the other close one there. But best is totally different. Probably Sansom.

It’s definitely Wilf.

I remember Taylor getting picked for England and being so proud, Lombardo looked different class, Samson quality too but defo Wilf for me (just opinion)

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Cannonball Flag High in the Ozarks. 07 Mar 21 2.37pm

Originally posted by crystal-purley

Most of those mentioned but Rachid just for the sheer entertainment value.

Loved watching him,any idea where his nick-name Spider came from ?

 


Touch my coffee and I will slap you so hard even Google won't be able to find you.

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > GOAT or GPPOAT