This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Spot on The only point I'd add is that they're all solid pros to have around to bed the newbies in. I'd worry a bit about the squad dynamic with loads of new faces all at once. Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
I'd extend their contracts because we don't want to have too many gaps in the squad to fill in one go. If the club can sign better players this summer, and enough of them to populate the squad not just the team, then fine, let all the out of contract players go, but I struggle with the idea that we can bring in that many new players who are that good all at once. It's the old chestnut - there is a world of difference between releasing a player and replacing him.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Pierre
I think you will find that as those players are not top of any other clubs shopping lists. There's logic to what you say here, but let's say we do end up needing the three players, even if only as squad members... Even if they somehow get to the requisite level of fitness without being part of the squad in preseason, we run the risk of the three players firstly feeling very undervalued by Palace, and secondly being seen to be a last resort by the rest of the squad. We need to refresh the squad, but managing the change well is vital. Three senior players who seem to have a good attitude are not to be undervalued. Cahill has done it all, Townsend has been around the block, and Ward knows the club and its modern history inside out. I wouldn't throw that away lightly. Even if we can sign seven or eight new players this summer (and I doubt that very much), the new players would benefit from coming into a stable and professional environment with the right senior players around. Edited by TheBigToePunt (11 Jul 2021 7.00pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Tom-the-eagle
Pretty much this mate. Plus when Ward goes, it would be nice to give him a bit of a send off. He’s been a good servant. Edited by Tom-the-eagle (11 Jul 2021 3.28pm) Yes indeed; and is not Cahill still younger than the Italian CBs?
|
|
|
Originally posted by silvertop
Yes indeed; and is not Cahill still younger than the Italian CBs? Cahill is younger than Chiellini but older than Bonucci. Edited by Willo (12 Jul 2021 10.01am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Omph
That we have just cancelled out first preseason friendly - probably on the basis that we don't have a team to put out - says quite a lot. Cahill Townsend and Ward are obviously temporary but all have acres of experience and would be reassuring squad members. Quite a lot to be said for having solid experience to fall back on and let's face it there will be times in the season when we will are likely down to bare bones and that's when it will be reassuring to one of these guys fit in The start of the PL is only a month away. The 'Optics' don't look good.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Omph
That we have just cancelled out first preseason friendly - probably on the basis that we don't have a team to put out - says quite a lot. Cahill Townsend and Ward are obviously temporary but all have acres of experience and would be reassuring squad members. Quite a lot to be said for having solid experience to fall back on and let's face it there will be times in the season when we will are likely down to bare bones and that's when it will be reassuring to one of these guys fit in The excuse was we had picked up injuries. That may be at least part of the truth. But let’s face it, we barely have a team at the moment anyway, If the developers are that far forward, to consider viable for first team action, why couldn’t some of them have a run out against Pompey, ? it would seem they are not that far forward. So that doesn’t look so good. And the over riding fact remains that with just weeks to go we have some major vacancies to fill. And one has to ask , even if we get a number of replacements in will they be up to speed for the start of the new season?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Putitout
The excuse was we had picked up injuries. That may be at least part of the truth. But let’s face it, we barely have a team at the moment anyway, If the developers are that far forward, to consider viable for first team action, why couldn’t some of them have a run out against Pompey, ? it would seem they are not that far forward. So that doesn’t look so good. And the over riding fact remains that with just weeks to go we have some major vacancies to fill. And one has to ask , even if we get a number of replacements in will they be up to speed for the start of the new season? Probably pick up an injury as soon as they turn into Copers Cope Road.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Omph
That we have just cancelled out first preseason friendly - probably on the basis that we don't have a team to put out - says quite a lot. Cahill Townsend and Ward are obviously temporary but all have acres of experience and would be reassuring squad members. Quite a lot to be said for having solid experience to fall back on and let's face it there will be times in the season when we will are likely down to bare bones and that's when it will be reassuring to one of these guys fit in
We have no senior right back and no timescale for 2 youngsters to return from injury so in my mind we should offer short term contracts to both Ward and Clyne on reduced terms. However if we are going for wing backs Ward is not fast enough. Again with Cahill how would he work in a back 3 if that is the PV way. However as we have a shortage of CD I think if he gets on with PV a role as a player coach may be suitable while he does his licences. Townsend I am not sure he is a solid squad player but would he accept squad player wages? I don't think that offering these contracts will prevent youngsters coming through as RB both are injured and CD we can buy/promote at least 2 and have a
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.