You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Coaching
November 16 2026 3.42am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Coaching


dreamwaverider Flag London 06 Apr 22 8.33am

This season is now showing the emergence of some very clever planning.
Bringing in Patrick Vieira was clearly a master stroke.
Then he brought in his coaching team.

Osian Roberts - first team assistant coach.
Kristian Wilson - first team coach.
Said Aigoun - development coach.
Dean Kiely - goalkeeper coach.

Plus we already had
Dougie Freedman- sporting director.

Between them, these guys look like they are pulling off something really special.

The completion of the Academy is all part of the plan.

Things are looking bright.

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 06 Apr 22 8.48am

Missed out . . .

Shaun Derry -first team coach

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

sydtheeagle Flag England 06 Apr 22 8.50am

Something that's overlooked but been a massive factor in our turnaround and may even just have had some input from Harris and Blitzer is how Palace are run using a very American sports-team business model.

Whatever job title you want to apply to his role, Dougie to all intents and purposes is what in the States they call a General Manager. It's now quite clear he runs the show and the scouting department and squad assembly fall to him. It's also quite clear that while he works with the manager, he's first among equals.

Unlike how teams operated in the old days and some other teams still do even now, the manager doesn't choose and buy his own players. Dougie does the scouting and buying and decides what sort of player is right for the Palace ethos. Yes, the manager can input his own preferences but it's the general manager who has the final decision. That's as it should be, at least in the clear GM business model. And Dougie has been hugely successful in the role. He's put the bullets in the gun, then (along with Parish) found the right marksman (Vieira) to do the shooting using the fully loaded gun he's assembled.

If Dougie's reputation was once diminished in these parts, it shouldn't be any more. As General Managers should be (in the States, they're broadly speaking just as high profile as coaches), he is the foundation stone on which everything this year has been built. And the owners (likely including Harris and Blitzer for the reasons given above) should get a lot of credit for installing a system to run the club that works, using their experience elsewhere to do so. Vieira, a brilliant choice of manager, is really the icing on the cake.

A lot of credit to be handed out at Palace these days. Dougie should be getting the lion's share.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

Midlands Eagle Flag 06 Apr 22 9.02am

Originally posted by sydtheeagle

Unlike how teams operated in the old days and some other teams still do even now, the manager doesn't choose and buy his own players. Dougie does the scouting and buying and decides what sort of player is right for the Palace ethos. Yes, the manager can input his own preferences but it's the general manager who has the final decision.

The problem with that system is that if the manager doesn't fancy the player that his "General Manager" has supplied him with he won't play him as we saw a couple of times with players that Roy Hodgson was given

 

Painter Flag Croydon 06 Apr 22 9.03am

I can understand people getting a bit carried away with the result against Arsenal. The reality is we have only won 27% of our Premier games this season, granted we haven’t lost that many.
It’s next season, that will be the telling season of progress we have made under Vieira and his coaching team. There will be no Gallagher, who is key to the way we are currently playing this season. That is the challenge facing them next season.

 

nead1 Flag 06 Apr 22 9.56am

Originally posted by sydtheeagle

Something that's overlooked but been a massive factor in our turnaround and may even just have had some input from Harris and Blitzer is how Palace are run using a very American sports-team business model.

Whatever job title you want to apply to his role, Dougie to all intents and purposes is what in the States they call a General Manager. It's now quite clear he runs the show and the scouting department and squad assembly fall to him. It's also quite clear that while he works with the manager, he's first among equals.

Unlike how teams operated in the old days and some other teams still do even now, the manager doesn't choose and buy his own players. Dougie does the scouting and buying and decides what sort of player is right for the Palace ethos. Yes, the manager can input his own preferences but it's the general manager who has the final decision. That's as it should be, at least in the clear GM business model. And Dougie has been hugely successful in the role. He's put the bullets in the gun, then (along with Parish) found the right marksman (Vieira) to do the shooting using the fully loaded gun he's assembled.

If Dougie's reputation was once diminished in these parts, it shouldn't be any more. As General Managers should be (in the States, they're broadly speaking just as high profile as coaches), he is the foundation stone on which everything this year has been built. And the owners (likely including Harris and Blitzer for the reasons given above) should get a lot of credit for installing a system to run the club that works, using their experience elsewhere to do so. Vieira, a brilliant choice of manager, is really the icing on the cake.

A lot of credit to be handed out at Palace these days. Dougie should be getting the lion's share.

I completely agree with you Syd. Freedman is front and centre of pretty much everything that is going on football wise and has clearly patched up any differences that existed with Parish when he left for Bolton. Indeed, clearly Parish recognised his capabilities and business sense and I suspect the role has grown significantly since he was first appointed.

Whilst I think Parish is a very savvy operator, I think he has had two major bits of luck since 2010. First Wilf and secondly Freedman - both of whom were already at the club back in 2010. Freedman appears to keep quite a low profile but his input is there for all to see and lets hope it continues for a long time to come.

 

taylors lovechild Flag 06 Apr 22 10.08am

Originally posted by sydtheeagle

Something that's overlooked but been a massive factor in our turnaround and may even just have had some input from Harris and Blitzer is how Palace are run using a very American sports-team business model.

Whatever job title you want to apply to his role, Dougie to all intents and purposes is what in the States they call a General Manager. It's now quite clear he runs the show and the scouting department and squad assembly fall to him. It's also quite clear that while he works with the manager, he's first among equals.

Unlike how teams operated in the old days and some other teams still do even now, the manager doesn't choose and buy his own players. Dougie does the scouting and buying and decides what sort of player is right for the Palace ethos. Yes, the manager can input his own preferences but it's the general manager who has the final decision. That's as it should be, at least in the clear GM business model. And Dougie has been hugely successful in the role. He's put the bullets in the gun, then (along with Parish) found the right marksman (Vieira) to do the shooting using the fully loaded gun he's assembled.

If Dougie's reputation was once diminished in these parts, it shouldn't be any more. As General Managers should be (in the States, they're broadly speaking just as high profile as coaches), he is the foundation stone on which everything this year has been built. And the owners (likely including Harris and Blitzer for the reasons given above) should get a lot of credit for installing a system to run the club that works, using their experience elsewhere to do so. Vieira, a brilliant choice of manager, is really the icing on the cake.

A lot of credit to be handed out at Palace these days. Dougie should be getting the lion's share.

To be fair, I don't think it's been overlooked at all. Roy mentioned at least once a week the role that Freedman had, so I think everyone within the club knew he had a big hand in the successful recruitment last summer. I also think we were a bit fortuitous with Vieira as he clearly was not the first choice, but kudos to the club for taking the chance on a manager looking to prove himself rather than panicking and going for a well worn option.

Right now we have every reason to be positive and Dougie definitely deserves praise, but I don't think it can be underestimated just how good our current coaching setup is. A positive sign is that we keep improving, showing that there is a plan. With Roy it always felt that his plan was finite once established, whereas it feels Vieira and his team have more ambitious plans which hopefully the club can help them fulfil.

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 06 Apr 22 11.52am

Originally posted by Painter

I can understand people getting a bit carried away with the result against Arsenal. The reality is we have only won 27% of our Premier games this season, granted we haven’t lost that many.
It’s next season, that will be the telling season of progress we have made under Vieira and his coaching team. There will be no Gallagher, who is key to the way we are currently playing this season. That is the challenge facing them next season.

V important point.

We're are all on a high, and rightly so. But remember it was only a couple of weeks ago that we were digging the out for not being able to beat Norwich and Brentford.

We will have loses of form, just look at Brighton, Villa, Newcastle, Southampton. All have stalled over the last couple of months.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 06 Apr 22 12.34pm

Originally posted by Painter

I can understand people getting a bit carried away with the result against Arsenal. The reality is we have only won 27% of our Premier games this season, granted we haven’t lost that many.
It’s next season, that will be the telling season of progress we have made under Vieira and his coaching team. There will be no Gallagher, who is key to the way we are currently playing this season. That is the challenge facing them next season.

Yes, but we have moved from lower mid table to upper mid table and the reason for the low win rate is the high draw rate, usually through silly errors mainly early season (save Wilf's comical pen miss) when we were transitioning with a new coaching team and many new squad players.

The likely loss of CG will certainly hurt, and all this talk of Eze being an available replacement is tosh as they are very different players offering a very different service.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 06 Apr 22 12.46pm

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

To be fair, I don't think it's been overlooked at all. Roy mentioned at least once a week the role that Freedman had, so I think everyone within the club knew he had a big hand in the successful recruitment last summer. I also think we were a bit fortuitous with Vieira as he clearly was not the first choice, but kudos to the club for taking the chance on a manager looking to prove himself rather than panicking and going for a well worn option.

Right now we have every reason to be positive and Dougie definitely deserves praise, but I don't think it can be underestimated just how good our current coaching setup is. A positive sign is that we keep improving, showing that there is a plan. With Roy it always felt that his plan was finite once established, whereas it feels Vieira and his team have more ambitious plans which hopefully the club can help them fulfil.

That is the difference. With Roy we had more points than we do now (still, I think?). We were effective lower-mid, but were never likely to improve on that, even with a better squad. We had achieved the Stoke formula that kept them precisely mid table for 10 years. However, that formula has risk - look where Stoke are now.

The current set up, with a freshened and younger squad, a largely new backroom, an academy likely to produce very decent talent, fabulous new training facilities and (one not to be overlooked) what appears to be a vastly improved physio team and facility, gives the impression that we have not fixed on any lower-mid certainty. It suggests - and this is why it is so exciting - that we are only at the start of a journey. The club seems to have created a platform that appears more likely to take us up rather than stagnate in the position we have sat for 9 years.

 

sydtheeagle Flag England 06 Apr 22 12.53pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

The problem with that system is that if the manager doesn't fancy the player that his "General Manager" has supplied him with he won't play him as we saw a couple of times with players that Roy Hodgson was given

That shouldn't happen, and rarely does in the General Manager system. If it works properly, it's the General Manager who is primarily responsible for hiring the manager/coach. Yes, the owner has to approve, but the manager nevertheless is part of the GMs "organisation" and the GM is responsible for choosing him just as he is for choosing the players. When a manager is hired, he has to dovetail with the GMs vision for the squad; not the other way around. If a manager is interviewed who wants to do it "his way" then he doesn't get the job.

I think when Dougie's role was more nascent, what you mentioned inevitably did happen with Roy. But now things have become clearer, I think Vieira accepting the job was probably partly influenced by the fact that he shared Dougie's vision and was happy with his role and responsibility for the squad. Given how many of Dougie's signings (even Mateta) are proving just what a job he's done, my guess is an awful lot of managers will be quite happy to work with him in future.

I feel for Roy. He did a great job with what, in reality, was a transitional squad reaching its sell-by date, something we can see clearly now. It's also now obvious that he was never part of the long-term planning. I wouldn't blame him if seeing where we are today rankles with him a little bit, though he's far too classy to ever say so.

But even Roy's departure shows the degree of competence behind Dougie's thinking and planning. Everything that's happened in the past twelve months has been scripted by us. Even the Wilf conversation, for the first time ever this summer, is no longer a matter of "can we persuade Wilf to stay?' but, rather, now it's "shall we let Wilf go if it suits us to?" And short of a top, top club coming in for him (which they won't), why would he want to leave?

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

sydtheeagle Flag England 06 Apr 22 12.57pm

Originally posted by eagleman13

Missed out . . .

Shaun Derry -first team coach

I have no idea what roles and what degree of competence each of Vieira's staff possesses but I think there's always a place in a well-constructed coaching team for a "continuity" member; someone who understands the ethos of the club and can be a bridge with the supporters. Derry appears to have been chosen by Vieira for that role (similar to Duncan Ferguson's at Everton) and seems to be executing it well. He was a shrewd hire.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

Omph Flag Liverpool 06 Apr 22 1.05pm

Originally posted by Painter

I can understand people getting a bit carried away with the result against Arsenal. The reality is we have only won 27% of our Premier games this season, granted we haven’t lost that many.
It’s next season, that will be the telling season of progress we have made under Vieira and his coaching team. There will be no Gallagher, who is key to the way we are currently playing this season. That is the challenge facing them next season.

Absolutely.

I don't see that Gallagher can be replaced like for like and there'll likely be a need for a tweak to our approach next season. The comforting thing is PV has shown this season that he is capable of working with the resources he has and producing a system that maximises the strengths of those players rather than simply shoe horning players into a system. Thinking here mostly of our asymmetrical defensive system.


 

dreamwaverider Flag London 06 Apr 22 1.06pm

Originally posted by silvertop

Yes, but we have moved from lower mid table to upper mid table and the reason for the low win rate is the high draw rate, usually through silly errors mainly early season (save Wilf's comical pen miss) when we were transitioning with a new coaching team and many new squad players.

The likely loss of CG will certainly hurt, and all this talk of Eze being an available replacement is tosh as they are very different players offering a very different service.

Purely on a statistics note, positively, even if we had won or drawn those three or four earlier games this season with last minute goals against us, we would have added what, say 7 points. We are currently 12 points adrift of Wolves in 8th, so no difference.

The big difference that I see is the way we are gelling into a formidable force.
We didn't just beat Arsenal 3-0, we royally thumped them. Even when their substitutions improved them, our defence remained solid. Then of course Zaha singlehandedly finished them off.

Our junior teams and our women are all right up there now. CPFC is becoming a progressive force in motion.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 06 Apr 22 1.13pm

Originally posted by sydtheeagle

Something that's overlooked but been a massive factor in our turnaround and may even just have had some input from Harris and Blitzer is how Palace are run using a very American sports-team business model.

Whatever job title you want to apply to his role, Dougie to all intents and purposes is what in the States they call a General Manager. It's now quite clear he runs the show and the scouting department and squad assembly fall to him. It's also quite clear that while he works with the manager, he's first among equals.

Unlike how teams operated in the old days and some other teams still do even now, the manager doesn't choose and buy his own players. Dougie does the scouting and buying and decides what sort of player is right for the Palace ethos. Yes, the manager can input his own preferences but it's the general manager who has the final decision. That's as it should be, at least in the clear GM business model. And Dougie has been hugely successful in the role. He's put the bullets in the gun, then (along with Parish) found the right marksman (Vieira) to do the shooting using the fully loaded gun he's assembled.

If Dougie's reputation was once diminished in these parts, it shouldn't be any more. As General Managers should be (in the States, they're broadly speaking just as high profile as coaches), he is the foundation stone on which everything this year has been built. And the owners (likely including Harris and Blitzer for the reasons given above) should get a lot of credit for installing a system to run the club that works, using their experience elsewhere to do so. Vieira, a brilliant choice of manager, is really the icing on the cake.

A lot of credit to be handed out at Palace these days. Dougie should be getting the lion's share.

That's a very good summing up of what we are turning into and an accurate observation that i had not really considered

I wonder what role Mark Bright is playing in all of this? He has been on Parish's shoulder for a number of years now. As I recall they went out to the States together to meet Harris and Blitzer.

 

sydtheeagle Flag England 06 Apr 22 1.55pm

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

I wonder what role Mark Bright is playing in all of this?

That's a really interesting question. In one way, it's become quite enjoyable to poke fun at him in his public role of Steve Parish's fluffer but in another way, you have to believe he's doing at least something useful.

My guess (and the word "guess" is underlined and in bold because it is only a guess) is that Bright probably serves the role in the boardroom that Derry serves on the coaching staff; he's the "continuity" candidate; the person the board rely for expertise about the club itself from the players, not the owner's or manager's perspective. Thus, I imagine when it comes to "fit" around big decision-making on a fairly wide variety of issues, he probably has input in answering the question "is this right for Crystal Palace?" If my guess is correct then Bright, too, appears to be doing a pretty good job.

What I find instructive and shrewd with regard to our present owners is that they have gone beyond what many clubs do with regard to former players. Almost everyone uses them as ambassadors. Quite often, a popular ex-player is misguidedly given the manager's job at a club without any evidence that he's up to the task. But our owners have really found ex-players who have genuinely beneficial qualities and found useful, not just jobs-for-the-boys, roles for them. And it's a model that apparently works well. Dougie is an outstanding General Manager. Bright appears to be a very competent boardroom advisor. Derry is a useful member of the coaching staff. And McCarthy is a very good developer of young players.

It's another area of performance in which our owners deserve a considerable measure of credit.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

Qwijibo Flag Bournemouth 06 Apr 22 2.15pm

Originally posted by Painter

I can understand people getting a bit carried away with the result against Arsenal. The reality is we have only won 27% of our Premier games this season, granted we haven’t lost that many.
It’s next season, that will be the telling season of progress we have made under Vieira and his coaching team. There will be no Gallagher, who is key to the way we are currently playing this season. That is the challenge facing them next season.

I've thought about this a lot. Our defense has improved markedly in recent weeks and inexperienced players are now a little more street wise. Perhaps one or two of those naive draws earlier in the season would now be slender wins.

I do think some are getting a little carried away with our form. We are improving, but will severely miss Connor Gallagher. I feel he lost a bit of form from November to January which coincided with some poor results. It's only a few weeks since we couldn't even beat Burnley, Norwich or a pre-Eriksen Brentford, who were all badly off form at the time.

But I'm sure everyone at the club is aware of his presence. When we sign players, they do tend to appear out of nowhere. I'm sure we are investigating all options, but with an ageing Kouyaté, Milivojovic and MacArthur, I worry where the engine room will come from.

I suppose my paranoia is just normal from a lifetime of Palace. The optomist would see the fact that only 4 teams have lost fewer games than us. I just remember scars of being relegated 4th from bottom... or being safe with 8 minutes to go in 2005... or a late equaliser in the final.... or a Claridge shinned effort..... there's always a sob story eventually whenever I'm stupid enough to see the sunshine.

 

dg1937 Flag 06 Apr 22 6.59pm

There's another thread about Mateta but I suggest he is exhibit 1 in the case for PV and his coaching team. It was not so long ago that Mateta looked like a headless chicken skating on ice. He always seemed to have a knack for scoring goals but the rest of his play wasn't up to much. Still not the finished article but he's improving before our eyes.

Exhibit 2: Mitchell. His progress this season is not an accident, he is benefiting from top quality coaching.

Every time I see PV speak I am impressed by his calm authority. He has played at the very top, he is a proven winner, who wouldn't want to play for him (and that includes you, Conor!)?!

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 07 Apr 22 10.43am

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

Purely on a statistics note, positively, even if we had won or drawn those three or four earlier games this season with last minute goals against us, we would have added what, say 7 points. We are currently 12 points adrift of Wolves in 8th, so no difference.

The big difference that I see is the way we are gelling into a formidable force.
We didn't just beat Arsenal 3-0, we royally thumped them. Even when their substitutions improved them, our defence remained solid. Then of course Zaha singlehandedly finished them off.

Our junior teams and our women are all right up there now. CPFC is becoming a progressive force in motion.

Wait to see where we are come May. 5 points is closeable in the remaining games if we continue this run.

 


You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Coaching