You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Southgate (Hodgson Lite) on his way
November 16 2026 4.25am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Southgate (Hodgson Lite) on his way


Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 20 Jun 21 12.52pm

Originally posted by Mstrobez

So did Roy, at both Palace and England. But caricatures of him means he never got the credit for it.


Exactly, but there's none so blind as those who won't see and there seem to be a few of those on HOL.

 

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 20 Jun 21 1.00pm

Originally posted by sickboy

Carlton palmer , Tyrone mings ,plus many others.
Being mediocre doesn't stop you getting England caps.

I’m not sure what Mings has done to warrant that. I think he has been one of our better players so far, although the benchmark is very low as usual

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 20 Jun 21 1.18pm

Originally posted by Bexley Eagle

I’m not sure what Mings has done to warrant that. I think he has been one of our better players so far, although the benchmark is very low as usual

Credit to Mings who used to play for Yate Town and Chippenham before joining the professional ranks at Ipswich.It was Russell Osman who recommended Mings to Ipswich when Mings was at Chippenham.
Mick McCarthy signed him for Ipswich.
Mings has worked as a barman and a mortgage advisor.

 

Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 20 Jun 21 2.10pm

Southgate has a plethora of quality attacking options available to him and should be playing to England's strengths (i.e. attacking). We have the type of squad which should be winning games 4-2 rather than 1-0.

Whenever we have come up against quality opposition, he has been found wanting. He's done a great job of building moral and getting the feel good factor back to the national team and getting the media on their side, but truthfully he doesn't have the tactical naus to manage in the Premier League.

As others have said, he's not fit to tie Roy's bootlaces when it comes to management.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 20 Jun 21 2.26pm

Originally posted by Goal Machine

Southgate has a plethora of quality attacking options available to him and should be playing to England's strengths (i.e. attacking). We have the type of squad which should be winning games 4-2 rather than 1-0.

Whenever we have come up against quality opposition, he has been found wanting. He's done a great job of building moral and getting the feel good factor back to the national team and getting the media on their side, but truthfully he doesn't have the tactical naus to manage in the Premier League.

As others have said, he's not fit to tie Roy's bootlaces when it comes to management.

He has not had much experience managing at the top level in club football.

Compare his club management experience with that of managers of some of the top nations before they were appointed to their current job.
Deschamps was a manager for some 11 years before taking the France job, managing clubs like Monaco,Juventus and Marseille.
Low won leagues and cups and had about 11 years experience before being appointed manager of Germany.
Mancini had been a manager for 17 years with PL and Serie A clubs, winning leagues and cups.

 

Speronilover69 8=D~~ Flag Horsham 20 Jun 21 2.28pm

Please no!

 

sickboy Flag Deal or Croydon 20 Jun 21 3.28pm

Originally posted by doombear


Southgate won 57 England caps over a 9 year period. You don't achieve that if you are a mediocre player.

And Matt Le Tissier had how many?
Far from mediocre.
Southgate was no more than average, but his face fit and was a good steady pro, hence the amount of caps.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 20 Jun 21 3.52pm

Originally posted by Goal Machine

Southgate has a plethora of quality attacking options available to him and should be playing to England's strengths (i.e. attacking). We have the type of squad which should be winning games 4-2 rather than 1-0.

Whenever we have come up against quality opposition, he has been found wanting. He's done a great job of building moral and getting the feel good factor back to the national team and getting the media on their side, but truthfully he doesn't have the tactical naus to manage in the Premier League.

As others have said, he's not fit to tie Roy's bootlaces when it comes to management.

Why on earth would we be seeking to win group stage games 4 - 2?

England have to drag 25 fatigued players through 7 tough matches. The method must be don't concede don't get injured steer the easiest course and progress as far as you can.

Portugal gave the impression of being hopeless in the group stage of the last euros...

 

Helmet46 Flag Croydon 20 Jun 21 4.45pm

Originally posted by silvertop

Why on earth would we be seeking to win group stage games 4 - 2?

England have to drag 25 fatigued players through 7 tough matches. The method must be don't concede don't get injured steer the easiest course and progress as far as you can.

Portugal gave the impression of being hopeless in the group stage of the last euros...

Each to their own, but it’s the third group game where you can consider that sort of tactics once you have the points tucked away. There is no way they were trying to be clever against Scotland.
I’ve worked with a lot of players (albeit at a lower level) and the one thing they all have in common is the absolute desire to win - not the desire to draw, take it easy etc.

It’s harder, causes more fatigue and risks more injuries trying to get good attacking players to play as Southgate wants them to, rather than play their natural game. Zaha, for example, is more likely to get injured/frustrated/carded trying to defend.

If you play silly games in match 2 - trying to be clever etc, you can get caught out and then you have to really go for it in game 3 and that’s where you’ll get the injuries, risk the cards etc as you’ll need to play your best team to ensure qualification. Too much pressure, too much hype and that causes angst, panic and ultimately aggression as the clock counts down. If they were Southgates tactics he’s a lot more inept than I game him credit for and I didn’t think that was possible.

Edited by Helmet46 (20 Jun 2021 5.25pm)

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 20 Jun 21 4.47pm

Originally posted by Willo

He has not had much experience managing at the top level in club football.

Compare his club management experience with that of managers of some of the top nations before they were appointed to their current job.
Deschamps was a manager for some 11 years before taking the France job, managing clubs like Monaco,Juventus and Marseille.
Low won leagues and cups and had about 11 years experience before being appointed manager of Germany.
Mancini had been a manager for 17 years with PL and Serie A clubs, winning leagues and cups.

All very well n good, BUT, we are discussing Southgate & the England managers job/position. We are concerned with what 'Johnny foriegner' manager does for his team/club/country, unless of course he happens to either managed or signed to manager our club.

IF, one of those managers you mention & there are others, were to become a Palace manager, then, yes, I'd love to read their stats.

C'mon Wales(tonight), c'mon England(tuesday) & more importantly in the Concacaf, c'mon Bermuda.

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 20 Jun 21 5.53pm

Originally posted by silvertop

Why on earth would we be seeking to win group stage games 4 - 2?

England have to drag 25 fatigued players through 7 tough matches. The method must be don't concede don't get injured steer the easiest course and progress as far as you can.

Portugal gave the impression of being hopeless in the group stage of the last euros...

We’ll, because as I explained, that’s the strength of the squad. We have so many attacking threats we should be out scoring our opposition not trying to out defend them. Defensive tactics breeds such negativity and turns fans and media against them. Playing both Rice and Phillips with Grealish on the bench pretty much sums it up.

If we had quality defenders and crap strikers, I’d agree with you.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 20 Jun 21 6.05pm

Originally posted by Helmet46

Each to their own, but it’s the third group game where you can consider that sort of tactics once you have the points tucked away. There is no way they were trying to be clever against Scotland.
I’ve worked with a lot of players (albeit at a lower level) and the one thing they all have in common is the absolute desire to win - not the desire to draw, take it easy etc.

It’s harder, causes more fatigue and risks more injuries trying to get good attacking players to play as Southgate wants them to, rather than play their natural game. Zaha, for example, is more likely to get injured/frustrated/carded trying to defend.

If you play silly games in match 2 - trying to be clever etc, you can get caught out and then you have to really go for it in game 3 and that’s where you’ll get the injuries, risk the cards etc as you’ll need to play your best team to ensure qualification. Too much pressure, too much hype and that causes angst, panic and ultimately aggression as the clock counts down. If they were Southgates tactics he’s a lot more inept than I game him credit for and I didn’t think that was possible.

Edited by Helmet46 (20 Jun 2021 5.25pm)

Sure there are risks but 2nd place with no injuries or much effort is job done.

The only negative is fodens card.

 

Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 20 Jun 21 6.14pm

Originally posted by silvertop

Sure there are risks but 2nd place with no injuries or much effort is job done.

The only negative is fodens card.

Not sure I subscribe to the idea of trying to finish second to get in the easiest side of the draw. It always bites you in the arse.

You’ve got to beat the best to be the best and I’d rather we took momentum and confidence into round two rather than limping over the line. We have enough depth in every position to go 100% in every game.

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 20 Jun 21 6.24pm

Originally posted by silvertop

Sure there are risks but 2nd place with no injuries or much effort is job done.

The only negative is fodens card.

Gets wiped out after the next & last group game, providing he stays clear of another one, if picked to play.

Bit like Wales, their 3 players who are on a yellow, were omitted from todays squad, so they are 'free' in the knockout stages, which, btw, is looking ok for them.

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 20 Jun 21 6.34pm

Originally posted by silvertop

Sure there are risks but 2nd place with no injuries or much effort is job done.

The only negative is fodens card.

I don't quite think it's the only negative. There were plenty of others, so glaringly obvious I can't even be bothered to mention them.

 


Red and Blue Army!

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 20 Jun 21 7.31pm

Southgate was chosen by Venables primarily because he had great football intelligence. He was totally inexperienced when he got the Boro job and he has clearly learnt from his mistakes - you can't just take for granted the three at the back system he employed leading up to the last World Cup and how successful it was. I had big doubts before the Croatia game and Southgate rammed it all back down our throats - totally vindicated. You can argue that he should have started Grealish last game and not played Trippier on the left but professor hindsight is always right - it's never that straightforward. Generally I'd say for Palace fans to turn their nose up at Southgate is a serious case of delusions of grandeur - it would be an amazing appointment, but this is very hypothetical.

 

PatrickA Flag London 20 Jun 21 8.08pm

Southgate is in the ideal job.
Part of the blazer brigade at the FA, loves a soundbite, will champion whatever the latest PC fad is and happier talking about e.g ‘emotional intelligence’ rather than football tactics.
The FA are very comfortable with him, apparently assuring him he will stay in the job even if England flop at the Euros.
Keep him as far way from managing Palace as possible.
Despite being highly intelligent Hodgson used to steer well clear from discussing non- football matters .
Southgate on the other hand gives the impression of wanting to discuss anything other than football.
With Southgate I’m reminded of the old saying - better to be thought a fool rather than to open your mouth and confirm it.

 

Helmet46 Flag Croydon 20 Jun 21 8.39pm

Originally posted by ex hibitionist

Southgate was chosen by Venables primarily because he had great football intelligence. He was totally inexperienced when he got the Boro job and he has clearly learnt from his mistakes - you can't just take for granted the three at the back system he employed leading up to the last World Cup and how successful it was. I had big doubts before the Croatia game and Southgate rammed it all back down our throats - totally vindicated. You can argue that he should have started Grealish last game and not played Trippier on the left but professor hindsight is always right - it's never that straightforward. Generally I'd say for Palace fans to turn their nose up at Southgate is a serious case of delusions of grandeur - it would be an amazing appointment, but this is very hypothetical.

I have no delusions of grandeur, thanks. I just don’t think he’s a very good manager, at any level. I actually think he’s a very poor manager.

It’s not hindsight if you see his selection and his tactics and, before a ball is even kicked, consider it poor decision making. Hindsight says ‘he should have done that….’ after the event.
A number of us here were saying “what is he doing and why has he done that” an hour before the game. That’s not hindsight, that’s confusion, disbelief.
Had we won some might have said ‘with hindsight not playing your best players was a great idea.’ Some would have said he got lucky. Hindsight works both ways.

We are all entitled to our opinion and, for me, it would be a shocking appointment and I’m glad it’s hypothetical and hope it never becomes reality.


Edited by Helmet46 (21 Jun 2021 6.55am)

 

AuntyAnne70 Flag Tunbridge WElls 20 Jun 21 10.43pm

Originally posted by sickboy

And Matt Le Tissier had how many?
Far from mediocre.
Southgate was no more than average, but his face fit and was a good steady pro, hence the amount of caps.

You do not play for your country 57 times if you are mediocre!

 

sickboy Flag Deal or Croydon 21 Jun 21 5.36am

Originally posted by AuntyAnne70

You do not play for your country 57 times if you are mediocre!

Southgate did.

 

Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Southgate (Hodgson Lite) on his way