You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Back from yesterday's game
November 16 2026 4.12am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Back from yesterday's game


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
topcat Flag Holmesdale / Surbiton 24 Aug 21 7.56am

Originally posted by Aray

Defence:
CBs are excellent.

Guita is a problem. I've always thought his distribution was terrible and now its a real issue. As for the constant punching...And while I'm at it - I think he had a poor game last week at Chelski.

I didn't see much wrong with Mitchell or Ward but we could do with LB cover, for sure. Reckon Clyne plays when fit.

Midfield:
Thought Kouyate's first half performance was one of the worst I've seen from him. He did get better. Gallagher put him self about - not used to seeing that from our midfield - notwithstanding Jimmy Mac's tireless work. He was my MoM. But the midfield didn't really create much.

Upfront:
Wilf has had better games but the ref had a shocker. the rugby tackle in front of the Holmesdale towards the end of the match was terrible, as was the non-advantage decision.

He's moaning too much though. Losing sympathy with the fans - alot of folk where I sit weren't impressed.

I've seen Benteke and Schlupp play better and worse. Ayew was ok for the short passage he was on the pitch. Made stuff happen.

I personally feel that for a new approach we played in places. On the train after the game I got talking to some fellow Palace fans. They were far more downbeat on the performance than I.

One made an interesting point, that we dont have the players for this new system - we're a counter attack team with players who run with the ball. Maybe he's right - we need Olise and Eze back soon either way.

This was pretty much my view too. I fully expected the Brentford player (#6, I think) to be sent off as he was already on a yellow.

Wilf, Kouyate and Guita can all play better and need to ASAP.

 


It's 106 miles to Chicago, we got a full tank of gas, half a pack of cigarettes, it's dark... and we're wearing sunglasses.

aashman12 Flag 24 Aug 21 9.15am

Originally posted by Spiderman

Don’t forget that the Brentford player involved had already been booked. Definitely a yellow card but Atkinson just doesn’t like Wilf

Wonder why

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 24 Aug 21 11.25am

Originally posted by aashman12

Wonder why



Maybe he can’t get over being totally embarrassed at Arsenal, when he couldn’t book Wilf quick enough for diving, only to have it overturned and had to give a penalty.
Wilf does himself no favours with his attitude at times but some officials need to take a long hard look at themselves.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 24 Aug 21 11.28am

Originally posted by Aray

Defence:
CBs are excellent.

Guita is a problem. I've always thought his distribution was terrible and now its a real issue. As for the constant punching...And while I'm at it - I think he had a poor game last week at Chelski.

I didn't see much wrong with Mitchell or Ward but we could do with LB cover, for sure. Reckon Clyne plays when fit.

Midfield:
Thought Kouyate's first half performance was one of the worst I've seen from him. He did get better. Gallagher put him self about - not used to seeing that from our midfield - notwithstanding Jimmy Mac's tireless work. He was my MoM. But the midfield didn't really create much.

Upfront:
Wilf has had better games but the ref had a shocker. the rugby tackle in front of the Holmesdale towards the end of the match was terrible, as was the non-advantage decision.

He's moaning too much though. Losing sympathy with the fans - alot of folk where I sit weren't impressed.

I've seen Benteke and Schlupp play better and worse. Ayew was ok for the short passage he was on the pitch. Made stuff happen.

I personally feel that for a new approach we played in places. On the train after the game I got talking to some fellow Palace fans. They were far more downbeat on the performance than I.

One made an interesting point, that we dont have the players for this new system - we're a counter attack team with players who run with the ball. Maybe he's right - we need Olise and Eze back soon either way.

Maybe that is why we are after Hughes, a mobile midfielder who can pass, PL ready and only 26

 

djmikeyp Flag 24 Aug 21 1.52pm

I can't help wondering if Max Meyer would have thrived under PV. We all see games differently, but I thought he was a classy player who could have excelled if used properly.

 

taylors lovechild Flag 24 Aug 21 2.16pm

The main thing is we keep showing signs of improvement. We at least pushed and hurried Brentford rather than taking the passive approach of last season and with the creativity of Olise and Eze to come in I think we have reasons to be upbeat about the season. Vieira seems to want the team to play on the front foot, such as the way Guehi pushed into midfield with the ball at times with Kouyate able to slip back and cover him, or how much further up the pitch Ward went with Andersen covering him. Bentenke still looked too static although he did use his body well on one occasion to create a chance for Wilf (I think it was Zaha, I can't remember?) You do wonder how much value he has under Vieira if we are not going to cross the ball.

We still have a lot to prove in the final third, but we certainly looked more solid. I certainly didn't come away thinking it was a poor performance, just an evolving one. West Ham will be a real test.

 

croydon proud Flag Any european country i fancy! 24 Aug 21 2.49pm

Anyone else notice lots of empty seats on Saturday? Saw lots in the Arthur near the Holmesdale, and lots in the main stand near the White horse end. I know some are on holiday but for the first home game of the season, and a new manager, with quite a good transfer window, it seemed a bit sparce! The noise on the tv was like a packed house to be fair!

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 24 Aug 21 3.49pm

Originally posted by croydon proud

Anyone else notice lots of empty seats on Saturday? Saw lots in the Arthur near the Holmesdale, and lots in the main stand near the White horse end. I know some are on holiday but for the first home game of the season, and a new manager, with quite a good transfer window, it seemed a bit sparce! The noise on the tv was like a packed house to be fair!


The noise in the ground was also like a packed house at times!

 

DANGERCLOSE Flag London 24 Aug 21 4.37pm

Zaha was just having a bad day, He had a great pre-season so peeps don't panic

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 24 Aug 21 4.57pm

Originally posted by DANGERCLOSE

Zaha was just having a bad day, He had a great pre-season so peeps don't panic

Zaha, doesn’t have quiet the pace and energy of even two seasons ago. He is still a real threat , but teams don’t find it as hard now to shut him down. Pressing him really quickly with two or three bodies is often used on him, but more recently because his pace and trickery is not what it was , one strong pacy close marker ,as Brentford , employed can shut him down. To make matters worse for Wilf, these changes in refereeing will not help him one bit, he is ,and always has suffered from what I would call the up close and personal annoying fouls, the very type that refs are ignoring and tearing up the rule book over. Regardless it still remains the case ,we are not better without him , and probably worse.

 

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Back from yesterday's game