This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
Isn't Islam like that - how are they evolutionary better? I'm not seeing it, although having two parents can often be an advantage, I suspect. I haven't particularly looked into anything. I'm from a single parent family myself, shock horror. The marriage aspect seems like a typical Catholic Church power grab to me, personally. The stats do bear it out. The kind of people who value the church's seal on a marriage are more likely to be more conservative on marriage vows and treat them more seriously than those who view marriage more liberally. Parents staying together statistically improves the chance of the children achieving or even more importantly staying out of trouble. It isn't about intelligence......when I last looked into inheritance on intelligence it seemed to be more affected by the mother's IQ than the father, though how much and how consistently that's the case is hard to say. It's about mental stability and self worth......there are plenty of good single parents and step-parents but we all know that blood makes a difference.....When you look at your own boy/girl you see a distorted version of yourself and your partner....and vice versa for the child and that matters a lot psychologically. Break ups...especially when they aren't handled well, feck up a lot of people. I think a lot of people intrinsically know this and will stay together because of it until the children are old enough to process it and be ok. Then again, that takes two reasonable people. Edited by Stirlingsays (31 May 2021 6.35pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
The stats do bear it out. The kind of people who value the church's seal on a marriage are more likely to be more conservative on marriage vows and treat them more seriously than those who view marriage more liberally. Parents staying together statistically improves the chance of the children achieving or even more importantly staying out of trouble. It isn't about intelligence......when I last looked into inheritance on intelligence it seemed to be more affected by the mother's IQ than the father, though how much and how consistently that's the case is hard to say. It's about mental stability and self worth......there are plenty of good single parents and step-parents but we all know that blood makes a difference.....When you look at your own boy/girl you see a distorted version of yourself and your partner....and vice versa for the child and that matters a lot psychologically. Break ups...especially when they aren't handled well, feck up a lot of people. I think a lot of people intrinsically know this and will stay together because of it until the children are old enough to process it and be ok. Then again, that takes two reasonable people. Edited by Stirlingsays (31 May 2021 6.35pm) I can imagine what you mean. I just tend to look at church weddings as a bit of a throwback. More a personal opinion. I tend to think civil ceremonies, or legal partnerships are just as valid as church weddings. I can imagine where that throws up certain current issues too.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
I can imagine what you mean. I just tend to look at church weddings as a bit of a throwback. More a personal opinion. I tend to think civil ceremonies, or legal partnerships are just as valid as church weddings. I can imagine where that throws up certain current issues too. I suppose I value a church wedding more, but I get your beat. It's really down to how seriously both take the marriage....some people will put up with a lot and others not so much and until you're in that situation who ever really knows. Even if two people are well matched life is going to throw in reasons to bale....because, as we know, life is rarely a party and a series of breezy smiles.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
I can imagine what you mean. I just tend to look at church weddings as a bit of a throwback. More a personal opinion. I tend to think civil ceremonies, or legal partnerships are just as valid as church weddings. I can imagine where that throws up certain current issues too. Any religious 'marriage' is not a throw-back. That is the norm. How humanity evolved. Again, kids who parents were married in Church before they were born are statistically less likely to end up in jail, to misuse drugs, and will grow up into people who make a contribution to society as opposed to being a drag on it. The reason why the West is in so, so much trouble can be traced back to the decline in this acceptance of this as the ideal, a concept to be embraced and celebrated. . If you consider yourself on the Right, I truly cannot understand how you can not be in favour of the traditional family unit as the centre stone of it all. That is the purpose of it. The entire point. And why the Left are hell-bent on destroying it. The more they convince people that it is fine to just have babies when you want and not worry about raising them with two parents, the more we sink into the mire. I guarantee that of those girls who were abused up North, less than 10% came from families where the parents had married in Church and done so before they had them. The family unit protects and nourishes, along with embracing much wider family connections that encourage all kinds of positive behaviour. Of course, we can all quote incidences where single parents are wonderful and families an utter nightmare but those are the exceptions, not the norms. You want to be a true rebel in this day and age then get married in a Church. And be bloody proud of that because you are part of the Resistance.
"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell. |
|
|
The Church of England is 'the tory party at prayer'. And Rt.Hon Justin Welby, doesn't your silence show that all too clearly.
|
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
The Church of England is 'the tory party at prayer'. And Rt.Hon Justin Welby, doesn't your silence show that all too clearly. Did you copy your first line from the bbc article written in 2014?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Matov
Any religious 'marriage' is not a throw-back. That is the norm. How humanity evolved. Again, kids who parents were married in Church before they were born are statistically less likely to end up in jail, to misuse drugs, and will grow up into people who make a contribution to society as opposed to being a drag on it. The reason why the West is in so, so much trouble can be traced back to the decline in this acceptance of this as the ideal, a concept to be embraced and celebrated. . If you consider yourself on the Right, I truly cannot understand how you can not be in favour of the traditional family unit as the centre stone of it all. That is the purpose of it. The entire point. And why the Left are hell-bent on destroying it. The more they convince people that it is fine to just have babies when you want and not worry about raising them with two parents, the more we sink into the mire. I guarantee that of those girls who were abused up North, less than 10% came from families where the parents had married in Church and done so before they had them. The family unit protects and nourishes, along with embracing much wider family connections that encourage all kinds of positive behaviour. Of course, we can all quote incidences where single parents are wonderful and families an utter nightmare but those are the exceptions, not the norms. You want to be a true rebel in this day and age then get married in a Church. And be bloody proud of that because you are part of the Resistance. As much as you're religious, I am an athiest. I tend to believe that human morality was generally mirrored by the church and standardised as a product in the main. Our religious views would not be compatible - although I respect that I shouldn't disrespect your beliefs.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
The Church of England is 'the tory party at prayer'. And Rt.Hon Justin Welby, doesn't your silence show that all too clearly. Best cake sales though.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
As much as you're religious, I am an athiest. I tend to believe that human morality was generally mirrored by the church and standardised as a product in the main. Our religious views would not be compatible - although I respect that I shouldn't disrespect your beliefs. How can an Athiest have 'morals'? The entire point of believing in a diety is an acceptance that there is a higher power than you who defines what is wrong and right i.e morality, which you aspire, and it is a struggle, to uphold/live by But an Athiest can define their own set of rights and wrongs. Surely that is the point of it? An Athiest does not accept the existance of a higher-power and therefore defines their own set of rules.
"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell. |
|
| Tom-the-eagle |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Spiderman
Does anyone actually give a s*** what the Catholic Church thinks? When they openly condemn the abuse of children, who were supposedly in their care, then maybe they can try to take the moral high ground. Pointless thread. I say this as a fellow bast@rd. Horrible word. His kids are not guilty of anything, why label them.
"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit |
|
|
Originally posted by Tom-the-eagle
Pointless thread. I say this as a fellow bast@rd. Horrible word. His kids are not guilty of anything, why label them. Didn’t realise you were a referee Tom, that’s what you meant right?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Matov
How can an Athiest have 'morals'? The entire point of believing in a diety is an acceptance that there is a higher power than you who defines what is wrong and right i.e morality, which you aspire, and it is a struggle, to uphold/live by But an Athiest can define their own set of rights and wrongs. Surely that is the point of it? An Athiest does not accept the existance of a higher-power and therefore defines their own set of rules.
Most societies have a group think view of what is and isn't acceptable. You don't have to be religious to agree that killing and stealing is wrong. Personally I believe that to enforce these rules religion was invented. It is a lot easier to explain to a peasant that "god say don't do this" than to explain about property rights being conducive to the socioeconomic well being of a society. Of course as an atheist I don't agree with some of the so called church morals e.g. you shall worship only one god, that smacks of protectionism and a cartel I'm more a free market guy you can worship who you want or not.
Edited by Badger11 (01 Jun 2021 8.38am)
One more point |
|
|
Agree, its basically a click bait thread started by crown centre post Originally posted by Tom-the-eagle
Pointless thread. I say this as a fellow bast@rd. Horrible word. His kids are not guilty of anything, why label them.
Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance. |
|
|
Originally posted by Matov
How can an Athiest have 'morals'? The entire point of believing in a diety is an acceptance that there is a higher power than you who defines what is wrong and right i.e morality, which you aspire, and it is a struggle, to uphold/live by But an Athiest can define their own set of rights and wrongs. Surely that is the point of it? An Athiest does not accept the existance of a higher-power and therefore defines their own set of rules. I'd agree that Atheism, at its core, isn't morally constrained. Then again, you can be an atheist and agree with most of what Christians think anyway. Indeed, wokism (if we call it that) is a kind of humanist secular replacement for religion because when you look at its adherents they act like they are following holy orders....but like everything else it's very pick and choose, for example, the elevation of equality and egalitarianism is highlighted to extents far beyond its context within Christianity because it fits their idealism....they want the 'sermon on the mount' stuff but not the rest. That said, most religious adherence is pick and choose anyway....I mean look at the Catholic church here, finding excuses to re-marry those two. Everywhere you look in Christianity they pick and choose from abortion to homosexuality to women in the priesthood....and anyone other than fundamentalists have ignored most of the old Testament. I know there is a movement within the dissentient right to move back towards traditionism and I broadly agree with that. That said, I think we need to accept that we can be a broad church as it were and define ourselves by what we reject more than an insistence that we each sign up to what we accept....otherwise it's permanent fragmentation. For example, I'm not religious but I'm pretty strongly against abortion, whereas I know that's not fully agreed with even within the dissentient right. The progressives hold all the reigns of power other than government....and many of their social ideas are accepted and implemented by Tories who capitulated. They censor and persecute those that fight against their progressive ideas (when in the past the right allowed theirs to develop). In my view, we have far bigger issues Edited by Stirlingsays (01 Jun 2021 10.30am)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
Most societies have a group think view of what is and isn't acceptable. You don't have to be religious to agree that killing and stealing is wrong. Personally I believe that to enforce these rules religion was invented. It is a lot easier to explain to a peasant that "god say don't do this" than to explain about property rights being conducive to the socioeconomic well being of a society. Of course as an atheist I don't agree with some of the so called church morals e.g. you shall worship only one god, that smacks of protectionism and a cartel I'm more a free market guy you can worship who you want or not.
Edited by Badger11 (01 Jun 2021 8.38am) Morals are the norms of a society, pretty much to make it work best for everyone and usually laid down on some kind of codification of law. People who don't follow morals are sometimes ostracised. When you consider today, they would be quite hard to fully explain.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
Morals are the norms of a society. Sorry to be pedantic but morals are not the norms of a society. I suspect what you are referring to are more conventions. With those varying widely from nation to nation and even then, differing based on regional differences. Morality can only come from subscribing to a spiritual belief system that promotes the notion that there are universal rights and wrongs that are superior to any kind of man made conventions. But I concede I can be boring about this. If people want to be athiest, then best of British to them but it has to acknowledge that atheism means you get to make up your own rules because there is no higher power in your life. You are effectively your own God. Which is probably its biggest attraction along with being its most dangerous drawback.
"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell. |
|
|
Originally posted by Matov
Sorry to be pedantic but morals are not the norms of a society. I suspect what you are referring to are more conventions. With those varying widely from nation to nation and even then, differing based on regional differences. Morality can only come from subscribing to a spiritual belief system that promotes the notion that there are universal rights and wrongs that are superior to any kind of man made conventions. But I concede I can be boring about this. If people want to be athiest, then best of British to them but it has to acknowledge that atheism means you get to make up your own rules because there is no higher power in your life. You are effectively your own God. Which is probably its biggest attraction along with being its most dangerous drawback.
Matov, I'm not going to get into a big argument about it but a couple of points. Morals are basically what I stated they are. They are the accepted standard behaviour of a society. Now, you would have a big point about Christian values being a big part of our morals and laws, but it's kind of a circular argument as societies often had similar morals before Christ was born. As for Athiests, you have a funny view of them. They are not their own gods, simply they do not believe that God or gods exist or regulate anything. Then it is up to humankind to sort its own issues, not for some kind of higher power to assess or intervene.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
the morality of many old religious books is deeply nasty & vindictive.
Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford |
|
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
If you consider it, atheism may then lead to responsible behaviour, rather than doing what you like and then asking for forgiveness, which is Catholicism's main attraction. I will light a candle and offer up a prayer for your unsaved soul!
"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell. |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.