You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Our best football ever?
November 16 2026 4.12am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Our best football ever?


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
martin2412 Flag Living The Dream 09 Nov 21 1.07pm

Although I think we have a decent side this season, I'm not sure it's our best ever.

The team that finished third and got to the cup final first time around may be better. A few names off the top of my head without googling:

Martyn
Salako
Wright
Bright
Gray
Thomas
Thorn
Pemberton
O'Reilly
Pardew
Barber

I'm sure I've forgotten a couple.

 

Pete53 Flag Hassocks 09 Nov 21 1.24pm

Originally posted by martin2412

Although I think we have a decent side this season, I'm not sure it's our best ever.

The team that finished third and got to the cup final first time around may be better. A few names off the top of my head without googling:

Martyn
Salako
Wright
Bright
Gray
Thomas
Thorn
Pemberton
O'Reilly
Pardew
Barber

I'm sure I've forgotten a couple.

I think if you watched old footage of games from back then you'd probably find the skill level wasn't on the same level as now. Obviously finishing 3rd was a fantastic achievement and if we are talking about success alone, then we haven't matched that since.

However, there is a now a greater level of quality and technical skill in top flight football. We had some very good players back then but I do I think our current team would beat the early 90s side.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 09 Nov 21 1.44pm

Originally posted by Pete53

Agreed, we did play some lovely football during the promotion season 78/79, and the first half of 79/80.

I think that's the only time I can remember, prior to now, where we played classy football on a consistent basis.

Since getting promotion to the PL in 2013 I have constantly bemoaned our seeming inability to string more than a few passes together. Yes we survived and I fully appreciate that, but it was very frustrating to watch.


Those were certainly the days and we did it with a good number of players from our youth-cup winning teams. That promotion season was one where we didn't expect to get beat (we only lost 4 all season, 2 of them at home). It was mainly a question of would we score the extra goal needed for the win. The style of football, though, was classy for that era, playing it on the deck as much as possible. I'd better stop there before Becky moves this entry to Nostalgia.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 09 Nov 21 1.44pm

Originally posted by andy p

i am a little bit worried about burn out.Were a hundred miles an hour every game,that's fine after 11 games,but come 22,25 games we may well see a slow down in performance and,or points........hope i am way out though.

If players are unhappy and frustrated then burn out will happen, we can all see the difference with one player in particular who was totally frustrated and unhappy with the players around him resulting in showing his worse side to all of us on the pitch, he had total burn out because he'd lost all interest with the club.

I cannot see any reason at all why we'll see burn out at any time this season.

 

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 09 Nov 21 2.05pm

I'm expecting us to get 'found out' at some point. Right now, we're playing excellent, and feels like a whole new team has arrived in the league. that is to say, I'm expecting a 'difficult 2nd season' syndrome akin to what Leeds utd appear to be having at the moment.

hopefully this happens next season, and not earlier.

As for burn out. I think our CB's are our biggest issue - Lose either of them to injury, and our passing out from defence all of a sudden becomes a lot riskier with the likes of Tompkins.

RB cover good.
LB cover, Jairo can step in, and also Hannam ?

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 09 Nov 21 2.07pm

Since we "only" have to play Premier League games until FA Cup 3. round beginning of January, we should be all right. Some teams - like West Ham and Leicester - also compete in Carabao Cup and the European Cup. That might be too much in the long run....

 

Sansbup Flag Norfolk 09 Nov 21 2.51pm

If you watch the ZDS cup final again you'll see what an exciting team we were then. I think the current team is playing some great stuff and will be recognised one of our best ever - if we keep it up all season. And if we get some silverware then definitely!

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 09 Nov 21 3.34pm

Originally posted by antipodeagle

We've got a bigger/better squad this season, so we can rotate the forward line, CBs should be fine, and we've got EE and Olise waiting in the wings for the wings. In theory we have okay central midfield cover, but I think a lot of that will depend on whether Will Hughes is able to be used interchangeably with JMac without losing performance quality.

The main concern then is our full-backs: we have cover at a push, but no-one yet who is guaranteed to maintain the same level. Hopefully Fergusson comes good in time for a decent chunk of the season.

I also believe our fitness levels have reached a new high. So far, no niggly injuries picked up in training, the high pressing is being sustained for longer, since the beginning of the season. Praise to PV but also massive praise to the training/coaching staff he has brought in

 

Omph Flag Liverpool 09 Nov 21 4.16pm

Originally posted by Pete53

I think if you watched old footage of games from back then you'd probably find the skill level wasn't on the same level as now. Obviously finishing 3rd was a fantastic achievement and if we are talking about success alone, then we haven't matched that since.

However, there is a now a greater level of quality and technical skill in top flight football. We had some very good players back then but I do I think our current team would beat the early 90s side.

Not up for debate which team would win. It's a different game now.

The 90s side has a fair bit in common with the current lot as it too was a beautifully drilled side that simply did what it did very well. In some ways I'd have it ahead of this lot which is still embryonic really and finding out how to beat teams and not simply be competitive.

 

rollercoaster Flag Cornwall 09 Nov 21 4.43pm

On their day Rogers, Whittle, Possee were class, especially after some of the previous Div 1 forward lines.

Trouble was they didn't have many days!!

 

Qwijibo Flag Bournemouth 09 Nov 21 6.39pm

We were good in November 2012.

 

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 10 Nov 21 1.49pm

Originally posted by Omph

Not up for debate which team would win. It's a different game now.

The 90s side has a fair bit in common with the current lot as it too was a beautifully drilled side that simply did what it did very well. In some ways I'd have it ahead of this lot which is still embryonic really and finding out how to beat teams and not simply be competitive.

To my mind, the Coppell side was an excellent long-ball team and it finished third. Since era comparisons are unfair, I think you just have to say that team was better.

But the football this team plays is, in my mind, head and shoulders better. We pass the ball out from the back with pace and skill and it's exhilarating to watch.

It's true though that we are still less 5hab a third way through a single season.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

TheBigToePunt Flag 10 Nov 21 2.32pm

We played incredible stuff in the first half of the season when we won what is now the Championship, but as the OP said, that was second-tier football.

Personally, I loved watching the Coppell era team play precisely because they lumped it long and knocked people about! Nothing better than seeing the big boys steamrolled in that fashion, but those days are long gone.

As many have said (including the OP) it is too early to say that this is what we can expect from the team most weeks. It might just be a purple patch, and we must keep in mind that many successful 'upstart' teams can only maintain their form for as long as it takes the rest of the league to take them seriously. Then they get analysed in greater detail, and coaches start working out plans to counter what the successful side is doing. It will be interesting to see if teams start pressing us more intensely for instance and whether we can still operate as well under such conditions.

The hope must be that we are in the category whereby teams know what to expect but can't always stop us. There will of course be difficult periods, but this is still great.

I wasn't sure that our summer spending had landed good enough players for us to play nice football and still stay up, but at the moment it looks like perhaps the money has been well spent. The two centre backs have done well (especially with the ball), and of course, Gallagher has been amazing. Olise looks like he will be a real asset, and we have seen flashes of good stuff from Edouard too. Hughes remains an unknown, but otherwise not a duff in sight.

 

Pete53 Flag Hassocks 10 Nov 21 2.37pm

Originally posted by rollercoaster

On their day Rogers, Whittle, Possee were class, especially after some of the previous Div 1 forward lines.

Trouble was they didn't have many days!!

Exactly. The squad we ended up with in the 72/73 was, on paper at least, the strongest we had had during our 4 year stint in Division One. Unfortunately, it was the one that got relegated. There were some good moments along the way though ... the 5-0 beating of Man Utd, a 4-0 win at West Brom, beating Chelsea 2-0 at Selhurst and beating Southampton at home in the league and cup in the space of a couple of weeks, but there was not enough consistency.

 

Ipswich Eagle Flag Ipswich 10 Nov 21 4.42pm

Originally posted by andy p

i am a little bit worried about burn out.Were a hundred miles an hour every game,that's fine after 11 games,but come 22,25 games we may well see a slow down in performance and,or points........hope i am way out though.

But almost the point is, what's the other option?? I coach American Football and there was the phrase "don't save anything for the 4th quarter, it'll be too late by then."

You're almost certainly right, but I'd rather we went flat out, got our points tally up, blew a few teams off the park and then when we start being a bit leggy it'll be a matter of us dropping from 3rd in the table to 5th, lol (we can dream).

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 10 Nov 21 5.07pm

Originally posted by Ipswich Eagle

But almost the point is, what's the other option?? I coach American Football and there was the phrase "don't save anything for the 4th quarter, it'll be too late by then."

You're almost certainly right, but I'd rather we went flat out, got our points tally up, blew a few teams off the park and then when we start being a bit leggy it'll be a matter of us dropping from 3rd in the table to 5th, lol (we can dream).


Agree and we can worry about burn-out etc. if and when it happens. PV has an excellent team working with him and we have to rely on them to tell the manager when players need resting. Meanwhile let's just get on with amassing points as quickly as we can.

 

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 10 Nov 21 5.44pm

I always think it’s a bit harsh saying the Coppell early 90’s team were totally long ball, yes we were solid, sometimes with a bit of a nasty streak and we did bang it forward for Wrighty to chase at times, but if we were totally a long ball team, how come we had two of the best midfielders in the country who forced their way into the England squad? We could play a bit as well.

In my opinion the so called ‘team of the 80’s’ around 78-79 were unplayable at times, teams just couldn’t live with our pace and the speed we moved the ball. I’d love to see that team in its prime on the bowling greens they play on today instead of the bumpy mud baths and sand pits they had to put up with back then

Edited by monkey (10 Nov 2021 5.45pm)

 

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 10 Nov 21 8.08pm

I think it is. Hopefully we can sustain it and build on it. I was in my early teens when the Venables team developed although I went to all home games and plenty of away games. The real affinity with that team was they came through the youth set up and hence were such a tight unit with a tremendous understanding. For pure footballing talent and ease on the eye they are the two teams that stand out, but it is so difficult to compare as the game has evolved so much. Now if you were talking effective / powerful football then Coppell’s team of the late 80’searly 90’s would win hands down.

Edited by Bexley Eagle (10 Nov 2021 8.09pm)

 

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 11 Nov 21 6.50am

Originally posted by monkey

I always think it’s a bit harsh saying the Coppell early 90’s team were totally long ball, yes we were solid, sometimes with a bit of a nasty streak and we did bang it forward for Wrighty to chase at times, but if we were totally a long ball team, how come we had two of the best midfielders in the country who forced their way into the England squad? We could play a bit as well.

In my opinion the so called ‘team of the 80’s’ around 78-79 were unplayable at times, teams just couldn’t live with our pace and the speed we moved the ball. I’d love to see that team in its prime on the bowling greens they play on today instead of the bumpy mud baths and sand pits they had to put up with back then

Edited by monkey (10 Nov 2021 5.45pm)

I hear you and that team gave great memories. All I'd say is, there were times when we'd have won and there wasn't that elation going home after the match. Leaving a game having outplayed some great footballing teams. It's a fantastic feeling.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 11 Nov 21 9.44am

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig

I hear you and that team gave great memories. All I'd say is, there were times when we'd have won and there wasn't that elation going home after the match. Leaving a game having outplayed some great footballing teams. It's a fantastic feeling.

I beg to differ, to this day, I don’t think I’ll ever forget that day when we outclassed that great Ipswich side at selhurst, we stuffed them 4-1, still in my opinion our best performance in my time. We’d just beaten Derby 4-0 as well. Beating the European champions in Forest, I’ll never forget the excitement of the bus ride home after these games. made all the more special by the fact that not so long ago we were playing the likes of Mansfield, York, Wrexham, etc

But I will say, after the last 2 or 3 years, it is so nice coming away from selhurst having enjoyed every game so far

Edited by monkey (11 Nov 2021 9.45am)

 

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Our best football ever?