This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by sprites
Just watched some highlights. Seems like a decent player to have in the squad. Not sure he gets in the 11 above what we currently have...but like I say, worth having at a decent price. May not be an instant selection but if you take ease on the ball as a prerequisite in a PV midfield then I suspect he could work his way in pretty quickly if he is the player I think he is. This may come from having seen them in a RH side but Schlupp, Luca and Jimmy Mc all feel as if they might be quite an awkward fit in a midfield that was receiving the ball from the back and having to press more and work their way upfield to support the attack - especially if there is only room for one sitting mid.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Omph
May not be an instant selection but if you take ease on the ball as a prerequisite in a PV midfield then I suspect he could work his way in pretty quickly if he is the player I think he is. This may come from having seen them in a RH side but Schlupp, Luca and Jimmy Mc all feel as if they might be quite an awkward fit in a midfield that was receiving the ball from the back and having to press more and work their way upfield to support the attack - especially if there is only room for one sitting mid. Potentially. Although Macca is much better on the ball than given credit for. People just see him as a workhorse. I agree about Luka though. My admiration for him is well documented on here, but he's not quick and he may struggle to keep up. We'll see.
|
|
|
Originally posted by sprites
Potentially. Although Macca is much better on the ball than given credit for. People just see him as a workhorse. I agree about Luka though. My admiration for him is well documented on here, but he's not quick and he may struggle to keep up. We'll see. True - I am quite probably misunderestimating Macca - he's a baller really and not what I think of as a "hot potato player' - and maybe he's one that is more genuinely pleased by PV approach and release from the shackles of Roy Ball.
|
|
|
Originally posted by slubglurge
Macca's engine is showing signs of wear and tear and he can only do about an hour these days plus he has alway chipped in with a few goals and tellingly he didn't find the net once last season. Hughes is younger good on the ball and can put a foot in too. At the right price would be a good signing Fair point on the engine and likely 60 + mins optimum pitch time. Not sure that least season is a guide though. Not a sufficiently expert viewer to reason this out fully but it felt to me that after the early season splurge where we were tolerably front foot the midfield was around 5 paces behind or so from what you'd expect. Everyone more or less stationed as they were historically but just that telling bit further off goal. My hypothesis was that Eze pushed everyone else back a bit. partly perhaps because there was a need to cover more in defence for him but also because he was notably our best option going forward - discounting Wilf of course. The other factor possibly being we were fielding 4th and 5th choices at CB almost the whole season and we were sitting back more to give extra cover there. It just felt to my non-expert eye that we became a slight parody of ourselves as a Roy team last time out.
Edited by Omph (05 Aug 2021 10.02am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by slubglurge
Macca's engine is showing signs of wear and tear and he can only do about an hour these days plus he has alway chipped in with a few goals and tellingly he didn't find the net once last season. Hughes is younger good on the ball and can put a foot in too. At the right price would be a good signing Macca injured quite a lot. Not sure he is match fit today.
|
|
| palace99 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by sprites
Potentially. Although Macca is much better on the ball than given credit for. People just see him as a workhorse. I agree about Luka though. My admiration for him is well documented on here, but he's not quick and he may struggle to keep up. We'll see. you've changed your tune very quickly. Only a couple of days ago you were saying we didn't need another centre mid player and now you are all over Hughes. IMHO this will not happen - his agent is just trying to get the best new contract for his client. If he has been offered £50k by Watford we won't be offering much more.
|
|
|
Will Hughes being linked to us is doing the rounds again today. Wouldn’t be a bad signing in my book.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Mathers
Would be a very good signing. Knows the league well and would fit seamlessly into our midfield. Not likely to score many but his passing and tackling stats are decent. Definite Macca replacement Hopefully addition not relacement, we are short of experienced options in midfield
|
|
|
A good championship standard player.
|
|
|
Originally posted by BelfastEagle
A good championship standard player. A couple of levels above Riedewald so!
|
|
|
Would rather have Johnny Williams (he’s just signed for Swindon)
Raised on a diet of broken biscuits |
|
|
Originally posted by Leecpfc
Would rather have Johnny Williams (he’s just signed for Swindon)
|
|
|
And a real shame, a Palace boy through and through. The very best of luck to him.
Bring back Brolin |
|
|
Originally posted by EddieMac
A couple of levels above Riedewald so! I cannot understand how a player coached at Ajax can run around like a headless chicken for the best part of 90 mins. Just not a midfield player but where else I honestly don’t know. Love to see him change but .....
Bring back Brolin |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.