You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Economics vs Existentialism
November 16 2026 4.45am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Economics vs Existentialism


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
Dubai Eagle Flag 12 Apr 21 10.35am

Hi Elwiss,
In terms of the feeling that the wealth of a club or their expenditure on better players roughly equates to the league position I agree with you - however I didn't see the Chelsea / WB game or the highlights, (so my thoughts may be complete BS) but when I saw the score my first thought was that Chelsea had probably underestimated WB & we were going to pay the price.


Originally posted by Elwissthebest

Apologies, and to Midland Eagle as well, for any obscurity.
By 'existential', I mean an assertion of the will that exceeds expectation. In this case, the expectation is that you can't escape economics. At the end of the season, you are looking, by and large, at a League table that reflects economic advantage. But Chelsea 2 West Brom 5 can't be explained by that. So how to explain it other than by a 'super-human' effort?
So when did Palace last exceed expectation? You can't overcome a technically superior opposition other than by countering that superiority by something different, unusual, unexpected. But in no respect could we even match Chelsea yesterday. As Chris Coleman said, Chelsea 'wanted it more'. How can that be?
Let's imagine that for some reason, we had Klopp or Guardiola managing us for a season. What difference would it make? Ten more points a season? So in that respect Hodgson isn't the problem. What is a problem is that we can still be as outclassed as we were yesterday. We'll never have the money to compete with the big teams, but in the absence of that, we need inspiration from somewhere, and it's in pretty short supply at the moment. My point was simply that many posters, and perhaps the Board, accepts that economic circumstances means we can't do better than hope to escape relegation every year. Really? After eight seasons in the top flight? That we might do better than just that is what, for good or ill, I chose to term Existentialism. With respect, my use of the term is not misplaced. An early poster-The Big Toe Punt?-caught the sense of this very well.

 

JRW2 Flag Dulwich 12 Apr 21 12.49pm

Originally posted by slubglurge

It wouldn't bother me if it did, a club like ours doesn't belong in the same competition as the big moneybags clubs. At least we wont have to forfeit 12 fixtures every season which is what Roy is doing at the moment

Couldn't agree more. These clubs are a blot on the football landscape. I wish they's go off and play with themselves and their Continental equivalents so that the rest of us can get back to a truly competitive league structure.

 

Elwissthebest Flag Marlborough 12 Apr 21 1.06pm

Originally posted by Dubai Eagle

Hi Elwiss,
In terms of the feeling that the wealth of a club or their expenditure on better players roughly equates to the league position I agree with you - however I didn't see the Chelsea / WB game or the highlights, (so my thoughts may be complete BS) but when I saw the score my first thought was that Chelsea had probably underestimated WB & we were going to pay the price.

Greetings!

I'm sure you're right. When you look at the gulf in class between Chelsea and WBA it's a result that shouldn't have happened. Chelsea had a man sent off but even so. How often have we struggled against ten man oppositions!
In a way, it's the sort of result that should keep one optimistic because it shows wealth doesn't always win. But of course, over the long term it does. The whole point of my original post was to savour all those things about football that mean results are not always economically determined. An example of the sort of thing I had in mind would be charisma, imagination, belief, commitment, even sheer cussedness. The sort of thing that is exemplified by Marco Bielsa. He's got five players in his current team who were part of a Leeds side that not so long ago was struggling in the Championship. He has simply made them better players in a way that our manager is not capable. How many Palace players has Roy Hodgson improved? I can think of several he hasn't! But this isn't intentionally an anti-Hodgson post. I don't want him sacked, but I don't want his contract renewed either. Posters who are unhappy about my use of 'existential' to describe that sense of being able to exceed economic expectation might consider what Claudio Ranieri achieved with Leicester when they won the Premiership. If ever there was an example of a man who 'changed the world by thinking about it' (pure Sartre) it was he.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 12 Apr 21 2.43pm

It’s fairly simple, league position is generally determined by the financial budget of the club.
A manager can make a small difference, but not as much as money can.

 

Davepalace707 Flag Northumberland 12 Apr 21 3.47pm

Originally posted by Painter

It’s fairly simple, league position is generally determined by the financial budget of the club.
A manager can make a small difference, but not as much as money can.

Sad but true. You can see the gap between Wolves and above and look at most of the teams where they are and this is borne out by that

 

Dubai Eagle Flag 12 Apr 21 4.46pm

Must be tough being the owner of a football club - if you looked at each of the clubs in the bottom half of the league & tried to estimate how much money would be needed to spend to -
Keep them in the league ?
improve their position by 2 places ?
Improve their position by 4 places ?
Etc.
If you look at say Everton & Brighton, both have spent a lot of money in recent years (comparatively speaking) but when you look at the table they are more or less in about the same league position as they were before - I am sure there are many similar examples

 

Davepalace707 Flag Northumberland 12 Apr 21 6.24pm

Originally posted by Dubai Eagle

Must be tough being the owner of a football club - if you looked at each of the clubs in the bottom half of the league & tried to estimate how much money would be needed to spend to -
Keep them in the league ?
improve their position by 2 places ?
Improve their position by 4 places ?
Etc.
If you look at say Everton & Brighton, both have spent a lot of money in recent years (comparatively speaking) but when you look at the table they are more or less in about the same league position as they were before - I am sure there are many similar examples

I guess there is an element of spending enough to make sure you don’t have a season where you go down. Suspect next season will prove whether we have or not.

 

Pete53 Flag Hassocks 14 Apr 21 1.30pm

I'm slightly disappointed to discover this is not a debate about the relatives merits of the thinking of John Maynard Keynes and John Paul Sartre!

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 14 Apr 21 3.21pm

Originally posted by Pete53

I'm slightly disappointed to discover this is not a debate about the relatives merits of the thinking of John Maynard Keynes and John Paul Sartre!

We can always start.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Pete53 Flag Hassocks 14 Apr 21 4.27pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC


We can always start.

You first

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 14 Apr 21 4.36pm

Originally posted by Pete53

You first

I guess Keynes would advocate investment in infrastructure so that economic progress could be made. Sarte would have us believe that if we thought hard enough that we could do well, we could make that our version of reality. I would certainly think that we need investment. I would also question the team's motivation on occasions. Do they truly believe? Or have false beliefs due to the constructs of their own version of reality?
I'm no expert on either of these by the way and could be entirely wrong.
However, I could ask is anyone or anything actually right, if I were to get all philosophical? I suspect no one's too bothered about my questions anyhow.

 


Red and Blue Army!

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 14 Apr 21 4.42pm

Essentially in existentialism people are free agents who have control over their choices and actions, and are therefore responsible for them.

In our society, especially at present, the state and its agencies restrict the individuals life or actions.

Existentialists believe this is harmful destroying the development of an individual's potential and society in general.

I think...


 

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 14 Apr 21 4.51pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

Essentially in existentialism people are free agents who have control over their choices and actions, and are therefore responsible for them.

In our society, especially at present, the state and its agencies restrict the individuals life or actions.

Existentialists believe this is harmful destroying the development of an individual's potential and society in general.

I think...


The most obvious existentialist I can think of would be PVA, as his defending demonstrates......

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 14 Apr 21 4.56pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

The most obvious existentialist I can think of would be PVA, as his defending demonstrates......

And in a Sartre tie-in he sometimes induces nausea.

 

Mwncisee Flag Middlesbrough 14 Apr 21 5.04pm

After 20 odd years of Holmesdale Online, this is the first high brow debate. What a welcome change lol

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 14 Apr 21 5.23pm

Originally posted by Mwncisee

After 20 odd years of Holmesdale Online, this is the first high brow debate. What a welcome change lol

Found your Nietzsche?

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 14 Apr 21 6.15pm

If I write 500 more words can I get a BA?

 


Red and Blue Army!

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 14 Apr 21 7.50pm

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle

Found your Nietzsche?


Nice one Teddy!

 

Aray Flag South London 14 Apr 21 9.18pm

Bravo! Though I’m not sure taking Keynes’s beliefs on the macroeconomic realm are appropriate for a firm operating in a sporting league. I have seen some dismal attempts to model this and they are half baked, like much economic modelling.

What is clear is that a great coach, with good infrastructure and a bit of luck can break the clear and long established correlation between club finances and league position at least in the short-term. How did Coppell get us to 3rd?

Not a shock revelation but our best bet is to get a smart manager and pray we get a few rough diamonds come through the academy.

Originally posted by ASCPFC

I guess Keynes would advocate investment in infrastructure so that economic progress could be made. Sarte would have us believe that if we thought hard enough that we could do well, we could make that our version of reality. I would certainly think that we need investment. I would also question the team's motivation on occasions. Do they truly believe? Or have false beliefs due to the constructs of their own version of reality?
I'm no expert on either of these by the way and could be entirely wrong.
However, I could ask is anyone or anything actually right, if I were to get all philosophical? I suspect no one's too bothered about my questions anyhow.

 

TheBigToePunt Flag 14 Apr 21 11.07pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

I guess Keynes would advocate investment in infrastructure so that economic progress could be made. Sarte would have us believe that if we thought hard enough that we could do well, we could make that our version of reality. I would certainly think that we need investment. I would also question the team's motivation on occasions. Do they truly believe? Or have false beliefs due to the constructs of their own version of reality?
I'm no expert on either of these by the way and could be entirely wrong.
However, I could ask is anyone or anything actually right, if I were to get all philosophical? I suspect no one's too bothered about my questions anyhow.

Yes, I think the Keynsian thing to do would be to spend money on the stand in the belief that the state (or club in this case) would grow in income terms to such an extent that it wouldn't matter what debt we accrued in the process, and that we could, and should, continue to spend in that way.

From what I understand Keynes was a genius who possibly did more for the rapid increase in standards of living in the second half of the last century than anyone else apart from Steve Coppell.

 

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Economics vs Existentialism