You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > While Wilf & Jordan are away...
November 16 2026 4.01am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

While Wilf & Jordan are away...


Gribbo Flag Bromley 03 Jan 22 7.05pm

Olise, Benteke and Edouard across the front with Eze in behind. And if we can snag Nketiah, swap out Benteke.

With Gallagher and Hughes in midfield with Jimmy Mac as soon as he returns.

Happy days!

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 03 Jan 22 8.09pm

Originally posted by Gribbo

Olise, Benteke and Edouard across the front with Eze in behind. And if we can snag Nketiah, swap out Benteke.

With Gallagher and Hughes in midfield with Jimmy Mac as soon as he returns.

Happy days!


Not sure about Benteke. Would prefer to see Mateta given a couple of starts to see if he might be worth persevering with. We can afford to let him have those starts without risking triggering any commitment to buy. If he proves promising and we end up buying him we can jettison Benteke in the summer.

 

Brinscalleagle2 Flag Brinscall 03 Jan 22 8.13pm

I would suggest we need points rather than trying to establish if a loanee is worth buying. The coaching staff on the training ground is capable with that judgement without risking dropped points. COYP

 

sprites Flag Auckland 03 Jan 22 9.03pm

Originally posted by doombear


Not sure about Benteke. Would prefer to see Mateta given a couple of starts to see if he might be worth persevering with. We can afford to let him have those starts without risking triggering any commitment to buy. If he proves promising and we end up buying him we can jettison Benteke in the summer.

With all due respect, I'm glad PV is in charge instead of you. Mateta is cabbage (good finish aside).

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 04 Jan 22 9.01am

Originally posted by sprites

With all due respect, I'm glad PV is in charge instead of you. Mateta is cabbage (good finish aside).

Unfortunately Benteke is also a cabbage.

With Ayew and Wilf away, I'd assume we'll need to play Edouard wide, so will need one of those 2 duffers to play through the middle.

But I'd also be a fan of trying Eze wide (as he played last season)and go with a front 3 of Olise, Edouard and Eze

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 04 Jan 22 9.12am

I think Benteke is no more than a squad player these days. He had a brief spell earlier in the season when he looked like the player of old, but he hasn't maintained it.

Mateta, still looks a long way off being able to play at this level. In my view, he and Benteke aren't reliable starters. And I don't think we need the two of them if they are blocking a potential signing. Whether we have the funds available I don't know.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

sprites Flag Auckland 04 Jan 22 9.24am

Originally posted by NEILLO

I think Benteke is no more than a squad player these days. He had a brief spell earlier in the season when he looked like the player of old, but he hasn't maintained it.

Mateta, still looks a long way off being able to play at this level. In my view, he and Benteke aren't reliable starters. And I don't think we need the two of them if they are blocking a potential signing. Whether we have the funds available I don't know.

That’s because we stopped playing him.

He’s a confidence player, which means play him, feed him and he’ll score. Muck around giving him the odd start mixed with a few minutes etc and he’ll suffer.

Just my take. There’s still a player there.

 

beak Flag croydon 04 Jan 22 9.51am

Originally posted by doombear


Not sure about Benteke. Would prefer to see Mateta given a couple of starts to see if he might be worth persevering with. We can afford to let him have those starts without risking triggering any commitment to buy. If he proves promising and we end up buying him we can jettison Benteke in the summer.

Two more appearances and I think we will have to buy him,we all agree that for £13 million there are better player available.

Edited by beak (04 Jan 2022 9.51am)

 

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 04 Jan 22 9.53am

My wish for 2022 - bye-bye to Benteke! Fed up with the big. static man missing chances and giving the ball away.

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 04 Jan 22 10.04am

Originally posted by sprites

That’s because we stopped playing him.

He’s a confidence player, which means play him, feed him and he’ll score. Muck around giving him the odd start mixed with a few minutes etc and he’ll suffer.

Just my take. There’s still a player there.

I couldn't agree less. Yep, he might score the odd goal if he plays 90 mins every week, but the guy is detrimental to our style of football.

Limited movement - no intelligent runs, no pressing
Unable to physically impose himself on games, especially poor considering his size
Spends more time with his arms in the air than Wilf

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 04 Jan 22 10.14am

Originally posted by beak

Two more appearances and I think we will have to buy him,we all agree that for £13 million there are better player available.

Edited by beak (04 Jan 2022 9.51am)


He hasn't made anywhere near 15 STARTS, so not sure where you get 2 more games from.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 04 Jan 22 11.26am

Originally posted by MrRobbo

Unfortunately Benteke is also a cabbage.

With Ayew and Wilf away, I'd assume we'll need to play Edouard wide, so will need one of those 2 duffers to play through the middle.

But I'd also be a fan of trying Eze wide (as he played last season)and go with a front 3 of Olise, Edouard and Eze


If Eze was fully match fit then I'd like this front 3 as well but I doubt that he is. I hope to see him get some minutes from the bench whilst Wilf and Jordan ae at AFCON, though. It will be interesting to see who, out of the two you have called 'duffers, PV starts as striker in the cup on Saturday .

 

sprites Flag Auckland 04 Jan 22 6.58pm

Originally posted by MrRobbo

I couldn't agree less. Yep, he might score the odd goal if he plays 90 mins every week, but the guy is detrimental to our style of football.

Limited movement - no intelligent runs, no pressing
Unable to physically impose himself on games, especially poor considering his size
Spends more time with his arms in the air than Wilf

Fine by me - healthy disagreements are all part of a fan forum.

Although no one in the league throws their arms in the air more than Wilf.

 

Mathers Flag 04 Jan 22 11.28pm

Surely the FA cup tie this weekend has been pencilled in as Eze’s 1st start. Would love to see what a front 3 of Eze, Edouard and Olise can do in that game.

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 05 Jan 22 9.10am

Originally posted by sprites

Fine by me - healthy disagreements are all part of a fan forum.

Although no one in the league throws their arms in the air more than Wilf.

Cant disagree with that!

 

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 06 Jan 22 3.33pm

Would like to see JRS get at least some Bench time.

That leaves an Obvious front 3 of OE CB MO

EE and JRS can fill in when required.

I can't see Benteke being benched much whilst Zaha and Ayew are away. Especially if Mateta is sold too. And even if Nkitiah arrives, he won't start immediately.

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"


You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > While Wilf & Jordan are away...