This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by jeeagles
Reading it, they seem like nutters. There isn't anything I've spotted that infringes on anyone else freedoms, or anything that is deliberately deceptive. It's quite obvious to the reader that it's an opinion piece and a bit strange that Germany wants to take action against them. The story itself could be fake news? In previous generations these people would be wearing tin foil on their heads claiming the government could read our minds.
Lying behind all of this is the owner's personal outlook. Take a look at this, which was published today, and ask yourself what the motivation is:- I asked a question in my initial post about whether it is wise to regard God as the ultimate authority. No-one expressed an opinion. Andrew Torba's version of Christianity is infused throughout Gab, which leads me to question the "free speech" claims which are made for it by him, as it seems to be a platform for one viewpoint only.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Lying behind all of this is the owner's personal outlook. Take a look at this, which was published today, and ask yourself what the motivation is:- I asked a question in my initial post about whether it is wise to regard God as the ultimate authority. No-one expressed an opinion. Andrew Torba's version of Christianity is infused throughout Gab, which leads me to question the "free speech" claims which are made for it by him, as it seems to be a platform for one viewpoint only. And other platforms don't? CND, Labour Party, Ban Abortion will all hold a certain view point. Don't like it try Pro trident, Tories, Pro Abortion sites. Free speech doesn't mean that every view has to be represented on a website it means a person or group are free to express their views and if you disagree with them start your own site with a counter point.
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
I would never describe you as boring! Ridiculous, prejudiced and often unpleasant, but not boring. You are too funny for that! So thanks again. I needed a laugh this morning. That's no more a summary of my views than it is a summary of Einstein's theory of special relativity! I won't bother to explain why. Anyone sensible will already understand, whilst those who see any alternative view as a lie, like yourself, won't. You're welcome. All the time you post your bulls*** on here, I will be around to highlight your double standards.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
And other platforms don't? CND, Labour Party, Ban Abortion will all hold a certain view point. Don't like it try Pro trident, Tories, Pro Abortion sites. Free speech doesn't mean that every view has to be represented on a website it means a person or group are free to express their views and if you disagree with them start your own site with a counter point. Of course but that also means that others have the right to reject views in situations where they have the jurisdiction. Torba believes he has a God given right to reach everyone. Which presents a problem in today’s borderless internet world,
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Of course but that also means that others have the right to reject views in situations where they have the jurisdiction. Torba believes he has a God given right to reach everyone. Which presents a problem in today’s borderless internet world, Not really what you are saying is that he has an opinion and that the German government disagrees, my money is on the Germans.
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
Not really what you are saying is that he has an opinion and that the German government disagrees, my money is on the Germans. We might both consider it just his opinion but if you read Torba you will realise his view is that God’s authority is above anything imposed by man. In this he has more in common with the extreme versions of Islam than most of us. Fundamentalists are a problem whatsoever faith they subscribe to.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
Not really what you are saying is that he has an opinion and that the German government disagrees, my money is on the Germans. People have lost by putting their money on the Germans a couple of times.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
People have lost by putting their money on the Germans a couple of times. So the second one was an attempted betting coup?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
So the second one was an attempted betting coup? Nein to one.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
'if you read Torba you will realise his view is that God’s authority is above anything imposed by man. In this he has more in common with the extreme versions of Islam than most of us.' ? Is knowledge of the Abrahamic religions this poor? Anyone with even the most simple understanding of Islam knows that 'god's authority is above anything imposed by man'....Hell, that's all the Abrahamic religions....for feck's sake that's the whole point of religion. Jesus wept. Indeed, it's entirely mainstream Islam. The only discussion point is what that authority is in practice. I get being against religion but arguments that don't understand it get nowhere. Edited by Stirlingsays (23 Sep 2021 1.33pm) There is a world of difference between the ancient texts of a religion, written when mankind knew no better, and someone today genuinely believing them to the point of ignoring the will of the majority. I have no problem with those who believe just so long as they keep that belief in a historical context and don’t try to pretend that scientific discovery hasn’t happened.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Nein to one. That's where each way bets come in although admittedly a draw was always unlikely.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Sounds like extremist atheism to cherry pick those you want to be prosecuted for their beliefs. No one is required to go to Gab, just as no one is required to enter a Mosque. If you don't like someone's views then don't bother yourself with them. If religion genuinely bothers you that much then go picket your local Mosque. Because your statement that they....or any of the main religions don't put God's words above man's is pure fantasy.....in fact the Jews and Christians allow for far more interpretation than Muslims as Islam teaches that the Quran is the actual word of god, while the main bulk of Christians believe the Bible to be 'inspired' by god written by prophets. Edited by Stirlingsays (23 Sep 2021 4.36pm) As usual, you are either misunderstanding or, more likely, misrepresenting what I have said. I don't want anyone prosecuted for their beliefs. Prosecutions should only follow actions. Any individual putting "God's words above man's" for himself, isn't a problem. If that is how they wish to run their life, that's their decision and their right. It only becomes one if they decide to ignore any laws that conflict with their personal viewpoint and act unlawfully. Whether people can choose whether to visit Gab, or indeed a mosque populated by extremists, is beside the point. They exist and are populated. What happens there cannot be ignored because it impacts all of us.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Sounds like extremist atheism to cherry pick those you want to be prosecuted for their beliefs. No one is required to go to Gab, just as no one is required to enter a Mosque. If you don't like someone's views then don't bother yourself with them. If religion genuinely bothers you that much then go picket your local Mosque. Because your statement that they....or any of the main religions don't put God's words above man's is pure fantasy.....in fact the Jews and Christians allow for far more interpretation than Muslims as Islam teaches that the Quran is the actual word of god, while the main bulk of Christians believe the Bible to be 'inspired' by god written by prophets. Edited by Stirlingsays (23 Sep 2021 4.36pm) It goes further, it is the last word of god, everything before and everything after is to be discarded.
The mountains are calling & I must go. |
|
|
Originally posted by Ouzo Dan
It goes further, it is the last word of god, everything before and everything after is to be discarded. Yep, which explains why it has licence to be much more dangerous. As Erdogan said, there is no such thing as radical Islam, there is just Islam.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
The appropriate balance should be both adhering to the law of the land (in this case the US) and yet also providing platforms for free speech. A celebration of the dismantling of entire platforms due to who they attract could be short lived as governments are less worried about what is said, and more about the extent of what powers they can exert. What they take they rarely return, and in the big picture that is as if not more concerning than anything isolated nutters could conjure up (think a China censorship and social credits type existence). Gab hand over info when someone legitimately breaks the law; that is better than pushing concerning types underground and I can see in a way why he'd be frustrated at doing all he can but still facing these issues. Sure if there's a way to easily block certain content specifically in Germany that goes against German law than that is a possible solution. But if that isn't doable then Germany will have to decide on a solution to this themselves, as it becomes ludicrous for a website to have to simultaneously adhere to the laws of every country in the world. That's all but impossible.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
He doesn't want anyone prosecuted for their beliefs but if they break a law he does. So in other words whatever the law says regardless of what your religion is you have to obey. That's fine if the law doesn't seek to step on toes. As Jesus is meant to have said, 'Give to Caesar what is Caesar's, and to God what is God's'. It's the basis of the west's separation of church and state. Seems to me that WE just wants Gab restricted and is willing to defend any old crap motive to that end. More waffles than Tescos.....just the same rolling trolling. Edited by Stirlingsays (23 Sep 2021 7.25pm) Are you seriously suggesting that someone can use their religious belief as a justification to break the law and not be prosecuted as a consequence? Just think of the implications of that, because what is permitted for one is permitted for all. It's total nonsense. It also has nothing to do with the separation of church and state, which is a philosophical political covenant that says that the state won't interfere in how a church is run, and the church won't interfere in how the state is run. It does not mean that church members are isolated from state law. All citizens are. Some churches, for instance the Roman Catholics, define canon law, but that's all they do, and it's restricted solely to church matters. I don't want Gab "restricted". I want all social media platforms to obey the law and to behave responsibly. I want them to co-operate with government to eliminate things that are found, by a generally accepted consensus, to be dangerous to others. That consensus not being established either by government or the companies themselves, but by a respected independent watchdog. I realise the downside, but the alternative of not doing something is worse, in my view, than in doing it. We are in a new era which demands new thinking on an international scale. There is a great deal more at stake here than just the plaything of an American Christian fundamentalist, whose motivations are becoming increasingly questionable.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by BlueJay
The appropriate balance should be both adhering to the law of the land (in this case the US) and yet also providing platforms for free speech. A celebration of the dismantling of entire platforms due to who they attract could be short lived as governments are less worried about what is said, and more about the extent of what powers they can exert. What they take they rarely return, and in the big picture that is as if not more concerning than anything isolated nutters could conjure up (think a China censorship and social credits type existence). Gab hand over info when someone legitimately breaks the law; that is better than pushing concerning types underground and I can see in a way why he'd be frustrated at doing all he can but still facing these issues. Sure if there's a way to easily block certain content specifically in Germany that goes against German law than that is a possible solution. But if that isn't doable then Germany will have to decide on a solution to this themselves, as it becomes ludicrous for a website to have to simultaneously adhere to the laws of every country in the world. That's all but impossible.
Determining who has legal jurisdiction in the internet era is one of the major issues. It's a parallel problem to where tax ought to be levied. In the country where the trade occurs, or where the supplier is domiciled? I see this becoming a huge source of international dispute in the future, which won't easily be reconciled. Driving bad actors underground is a risk, but at least there they won't be so easily found by the impressionable, and in some ways it would make the job of the security community easier. Smaller numbers being easier to monitor. Controlling content purely on political grounds, as China does, is not acceptable and not what I am arguing for. I want to see obvious misinformation that ignores established scientific consensus to be the target for action. I want to see things that harm people being removed. Germany can block the IPs, but we all know that can easily be circumnavigated with a VPN. Co-operation and a willingness to behave responsibly is much better, but when one party is actively resisting that, then things get could get messy.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.