You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Hodgson's Future Undecided?
November 16 2026 4.45am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Hodgson's Future Undecided?


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 03 May 21 2.36pm

Originally posted by Crystal_Clear

In my opinion, keeping Hodgson for another year is the option Parish would prefer. It's the easiest and cheapest option, and from that interview Roy is indicating he would probably carry on given the opportunity.

The issue for them is the fans.

Had we still been in lockdown for the foreseeable future, they could getaway with it. However, with fans returning to stadiums, we simply would not remain silent about this uninspiring, dour, boring and tedious football.

The crowd would be on everyones backs. I think Parish is astute enough to know this which is why there a delay over any decision.

Of course, ann announcement of another lockdown and his problem would be solved.

I think you’re right regarding SP being hesitant but also worth remembering that he, Harris and Blitzer will be most concerned the value of their investment and that two of the three probably don’t give a sh1t about fan discontent.

 

Brinscalleagle2 Flag Brinscall 03 May 21 3.49pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

Just reading Hodgson’s comment about Sterling after Saturday’s game.
He was asked about Sterling and England and responded, ‘ I’m certain he will be an important cog in the wheel. He plays an important role in the team’s defensive work.’
It does appear that Hodgson’s key criteria for measuring a forward’s worth is his defensive work.
Perhaps a new manager would judges forwards on their attacking play and concentrate on maximising their strengths to hurt the opposition.
It’s not as if the defensive work demanded of our offensive players has led to a solid defensive record - it’s amongst the worst in the division.

It would appear that Guardiola agrees with Roy as he insists on the same work ethic as illustrated by Sterling.Th3 difference is they can spend fortunes on players and we can’t so they can buy quality players and unfortunately we can’t.

 

PatrickA Flag London 03 May 21 5.59pm

I don’t dispute the work ethic requirement which should be a given for professional footballers at an elite level.
It’s Hodgson’s lauding of a forward’s defensive attributes rather than what can he bring to the attacking side that is difficult to understand.
It’s very revealing about his negative mindset and approach to the game.
Perhaps understandable against the better teams, but not against the majority of teams we face.
And all this defensive work from our forwards which Hodgson demands has not exactly contributed to a good defensive record this season.
And it certainly hasn’t made us more threatening in attack.

Originally posted by Brinscalleagle2

It would appear that Guardiola agrees with Roy as he insists on the same work ethic as illustrated by Sterling.Th3 difference is they can spend fortunes on players and we can’t so they can buy quality players and unfortunately we can’t.

 

Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 03 May 21 5.59pm

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

Its not Roys Decision, His contract is up, its Parish's , a new manager is imperative, as is getting rid of at least Benteke, Sakho, Wickham, Ward, PVA, Dann, Hennessey and Kelly, and also sending Bats back

Pretty much agree and it’s been pretty obvious for some months now that Roy will not be our manager next season.

 

redshift Flag Toronto 04 May 21 3.51pm

Originally posted by Phil’s Barber

Pretty much agree and it’s been pretty obvious for some months now that Roy will not be our manager next season.

Well, you're better than me because I can't get any sort of read on what's going on unless the whole plan of all EPL management during Covid is to mess with their fans... yes I'm looking at you Glazer.

 


Success will lie to you but failure always tells you the truth.

eaglesdare Flag 04 May 21 4.40pm

We are pretty much out of plan B managers now if a new plan A manager is having a bad run of games in the relegation zone!

Don't think any manager could have gotten more out of the group of players roy has this season!

We havnt been in a relegation fight since roy took over! I remember saying to myself! I just want a few seasons of no relegation worries which is what I've gotten! :-)

When we do eventually get relegated I just want somthing to show for being so long in the prem! It will take years to come back up!

 

scuffy Flag orpington 04 May 21 6.30pm

This is why I hope any parting of the ways with Roy is amicable. He could well be our plan B again if things were to backfire under a new manager.

Originally posted by eaglesdare

We are pretty much out of plan B managers now if a new plan A manager is having a bad run of games in the relegation zone!

Don't think any manager could have gotten more out of the group of players roy has this season!

We havnt been in a relegation fight since roy took over! I remember saying to myself! I just want a few seasons of no relegation worries which is what I've gotten! :-)

When we do eventually get relegated I just want somthing to show for being so long in the prem! It will take years to come back up!

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 04 May 21 8.47pm

Originally posted by eaglesdare

We are pretty much out of plan B managers now if a new plan A manager is having a bad run of games in the relegation zone!

Don't think any manager could have gotten more out of the group of players roy has this season!

We havnt been in a relegation fight since roy took over! I remember saying to myself! I just want a few seasons of no relegation worries which is what I've gotten! :-)

When we do eventually get relegated I just want somthing to show for being so long in the prem! It will take years to come back up!

Plan B supports the Clowns.

 


Red and Blue Army!

southnorwoodhill Flag 05 May 21 10.17am

Earlier in the season Hodgson mentioned that he was keen on still managing / coaching yet now he says he's not sure?
Put yourself in Parish's shoes for one moment: next season is critical to the club's fortunes - playing staff out of contract and over the hill, need to reduce salaries, Academy not ready yet for PL level, return of crowds etc. There's a lot to do so the last thing I would want is a manager who can't make up his mind.
Another year's contract for Hodgson would be mere short termism whilst the real rebuilding job is at our doorstep.

 

Palace Old Geezer Flag Midhurst 05 May 21 10.26am

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

Earlier in the season Hodgson mentioned that he was keen on still managing / coaching yet now he says he's not sure?
Put yourself in Parish's shoes for one moment: next season is critical to the club's fortunes - playing staff out of contract and over the hill, need to reduce salaries, Academy not ready yet for PL level, return of crowds etc. There's a lot to do so the last thing I would want is a manager who can't make up his mind.
Another year's contract for Hodgson would be mere short termism whilst the real rebuilding job is at our doorstep.

 


Dad and I watched games standing on the muddy slope of the Holmesdale Road end. He cheered and I rattled.

Palace Old Geezer Flag Midhurst 05 May 21 10.28am

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

Earlier in the season Hodgson mentioned that he was keen on still managing / coaching yet now he says he's not sure?
Put yourself in Parish's shoes for one moment: next season is critical to the club's fortunes - playing staff out of contract and over the hill, need to reduce salaries, Academy not ready yet for PL level, return of crowds etc. There's a lot to do so the last thing I would want is a manager who can't make up his mind.
Another year's contract for Hodgson would be mere short termism whilst the real rebuilding job is at our doorstep.

I've just put myself in Mr Parish's shoes. Tell you what, they're bloody uncomfortable.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 05 May 21 10.34am

Originally posted by Palace Old Geezer

I've just put myself in Mr Parish's shoes. Tell you what, they're bloody uncomfortable.

Don't forget you have a hairdresser's appointment today too

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 05 May 21 10.35am

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

Earlier in the season Hodgson mentioned that he was keen on still managing / coaching yet now he says he's not sure?

There's a lot to do so the last thing I would want is a manager who can't make up his mind.

Don't believe anything that you read in the media or what people are saying as it's all Smoke & Mirrors

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 05 May 21 10.36am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

I don't believe it as the job of a chairman is to plan for the future which is impossible if the manager is so indecisive. Roy's position has been decided but for some reason or other hasn't been announced to the world

Perhaps it is a discussion for the summer thereby avoiding the team being seen to be led by a lame duck coach? Any responses to direct questions will thus be met with obfuscation and polite fudge.

If my complete guess is true, expect an announcement within not much time of the Liverpool game.

Until then, enjoy the pointless speculation.

 

Palace Old Geezer Flag Midhurst 05 May 21 10.38am

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

Don't forget you have a hairdresser's appointment today too

Oh blimey! Must dash!

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 05 May 21 10.43am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Don't believe anything that you read in the media or what people are saying as it's all Smoke & Mirrors

Funny enough the term "smoke and mirrors" did pass my mind. At least we missed out on Mourinho!

 

A1969Eagle Flag Redhill 05 May 21 10.48am

TIME IS UP Roy

Thank you for holding fort but club has stagnated, which means its going backwards, we might still finish in 17th way things are going, and still fans will say "Great job Roy, can you stay for another season"..

Time to get real, we have defenders on the bench but he still plays a midfield player in defence and look at goal difference, third worse in the league.

End of season is coming. Phew!!

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 05 May 21 10.53am

Originally posted by A1969Eagle

TIME IS UP Roy

Thank you for holding fort but club has stagnated, which means its going backwards, we might still finish in 17th way things are going, and still fans will say "Great job Roy, can you stay for another season"..

Time to get real, we have defenders on the bench but he still plays a midfield player in defence and look at goal difference, third worse in the league.

End of season is coming. Phew!!

Kouyate had been a CB and has had some excellent performances in that position this season. Also, he has had to step up in extremis to cover serious injuries in that position.

I doubt there have been 2 consecutive matches where we have been able to field a settled back 2 which has largely contributed to the poor goal difference and less confident team in front.

Roy is as open to fair criticism as any other manager, but this criticism is not fair.

 

Eagle Black. Flag South Croydon 05 May 21 10.58am

Originally posted by A1969Eagle

TIME IS UP Roy

Thank you for holding fort but club has stagnated, which means its going backwards, we might still finish in 17th way things are going, and still fans will say "Great job Roy, can you stay for another season"..

Time to get real, we have defenders on the bench but he still plays a midfield player in defence and look at goal difference, third worse in the league.

End of season is coming. Phew!!

Agree with all you say,all change.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 05 May 21 11.33am

Originally posted by Palace Old Geezer

Oh blimey! Must dash!

Will you be able to cope with Susannah?

 

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Hodgson's Future Undecided?