You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Is Parish ever to blame???
November 16 2026 4.25am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Is Parish ever to blame???


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
lefty27 Flag ipswich 14 Jun 21 3.02pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Not so. There are many billionaires that would love to buy Palace but the sticking point is that Parish wants to continue running the club with a minority share interest too and most billionaires want full control

Edited by Midlands Eagle (14 Jun 2021 2.43pm)

Really? Like who? We already have 2 billionaire owners and a mutual millionaire. What makes you think things would be better under new ownership.
Apart from Man City and Chelsea, who has been taken over and seen the fortunes of their club charge for the better?

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 14 Jun 21 3.44pm

Originally posted by lefty27

Really? Like who? We already have 2 billionaire owners and a mutual millionaire. What makes you think things would be better under new ownership.
Apart from Man City and Chelsea, who has been taken over and seen the fortunes of their club charge for the better?

Leicester, Villa, Wolves

 


Red and Blue Army!

rollercoaster Flag Cornwall 14 Jun 21 4.07pm

It's hard to know how much the Americans interfere with the decision making. It does appear that Palace are very poor at making quick decisions. Is it all down to Parish as the op suggests? I think not, but totally agree that Parish has to take his share of the criticism.

The club need to do a huge amount better from here on or our run in the top league will end next year

 

mrfantasy Flag maidstone 14 Jun 21 4.55pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

The never blame Parish disease has been in existence for many years now on the various Palace sites.
His inexperience was a fair excuse for mistakes in the early days but he has had a long time to understand how football works or employ people who do.

It is fair to say that his record speaks for itself in terms of promotion and keeping us up, but one cannot help but feel that his over careful attitude and occasional naivety has also held us back at times.

If he sorts out the contract issues and signs some quality players this Summer, which keeps us up once again, then he will get my vote going forward.
I would also add that the new stand marathon needs sorting out and soon.

Naivety? Can you quantify this comment? Give us some examples please.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 14 Jun 21 5.34pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

The never blame Parish disease has been in existence for many years now on the various Palace sites.
His inexperience was a fair excuse for mistakes in the early days but he has had a long time to understand how football works or employ people who do.

It is fair to say that his record speaks for itself in terms of promotion and keeping us up, but one cannot help but feel that his over careful attitude and occasional naivety has also held us back at times.

If he sorts out the contract issues and signs some quality players this Summer, which keeps us up once again, then he will get my vote going forward.
I would also add that the new stand marathon needs sorting out and soon.

Its a bit like someone being saved from drowning, then years later as they havent bought you a new house, stabbing them in the back. As without them saving you, you wouldnt have to put up with not getting what you want.
The club is in safe hands with Parish, not going to challenge to win anything, but safe. Wolves spent £214m since promotion, but ended up one point ahead of us last season. Not a great return on investment, but they dont want to win anything either, just develope Mendes clients and sell on at a profit.
The wish for billionaire owners is fanciful, they dont use their own money, just refinance the club and borrow against the assets, which is how Burnley was purchased.
Parish has mede mistales, who hasnt, but I doubt he will lead us into administration, like the previous 2 Chairmen.

 

lefty27 Flag ipswich 14 Jun 21 6.17pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

Leicester, Villa, Wolves

Leicester yes, wolves were a point above us and villa have had one good season. There starting point is also a bit further on than ours all have bigger fan bases and better facilities/ stadiums.
For every Wolves, Villa and Leicester there is a Birmingham, Portsmouth, Coventry city, Wigan, Charlton etc.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 14 Jun 21 6.23pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

Leicester, Villa, Wolves


Leicester - agree. They have that rarity - billionaire owners who seem to care about both the club and its local community.

Villa - currently throwing money at trying to become a big club. Too early to judge the outcome - revisit in 2 or 3 years.

Wolves - Really? Let's see how they fare now Nuno's gone and once we have a clearer picture of what Mendes's future role in that club will be, if any. I can see Wolves making a return to the Championship in the not too distant future despite the £200m spent on getting into the PL and trying to stay there.

 

OldFella Flag London 14 Jun 21 6.57pm

Originally posted by Painter



Its a bit like someone being saved from drowning, then years later as they havent bought you a new house, stabbing them in the back.
As without them saving you, you wouldnt have to put up with not getting what you want.
The club is in safe hands with Parish, not going to challenge to win anything, but safe. Wolves spent £214m since promotion, but ended up one point ahead of us last season. Not a great return on investment, but they dont want to win anything either, just develope Mendes clients and sell on at a profit.
The wish for billionaire owners is fanciful, they dont use their own money, just refinance the club and borrow against the assets, which is how Burnley was purchased.
Parish has mede mistales, who hasnt, but I doubt he will lead us into administration, like the previous 2 Chairmen.

What a soppy analogy - but sort of predictable and expected, from one of HOL's leading sycophants

 


Jackson.. Wan Bissaka.... Sansom.. Nicholas.. Cannon.. Guehi.... Zaha... Thomas.. Byrne... Holton.. Rogers.. that should do it..

Midlands Eagle Flag 14 Jun 21 7.23pm

Originally posted by doombear

Wolves - Really? Let's see how they fare now Nuno's gone and once we have a clearer picture of what Mendes's future role in that club will be, if any. I can see Wolves making a return to the Championship in the not too distant future

Oddly enough most pundits are saying that about us with no manager, half the squad out of contract, our best player wants out and our second best player injured until the new year

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 14 Jun 21 8.23pm

Originally posted by Painter

Its a bit like someone being saved from drowning, then years later as they havent bought you a new house, stabbing them in the back. As without them saving you, you wouldnt have to put up with not getting what you want.
The club is in safe hands with Parish, not going to challenge to win anything, but safe. Wolves spent £214m since promotion, but ended up one point ahead of us last season. Not a great return on investment, but they dont want to win anything either, just develope Mendes clients and sell on at a profit.
The wish for billionaire owners is fanciful, they dont use their own money, just refinance the club and borrow against the assets, which is how Burnley was purchased.
Parish has mede mistales, who hasnt, but I doubt he will lead us into administration, like the previous 2 Chairmen.

I'm not sure that it's a bit like anything of the sort.

The buck stops with Parish however you rate him. He can't continue to live on past success when making new mistakes, but neither should he be judged unfairly as the chairman of a medium sized club.

It is not easy to take giant leaps without giant cash.

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 14 Jun 21 9.02pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

Leicester, Villa, Wolves

Apart from leicester, villa ,wolves, roads, drainage, buildings, Bath houses what have the romans ever done for us

 

deleted 25 Flag 14 Jun 21 9.06pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

Depends who you benchmark him against. We've certainly done a better job in terms of managers than Watford and Brighton who are the best two sides to draw a direct comparison with. Numerous others have fallen by the wayside since 2010 when we were 40th in the league system and unsustainable, now we are consistently around 15th pretty solid.

At the time all appointments on paper were fairly sensible. Warnock and Hodgson were both put in with mitigating circumstance. Holloway and Pardew get the most criticism but were both poached from clubs higher in the league and delivered relative success.

With the 13 players out of contract. Henderson, Wickham, Woods, Hennessey are surplus to requirements. 7 out of the remaining 9 are over 30 and none are vital 1st team players. Personally, I wouldn't bother renewing PVA's contract with Mitchell and Reidewald able to play in his position. It's unlikely Ward/Clyne will leave unless a replacement is signed so right back is covered. I think Schlupp and Townsend will sign new deals.

That brings the total down to 4. McCarthy has looked tidy but always injured - no big issue. Sakho/Dann/Cahill aren't all required - no need to panic.

I'd say that possibly that having 4 owners is/was as much a help as a hindrance. One thing for certain is that Parish takes on board fans POV- and probably why we are now managerless is because fans were fed up with Roy's MO.

Parish is probably as much a business man as a football man, and that is no bad thing.

 

Palace 1979 Flag Surrey 14 Jun 21 9.14pm

He is the best chairman we have had since I started supporting the team in the late 70s. I cannot think of anyone else who has come close...

He could always do some things better, but he will not let our club be held to ransom by any player or manager and that's not easy to do in a world where everyone wants everything now.

Glazier, please tell me who you think has done a better job than Parish as I find your thread an easy dig with no thought for where the club has come from and the restrictions we have in place to ensure we do not end up going down that horrible road again. I suggest you watch the recent Amazon documentary to jog your memory.

 


Some people are like Slinkies … not really good for anything, but you can’t help smiling when you see one tumble down the stairs.

deleted 25 Flag 14 Jun 21 9.33pm

Originally posted by Palace 1979

He is the best chairman we have had since I started supporting the team in the late 70s. I cannot think of anyone else who has come close...

He could always do some things better, but he will not let our club be held to ransom by any player or manager and that's not easy to do in a world where everyone wants everything now.

Glazier, please tell me who you think has done a better job than Parish as I find your thread an easy dig with no thought for where the club has come from and the restrictions we have in place to ensure we do not end up going down that horrible road again. I suggest you watch the recent Amazon documentary to jog your memory.

Well said. Thread closed.

 

Elphers40 Flag Sunny South Coast 14 Jun 21 10.33pm

Originally posted by Palace 1979

He is the best chairman we have had since I started supporting the team in the late 70s. I cannot think of anyone else who has come close...

He could always do some things better, but he will not let our club be held to ransom by any player or manager and that's not easy to do in a world where everyone wants everything now.

Glazier, please tell me who you think has done a better job than Parish as I find your thread an easy dig with no thought for where the club has come from and the restrictions we have in place to ensure we do not end up going down that horrible road again. I suggest you watch the recent Amazon documentary to jog your memory.

Spot on.

He is not perfect but he has done a pretty good job thus far. Okay, I’m as impatient as the next man for a new manager announcement but I don’t want the quick announcement of a sh1t one. Take our time and get it right - and tbf his previous appointments have earned him the benefit of my doubt.

I’ll happily moan about him when he screws up and gets it wrong - but in 40 odd years I can’t think of a better chairman than SP. (okay I also accept some may suggest that’s because the others were dire)!

 

Elwissthebest Flag Marlborough 15 Jun 21 11.46am

Originally posted by cryrst

Apart from leicester, villa ,wolves, roads, drainage, buildings, Bath houses what have the romans ever done for us

Spot on. Took the words right out of my mouth. SP is a businessman. Reading some of the posts on this topic, you'd think he ran Palace as a charity.

In many ways, Palace overachieves, given the economic fundamentals. My point was simply that if Palace is to reach the 'next level', it needs more investment than the current incumbent seems able to provide. He runs a financially tight ship and has probably taken the club as far as he can. But can we stop all this 'local boy made good' twaddle? There's little room for sentiment in the game at this level and emotion can as often cloud the judgement as enhance it. Leicester supporters don't seem too bothered by the Chairman's being moneyed and not particularly local...

 

midlandspalace Flag kidderminster 15 Jun 21 2.16pm

Can you define what you mean by "the next level", and "significant investment"? At the moment we have spent many seasons in the third of what I see as four groups in the Prem. (i) Champions League certainties and possibles (ii) Top half, challenging for Europa League spots (iii) Top of the bottom half (iv) Relegation scrappers.

There has been little sustained change in these groups over the time we have been in the Prem. Arsenal and Spurs have occasionally slipped (last season) from group (i) to group (ii). Some clubs have an occasional good season (West Ham, Burnley, Southampton) and finish 7th. Wolves and Everton have both spent £200 million without moving out of group (ii). Most promoted clubs are in group (iv), with the occasional one like Leeds last season doing better. The only team that has moved up and stayed there is Leicester.

We have spent most of our seasons in group (iii). I am one of those awful people who feel that is success and would happily stay in that group forever. What would the fans of Charlton, Wigan, Sunderland, Portsmouth etc etc give to be where we are.

Who is there out there who will provide "significant investment (more than £200 million) to have a chance of reaching group (ii)?

 

Elwissthebest Flag Marlborough 15 Jun 21 4.32pm

If I may say so, you make a very good case and ask a fair question. To put the matter in context, the original poster asked whether supporters could expect more of the owners of the club and that is not a question that should somehow be thought to be in bad taste.
In order to move from 'group three' as you put it (where we are now) to 'group two' doubtless involves more expenditure than the present owners are able or prepared to make. If we had an exceptional scouting set-up (Bayer Leverkusen!) we might manage it, or given the pool of talent there must be in the South London hinterland, the necessary talent to make the progress might come from the Academy to which Steve Parish has certainly paid much attention. But there's not much point in having a vibrant Academy unless you have a manager who believes in giving young talent a chance- and the last manager didn't obviously.
That so much about the Premiership and what supporters might expect from their team is economically determined is something I have long argued on this site. By what means is it possible to break out of the dreary predictability of that scenario? Your comments make the point beautifully (Newcastle should do better than it does).
So it may well be that no Chairman could do more with the club than Steve Parish does. There are other aspects of the business besides how much money is put into the club- our transfer business is exceptionally unexciting and excruciatingly protracted and we have a problem that the Chairman and Director of Football buy players that the manager may or may not play. Apart from that and the need to improve the ground (not for the want of Steve Parish's trying), fine.
If you pay £2m you get a player like Jordan Ayew. Eze, at £15-20m. looks good business. Liverpool seems to be able to get us to pay top whack by our standards) for players it deems surplus to requirements (less so Kelly).The mixed successes, at best, of Sakho and Benteke don't obviously suggest that when more than £20m is spent on a player, improvement follows.
Where we differ is that I'd actually prefer the yoyo of promotion and relegation to the 'devil's compact' that we can stay forever in the lower reaches of the Premiership as long as we play the sort of football we played last season. But I know that's a heresy.


Edited by Elwissthebest (15 Jun 2021 4.33pm)

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 15 Jun 21 5.07pm

Originally posted by Elwissthebest

If I may say so, you make a very good case and ask a fair question. To put the matter in context, the original poster asked whether supporters could expect more of the owners of the club and that is not a question that should somehow be thought to be in bad taste.
In order to move from 'group three' as you put it (where we are now) to 'group two' doubtless involves more expenditure than the present owners are able or prepared to make. If we had an exceptional scouting set-up (Bayer Leverkusen!) we might manage it,

I don't know what you call exceptional but according to an article in Evening Standard five years ago we beefed up our scouting to match that of West Ham and Southampton.

"Crystal Palace have strengthened their scouting network in a bid to emulate the success of the likes of West Ham and Southampton in the transfer market.

Palace have hired scouts to work in Belgium, France and Spain as part of improvements to their recruitment department as chairman Steve Parish looks to move for players from abroad this summer."

 

Elwissthebest Flag Marlborough 15 Jun 21 5.54pm

This happened five years ago, you say?
Not obviously productive.
As for West Ham, I didn't realise they had a scouting network. I thought they waited for us to show interest in a player and then bought him (Cresswell, Bowen, Benrahma).

 

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Is Parish ever to blame???