This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by southnorwoodhill
The thing is, how do you get a bunch of overpaid journeymen to have that bit of fire and pride when the bar is set so ridiculously low? PL survival at all costs, 17th place acceptable. We've seen the lack of desire for a cup run, instigated by the manager's team selection and tactics in those games. Player: "Brilliant. I don't fancy playing too much but I hear from my mate Connor they have a comfy treatment room with all the mod cons to hang out in. He's been on the skive there for years ... Easy money ! "
|
|
|
Originally posted by southnorwoodhill
The thing is, how do you get a bunch of overpaid journeymen to have that bit of fire and pride when the bar is set so ridiculously low? PL survival at all costs, 17th place acceptable. We've seen the lack of desire for a cup run, instigated by the manager's team selection and tactics in those games. Bloody agents!!
|
|
|
Originally posted by Palace Old Geezer
Something, somewhere is very wrong. I watched yesterday's game with Chelsea and it was painful to sit through. Indeed, at one point I switched to the rugby for some respite. I returned to see more of the same. Now, I'm merely a Palace fan and have no expert knowledge, but I know a good game of football when I see one. I certainly didn't see one yesterday. There are those of you who are quick to blame the manager for sending out the team to play in wrong positions in a system and formation you consider unsuitable. I happen to think Roy has done a brilliant job for our cash strapped club and I am not looking to see him forced out now, but I do think, for the sake of the club, a change is needed before we start another season in the Premier League. What of the players though? Are they to blame? There appears to be no enthusiasm or passion for the game. Eze looks lost sometimes and I had such high hopes. Benteke lacks movement and, to my untrained eye, he doesn't appear to read the game well at all. OK, he scored our only goal but..... Zaha is nowhere near the player he was. I'd have liked to see Schlupp start and Mateta come off the bench at least. To me though, without even attempting to suggest a solution, the team as a whole looks jaded. So, a change is needed here too. Point is, where does the responsibility lie for our poor form? It would be easy to say with both the manager and the players. But is it that simple? If we take on a new manager and had a clear out of some players, would we see a revitalised Palace? I'm not convinced although, as I said at the start of this I'm no expert. In my old fashioned way I think the players have to show more fire in their bellies, use their footballing skills and do what the manager expects to at least look like they want to win a game of football. Just jotting down a few thoughts really, but I expect it'll start a few Hares running. Over to you lot.
Had we have won yesterday, we would have accumulated more points per games played since getting promoted. I think that when we have lost games this season, we have lost badly. And most of the games we have won have hardly been won in style. Consequently the season feels a lot worse than it's actually been. A re-set is certainly needed in the summer. It won't be a job for the faint hearted. I'm highly dubious about the supposed £50m ' war chest ' being available and if I'm right, Parish will lean towards a manager that can perform with limited funds. We already have one of those in Roy, but a logical successor on those terms is Dyche. Which does not fill me with enthusiasm. So in conclusion...if there is something '' very wrong '' I think it's the manager and the players but add to that the owners who are trying to run the club wearing a financial straightjacket.
Old, Ungifted and White |
|
|
Originally posted by Plaistow Eagle
EDITED (rs) So why is this happening – again IMO it’s because we have no pace and no mobility through the spine of the team. Which also means unlike Chelsea we can’t press as the lack of pace and mobility means that if players get caught out of position they can’t recover and we’re left exposed. Point of all this is that as proved this season at the moment our/Roy’s rigid formations and tactics will get us by against the lesser teams in the Premiership, but come up against the better sides they and our lack of mobility will be ruthlessly exposed by the better teams on “their day” as proved yesterday and against Liverpool. Added issue that we have is that the “status quo” of our current modus operandi has limited/and quickly diminishing shelf life given the age of our squad and Manager..!! So in summary change is required both on and off the pitch this summer – in terms of injection of youth, mobility and innovation if we are to push on – or even if to just maintain our Premiership status. COYP Agree with pretty much everything here. (I edited some out just for space. Please read PE's original.) I've said it before; I believe Roy is just doing exactly what the Board has mandated him to do as best he can, keep us out of relegation with minimal expenditures. Make do with what you have plus a bit we give you and he's done that very well. It's ugly, but it works. Also I think the players are still trying, it just doesn't appear like it because we lack so much pace and quality. With the financial situation after Covid I can see Palace just doing a repeat of this year. Give Roy a contract for the year, dump some deadwood, buy one or two cheap plus some loans and try to stay up for another year. I'm not sure I can watch another year like this though. it's just not enjoyable. Or we could take the more risky route of new manager (would need it if a rebuild is in the works) try to pick up players cheaply from clubs looking to shed players to trim the salaries load and come out of this stronger with actual goals other than just avoiding relegation. I'm not sure the Board is up for this.
Success will lie to you but failure always tells you the truth. |
|
|
Originally posted by Plaistow Eagle
I enjoyed your entire post, but I want to pick up on one thing. To me you make it sound (obviously unintentionally) as if we are uniquely bad in the Premier League. Who are the lesser teams? The bottom half of the table? Bottom third? The point I'm frankly struggling to put into words is that all of us "lesser" teams, however defined, "get by" to a greater or lesser extent against other "lesser" teams, but "come unstuck" against the better sides. A glance at the table demonstrates that with 85% of the season over there are several teams who have "got by" less often than us and "come unstuck" more often than us. Maybe in our case we are a "lesser" team because of, as you say, a lack of mobility. Other "lesser" teams will have other issues. To conclude, we are far from unique in being a "lesser" club. Let's all try to recognise that and be less downcast.
|
|
|
Originally posted by southnorwoodhill
The thing is, how do you get a bunch of overpaid journeymen to have that bit of fire and pride when the bar is set so ridiculously low? PL survival at all costs, 17th place acceptable. We've seen the lack of desire for a cup run, instigated by the manager's team selection and tactics in those games. Have we got a bunch of overpaid journeymen ? Ward, Zaha. JMac most of our team have been there several seasons. It’s 100% management, we buy a #10 Eze play him on the left wing instead of Townsend/Wilf or Schulp take your pick. Ayew play him on the right ... after him having a good season up front. Tekkers with nobody to cross to him. Matea scores, gets subbed and is never seen again. The team gets over run playing 442 yesterday, what does Roy do swap 2 midfield players for 2 midfielders, it’s an ever decreasing circle of misery for our team .... You listen to Leeds players, looking up the table, Roy well 17th is all I want .. last season we ended 7 loses .. this season let’s do it again. If we are changing managers do it now SP or let us know if Roy is staying so I can refund my ST £ and return when s*** changes.
|
|
|
Originally posted by kev64
Have we got a bunch of overpaid journeymen ? Ward, Zaha. JMac most of our team have been there several seasons. It’s 100% management, we buy a #10 Eze play him on the left wing instead of Townsend/Wilf or Schulp take your pick. Ayew play him on the right ... after him having a good season up front. Tekkers with nobody to cross to him. Matea scores, gets subbed and is never seen again. The team gets over run playing 442 yesterday, what does Roy do swap 2 midfield players for 2 midfielders, it’s an ever decreasing circle of misery for our team .... You listen to Leeds players, looking up the table, Roy well 17th is all I want .. last season we ended 7 loses .. this season let’s do it again. If we are changing managers do it now SP or let us know if Roy is staying so I can refund my ST £ and return when s*** changes. Oh I agree, I'm no fan of Hodgson either for the reasons you give. Under him everything has become jaded and stale. The point I was trying to make is that the players we have are overpaid for the task they have to achieve and the ability they actually display.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.