This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Beanyboysmd
I believe we should scrap the monarchy, therefore playing god save the queen at the start of the FA cup final is a political statement. Never called for it to be scrapped though, just let it happen. Its impossible to keep politics out of football because the definition of politics is nearly impossible to define. Is showing solidarity behind Ukraine politics? Or is it showing that the country almost universally showing how they feel about the whole thing? Probably both. I think you dont like it because you dont agree with the message. I don't know what the technical term for a right wing tankie is but before this war there were a lot of them lurking around here... You make a decent point, as there is whole poppy situation and where people fall on that. Politics in some way, big or small will always creep back in and football on occasion, as clubs are often the heart of a community and its values. And how far do we take it? For instance, if we banned all political expression, what if say someone is waving a Ukrainian flag from the terraces? Do we ban them? And if not, well then political statements will happen regardless. What about the messages of Newcastle fans to Saudi owners? They were investigated by police.. I don't think things are so simple, as there end up being aspects of freedom of speech at play too. No easy answers, other than to say I'm pretty sure you could find a 'I want politics kicked out of football.. but not that.. that's different' exception for almost anyone who wants politics out of the game.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Beanyboysmd
I believe we should scrap the monarchy, therefore playing god save the queen at the start of the FA cup final is a political statement. Never called for it to be scrapped though, just let it happen. Its impossible to keep politics out of football because the definition of politics is nearly impossible to define. Is showing solidarity behind Ukraine politics? Or is it showing that the country almost universally showing how they feel about the whole thing? Probably both. I think you dont like it because you dont agree with the message. I don't know what the technical term for a right wing tankie is but before this war there were a lot of them lurking around here... I'd agree to an extent with that. While I don't agree with the far leftist view that everything is racist, I've always thought that....to an extent....that everything is political for the very reason that the 'political' can be seen far more generally while I'd argue that the racial is more a subset and distinct. Nevertheless I think it's just best for sport to try very hard not to be political precisely because that divides and excludes....sport is meant to be an escape, not thought messaging. One of the only sports to keep politics....or rather change, away from its events is boxing. Boxing seems inherently conservative....not in the political sense but in the conserving sense. It's one of the reasons it's been doing very well. Edited by Stirlingsays (15 Mar 2022 8.01am)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Slimey Toad
Why not extend to all entertainment? Rebel Wilson's finger to Putin was so cringingly embarrassing it proved yet again what a fairyland bubble these people live in. But at the same time let's not have more of an issue with a celebrity giving the middle finger, than Putins meat grinder of women and children. I get how ridiculous celebrity contributions can often be, but with the Russia invasion we also see the cowardice from the other perspective of people scared of Putin not getting his way. This lot are lot deserving of each other in my view.
|
|
|
Originally posted by BlueJay
But at the same time let's not have more of an issue with a celebrity giving the middle finger, than Putins meat grinder of women and children. I get how ridiculous celebrity contributions can often be, but with the Russia invasion we also see the cowardice from the other perspective of people scared of Putin not getting his way. This lot are lot deserving of each other in my view. The trouble is that these celebrities have an opinion on absolutely everything and it’s almost always entirely predictable.
|
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
The trouble is that these celebrities have an opinion on absolutely everything and it’s almost always entirely predictable. Certainly, I agree. They are in a way a human facet of the commercialisation dynamic. They latch onto what is the opportune view or take of the moment. I'm not saying that we should take them seriously, unless they act upon their supposed or actual conviction. My point is that holding 'any' apparently strident or heart felt view that isn't actioned in any meaningful way is no better that this. And also that in the bigger picture what a celebrity thinks about this or that is most often still less relevant than the rights or wrongs of the issue at hand.
|
|
|
Originally posted by BlueJay
But at the same time let's not have more of an issue with a celebrity giving the middle finger, than Putins meat grinder of women and children. I get how ridiculous celebrity contributions can often be, but with the Russia invasion we also see the cowardice from the other perspective of people scared of Putin not getting his way. This lot are lot deserving of each other in my view. To temper criticism of a publicity-seeking gesture by 'reminding' us of the atrocities currently being committed by Putin's Russian army is ridiculous. What is the point of them? At best, they show your peers what a great person you are. At worst they are meant to remind the general public of how bad Putin is. How insulting, particularly in a week when over 100,000 British people have opened their doors to Ukrainians.
|
|
|
Originally posted by BlueJay
It was an interesting point that boxing has avoided getting involved in any of this and exists in its own little bubble, with no-one really expecting it to take a view this way or that on anything. I certainly wouldn't say that's a bad idea by any means, but that it's understood, whereas football is more tribal on multiple fronts and as such telling people they shouldn't express what could be deemed a political opinion is something they will certainly get behind... until it's theirs! Edited by BlueJay (17 Mar 2022 3.47pm) I suppose Joshua wanting people only to shop in black owned shops might fall into that very catergory.
|
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
I suppose Joshua wanting people only to shop in black owned shops might fall into that very catergory. Interesting point. I think Eubank is against all of that and said basically people need to work harder - or something similar. So boxers have given opinions alright. When I think of Mohammad Ali, he had plenty to say - we've just largely forgotten.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
| W12 19 May 22 8.02pm | |
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
Interesting point. I think Eubank is against all of that and said basically people need to work harder - or something similar. So boxers have given opinions alright. When I think of Mohammad Ali, he had plenty to say - we've just largely forgotten. Ali knew liberalism was all bollocks:
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.