You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace vs. Watford match thread
November 16 2026 4.26am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Palace vs. Watford match thread


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
CT Charlie Flag 07 Aug 21 5.14pm

Waterford lacked enthusiasm, and we played with energy. Our defense looked formless and suspect, but our attack was lively, making good use of space and actually completing passes around the box. Midfield showed more effort, promise, and commitment than they ever did last season. Despite being only a friendly, it gave me hope.

Based on this, good teams will slice & dice our defense early in the season. The midfield, though, will not be nearly as porous as last season, and it will create some chances via pressing and alert passing that we haven't seen in a while.

If supporters can accept a rough start, by October we should see a team that will be competitive and fun to watch.

 

Rogers Don Flag Horsham 07 Aug 21 5.29pm

Jimmy was the best player on the pitch
We don't need Luka. Watford looked like they should still be in the Championship.

 


Let's keep the ball this season!

Spiderman Flag Horsham 07 Aug 21 6.19pm

Originally posted by CT Charlie

Waterford lacked enthusiasm, and we played with energy. Our defense looked formless and suspect, but our attack was lively, making good use of space and actually completing passes around the box. Midfield showed more effort, promise, and commitment than they ever did last season. Despite being only a friendly, it gave me hope.

Based on this, good teams will slice & dice our defense early in the season. The midfield, though, will not be nearly as porous as last season, and it will create some chances via pressing and alert passing that we haven't seen in a while.

If supporters can accept a rough start, by October we should see a team that will be competitive and fun to watch.

Having been at the game not sure I cannot agree with your assessment of the defence. One or two hairy moments but looked in control

 

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 07 Aug 21 6.24pm

Anyone know how bad Mitchell’s injury is. He went down after making a clearance and didn’t look like there was any contact with the Watford player? It would be a disaster for us if he is out for any length of time as I thought he was really looking the part today

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 07 Aug 21 6.33pm

Originally posted by Bexley Eagle

Anyone know how bad Mitchell’s injury is. He went down after making a clearance and didn’t look like there was any contact with the Watford player? It would be a disaster for us if he is out for any length of time as I thought he was really looking the part today

He walked off ok. Could be cramp as he had just completed one of his many runs forward, here’s hoping

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 07 Aug 21 6.35pm

Must say Watford were very poor, thought with a new manager they would cut out the nasty stuff but they most certainly haven’t. They love having a go at the Achilles area , but only after the ball has gone. Ref had a shocker

 

Elwissthebest Flag Marlborough 07 Aug 21 6.38pm

Regarding the comments about our defence, I'm a bit nonplussed by Tomkins' omission. For me, he's still our best centre back, although I accept he is very injury prone. Guehi and Andersen might prove to be better in the long run, and I hope they do, but neither is anywhere near the finished article yet.

 

Gribbo Flag Bromley 07 Aug 21 7.13pm

Watford really are a poor side. Heading straight back down, probably with fewer than 20 points.

 

inflikted Flag 07 Aug 21 7.18pm

Wonder how many of the academy kids will be featuring against Chelsea next week. Kirby's been absent, not sure if due to injury or just not part of the plans right now. Especially with Palace reportedly looking at Ronaldo Vieira. But I do want Kirby to succeed, not just cos he's definitely a talent, but also cos his name would open so many opportunities for sponsorships with Nintendo.

In other news I've heard that Chelsea have arranged a friendly against Weymouth the day after they play us, and that some of the players who have just returned from extended post-Euros breaks will feature in that game. So likely that Chilwell, Mount and co will not feature on the opening day.

 


Milkshakes Against Fascism

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 07 Aug 21 7.27pm

We are still lacking need another striker and a winger. (even if loaning from abroad which we can do)

Positives are it does look like just based of a few of these pre season games we are going to use players strengths not play a system that expects anybody dropped in to change their natural game (this is what annoyed me about Roy his tactics can work but you need to change it for the players playing not putting in crosses etc made no sense with a guy like Benteke)

Still worried how bad we are at defending the likes of corners this showed under Roy last few seasons it needs fixing the same with use putting in better quality when we are having these other end

 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

Omph Flag Liverpool 07 Aug 21 7.59pm

Didn't get to see it but if PV is going to be pragmatic and work around players strengths and weaknesses I feel at least 100% more optimistic.

From everything I've read passing out from the back is a non-negotiable under him but that can be fine if he adapts elsewhere.


Originally posted by grumpymort

We are still lacking need another striker and a winger. (even if loaning from abroad which we can do)

Positives are it does look like just based of a few of these pre season games we are going to use players strengths not play a system that expects anybody dropped in to change their natural game (this is what annoyed me about Roy his tactics can work but you need to change it for the players playing not putting in crosses etc made no sense with a guy like Benteke)

Still worried how bad we are at defending the likes of corners this showed under Roy last few seasons it needs fixing the same with use putting in better quality when we are having these other end

 

Daddyorc Flag Atlantic Highlands, NJ 07 Aug 21 8.00pm

Other than 10 minutes toward the end of the first half, we looked pretty much in control.

Ratings:

Ward - 6, perhaps could have been closer to Deeney
Kouyate - 6, a few last minute clearences
Guehi - 6, solid, but nothing spectacular
Mitchell - 7, was against Saar, who had a few crosses, but generally did okay
McArthur - 7, seemed to be in the right place a lot for Zaha
Riederwald - 7, probably one of his better performances
Schlupp - 5, not a bad game, just nothing too spectacular
Ayew - 5, same as schulupp
Mateta - 6, his best pre-season game so far
Zaha - 8, player of the match, had fouls not called and still managed to get 2 goals

Subs
Gallagher - 7, he looks class
Hannam - 4, I like him, but looked shell shocked a bit
Benteke - 7 (I guess), short spell on, but scored in both goals (although the OG was tough).
Rak-Sakyi, Banks, Tomkins - No rating - too short of a spell and not involved much

 

Omph Flag Liverpool 07 Aug 21 8.03pm

Originally posted by grumpymort

Still worried how bad we are at defending the likes of corners this showed under Roy last few seasons it needs fixing the same with use putting in better quality when we are having these other end

Think this is where we may see the best of Olise early on - he has a bit of reputation as being very good from set pieces including corners

 

TheBigToePunt Flag 07 Aug 21 8.14pm

I have now returned from the good ship Selhurst and am some way into the important task of weekend-appropriate rehydration. Standby to receive the type of 'wisdom' that may contain spelling mistakes therefore.

1. Watford were s***. I know its only preseason, but I know s*** when I see it, and they were s***.

2. Palace were pretty good actually. How much to read into this I don't know. I thought playing our last preseason friendly against a team in our league one week before that league starts was: A. Unusual and possibly risky (it's just a free go at kicking Zaha surely?) but, B. A better gauge than normal of how we're measuring up. Watford were so bad though that I really don't know what to make of our performance. If we played like that in a league game we'd call it a very good performance, I think.

3. The system remains a twist on the classic Dutch 433. The twist is not so much that one of our wingers like to cut inside, but that both of our advanced midfielders are deliberately placed on their 'wrong' side. Dunno why. I'm sure the manager has his reasons, but I'm not sure it suits Schlupp.

4. Gallagher should be looking at McArthur and learning. The former has acceleration and energy the latter can no longer muster, but that's irrelevant if you don't know what you're doing. Mac picked up a booking for a counter-attack-preventing foul that was as cynical as it was necessary, whilst young Gallagher, determined to press to maximum effect at every turn, conceded a string of fouls that disrupted our rhythm, let Watford off the hook whenever they might have been making a mess of playing out, and would have picked up a totally unnecessary yellow of his own in a league game. Hopefully Gallagher will be brilliant for us, but I'm not up for us spending a year smoothing his rough edges for Chelsea's benefit.

5. For all the nice, neat and very patient football we played, our main goal-sources remain exactly the same. No manager in the world has a system that could offset the loss of Zaha.

6. I presume Tomkins is on the bench as Vieira wants the best passing centre backs in the side, and as a (mostly) midfielder, Kouyate perhaps fits the bill ahead of the best actual centre back we've got.

7. Mateta. No ta. If he's got what it takes he's hiding it well. Almost as well as he hid himself when his team sent in three or four good crosses in the second half. One peach from Mitchell in particular showed up how inadequate Mateta's anticipation, movement and determination appeared to be. He did so some good work clearing Watford corners though.

8. McArthur is brilliant. He can play any system, any style, any midfield position and never give less than a solid 7 every single time. He's a better deep midfielder than Riedewald. He's a better box to box midfielder than Schlupp and Gallagher. He's a better all round footballer than anyone else we've got, or have had that I can remember. If he had ever had pace and power he'd have played in the champions league.

9. Geuhi looks good. Not very tall though. He'll need to sort that out.

10. Ayew puts a proper shift in, but if Olise or Rak-Sahki can't get in ahead of him on the right wing by the end of the season then they ain't going to make it.


Cheers all!

Edited by TheBigToePunt (07 Aug 2021 8.23pm)

 

Sansbup Flag Norfolk 07 Aug 21 8.36pm

So where was Luka today??

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 07 Aug 21 9.34pm

Originally posted by Sansbup

So where was Luka today??

In the stand watching

 

Mathers Flag 07 Aug 21 11.30pm

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

I have now returned from the good ship Selhurst and am some way into the important task of weekend-appropriate rehydration. Standby to receive the type of 'wisdom' that may contain spelling mistakes therefore.

1. Watford were s***. I know its only preseason, but I know s*** when I see it, and they were s***.

2. Palace were pretty good actually. How much to read into this I don't know. I thought playing our last preseason friendly against a team in our league one week before that league starts was: A. Unusual and possibly risky (it's just a free go at kicking Zaha surely?) but, B. A better gauge than normal of how we're measuring up. Watford were so bad though that I really don't know what to make of our performance. If we played like that in a league game we'd call it a very good performance, I think.

3. The system remains a twist on the classic Dutch 433. The twist is not so much that one of our wingers like to cut inside, but that both of our advanced midfielders are deliberately placed on their 'wrong' side. Dunno why. I'm sure the manager has his reasons, but I'm not sure it suits Schlupp.

4. Gallagher should be looking at McArthur and learning. The former has acceleration and energy the latter can no longer muster, but that's irrelevant if you don't know what you're doing. Mac picked up a booking for a counter-attack-preventing foul that was as cynical as it was necessary, whilst young Gallagher, determined to press to maximum effect at every turn, conceded a string of fouls that disrupted our rhythm, let Watford off the hook whenever they might have been making a mess of playing out, and would have picked up a totally unnecessary yellow of his own in a league game. Hopefully Gallagher will be brilliant for us, but I'm not up for us spending a year smoothing his rough edges for Chelsea's benefit.

5. For all the nice, neat and very patient football we played, our main goal-sources remain exactly the same. No manager in the world has a system that could offset the loss of Zaha.

6. I presume Tomkins is on the bench as Vieira wants the best passing centre backs in the side, and as a (mostly) midfielder, Kouyate perhaps fits the bill ahead of the best actual centre back we've got.

7. Mateta. No ta. If he's got what it takes he's hiding it well. Almost as well as he hid himself when his team sent in three or four good crosses in the second half. One peach from Mitchell in particular showed up how inadequate Mateta's anticipation, movement and determination appeared to be. He did so some good work clearing Watford corners though.

8. McArthur is brilliant. He can play any system, any style, any midfield position and never give less than a solid 7 every single time. He's a better deep midfielder than Riedewald. He's a better box to box midfielder than Schlupp and Gallagher. He's a better all round footballer than anyone else we've got, or have had that I can remember. If he had ever had pace and power he'd have played in the champions league.

9. Geuhi looks good. Not very tall though. He'll need to sort that out.

10. Ayew puts a proper shift in, but if Olise or Rak-Sahki can't get in ahead of him on the right wing by the end of the season then they ain't going to make it.


Cheers all!


Edited by TheBigToePunt (07 Aug 2021 8.23pm)

Very entertaining post and good summary.

Gallagher sounds like he will entertain and frustrate in equal measure. He picked up 8 yellows last season so it’s clear his tackling is clumsy at best.

Guehi doesn’t need to be a giant as he’s strong as f*** and quicker than most CBs in the league. Anderson is 6ft4 so he’ll be our resident “Big Defender”.

 

cpfcse25 Flag Tokyo 08 Aug 21 12.20am

9. Geuhi looks good. Not very tall though. He'll need to sort that out.

Haha! that's gold!
Weird Schlupp was on the right of midfield I take it?

 

iheartcpfc Flag SE25 08 Aug 21 2.57am

Originally posted by Elwissthebest

Regarding the comments about our defence, I'm a bit nonplussed by Tomkins' omission. For me, he's still our best centre back, although I accept he is very injury prone. Guehi and Andersen might prove to be better in the long run, and I hope they do, but neither is anywhere near the finished article yet.

Love Tomkins but I think you need to understand just how good the two new boys are. Guehi already looks unbelievable imo

Edited by iheartcpfc (08 Aug 2021 2.57am)

 

taylors lovechild Flag 08 Aug 21 8.27am

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

3. The system remains a twist on the classic Dutch 433. The twist is not so much that one of our wingers like to cut inside, but that both of our advanced midfielders are deliberately placed on their 'wrong' side. Dunno why. I'm sure the manager has his reasons, but I'm not sure it suits Schlupp.

Bright pointed out that under the new system when we go forward we change into a 3-5-2 formation with Ward joining the centre backs, Mitchell moving to left-wing and Zaha playing more central, but when defending we revert to an almost 4-5-1 formation. Seemed to work really well and the players (apart from possibly Schlupp) seemed to know what they were doing.

4. Gallagher should be looking at McArthur and learning. The former has acceleration and energy the latter can no longer muster, but that's irrelevant if you don't know what you're doing. Mac picked up a booking for a counter-attack-preventing foul that was as cynical as it was necessary, whilst young Gallagher, determined to press to maximum effect at every turn, conceded a string of fouls that disrupted our rhythm, let Watford off the hook whenever they might have been making a mess of playing out, and would have picked up a totally unnecessary yellow of his own in a league game. Hopefully Gallagher will be brilliant for us, but I'm not up for us spending a year smoothing his rough edges for Chelsea's benefit.

Gallagher came on like an excitable puppy, but my god he has energy in abundance and he hit the best pass of the game without blinking. The way he snaps away and commits little fouls actually reminds me of McArthur who has always done that. If he had started I think he might have been a bit calmer. To refer to Bright again, he said of Gallagher that we have been missing that type of player for a long time (i.e. one who can hit long, accurate cross-field balls). Given Viera seems to be looking to use those balls to stretch the game I can see why he has been brought in. As good as McArthur is, he is not that type of player.

5. For all the nice, neat and very patient football we played, our main goal-sources remain exactly the same. No manager in the world has a system that could offset the loss of Zaha.

While that is true, we are missing Eze and Olise, plus Bentenke scored when he came on. I personally still think we need either another goal-scoring wide player or a fox in the box type striker though (like Armstrong).

6. I presume Tomkins is on the bench as Vieira wants the best passing centre backs in the side, and as a (mostly) midfielder, Kouyate perhaps fits the bill ahead of the best actual centre back we've got.

I wonder if part of it might also be that Kouyate is more of a leader than Tomkins, who although possibly a better defender doesn't come across as someone who commands the back line.

7. Mateta. No ta. If he's got what it takes he's hiding it well. Almost as well as he hid himself when his team sent in three or four good crosses in the second half. One peach from Mitchell in particular showed up how inadequate Mateta's anticipation, movement and determination appeared to be. He did so some good work clearing Watford corners though.

Worked really hard outside the box and his long rangy legs helped him carve out a chance, but inside the box he still fails to convince. Maybe it's just a confidence thing, but I wonder if that showing will convince Parish to sanction a move for another striker.

8. McArthur is brilliant. He can play any system, any style, any midfield position and never give less than a solid 7 every single time. He's a better deep midfielder than Riedewald. He's a better box to box midfielder than Schlupp and Gallagher. He's a better all round footballer than anyone else we've got, or have had that I can remember. If he had ever had pace and power he'd have played in the champions league.

MOTM for me too. His best performance since I don't remember when. Viera's arrival and his long injury absence seems to have re-energised him. Zaha should have done better with his perfect chip pass. Freed from the shackles of Hodgson's deep-lying midfield he could thrive.

9. Geuhi looks good. Not very tall though. He'll need to sort that out.

Looks extremely comfortable on the ball and made the tackle of the game. He did do a swing and a miss at a cross though!

10. Ayew puts a proper shift in, but if Olise or Rak-Sahki can't get in ahead of him on the right wing by the end of the season then they ain't going to make it.

Ayew is a very clever player. He knows how to run across players to stop them tackling without fouling, and how to use your body to keep possession. He is also very good at taking the pressure off the defence. It was noticeable how once Banks and Rak-Sakyi came on we looked more vulnerable


Edited by TheBigToePunt (07 Aug 2021 8.23pm)

 

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace vs. Watford match thread