You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Manager. The Players. Or Both?
November 16 2026 4.45am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The Manager. The Players. Or Both?


Palace Old Geezer Flag Midhurst 11 Apr 21 12.41pm

Something, somewhere is very wrong. I watched yesterday's game with Chelsea and it was painful to sit through. Indeed, at one point I switched to the rugby for some respite. I returned to see more of the same. Now, I'm merely a Palace fan and have no expert knowledge, but I know a good game of football when I see one. I certainly didn't see one yesterday.

There are those of you who are quick to blame the manager for sending out the team to play in wrong positions in a system and formation you consider unsuitable. I happen to think Roy has done a brilliant job for our cash strapped club and I am not looking to see him forced out now, but I do think, for the sake of the club, a change is needed before we start another season in the Premier League.

What of the players though? Are they to blame? There appears to be no enthusiasm or passion for the game. Eze looks lost sometimes and I had such high hopes. Benteke lacks movement and, to my untrained eye, he doesn't appear to read the game well at all. OK, he scored our only goal but..... Zaha is nowhere near the player he was. I'd have liked to see Schlupp start and Mateta come off the bench at least. To me though, without even attempting to suggest a solution, the team as a whole looks jaded. So, a change is needed here too.

Point is, where does the responsibility lie for our poor form? It would be easy to say with both the manager and the players. But is it that simple? If we take on a new manager and had a clear out of some players, would we see a revitalised Palace? I'm not convinced although, as I said at the start of this I'm no expert.

In my old fashioned way I think the players have to show more fire in their bellies, use their footballing skills and do what the manager expects to at least look like they want to win a game of football.

Just jotting down a few thoughts really, but I expect it'll start a few Hares running. Over to you lot.

 


Dad and I watched games standing on the muddy slope of the Holmesdale Road end. He cheered and I rattled.

davehuggins Flag 11 Apr 21 12.51pm

Great post, for me we just lack the passion of past Palace teams. I believe RH has done a brilliant job on the whole but with our situation now I wonder if a change is needed? So, why are our performances so disappointing? Could it be the contract issue? could it be no crowds? Could it be players are fed up with RH? I guess only those involved really know!

Posted this on Next game, I agree with you.

 

SwordFish Flag Peasmarsh,East Sussex 11 Apr 21 12.54pm

I agree , as I said in my post and I’m sure fans will agree, I almost feel guilty with being disappointed with our season because on paper , we have again survived , comfortably! Not spent much money at all compared to the rest of the league and yet after every game almost I feel flat and deflated. Maybe it’s neither the team or management , maybe it’s this ridiculous time we live in, no fans, packed schedules , Covid tests , family worries , maybe it really is just the times .
Either way, one thing is for certain, Roy needs to make changes when things go wrong as I said in my thread , if he doesn’t do that he opens his self up to criticism and rightly so , because 99 times out of 100, when we go a goal down, we have no idea how to get back in the game

Good post

 


“This is a crisis, a large crisis.... in fact if you have a moment, it’s a 12 storey crisis, magnificent entrance hall, carpeting throughout, 24 hour portage , and an enormous sign on the roof saying “This , is a large crisis” - Edmund Blackadder

southnorwoodhill Flag 11 Apr 21 1.05pm

The thing is, how do you get a bunch of overpaid journeymen to have that bit of fire and pride when the bar is set so ridiculously low? PL survival at all costs, 17th place acceptable. We've seen the lack of desire for a cup run, instigated by the manager's team selection and tactics in those games.
I can imagine an agent saying to his player: "I've got a lovely little club lined up for you, will see you out until retirement, generous benefits, minimum requirement is to avoid relegation. Sounds good? Crystal Palace is the club, what do you think?"

 

babylonjohn Flag St Leonards-on-Sea 11 Apr 21 1.29pm

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

The thing is, how do you get a bunch of overpaid journeymen to have that bit of fire and pride when the bar is set so ridiculously low? PL survival at all costs, 17th place acceptable. We've seen the lack of desire for a cup run, instigated by the manager's team selection and tactics in those games.
I can imagine an agent saying to his player: "I've got a lovely little club lined up for you, will see you out until retirement, generous benefits, minimum requirement is to avoid relegation. Sounds good? Crystal Palace is the club, what do you think?"

Player: "Brilliant. I don't fancy playing too much but I hear from my mate Connor they have a comfy treatment room with all the mod cons to hang out in. He's been on the skive there for years ... Easy money ! "

 

Palace Old Geezer Flag Midhurst 11 Apr 21 1.44pm

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

The thing is, how do you get a bunch of overpaid journeymen to have that bit of fire and pride when the bar is set so ridiculously low? PL survival at all costs, 17th place acceptable. We've seen the lack of desire for a cup run, instigated by the manager's team selection and tactics in those games.
I can imagine an agent saying to his player: "I've got a lovely little club lined up for you, will see you out until retirement, generous benefits, minimum requirement is to avoid relegation. Sounds good? Crystal Palace is the club, what do you think?"

Bloody agents!!

 

Plaistow Eagle Flag 11 Apr 21 3.19pm

I sat and watched the whole game yesterday, (as painful a watch at it was) and the clear difference was Chelsea pressed all over the pitch from back to front and vice versa – we did not, we just sat and off the ball and let them have it.

There were numerous times yesterday where we had the ball at the back but there was no out ball, IMO that was a combination of Palace players not showing/able to make space to show themselves as a viable passing option and Chelsea’s pressing.

As prime example being Eze and the first goal, OK there is some vindication in that he was culpable and he has got to learn that sometimes in those positions he has got to put the proverbial foot through it and clear our lines, but he literally had no passing options.

So why is this happening – again IMO it’s because we have no pace and no mobility through the spine of the team. Which also means unlike Chelsea we can’t press as the lack of pace and mobility means that if players get caught out of position they can’t recover and we’re left exposed.

So we/Roy opt’s for a rigid formation and men behind the ball and “hope” they can’t/don’t pass and manoeuvre around that rigid formation – now against lesser teams you’ll get away with it, as has been proved, hence our points total.

But against better, more mobile teams able to move the ball quickly you will not.

Let’s be honest yesterday we were up against a side that are about to go into the Champions League semi final, a side full of youthful and exceptional talent and have the luxury of 32 players out on loan and if I dare say so a fair few of which would walk into the Palace first XI.

Beyond that they have Champions League Finalist as a Manager who is young and innovative in terms of tactics, approach and style of play. They also had the added incentive of being embarrassed last time out in the league by the team second from bottom scoring 5 against them at Home – so it was always going to be a tough ask.

But is that an the total story and an excuse for such an inept performance, I would say no it also highlights that Roy is very rigid and not a little stubborn in terms of his tactics and approach – he just trots out the same team and formation irrespective of who we are playing and the circumstances.

If ever there was an argument to play 3 in central midfield yesterday was it. Beyond that he continues to play square pegs in round holes to suit that formation – e.g. Ayew is not a right winger/midfielder – why not play Townsend who would have given an ageing Ward more protection.

Zaha is not a forward play him on the left and then Eze in behind Benteke, or as I said play 3 central midfielders and give Eze a rest for a game/ bring on later – his time will come he is a class act.
The lack of mobility and pace through our spine has been there for all to see for a while, which brings into question the recruitment of Mateta, was that what was really/urgently required? My answer is no we need/needed at least one if not two mobile central midfielders.

I know some will point to Mateta’s goal against Brighton – but that aside how often has he featured – 2 or 3 times as a Sub – so not required when we already had Bats warming the bench, who as proved against Everton given the opportunity will score goals.

Point of all this is that as proved this season at the moment our/Roy’s rigid formations and tactics will get us by against the lesser teams in the Premiership, but come up against the better sides they and our lack of mobility will be ruthlessly exposed by the better teams on “their day” as proved yesterday and against Liverpool.

Added issue that we have is that the “status quo” of our current modus operandi has limited/and quickly diminishing shelf life given the age of our squad and Manager..!!

So in summary change is required both on and off the pitch this summer – in terms of injection of youth, mobility and innovation if we are to push on – or even if to just maintain our Premiership status.

COYP

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 11 Apr 21 4.33pm

Originally posted by Palace Old Geezer

Something, somewhere is very wrong. I watched yesterday's game with Chelsea and it was painful to sit through. Indeed, at one point I switched to the rugby for some respite. I returned to see more of the same. Now, I'm merely a Palace fan and have no expert knowledge, but I know a good game of football when I see one. I certainly didn't see one yesterday.

There are those of you who are quick to blame the manager for sending out the team to play in wrong positions in a system and formation you consider unsuitable. I happen to think Roy has done a brilliant job for our cash strapped club and I am not looking to see him forced out now, but I do think, for the sake of the club, a change is needed before we start another season in the Premier League.

What of the players though? Are they to blame? There appears to be no enthusiasm or passion for the game. Eze looks lost sometimes and I had such high hopes. Benteke lacks movement and, to my untrained eye, he doesn't appear to read the game well at all. OK, he scored our only goal but..... Zaha is nowhere near the player he was. I'd have liked to see Schlupp start and Mateta come off the bench at least. To me though, without even attempting to suggest a solution, the team as a whole looks jaded. So, a change is needed here too.

Point is, where does the responsibility lie for our poor form? It would be easy to say with both the manager and the players. But is it that simple? If we take on a new manager and had a clear out of some players, would we see a revitalised Palace? I'm not convinced although, as I said at the start of this I'm no expert.

In my old fashioned way I think the players have to show more fire in their bellies, use their footballing skills and do what the manager expects to at least look like they want to win a game of football.

Just jotting down a few thoughts really, but I expect it'll start a few Hares running. Over to you lot.


Poor form ? - we had lost just once in six games prior to yesterday.

Had we have won yesterday, we would have accumulated more points per games played since getting promoted.

I think that when we have lost games this season, we have lost badly. And most of the games we have won have hardly been won in style.

Consequently the season feels a lot worse than it's actually been.

A re-set is certainly needed in the summer. It won't be a job for the faint hearted. I'm highly dubious about the supposed £50m ' war chest ' being available and if I'm right, Parish will lean towards a manager that can perform with limited funds. We already have one of those in Roy, but a logical successor on those terms is Dyche. Which does not fill me with enthusiasm.

So in conclusion...if there is something '' very wrong '' I think it's the manager and the players but add to that the owners who are trying to run the club wearing a financial straightjacket.


Edited by NEILLO (11 Apr 2021 4.33pm)

 


Old, Ungifted and White

palace chick Flag South Croydon 11 Apr 21 4.37pm

Nail on head Plaistow Eagle. Hodgson has a rigid set up and won’t change it and will play the same way against any team we play. I’m told On talksport today, Palace players were described as training cones. Basically, a team rigid with no option for change :-(

 

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 11 Apr 21 4.41pm

Dean Ashton said on talkSport he would hate to play in Roy Hodgson's side, as a forward you're just keeping shape and waiting on scraps - when Roy gives the 'park the bus' orders pre-match heads must drop a bit, and when it doesn't work and there's no attempt to reorganise to solve the problem heads must drop still further.

 

redshift Flag Toronto 11 Apr 21 4.45pm

Originally posted by Plaistow Eagle

EDITED (rs)

So why is this happening – again IMO it’s because we have no pace and no mobility through the spine of the team. Which also means unlike Chelsea we can’t press as the lack of pace and mobility means that if players get caught out of position they can’t recover and we’re left exposed.

Point of all this is that as proved this season at the moment our/Roy’s rigid formations and tactics will get us by against the lesser teams in the Premiership, but come up against the better sides they and our lack of mobility will be ruthlessly exposed by the better teams on “their day” as proved yesterday and against Liverpool.

Added issue that we have is that the “status quo” of our current modus operandi has limited/and quickly diminishing shelf life given the age of our squad and Manager..!!

So in summary change is required both on and off the pitch this summer – in terms of injection of youth, mobility and innovation if we are to push on – or even if to just maintain our Premiership status.

COYP

Agree with pretty much everything here. (I edited some out just for space. Please read PE's original.)

I've said it before; I believe Roy is just doing exactly what the Board has mandated him to do as best he can, keep us out of relegation with minimal expenditures. Make do with what you have plus a bit we give you and he's done that very well. It's ugly, but it works. Also I think the players are still trying, it just doesn't appear like it because we lack so much pace and quality.

With the financial situation after Covid I can see Palace just doing a repeat of this year. Give Roy a contract for the year, dump some deadwood, buy one or two cheap plus some loans and try to stay up for another year. I'm not sure I can watch another year like this though. it's just not enjoyable.

Or we could take the more risky route of new manager (would need it if a rebuild is in the works) try to pick up players cheaply from clubs looking to shed players to trim the salaries load and come out of this stronger with actual goals other than just avoiding relegation. I'm not sure the Board is up for this.

 


Success will lie to you but failure always tells you the truth.

JRW2 Flag Dulwich 11 Apr 21 5.34pm

Originally posted by Plaistow Eagle


Point of all this is that as proved this season at the moment our/Roy’s rigid formations and tactics will get us by against the lesser teams in the Premiership, but come up against the better sides they and our lack of mobility will be ruthlessly exposed by the better teams on “their day” as proved yesterday and against Liverpool.

I enjoyed your entire post, but I want to pick up on one thing. To me you make it sound (obviously unintentionally) as if we are uniquely bad in the Premier League. Who are the lesser teams? The bottom half of the table? Bottom third? The point I'm frankly struggling to put into words is that all of us "lesser" teams, however defined, "get by" to a greater or lesser extent against other "lesser" teams, but "come unstuck" against the better sides. A glance at the table demonstrates that with 85% of the season over there are several teams who have "got by" less often than us and "come unstuck" more often than us. Maybe in our case we are a "lesser" team because of, as you say, a lack of mobility. Other "lesser" teams will have other issues. To conclude, we are far from unique in being a "lesser" club. Let's all try to recognise that and be less downcast.

 

kev64 Flag Cambs 11 Apr 21 7.13pm

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

The thing is, how do you get a bunch of overpaid journeymen to have that bit of fire and pride when the bar is set so ridiculously low? PL survival at all costs, 17th place acceptable. We've seen the lack of desire for a cup run, instigated by the manager's team selection and tactics in those games.
I can imagine an agent saying to his player: "I've got a lovely little club lined up for you, will see you out until retirement, generous benefits, minimum requirement is to avoid relegation. Sounds good? Crystal Palace is the club, what do you think?"

Have we got a bunch of overpaid journeymen ? Ward, Zaha. JMac most of our team have been there several seasons.

It’s 100% management, we buy a #10 Eze play him on the left wing instead of Townsend/Wilf or Schulp take your pick. Ayew play him on the right ... after him having a good season up front. Tekkers with nobody to cross to him. Matea scores, gets subbed and is never seen again.

The team gets over run playing 442 yesterday, what does Roy do swap 2 midfield players for 2 midfielders, it’s an ever decreasing circle of misery for our team ....

You listen to Leeds players, looking up the table, Roy well 17th is all I want .. last season we ended 7 loses .. this season let’s do it again.

If we are changing managers do it now SP or let us know if Roy is staying so I can refund my ST £ and return when s*** changes.

 

Arthur Waite Flag Portsmouth 11 Apr 21 8.00pm

In answer to the thread headline, I think it's a mix of both.

First and foremost, the manager always has to take responsibility. At last, Hodgson accepted responsibility after the game.

However, the mindset and negative tactics employed against every team has been dispiriting and depressing to watch. We all know, we can't compete Onan equal footing with Man City, Spurs, etc etc, but when we concede possession against lower opposition and simply sit back, waiting for a mistake, we will consistently lose games.

Despite what the manager says after games, we do not put things right. I agree that Hodgson has kept Palace in the Premier, but his expectations are always too low. His ambition, which the players 'feed off' is too low. eg We are safe so therefore there is nothing left to do.

Re the players, there has been alack of desire from most, BUT we have players out of position and a midfield that lacks quality overall.

Eze is a potential quality player, but is played out of position, therefore seriously limiting his ability to create chances to win matches.

Zaha is not a typical 'front man'. He has been made virtually redundant in current position, where his dribbling skill has almost diminished.

Defensively, we are very much below Prem average.

We have some good young players in reserves. Some of them need 'blooding' before the end of the season, before we lose them!


The powers that be need to be decisive now- there needs to be clear out of players that a) are expensive on the wage bill and b) over the hill.

Hodgson has done a job that was necessary.

New blood at manager level and with the playing staff is now urgently required.

With fans in the stadium, I think there would have been mutiny by now!

 

CPFCwetrust Flag Maidstone 11 Apr 21 8.07pm

I think it's a mix of the following:
1. No fans to give the players a boost or a verbal kick up the arse.
2. Roy having the aforementioned impulse to play the same players even when there are alternative options and in positions that aren't their best suited position. ( No real competitiveness for a starting place for the likes of - Benteke, Ayew, Zaha, Mili etc....)
3. The 'slower than my dads walking football' midfielders.
4. The same game plan every game when it comes to getting it to Zaha when possible.
Not exactly surprising he gets hacked down and wound up every game.
5. The lack of investment in certain areas.
6. Roys talks must be the least inspiring talks in the history of football if the energy levels of the last game showed.
7. Players taking the piss qhen it comes to having their head in the game as we are just about safe.
8. No real captain on the pitch...Jedinak I sorely miss.

I predict at the end of the season that Zaha will be sold to offset the cost of new players that are needed. The likes of Sakho, Wickham, Benteke etc will finally be sacked off.

Ferguson may finally be fit next season, fingers crossed for some of the youth to make more of a show (wishful thinking), a new manager, less reliance on one player, some forward play with a forward more likely to score than our defenders, Cahill to have an extended contract, some of the elderly also to leave, a fresh start with a bit more ambition in the cups next season.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 11 Apr 21 8.09pm

Originally posted by kev64

Have we got a bunch of overpaid journeymen ? Ward, Zaha. JMac most of our team have been there several seasons.

It’s 100% management, we buy a #10 Eze play him on the left wing instead of Townsend/Wilf or Schulp take your pick. Ayew play him on the right ... after him having a good season up front. Tekkers with nobody to cross to him. Matea scores, gets subbed and is never seen again.

The team gets over run playing 442 yesterday, what does Roy do swap 2 midfield players for 2 midfielders, it’s an ever decreasing circle of misery for our team ....

You listen to Leeds players, looking up the table, Roy well 17th is all I want .. last season we ended 7 loses .. this season let’s do it again.

If we are changing managers do it now SP or let us know if Roy is staying so I can refund my ST £ and return when s*** changes.

Oh I agree, I'm no fan of Hodgson either for the reasons you give. Under him everything has become jaded and stale. The point I was trying to make is that the players we have are overpaid for the task they have to achieve and the ability they actually display.

 


You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Manager. The Players. Or Both?