You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Team for Leeds
November 16 2026 4.01am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Team for Leeds


Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
HolmesdaleUpper Flag Sanderstead 28 Nov 21 3.24pm

.

Edited by HolmesdaleUpper (28 Nov 2021 3.27pm)

 

HolmesdaleUpper Flag Sanderstead 28 Nov 21 3.25pm

Originally posted by doombear


PV is unlikely to play 442 so not that.
For me:
- Luka must NOT start
- Olise is better as an impact sub
- Edouard must start as he adds guile and is a proper striker.
- As PV has said he has been happy with Hughes in training, then time to start him.
- Would like Eze but not sure he's ready to start, So,

Guaita (or Butland)
Ward Tomkins Guehi Mitchell
Kouyate Gallagher Hughes
Zaha Benteke Edouard.

Edited by doombear (28 Nov 2021 1.44pm)

Schlupp for Hughes as he is still an unknown factor. Tomkins looked rusty first half but improved second should be much better for the run out. Not sure having seen Eze on Saturday how he will fit into PV's style.

 

PatrickA Flag London 28 Nov 21 4.36pm

Depends on whether this heading means the team you think Vieira will pick or the one you would personally pick.
It wouldn't surprise me if he went for the same team as yesterday but with Ayew for Olise.
He has shown no inclination to start Schlupp or Hughes instead of Mcarthur so I could see him persisting with Luka and Kouyate.
Personally I would replace Luka in the deepest midfield role with Kouyate. I would play Gallagher and Schlupp as the other more advanced 2 midfielders.
My front 3 would be Edouard, Benteke and Zaha.
If Benteke doesn't play well I would move Edouard into the middle and bring on either Olise or Eze.

 

sydtheeagle Flag England 28 Nov 21 4.54pm

Some observations:

Olise - is going to be a player, but isn't one yet. He looks a little lightweight physically to me and also lacking in confidence to take players on (which is his natural game). Being played out of position all season (his preferred role is central midfield) hasn't helped. Personally, I'd use him as an impact sub while he finds his feet in the PL this season.

Andersen - we missed him yesterday. What we missed wasn't his too-often suspect defending but his distribution; his ability to ping a long-distance pass and get the attack moving out of the blue keeps other teams honest and was notable by its absence. Most of our abundant possession yesterday was wasted by endless slow, sideways passing with very little penetration. If available, Andersen has to play.

Ayew - I wouldn't start him too often but wanted to note that I'm astonished how little respect he gets here. Always puts in a shift, has considerably more skill than he's given credit for and while he's not a world-class finisher by any stretch of the imagination, our squad is better with him than it would be without him.

Luka - Frankly, finished (at Palace). Offers very little indeed. Useful player for the sort of aspirations we had two years ago (surival) but simply not a useful player for a team looking to do better than that.

Schlupp - I think he needs a run of games, partly to see if he can translate his occasional impact into regular performance and also given that his contract is ending we ought to find out what we've got and what he's worth.

Wilf - dare I say that, at 29, while by no means old or over the hill, Wilf may have passed his summit? He was poor yesterday; the days when he could simply singlehandedly take a game by the scruff of the neck may be coming to an end. Still our most likely player to win a game but arguably no longer the first name on the teamsheet or, if he's still that, certainly no longer guaranteed never to be substituted if he isn't playing well.

Hughes - not sure he's ready to start on Tuesday, but he needs to begin getting some minutes and seeing time on the pitch. Another potentially astute signing that at some point we've got to understand how or if he fits into Vieira's masterplan going forwards.

Kouyate - better than Luka, but then so am I so not much of a compliment. Rather like Ayew, happy to have him around and there will be games when his presence is called for. But the more "winnable" games where we look to be on the front foot, I'm not sure either he or Luka should be on the teamsheet.

VG - great shot stopper but his ability to command a penalty area -- what ability? He hasn't got any - really isn't helping anyone. Surely at set pieces, getting the defense organised is part of the keeper's job? It used to be,anyway.

My team for Leeds:

VG

Ward
Mitchell
Guehi
Andersen

Schlupp
Eze
Gallagher
Zaha

Benteke
Edouard

Subs:

If Ebs is not 100% fit, likely given his comeback, I'd like to see Olise replace him for the last portion of the game in his (Olise's) preferred central midfield role. It's about time we put him in the best position to succeed.

I'd like to see Hughes make his debut at some point, if the state of the game dictates bringing him on.

Edited by sydtheeagle (28 Nov 2021 4.59pm)

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

Elwissthebest Flag Marlborough 28 Nov 21 5.04pm

Really thoughtful, well-considered and helpful commentary here. Thanks, Syd

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 28 Nov 21 6.36pm

There was one game this season that Luka was great, perhaps two where Kouyate was great, perhaps we should wonder why they have been poor since?

 


Red and Blue Army!

kevlee Flag born Wandsworth emigrated to Lanc... 28 Nov 21 6.42pm

I agree with the majority that Luka should not start. His tackling is reckless and he is a liability.
Would like to see Schlupp make an appearanace. Mot sure about Hughes. PV names the team from what he sees in training, maybe he thinks he's not ready or good enough. Would like to see him come on though so I can make up my own mind. I thougt it was an odd purchase, but once the injures start coming in we may need him.

 


Following Palace since 25 Feb 1978

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 28 Nov 21 9.10pm

We will make one change Ayew for Olise.

 

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 29 Nov 21 1.20am

Originally posted by lush1076

guaita
Ward - RB
Guehi - CB
Tomkins- CB
Mitchell -LB
Hughes CDM
Gallagher - CM
Eze - CM
Zaha -LW
Olise - RW
Edouard- CF

A good shout. No Kouyate, Luka and Benteke (back to his worst vs Villa.)When Gallagher created havoc and Villa almost scored an own goal, Tekkers was just standing there watching. And when Guhei scored (from where the big Belgian should have been), he was again just watching behind several Villa defenders.
For me a happy day when Christian B. packs his bags for good and say adios Eagles...

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 29 Nov 21 6.06am

Originally posted by thai-eagle

A good shout. No Kouyate, Luka and Benteke (back to his worst vs Villa.)When Gallagher created havoc and Villa almost scored an own goal, Tekkers was just standing there watching. And when Guhei scored (from where the big Belgian should have been), he was again just watching behind several Villa defenders.
For me a happy day when Christian B. packs his bags for good and say adios Eagles...

First class post, hope it is January

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 29 Nov 21 6.10am

Originally posted by lush1076

guaita
Ward - RB
Guehi - CB
Tomkins- CB
Mitchell -LB
Hughes CDM
Gallagher - CM
Eze - CM
Zaha -LW
Olise - RW
Edouard- CF

Would love to see that midfield and Attack start, bet Leeds wouldn't

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 29 Nov 21 7.48am

Originally posted by sydtheeagle

Some observations:

Olise - is going to be a player, but isn't one yet. He looks a little lightweight physically to me and also lacking in confidence to take players on (which is his natural game). Being played out of position all season (his preferred role is central midfield) hasn't helped. Personally, I'd use him as an impact sub while he finds his feet in the PL this season.

Andersen - we missed him yesterday. What we missed wasn't his too-often suspect defending but his distribution; his ability to ping a long-distance pass and get the attack moving out of the blue keeps other teams honest and was notable by its absence. Most of our abundant possession yesterday was wasted by endless slow, sideways passing with very little penetration. If available, Andersen has to play.

Ayew - I wouldn't start him too often but wanted to note that I'm astonished how little respect he gets here. Always puts in a shift, has considerably more skill than he's given credit for and while he's not a world-class finisher by any stretch of the imagination, our squad is better with him than it would be without him.

Luka - Frankly, finished (at Palace). Offers very little indeed. Useful player for the sort of aspirations we had two years ago (surival) but simply not a useful player for a team looking to do better than that.

Schlupp - I think he needs a run of games, partly to see if he can translate his occasional impact into regular performance and also given that his contract is ending we ought to find out what we've got and what he's worth.

Wilf - dare I say that, at 29, while by no means old or over the hill, Wilf may have passed his summit? He was poor yesterday; the days when he could simply singlehandedly take a game by the scruff of the neck may be coming to an end. Still our most likely player to win a game but arguably no longer the first name on the teamsheet or, if he's still that, certainly no longer guaranteed never to be substituted if he isn't playing well.

Hughes - not sure he's ready to start on Tuesday, but he needs to begin getting some minutes and seeing time on the pitch. Another potentially astute signing that at some point we've got to understand how or if he fits into Vieira's masterplan going forwards.

Kouyate - better than Luka, but then so am I so not much of a compliment. Rather like Ayew, happy to have him around and there will be games when his presence is called for. But the more "winnable" games where we look to be on the front foot, I'm not sure either he or Luka should be on the teamsheet.

VG - great shot stopper but his ability to command a penalty area -- what ability? He hasn't got any - really isn't helping anyone. Surely at set pieces, getting the defense organised is part of the keeper's job? It used to be,anyway.

My team for Leeds:

VG

Ward
Mitchell
Guehi
Andersen

Schlupp
Eze
Gallagher
Zaha

Benteke
Edouard

Subs:

If Ebs is not 100% fit, likely given his comeback, I'd like to see Olise replace him for the last portion of the game in his (Olise's) preferred central midfield role. It's about time we put him in the best position to succeed.

I'd like to see Hughes make his debut at some point, if the state of the game dictates bringing him on.

Edited by sydtheeagle (28 Nov 2021 4.59pm)

Assuming that Andersen is still unavailable, my defence would be

VG
JW
JT
MG
TM

Midfield

JA
CJ
WH

Up Top

WZ
CB
EO

Probably not going to be the starting line up selected by PV however.

If Hughes was to make a start then I think the Villa game was the best opportunity to see what he can do.

I don't think Ebs is ready to start a game just yet. He did ok on Saturday, largely kept it simple, and I think he needs a few more cameos before starting a game.

Olise looks better when the play is stretched. I wonder if the long term plan is to play him in his preferred position in midfield ? That area will require an overhaul next summer.

As for Wilf, he still managed our best piece of individual skill on Saturday with that first half turn and shot. Brave decision by PV to hook him, I'd have swapped CB for OE and left Wilf on.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 29 Nov 21 8.30am

Not that its going to effect the Leeds game, but, could effect the next one(manure), Wardy is now on 4(four) yellow cards. If he gets another against leeds, he'll be ruled out for 1 game.

So, if this is the case, who will be our RB v Manure?

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 29 Nov 21 8.31am

Originally posted by eagleman13

Not that its going to effect the Leeds game, but, could effect the next one(manure), Wardy is now on 4(four) yellow cards. If he gets another against leeds, he'll be ruled out for 1 game.

So, if this is the case, who will be our RB v Manure?

Nat Clyne I assume....

 


Old, Ungifted and White

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 29 Nov 21 8.46am

Originally posted by NEILLO

Nat Clyne I assume....

Doh, forgot all about him, my bad.

Coz i was bored, Wilf, Conor, Tekkers & Jmac are all on 3 yellows. Now, as has been pointed out on another thread, we have 8 games left before 1st Jan, plenty of time for 3 of them to rack up a couple more each & recieve a 1 match ban.

Wilf for his petulance, Conor for his tenacity & Tekkers for being slow & cumbersome in his 'tackling'.

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

Painter Flag Croydon 29 Nov 21 10.10am

Originally posted by thai-eagle

A good shout. No Kouyate, Luka and Benteke (back to his worst vs Villa.)When Gallagher created havoc and Villa almost scored an own goal, Tekkers was just standing there watching. And when Guhei scored (from where the big Belgian should have been), he was again just watching behind several Villa defenders.
For me a happy day when Christian B. packs his bags for good and say adios Eagles...

Kouyate crossed the ball for the goal against Villa, something Olise couldn’t do all game.
Benteke is the most successful Premier striker, we have ever had, one goal away from 100 Premier goals. Bad players don’t score that many goals in the Premier and you want to sell him.

 

Andy0629 Flag Warlingham 29 Nov 21 10.18am

Guaita

Ward Andersen (Tomkins) Guehi

Clyne Gallagher Kouyate Schlupp Mitchell

Edouard Benteke or Zaha

We need legs in the middle of the park and in the fullback positions as Leeds will out run us, wing backs gives us the ability to push them further into their half.

 

babylonjohn Flag St Leonards-on-Sea 29 Nov 21 10.31am

Originally posted by Painter

Kouyate crossed the ball for the goal against Villa, something Olise couldn’t do all game.
Benteke is the most successful Premier striker, we have ever had, one goal away from 100 Premier goals. Bad players don’t score that many goals in the Premier and you want to sell him.

Actually its 86 premier goals. Villa 42 goals in 89 appearances, Liverpool 9 in 29, Palace 35 in 150.

 

Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 29 Nov 21 10.49am

Would like to see Schlupp start. Just think he brings something different to the team - powerful and direct.

I'm also in the camp of Luka not being good enough anymore and that perhaps Olise is not ready for a start yet. More effective as a sub currently. I'd go with:

-------------Guaita--------------
Ward - Tomkins - Ghehi - Mitchell
------------Kouyate --------------
-------Gallagher---Schlupp--------
Eze ---------Edouard----------Wilf

If Eze isn't quite match fit, I'd start with Ayew.

 

OneWayTicketToMars Flag Selsdon 29 Nov 21 11.40am

This:

We will make one change Ayew for Olise.

Lets go on another unbeaten run

COYP

 


Record crowd 51,482 - The Whitehorse was rocking - Second Div Champs 1978 - 79 ... 'wot a night !

Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Team for Leeds