You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Jack Butland
November 16 2026 4.01am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Jack Butland


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 16 Jan 22 12.50pm

Originally posted by merganser

And don't forget the incomparable Billy Callender - the keeper who always saved penalties.

I don't think shinpads had been invented in his era, so he stuffed old copies of the Croydon Advertiser down his socks.

It's a terrible shame. RIP Billy.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Gribbo Flag Bromley 16 Jan 22 12.56pm

I see Palace are quoted in the Sky Bet odds for Henderson, along with other Premier League teams looking for a replacement keeper.

 

CT Charlie Flag 16 Jan 22 6.12pm

Guaita has better reactions, while Butland is better playing the ball in the air and commanding the box. Neither excels with his feet.

Viera may actually want to play each of them depending on the strengths of the opposition and the style he wants to play each match. Over the course of 15 games, I think VG would earn us a few (very few) more points, but against teams who love to cross or who win many corners, Butland would make sense.

A big unknown variable (to the fans) is who directs the defense better – or is that a job assigned to Anderson? PV and staff probably have a good handle on that aspect of the game.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 16 Jan 22 6.18pm

Originally posted by Gary St.Andrews

We have, I did see Johnny Jackson play and he was a great keeper. But for me Nigel Martyn away at Everton, game finished 0-0 and he made 12 saves that day which were incredible. He got a standing ovation from the crowd, never seen anything like it.

Where do you get your memory from?
Wish mine was that good. I don’t even remember the game.

 

Palace Old Geezer Flag Midhurst 16 Jan 22 6.46pm

Originally posted by merganser

And don't forget the incomparable Billy Callender - the keeper who always saved penalties.

I don't think shinpads had been invented in his era, so he stuffed old copies of the Croydon Advertiser down his socks.

I've just had a look at Wikipedia to find out a bit more, because I confess Billy's story had passed me by. What a sad story it is although there's not a great deal on Wiki.

Anyway, well done merganser for reminding us about him.

 


Dad and I watched games standing on the muddy slope of the Holmesdale Road end. He cheered and I rattled.

YT Flag Oxford 16 Jan 22 6.57pm

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

Where do you get your memory from?
Wish mine was that good. I don’t even remember the game.

He can't remember!

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

Gary St.Andrews Flag Kenley 16 Jan 22 7.49pm

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

Where do you get your memory from?
Wish mine was that good. I don’t even remember the game.

There are certain games you remember and Everton battered us that day, but Martyn was unbelievable. We sold him to Leeds and he did go to Everton for spell.

Another one that sticks in my mind, we are away to Southampton at the Dell. We take the kick off , Mark Bright plays it back to Richard Shaw who then puts it past Martyn into the net. Southampton hadn’t even touched the ball and they are 1-0 up!

Ian Wright and Mark Bright turned it around and we won 3-2…

 

YT Flag Oxford 16 Jan 22 8.56pm

Originally posted by Gary St.Andrews

There are certain games you remember and Everton battered us that day, but Martyn was unbelievable. We sold him to Leeds and he did go to Everton for spell.

Another one that sticks in my mind, we are away to Southampton at the Dell. We take the kick off , Mark Bright plays it back to Richard Shaw who then puts it past Martyn into the net. Southampton hadn’t even touched the ball and they are 1-0 up!

Ian Wright and Mark Bright turned it around and we won 3-2…

Yep. I was there. Then sadly I was there again a few days later when the Palace team didn't turn up for a League Cup tie. If I remember rightly a female ran the line. I don't know if that was the first time it ever happened or merely the first time I ever saw it.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

The Dolphin Flag 17 Jan 22 8.07am

I would like to see Jack Butland given the gloves for the rest of the season although I do really like Guaita.
He deserves the chance and if he can get his confidence back could be tops for us for a long time to come!

 

Gary St.Andrews Flag Kenley 17 Jan 22 8.57am

Originally posted by YT

Yep. I was there. Then sadly I was there again a few days later when the Palace team didn't turn up for a League Cup tie. If I remember rightly a female ran the line. I don't know if that was the first time it ever happened or merely the first time I ever saw it.

The game we won 3-2 a certain Alan Shearer with hair was playing for them. We were behind the goal, it was standing at the time and someone threw a load of fake £10 notes in the air with Steve Coppell’s face printed on them.

Edited by Gary St.Andrews (17 Jan 2022 8.57am)

 

Gary St.Andrews Flag Kenley 17 Jan 22 9.53am

Originally posted by The Dolphin

I would like to see Jack Butland given the gloves for the rest of the season although I do really like Guaita.
He deserves the chance and if he can get his confidence back could be tops for us for a long time to come!

I’m with you on this and you have got to hand it to Patrick, he managed Jacks cock up at Millwall perfectly. Would have been easy to put Guaita back in goal, but sticking with Jack has most probably helped his confidence.

Jack was our best player at Brighton, let’s be honest a few years ago he was top 5 keepers in the Country.

 

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 17 Jan 22 9.58am

Me too, really like Guaita, but Jack B. has earned his spot now. And with Liverpool's backs Trent and Robertson pumping in crosses, Butland will deal better with them.

 

Palace Old Geezer Flag Midhurst 17 Jan 22 10.03am

Originally posted by thai-eagle

Me too, really like Guaita, but Jack B. has earned his spot now. And with Liverpool's backs Trent and Robertson pumping in crosses, Butland will deal better with them.

Yep, I'm on board too.

 


Dad and I watched games standing on the muddy slope of the Holmesdale Road end. He cheered and I rattled.

Qwijibo Flag Bournemouth 17 Jan 22 3.46pm

This is probably an impression exaggerated by the disaster against Millwall, but his distribution from his feet seems really poor. Given the two central defenders are encouraged to pass it about, this could end badly.

He did some excellent stuff against Brighton. The disallowed goal was the correct decision, but I can't help feeling he was a little feeble.

 

Uphill Flag Bedford 17 Jan 22 4.01pm

Deservedly in The Times' team of the weekend.

He deserves a regular place if only because he is much more decisive with crosses - previously our biggest defensive weakness.

 


Man and boy Palace since my first game in 1948 sitting on my dad's shoulders

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 17 Jan 22 4.14pm

Prior to the Brighton game, Butland had been responsible for a howler at Millwall and done nothing of note in his other appearances.

Now, one good game later, people want him as No.1.

I'll reserve judgment until after a run of games should he get them.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

dg1937 Flag 17 Jan 22 4.38pm

I think the suggestion that Butland should immediately take over as No.1 keeper is a little premature. My main concern with him is that he looks less comfortable with the ball at his feet than Vicente. Millwall was just an extreme example of this. Playing it out seems to be a central part of Vieira's chosen style (personally, it gives me the heebie geebies every time) and so this is an important consideration. Personally I think we are very lucky to have Jack as our No.2 keeper and he may step up one day (he is 6 or 7 years younger), just not yet.

Incidentally, I don't think playing Jack at Brighton was a master stroke by Vieira, my impression, which could be wrong, is that Vicente hadn't fully trained due to an injury / recovering from Covid.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 18 Jan 22 7.29pm

He just needs game time which hopefully he's going to be getting more of now, McCarthy wasn't given game time with us when we played Hennessey and that was a lovely cock-up at the time ..I blame a certain home game against Liverpool for his demise then, we are fortunate at the moment though for having two excellent keepers.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 18 Jan 22 7.36pm

Originally posted by dg1937

I think the suggestion that Butland should immediately take over as No.1 keeper is a little premature. My main concern with him is that he looks less comfortable with the ball at his feet than Vicente. Millwall was just an extreme example of this. Playing it out seems to be a central part of Vieira's chosen style (personally, it gives me the heebie geebies every time) and so this is an important consideration. Personally I think we are very lucky to have Jack as our No.2 keeper and he may step up one day (he is 6 or 7 years younger), just not yet.

Incidentally, I don't think playing Jack at Brighton was a master stroke by Vieira, my impression, which could be wrong, is that Vicente hadn't fully trained due to an injury / recovering from Covid.

VG hurt his finger from a close range shot recently. I presumed he was recovering from that. I suspected he could play if absolutely necessary, but best to not chance it and use Butland. That was just my reading of the situation.
I think they are very contrasting keepers and each has his strengths and weaknesses. Generally, I think VG has better reflexes, and better footballing skills, Butland is better at dealing with the high ball. Obviously, there's more to it but they're both decent keepers.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Jack Butland